Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE
That's where we disagree.
Because you don't understand the mathematics. I'm not intending to disparage you when I say that. This same thing has happened to me countless times when fellow owners in fantasy leagues wanted to change settings and couldn't recognize the mathematical consequences of doing so. The fact is that most people don't readily recognize those issues. I'll quote my earlier attempted explanation again to see if it can help us reach some sort of understanding.
"While I have no idea about what is the actual performance penalty of throwing an interception, let's indulge in a hypothetical and say that it's -5% to stats. So after QB Joe's first interception, his stats drop to "0.95 x X." The penalized attributes increase the likelihood of a second interception, dropping him to "0.95^2 x X," or 0.9025 x X. With each passing interception, we see more drastic results. 0.857, then 0.815, then .774 and so on. By the end of this chain, the original AA level QB now has the effective attributes of someone much lower level.
A more appropriate design would be to have declining penalties where the fourth interception doesn't hurt as much as the first. You'd still see morale drop with every bad play, but instead of being three-fourths of the beginning stats, you could be something more along the lines of 85-90%. That's more realistic and would prevent these absurd results where quarterbacks throw 60% of their regular season interceptions total in one playoff game."
Having flat penalties as a result of "bad plays" creates this cascade issue, and it's one that just gets worse and worse with each iteration. Does it really make sense that a fourth interception should damage a quarterback's morale and thus performance as much as the first or second one? Wouldn't you think that by that point the damage was pretty much done?
Mathematically the problem is that flat penalties compound with each point in the sequence, which is why you end up with exponential applications instead of progressive ones. A progressive model would still have performance suffer from making bad plays, and it would still absolutely make confidence critical in mitigating the effects of those plays, but it would not produce a cascade that transforms the average AA quarterback into a D-league one during the course of a game.
Except for the FACT that he wasn't an average AA Quarterback, you can take that one to the bank, you can claim you know football, math, though that his sketchy now, see the 16x16 post if you have any doubt.
You have NO IDEA about builds in this game, that is a given, it is clear that you don't know how they work, how build affects outcome all the fun stuff, you think that because this QB was ranked #9 in something, he is average, when that couldn't be farther from the truth, in fact, I am willing to venture he is probably one of the worst QB in the AA loop, for any country, but that would be pure speculation as A. I ain't gonna look at all the AA teams and QB's there.
and B. they wouldn't have their builds open to begin with.