CB has an advantage in Return Specialist SA (not sure how much it helps, but other players don't have this) and an disadvantage of lower carrying. If Bort decides to reduce CB's carrying requirement when returning kicks, he will need to add Return Specialist SA to other positions too.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
zomgmike
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by merenoise
2000 yard rushing seasons are also not the norm in the NFL yet we have teams on GLB with 2 backs over 2000. QBs throwing 50 TDs? Almost unheard of in the NFL, here on GLB almost every league has one. So why can't we have LBs with over 20 FF in a season?
I don't care how many FFs a linebacker gets versus a gutted team. I care when it has a dramatic effect on teams that should be the same level of competition.
So offenses can score at will and RBs can have huge games both against guts and even teams but defenses shouldn't be able to counter with high FF or INT numbers?
Who said anything about allowing 2000 yard rushing seasons and where are offenses scoring at will?
In your league alone (SE Asia Pro) there are already 3 QBs with over 350 yards passing, and 2 RBs with over 200 yards rushing. There are only two players with more than 3 FFs.
My question is, if it is okay for offenses to put up unrealistic numbers why then is it not okay for defenses to do so?
i dont consider 350 yds passing and 200 yds rushing that unrealistic compared to 3 FF. Those offensive stats happen quite often in football, the 3 FF, not so much
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by merenoise
2000 yard rushing seasons are also not the norm in the NFL yet we have teams on GLB with 2 backs over 2000. QBs throwing 50 TDs? Almost unheard of in the NFL, here on GLB almost every league has one. So why can't we have LBs with over 20 FF in a season?
I don't care how many FFs a linebacker gets versus a gutted team. I care when it has a dramatic effect on teams that should be the same level of competition.
So offenses can score at will and RBs can have huge games both against guts and even teams but defenses shouldn't be able to counter with high FF or INT numbers?
Who said anything about allowing 2000 yard rushing seasons and where are offenses scoring at will?
In your league alone (SE Asia Pro) there are already 3 QBs with over 350 yards passing, and 2 RBs with over 200 yards rushing. There are only two players with more than 3 FFs.
My question is, if it is okay for offenses to put up unrealistic numbers why then is it not okay for defenses to do so?
i dont consider 350 yds passing and 200 yds rushing that unrealistic compared to 3 FF. Those offensive stats happen quite often in football, the 3 FF, not so much
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
So offenses can score at will and RBs can have huge games both against guts and even teams but defenses shouldn't be able to counter with high FF or INT numbers?
You can game plan against a RB, or a passing game. It's been proven time and time and time again. Most of the time, when a defense sucks, it's because the DC sucks. There isn't a huge difference between builds at the upper level.
Heck, you can even game plan against interceptions.
However, you can not game plan against fumbles. In fact, there is very, very little you can do, unless your team has an excess of funds, and even then there are issues. With players hitting 56, very few teams have excess.
So offenses can score at will and RBs can have huge games both against guts and even teams but defenses shouldn't be able to counter with high FF or INT numbers?
You can game plan against a RB, or a passing game. It's been proven time and time and time again. Most of the time, when a defense sucks, it's because the DC sucks. There isn't a huge difference between builds at the upper level.
Heck, you can even game plan against interceptions.
However, you can not game plan against fumbles. In fact, there is very, very little you can do, unless your team has an excess of funds, and even then there are issues. With players hitting 56, very few teams have excess.
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by j10er
For the most part, I think fumbling in the run game is fine.
It isn't. Fumbling on 2% of carries is normal for the NFL, and while GLB obviously isn't the NFL, it's still absurd to see some HBs fumbling on 40% of their carries like the ones in the OP.
Heh - I gave myself a little leeway with "For the most part".
I do agree, though, to a certain extent. Some builds need to be punished in order to keep balance.
Originally posted by j10er
For the most part, I think fumbling in the run game is fine.
It isn't. Fumbling on 2% of carries is normal for the NFL, and while GLB obviously isn't the NFL, it's still absurd to see some HBs fumbling on 40% of their carries like the ones in the OP.
Heh - I gave myself a little leeway with "For the most part".
I do agree, though, to a certain extent. Some builds need to be punished in order to keep balance.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
Define "high" please.
60+ carrying absolutely is "high" enough to avoid having 5+ fumble games. 2 or 3 fumbles in a game occasionally? Fine, but no one with 60+ carrying should ever fumble on 42% of their rushes. We don't expect WRs to have 70+ catching to avoid having 5+ drops in a game, so why should we expect something so dramatically different from HBs?
The reality is that everyone knows that fumbles are out of hand, but some trolls who are bitter about the Season 7 & 8 powerback arguments just don't care. The frustrating part for me is that I spent too much time arguing that powerbacks need to be fixed and now that fumbling needs to be fixed. I guess that's what comes with being both OC & DC, I'm not just pulling for one side of the ball to have something ridiculously overpowered.
Define "high" please.
60+ carrying absolutely is "high" enough to avoid having 5+ fumble games. 2 or 3 fumbles in a game occasionally? Fine, but no one with 60+ carrying should ever fumble on 42% of their rushes. We don't expect WRs to have 70+ catching to avoid having 5+ drops in a game, so why should we expect something so dramatically different from HBs?
The reality is that everyone knows that fumbles are out of hand, but some trolls who are bitter about the Season 7 & 8 powerback arguments just don't care. The frustrating part for me is that I spent too much time arguing that powerbacks need to be fixed and now that fumbling needs to be fixed. I guess that's what comes with being both OC & DC, I'm not just pulling for one side of the ball to have something ridiculously overpowered.
buffalobills_tw
offline
offline
Originally posted by j10er
However, you can not game plan against fumbles.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
However, you can not game plan against fumbles.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
merenoise
offline
offline
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by merenoise
So offenses can score at will and RBs can have huge games both against guts and even teams but defenses shouldn't be able to counter with high FF or INT numbers?
You can game plan against a RB, or a passing game. It's been proven time and time and time again. Most of the time, when a defense sucks, it's because the DC sucks. There isn't a huge difference between builds at the upper level.
Heck, you can even game plan against interceptions.
However, you can not game plan against fumbles. In fact, there is very, very little you can do, unless your team has an excess of funds, and even then there are issues. With players hitting 56, very few teams have excess.
You can absolutely game plan against players that have fumble machines. Throw it more. Tosses to the other side where that player can't get to the ball. Get creative. DCs have had to do far more work than OCs for a long time on GLB. Maybe now the pendulum will swing back the other way.
Originally posted by merenoise
So offenses can score at will and RBs can have huge games both against guts and even teams but defenses shouldn't be able to counter with high FF or INT numbers?
You can game plan against a RB, or a passing game. It's been proven time and time and time again. Most of the time, when a defense sucks, it's because the DC sucks. There isn't a huge difference between builds at the upper level.
Heck, you can even game plan against interceptions.
However, you can not game plan against fumbles. In fact, there is very, very little you can do, unless your team has an excess of funds, and even then there are issues. With players hitting 56, very few teams have excess.
You can absolutely game plan against players that have fumble machines. Throw it more. Tosses to the other side where that player can't get to the ball. Get creative. DCs have had to do far more work than OCs for a long time on GLB. Maybe now the pendulum will swing back the other way.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 12:46:56
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by j10er
However, you can not game plan against fumbles.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
At higher levels, when Carrying for these positions is in the 50-60+ range already?
No, it isn't an option.
The fact is, the rate of fumbles, especially on STs, has risen dramatically, with almost nothing changing. If you can explain why this is happening, I'd love to hear it.
Originally posted by j10er
However, you can not game plan against fumbles.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
At higher levels, when Carrying for these positions is in the 50-60+ range already?
No, it isn't an option.
The fact is, the rate of fumbles, especially on STs, has risen dramatically, with almost nothing changing. If you can explain why this is happening, I'd love to hear it.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
Read at least the OP before responding in a thread. The HBs in question both have over 60+ carrying and yet fumbled on 5 of their 12 rushes. Low carrying is absolutely not responsible for this fumble epidemic.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
Read at least the OP before responding in a thread. The HBs in question both have over 60+ carrying and yet fumbled on 5 of their 12 rushes. Low carrying is absolutely not responsible for this fumble epidemic.
zomgmike
offline
offline
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by j10er
However, you can not game plan against fumbles.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
At higher levels, when Carrying for these positions is in the 50-60+ range already?
No, it isn't an option.
The fact is, the rate of fumbles, especially on STs, has risen dramatically, with almost nothing changing. If you can explain why this is happening, I'd love to hear it.
+15 track star ---> +15 power tackler
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by j10er
However, you can not game plan against fumbles.
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
At higher levels, when Carrying for these positions is in the 50-60+ range already?
No, it isn't an option.
The fact is, the rate of fumbles, especially on STs, has risen dramatically, with almost nothing changing. If you can explain why this is happening, I'd love to hear it.
+15 track star ---> +15 power tackler
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 12:47:34
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
You can absolutely game plan against players that have fumble machines. Throw it more. Tosses to the other side where that player can't get to the ball. Get creative. DCs have had to do far more work than OCs for a long time on GLB. Maybe now the pendulum will swing back the other way.
I am an OC, and I do all you mentioned and more. I don't necessarily care about the LOLB or SS who forces an average of one fumble a game. I care about the defenders who are averaging a 33% or higher FF rate. That is not right.
And, pray tell, how do you game plan against fumbles on ST?
You can absolutely game plan against players that have fumble machines. Throw it more. Tosses to the other side where that player can't get to the ball. Get creative. DCs have had to do far more work than OCs for a long time on GLB. Maybe now the pendulum will swing back the other way.
I am an OC, and I do all you mentioned and more. I don't necessarily care about the LOLB or SS who forces an average of one fumble a game. I care about the defenders who are averaging a 33% or higher FF rate. That is not right.
And, pray tell, how do you game plan against fumbles on ST?
23yrwej
offline
offline
ZOMG a game with only 3 total fumbles:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=506955
And my team is forcing an average of 6-7 fumbles a game during this season so you obviously can find ways around the fumble problems.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=506955
And my team is forcing an average of 6-7 fumbles a game during this season so you obviously can find ways around the fumble problems.
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by zomgmike
+15 track star ---> +15 power tackler
So one VA has caused RBs to go from fumbling 3-5 times a season to 2-4 times a game? WOW! That's not an overpowered VA at all.
And that one little VA has caused upwards of 5 fumbles in a game on STs, up from maybe 1 a game? Yikes...
+15 track star ---> +15 power tackler
So one VA has caused RBs to go from fumbling 3-5 times a season to 2-4 times a game? WOW! That's not an overpowered VA at all.
And that one little VA has caused upwards of 5 fumbles in a game on STs, up from maybe 1 a game? Yikes...
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 12:52:03
buffalobills_tw
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
Read at least the OP before responding in a thread. The HBs in question both have over 60+ carrying and yet fumbled on 5 of their 12 rushes. Low carrying is absolutely not responsible for this fumble epidemic.
The question is if all HB with 60+ carrying fumble in such a higher rate or just a few. When other HBs not fumbling 5 out of 12, you can not say it like 60+ carrying doesn't help.
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Using SP on carrying is not an option?
Read at least the OP before responding in a thread. The HBs in question both have over 60+ carrying and yet fumbled on 5 of their 12 rushes. Low carrying is absolutely not responsible for this fumble epidemic.
The question is if all HB with 60+ carrying fumble in such a higher rate or just a few. When other HBs not fumbling 5 out of 12, you can not say it like 60+ carrying doesn't help.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 12:55:04
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























