User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Binestar
Originally posted by Robbnva


general SA helps everyone not just the mlb, if my MLB had more maybe the rest of the team would do better.

Who said SAs are so great anyway? I know a couple of players who dominate in Pro and don't have any SAs at all.


SA's aren't great for the most part. But a good Defense General, Line General, D-Line General and Field General reduce fatigue, making the late game advantage pretty large. Losing that by needing 70 str/tackling as a MLB would be.... a bad trade IMO.

I don't mind changes, this one is likely a good one, good teams will adapt, bad teams will fold, thus is the life of GLB.


I agree with this but my LB is now going into his 4th season of exsistance which is when i should start focusing on SAs
 
Joe_B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Mike Rogers



Tackler : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Tackling + (Vision+Agility/2)



I strongly disagree with the defender equation. One of the points that several people have made earlier in the thread is that while strength should ensure that defenders aren't dragged for yards after making a tackle, tackling should nonetheless be the single biggest factor in determining whether a successful tackle is made. So any formula that has strength and tackling given equal weight needs to be reworked.



so you would want something like this:

Tackler : (Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + (Vision+Agility/2))/2 + (Tackling*2)



 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade

Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.

Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs

Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate

Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs


How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?


IMO:

Power = Strength focus (end build high strength = 100)

Elusive = Agility focus (end build high is agility = 100)

As for speed? Johnny "The Jet" Rogers, for example, was not "fast", just elusive. Of course, in GLB I can see 2:1 agility/speed here.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
God damn it.


 
MrNomad
offline
Link
 
You know I think Bort really has a severe double standard sometimes. So you are basically trying to tell everyone what is needed to stop power backs. Ok...what should the build be to you know shutdown say a high agi super fast WR most of the time. How about what a DT needs to have stat wise to get just half the sacks of a good DE. Something small like say 40-50 sacks instead of the 120+ of the really good DEs. Hell why even have player profiles blocked just make them automatically open so you can see what the successful players are doing and copy it so we'll have nice cookie cutter molds for players.

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 10:07:02
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plax_Are_Meth
Originally posted by FatNasty

Originally posted by the man of doom


well a corner could cut his legs

and he would fall forward


Knocking a guys legs out is not an ideal tackling method, but can be effective once in a while. It's just a way little guys make big guys fall down, but an agile big guy will quickly learn to hop over a bowing little guy, or just juke around him, IMO.


But that's a good thing. It would make it balanced, rather then having all the RB guys start yelling out that "no more avoiding tackles".

Good against low agility powerbacks, high risk against evasive backs.


Agreed. But a power back should have good agility anyway. No need to max it. To me the whole issue of power vs. elusive is an issue of focus on strength vs. agility.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by Bort


Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


Assuming we are only talking about Breaking Tackles and not Avoiding Tackles.....

HB : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Carrying

ie 220+60/2+100+70= 310 (Base comparison value before modifiers)

VS

Tackler : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Tackling + (Vision+Agility/2)

So using some ball park figures that reresent some of the more common build types...

CB : 187 + 90/2 + 30 + 30 + (60+60)/2 = 258.5
LB : 250 + 80/2 + 48 + 48 + (50+60)/2 = 316.0
NT : 330 + 48/2 + 80 + 60 + (40+70)/2 = 384.0


NB: Current Speed = Current Speed /100 * Morale. So if your player has given up, he'll get run over more often.

I would then say the %age difference is the %age chance of Breaking the Tackle.

So as seen above, a CB with 30 Strength and 30 Tackling (value 258.5) Vs HB Value 310 is likely to miss 16.6% of his Tackles, before any Break Block/Make Tackle modifiers. Assuming they activate a lot, he will miss most tackle chances.

LB with Value 316.0 will make most tackles, but has no chance if a SA or Modifier fires.

NT with 384 value has no problem stopping the HB, and it would take high amount of modifiers triggering to make a difference.

Then as fatigue and morale loss kicks in, things can go to the HBs favour.

That seems to be rational and realistic to me, but might need some work to smooth it out.




This is a great breakdown..

Except your favoring the HB when fatigue/morale hits.. What about the fatigue factor of the HB?


The fatigue/morale drain is built in on both sides, for the purposes of the calculation, Current Speed = the current speed a player is moving at, divided by 100, times Morale.

So 100% Morale means the player has lost no momentum when going into a tackle, 0 morale would mean he effectively has no momentum. This would make Confidence important for all players.

The fatigue drain is a constant controlled by Stamina and per play energy loss so its balanced evenly.




 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe_B

so you would want something like this:

Tackler : (Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + (Vision+Agility/2))/2 + (Tackling*2)


That looks like an improvement to me, but I'm still a little uncomfortable with the big role that weight plays in it.

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Joe_B


so you would want something like this:

Tackler : (Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + (Vision+Agility/2))/2 + (Tackling*2)


That looks like an improvement to me, but I'm still a little uncomfortable with the big role that weight plays in it.



why, weight plays a role IRL
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Capaneus

Originally posted by Joe_B



so you would want something like this:

Tackler : (Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + (Vision+Agility/2))/2 + (Tackling*2)


That looks like an improvement to me, but I'm still a little uncomfortable with the big role that weight plays in it.



why, weight plays a role IRL



Because he's a FS.

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 10:11:36
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Agility would also play more of a role, since they would be able to slow down for impact quicker.
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrNomad
You know I think Bort really has a severe double standard sometimes. So you are basically trying to tell everyone what is needed to stop power backs. Ok...what should the build be to you know shutdown say a high agi super fast WR most of the time. How about what a DT needs to have stat wise to get just half the sacks of a good DE. Something small like say 40-50 sacks instead of the 120+ of the really good DEs. Hell why even have player profiles blocked just make them automatically open so you can see what the successful players are doing and copy it so we'll have nice cookie cutter molds for players.



Severe double standard? Huh? I don't hear him telling us what you say he's telling us. I hear him thinking out loud, responding to criticism. It is a game of strategy after all so dilemmas will appear. I'll bet he's faced with having to make difficult decisions all the time in the name of fair play and consistency across the board.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gott


Because he's a FS.



True, but it's at least partially because I think it would be a big change from the way tackles are currently calculated. I don't know what the formula is, but I assume weight plays a smaller role.

 
Stray Doug
offline
Link
 
Equation-wise, the "Quality of Tackle" (how squarely you hit, do you wrap-up/hold on, etc.) should be calculated first, and independently, of bringing the player down. Quality of Tackle would be calculated by Current Speed, Angle of Attack, Vision, Agility, Tackling, Weight, are you currently being blocked, etc. (vs. carrier's agility, juking skills, weight, vision, current balance/speed, etc.)

Once the QoT is established, you use strength (for both players) and agility (moreso for carrier, D player's agility has already gone in to quality of tackle) to calculate whether the carrier is brought to the ground, or if he's dragging D player along, or if he's completely broken free of D player, etc. Quality of Tackle is a major modifier to this calculation (a square hit or wrap up is going to have far more impact, in terms of at least you're slowing the carrier down and gang tackling him... and arm tackle or shoestring tackle is more of a "you either knocked him off balance or you didn't" attempt, and if unsuccessful the carrier can continue more-or-less unimpeded). QoT not recalculated for a given tackle attempt. Each tick you recalculate trying to bring player to the ground (and carrier trying to break free of a player holding on) until either a tackle is either made or completely broken.

But it shouldn't all just be in one big "make or miss" equation IMO. Way too simplistic.

Or course, there would also be a calculation of D players FF abilities vs. the carrier's carrying skill (and SAs and morale) to detect fumbles, but I think that's how it is now anyway.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.