User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I don't really know all the details other than the last few pages but this does stink. The mystery angle has always intrigued me and knowing people can play with builds to see what happens on a test server is disappointing.Considering human nature it wouldn't be a stretch to think there are some people who made it on who aren't looking at the games best interest but looking for insider information that they can exploit.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Why didn't Bort just ask Deathblade, Flames, and I BEFORE he decided to give all the secrets of the game to a select few. We could have told him it would be a disaster.


Going to attempt to reply to this again...will keep it brief this time.

Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.

The "disaster" is when the staff-user relationship comes into question. A good chunk of the userbase feels cheated because of it, added in with the fact that it was supposed to remain secret, and you have a lot of unhappy customers.

Me? I'm in it for the long haul, but I can't say the same for other people, especially people who have spent thousands to test, only to find out that it was wasted.


Getting Testers = good. No one questions that.

He should have just asked for some volunteers to test the new defensive play builder and made the results of those games public. I don't see the need for secrecy. The only need for secrecy was to conceal that some players were getting a big advantage.


 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Why didn't Bort just ask Deathblade, Flames, and I BEFORE he decided to give all the secrets of the game to a select few. We could have told him it would be a disaster.


Going to attempt to reply to this again...will keep it brief this time.

Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.

The "disaster" is when the staff-user relationship comes into question. A good chunk of the userbase feels cheated because of it, added in with the fact that it was supposed to remain secret, and you have a lot of unhappy customers.

Me? I'm in it for the long haul, but I can't say the same for other people, especially people who have spent thousands to test, only to find out that it was wasted.


Getting Testers = good. No one questions that.

He should have just asked for some volunteers to test the new defensive play builder and made the results of those games public. I don't see the need for secrecy. The only need for secrecy was to conceal that some players were getting a big advantage.


No the need for secrecy would be because irrational fear is rife on GLB and leads to extended whinge fests like this one.

The talk of blind, double blind tests etc is a waste of time and resources. The concept is repeated tests, repeatedly, to identify issues (and/or work with what currently exists) in order to fix the problems that already exist, or will exist, or that require tweaking in order to produce a more accurate sim.

GLB is built on "secret" builds with "secret" AI. So why doesn't everyone, in the spirit of transparency, unlock all their players and post up their tactics?

Then no championship can be in doubt, or advantage gained from testing.
 
iiiPOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Why didn't Bort just ask Deathblade, Flames, and I BEFORE he decided to give all the secrets of the game to a select few. We could have told him it would be a disaster.


Going to attempt to reply to this again...will keep it brief this time.

Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.

The "disaster" is when the staff-user relationship comes into question. A good chunk of the userbase feels cheated because of it, added in with the fact that it was supposed to remain secret, and you have a lot of unhappy customers.

Me? I'm in it for the long haul, but I can't say the same for other people, especially people who have spent thousands to test, only to find out that it was wasted.


Getting Testers = good. No one questions that.

He should have just asked for some volunteers to test the new defensive play builder and made the results of those games public. I don't see the need for secrecy. The only need for secrecy was to conceal that some players were getting a big advantage.




Bort decided that it would be a public test from now on. No need to talk about what happened as I doubt Bort will do anything to that. Bort's not sorry for what he did.
 
eso2008
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Termsofuse
Bort decided that it would be a public test from now on. No need to talk about what happened as I doubt Bort will do anything to that. Bort's not sorry for what he did.


Where is this post/announcement?

 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Why didn't Bort just ask Deathblade, Flames, and I BEFORE he decided to give all the secrets of the game to a select few. We could have told him it would be a disaster.


Going to attempt to reply to this again...will keep it brief this time.

Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.

The "disaster" is when the staff-user relationship comes into question. A good chunk of the userbase feels cheated because of it, added in with the fact that it was supposed to remain secret, and you have a lot of unhappy customers.

Me? I'm in it for the long haul, but I can't say the same for other people, especially people who have spent thousands to test, only to find out that it was wasted.


The choice may have been for the betterment of the game, but it was extremely naive to think it wouldn't blow up like this. 100% chance that at some point the public would find out about it.
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Romeorr

when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.


You don't think they were testing this on the test server?

Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.

I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.

Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,

Would you agree?





Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Romeorr


when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.


You don't think they were testing this on the test server?

Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.

I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.

Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,

Would you agree?





Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship



You lost because of a feature not implemented yet?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Romeorr



when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.


You don't think they were testing this on the test server?

Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.

I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.

Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,

Would you agree?





Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship



You lost because of a feature not implemented yet?


Classic, and proves my entire point, people will bitch about anything.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade


Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.




I think Bort's stated choice was very reactionary and short-sighted. I think if he makes test results transparent it is a significant negative for the future of the game.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Originally posted by Deathblade



Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.




I think Bort's stated choice was very reactionary and short-sighted. I think if he makes test results transparent it is a significant negative for the future of the game.


Chicago... I think DB was talking about Bort's decision to set up the secret testers....

Anyway you two are both right....
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

Originally posted by Deathblade




Bort's choice was without a doubt for the betterment of the game/sim itself.




I think Bort's stated choice was very reactionary and short-sighted. I think if he makes test results transparent it is a significant negative for the future of the game.


Chicago... I think DB was talking about Bort's decision to set up the secret testers....

Anyway you two are both right....


sry bout that...

I do agree testing software is a good thing. (I do it for a living...lol) I also understand what cold be learned in a few hours of testing.

 
Me1234
offline
Link
 
guys, just stop paying the machine... its that simple; play the game but don't spend money.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS


sry bout that...

I do agree testing software is a good thing. (I do it for a living...lol) I also understand what cold be learned in a few hours of testing.



No need for apologies... I can see you both want what's best for this game... I think we all do... The thing is in the original thread we were coming to some good decisions about what should be done about this... and right when the discussion was going good Bort makes a decision and ends discussion...

Now it seems that decision is going to be worse than the original one to set up secret testers....
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Romeorr


when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.


You don't think they were testing this on the test server?

Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.

I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.

Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,

Would you agree?





Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship



o_0 This is what's scary that this guy doesn't know.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 08:58:19
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.