User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Smooth Operator is still at least decent

Coverage LB's have Swat Ball and not much else

Most LB SA's suck - the Morale ones don't really work any more since QB's all have confidence 73-capped


Then don't chose one of them for your "Bonus" SA? Hulk's point was some positions don't have many SAs he wants as a Bonus, so he shouldn't need one to invest in the "Archetype Specific" SA which comes after it in the tree. However, there are always SAs that "help" and positions blessed with good SA trees shouldn't get to go right to the "Archetype" one without spending in the "Bonus" like everyone else.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
What if players got to choose their majors but with some restrictions. The restrictions would be as follows:

1 All players must have 4 majors and 4 minors. (It just makes the math simpler.)
2 Only 2 Physical skills can be majors.

Well I guess that is it. I thought i was going to make a long list of rules but I think that pretty much solves it. lol


Too simple and player-friendly (like having you choose your own intense training combo)....Rejected.


And I'm thinking a ban is in order for good measure.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Man, anyone remember the experimental "Aura" MLBs from like season 2?

Just loaded up on all the morale affecting SAs including Defense General.

I should start one of those for when they buff Morale SAs and they go all out of control for a season or two.


They won't go out of control. We're already working on testing all of the SAs to make sure they work, and are balanced enough to not be "over powered".
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Something needs to give regarding receiving TE's. Jumping is absolutely critical perhaps more so than the simple vision check required to see the pass coming in. LB'ers have Jumping as a major which is an absolute huge advantage to the D. I've gone from really excited about creating a receiving TE to really bummed that the TE won't be any good. This totally destroys the TE/LB interaction, and I'm assuming that the testing will confirm this theory.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
What if players got to choose their majors but with some restrictions. The restrictions would be as follows:

1 All players must have 4 majors and 4 minors. (It just makes the math simpler.)
2 Only 2 Physical skills can be majors.

Well I guess that is it. I thought i was going to make a long list of rules but I think that pretty much solves it. lol


Because that would create super players. On my WR, I'd go with Speed, Agility, Catching, Carrying as my majors with Strength, Vision, Jumping and Stamina as my minors. Beastly WR, imo.

Or how about a LB with Speed, Strength, Tackling, Vision as majors and Agility, Jumping, Confidence, Stamina as minors. Everybody would be doing that. Doesn't really encourage diversity, does it?


The reason they did this is to give you more diversity, but with to keep the uber builds from becoming the norm. There needs to be rewards and penalties to encourage people to take different paths. If you were able to choose whatever skills you wanted, then where would the rewards and penalties be? Everybody would basically be choosing the same path.
Edited by Staz on Feb 17, 2010 11:06:59
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
Something needs to give regarding receiving TE's. Jumping is absolutely critical perhaps more so than the simple vision check required to see the pass coming in. LB'ers have Jumping as a major which is an absolute huge advantage to the D. I've gone from really excited about creating a receiving TE to really bummed that the TE won't be any good. This totally destroys the TE/LB interaction, and I'm assuming that the testing will confirm this theory.


This is a valid concern, and something I could agree with you on. I'll bring it to the tester forum.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
This is a valid concern, and something I could agree with you on. I'll bring it to the tester forum.


a cover linebacker and a receiving TE should have the exact same ALG's. at least in my mind. I am all about equal and opposite.

The interactions I'm concerned about are also:

Strength built RE (Strength/Agility as Majors, Speed Minor: Str/Agi are the big two in block/breakblock interactions)) vs Pass Blocking OT( Popular for LT's I'm sure, only Agi as a Major Str is a minor. So it's basically .83 (Agi/Str) vs 1 pt (Agi/Str) for the first 21 levels. Is this going to be an issue later in the career? maybe, maybe not. I would hope that it's at least tested.

CB vs WR (.5 vs .4 ) is a little concerning as well.. however I think it could be argued that WR's need more therefore the .4 is fine.
Edited by slashxtreme on Feb 17, 2010 12:25:32
 
Preschooler05
offline
Link
 
My concern is that with giving the o-line and d-line 4 major attributes each, their strength levels won't be high enough to make for a more realistic sim. When a Guard pulls and meets a LB, he should be able to flatten him and take him out of the play; the same goes for a DT that breaks through the o-line and meets a FB. Those are the type of matchups you want with your OG or DT. The problem is that if they are running into a Hard-Hitting LB or a Blocking FB, they are essentially running into another DT or OG. Hard-Hitting LB has the addition of 1 minor as the only difference from a Strength DL, and a Blocking FB will actually be better than a Run-Blocking OG or C because it has Strength, Blocking, and Agility as majors.

The problem that this creates is that your team is no longer rewarded for getting o-linemen to second level or for d-linemen breaking a block as they will now run into another player of the same build or better.
Edited by Preschooler05 on Feb 17, 2010 13:39:58
 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Preschooler05
My concern is that with giving the o-line and d-line 4 major attributes each, their strength levels won't be high enough to make for a more realistic sim. When a Guard pulls and meets a LB, he should be able to flatten him and take him out of the play; the same goes for a DT that breaks through the o-line and meets a FB. Those are the type of matchups you want with your OG or DT. The problem is that if they are running into a Hard-Hitting LB or a Blocking FB, they are essentially running into another DT or OG. Hard-Hitting LB has the addition of 1 minor as the only difference from a Strength DL, and a Blocking FB will actually be better than a Run-Blocking OG or C because it has Strength, Blocking, and Agility as majors.

The problem that this creates is that your team is no longer rewarded for getting o-linemen to second level or for d-linemen breaking a block as they will now run into another player of the same build or better.


Yeah, that's a problem... except that this entire logic ignores the weight factor.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Also, just because you get the same level gain in an attribute doesn't mean you'll end up with the same overall total. There's no way that even hard-hitting LBs are going to be pushing strength as hard as guards will.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Also, just because you get the same level gain in an attribute doesn't mean you'll end up with the same overall total. There's no way that even hard-hitting LBs are going to be pushing strength as hard as guards will.


Yeah. This same argument applies to the WRs vs CBs complainers.
 
Preschooler05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sal Basss
Yeah, that's a problem... except that this entire logic ignores the weight factor.


You are right. The weight difference may be able to correct this if weight is factored in heavily, but you can create 270lb FBs and LBs, which are not small. The interaction among players at the second level should be watched during testing though rather than just focusing on o-line vs. d-line, RB's vs. LB's, etc.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
a cover linebacker and a receiving TE should have the exact same ALG's. at least in my mind. I am all about equal and opposite.


So you want your TE to have tackling? Or do you want your LB to have blocking?
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Also, just because you get the same level gain in an attribute doesn't mean you'll end up with the same overall total. There's no way that even hard-hitting LBs are going to be pushing strength as hard as guards will.


Hard Hitting LBs probably won't have much higher Strength than any other LBs as long as DvG stays the same tbh
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Preschooler05
My concern is that with giving the o-line and d-line 4 major attributes each, their strength levels won't be high enough to make for a more realistic sim. When a Guard pulls and meets a LB, he should be able to flatten him and take him out of the play; the same goes for a DT that breaks through the o-line and meets a FB. Those are the type of matchups you want with your OG or DT. The problem is that if they are running into a Hard-Hitting LB or a Blocking FB, they are essentially running into another DT or OG. Hard-Hitting LB has the addition of 1 minor as the only difference from a Strength DL, and a Blocking FB will actually be better than a Run-Blocking OG or C because it has Strength, Blocking, and Agility as majors.

The problem that this creates is that your team is no longer rewarded for getting o-linemen to second level or for d-linemen breaking a block as they will now run into another player of the same build or better.


Also, I see that while the O-Line can't have Str/Blk/Agil/(something else) because it would be "Too obviously good", the Blocking FB archetype gets to have exactly that. Blocking FBs are quite possibly going to get to better builds for blocking than the Oline no matter which route they take. And, while the FB can't be as heavy, he gets to be shorter by several inches, which is better for the blocker from what I understand - the weight/height situation is probably at best a wash, and at worse favoring the FB.

It's a little silly that people are going to wonder if it's worth it to make an O-Line of FBs (it's not, obviously, I can't see the gains overcoming the large OOP).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.