User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Plax_Are_Meth
offline
Link
 
I agree, even if your player has 20 strength, but 80 tackling, the player should find a way to bring him down albeit giving up an extra 2-3 yards.

That's why the 100000 time suggested "go for the feet" tackling method needs to be implemented, to help out defensive players that can't possibly be expected to 2nd-3rd softcap strength/tackle and be efficient in pass coverage.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 09:30:36
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
So, thread summary? Did the whiners prevail or are things going to pretty much stay the way they are?


If Bort started the thread, does that mean Bort was whining?
 
Alpha Q
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
So, thread summary? Did the whiners prevail or are things going to pretty much stay the way they are?


pertinent question imo
 
NSab
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by NSab


Mike is awesome!


I have been trying to tell people


If the don't get it, you can't explain.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
So, thread summary? Did the whiners prevail or are things going to pretty much stay the way they are?


We don't really know until Bort makes changes, or doesn't.

Pretty sure that there were no whiners though, so don't really know what you are talking about there.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Mike Rogers



Tackler : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Tackling + (Vision+Agility/2)



I strongly disagree with the defender equation. One of the points that several people have made earlier in the thread is that while strength should ensure that defenders aren't dragged for yards after making a tackle, tackling should nonetheless be the single biggest factor in determining whether a successful tackle is made. So any formula that has strength and tackling given equal weight needs to be reworked.


And speed shouldn't be a factor, in my opinion.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gott
Originally posted by Capaneus

Originally posted by Mike Rogers




Tackler : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Tackling + (Vision+Agility/2)



I strongly disagree with the defender equation. One of the points that several people have made earlier in the thread is that while strength should ensure that defenders aren't dragged for yards after making a tackle, tackling should nonetheless be the single biggest factor in determining whether a successful tackle is made. So any formula that has strength and tackling given equal weight needs to be reworked.


And speed shouldn't be a factor, in my opinion.


Current speed the player is running at, right? Not the speed attribute.
^Of course this is relevant.
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TehKyou
Originally posted by Bort

We'll see how things go today with the vast range of stuff that happens across the world, and go from there. I think we're fairly dialed in to where I want it at this point though.


So does this mean the gang tackling is in right now? or tommorrow like the changelog says?

And for the fumble changes, can the person who forced the fumble, or the person who fumbled the ball cover it up yet?


 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gott


And speed shouldn't be a factor, in my opinion.


I can see your point. Impact has no bearing on a tackle's success...

 
cclanconan
offline
Link
 
I see all the runningbacks are of the opinion this guy should be invincible.
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva

general SA helps everyone not just the mlb, if my MLB had more maybe the rest of the team would do better.

Who said SAs are so great anyway? I know a couple of players who dominate in Pro and don't have any SAs at all.


SA's aren't great for the most part. But a good Defense General, Line General, D-Line General and Field General reduce fatigue, making the late game advantage pretty large. Losing that by needing 70 str/tackling as a MLB would be.... a bad trade IMO.

I don't mind changes, this one is likely a good one, good teams will adapt, bad teams will fold, thus is the life of GLB.
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RiverRat2
Originally posted by EastBayFunk

Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


nfl cornerbacks are pretty good at tackling IMO


Huh? A true POWER BACK licks his chops when thinking about being tackled by a skinny little CB. Think Jerome "The Bus" Bettis. What CB was going to tackle him solo twice in a row? My money is on "The Bus" 9 times out of 10. These guys as described should not get solo tackled very often, but swarm tackled.

If you ask me, energy and moral should take a good sized hit each time a player with less strength and "non competitive" SA's and VA's takes on a power back as described one on one.

Also, Newton's first law would be nice here (i.e., every action has an equal and opposite reaction), and the backs current energy (i.e., velocity and mass) at time of impact figured into the results, but I doubt such physics are actually programed into the game. Or are they?

Anyway, no way should a soft cap regularly take down a hundie. That's ridiculous.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 09:40:47
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
well a corner could cut his legs

and he would fall forward


Knocking a guys legs out is not an ideal tackling method, but can be effective once in a while. It's just a way little guys make big guys fall down, but an agile big guy will quickly learn to hop over a bowing little guy, or just juke around him, IMO.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supersoul
Originally posted by Gott



And speed shouldn't be a factor, in my opinion.


I can see your point. Impact has no bearing on a tackle's success...



Velocity may help when a RB is receiving and has his back to the defender, but more often than not, velocity won't help a tackler take down a back one on one. Often, if a defender is going full steam, they miss. (smaller defenders)

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 09:48:44
 
Plax_Are_Meth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FatNasty
Originally posted by the man of doom

well a corner could cut his legs

and he would fall forward


Knocking a guys legs out is not an ideal tackling method, but can be effective once in a while. It's just a way little guys make big guys fall down, but an agile big guy will quickly learn to hop over a bowing little guy, or just juke around him, IMO.


But that's a good thing. It would make it balanced, rather then having all the RB guys start yelling out that "no more avoiding tackles".

Good against low agility powerbacks, high risk against evasive backs.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.