User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Season 4 is over! What's in store for season 5 and beyond?
Page:
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JTullDotCom
I cannot believe I'm on page 60 something in orger to have to make a post, but here it is. Having been, and being a professionally trained programmer for over 20 years, I do really appreciate Borts incredible attempt at not only getting new information to people, but seriously requesting suggestions and likeley implementing the best ideas. This is an aggressive and hopefully progressive and not divisive way to keep everyone involved. This is an immense project, and just keeping in touch and getting feed back is becoming a tremendous project as well,
My 2 cents :
I'm concerned about the training. My hopes are it is simple enough for new people, as I'm sure those who've been around will pick it up quickly. Training, though, was a relatively easy process for new people before, if it gets too convoluted, it could keep many people from either joining or staying.
I support the injuries, as this will prompt owners to HAVE backups, therby making lowere level players more important, but make thise working hard to build hihger level players the appreciation for the opportunity to play. This is a violent sport, and to ignore injuries is ubrealistic at best. As long as it's kept to 3 games or less. And perhaps orthopedic equipment could be made available to allow a player to play sooner.
Offensive AI needs work, but I don't see anything that everyone will find somewhat acceptable for some time, As a programmer, I can barely imagine the headaches involved. My first GM position, I was told "This ain't Madden", and we shouldn't expect it to be. My suggestions to make the most impact for the short term are as follows:
a. Alllow the choice of which side the running play goes to in the AI.
b. ideally you have a blocking FB and a running FB. Be able to choose which on different running plays. Same with TE's.
Holding my breath on the new training, hoping it is a plus for the experienced players and not a deterrent for the new(er) players. I'm curious as to why the relaxed mode had to be removed.
Replays: Too often when a player is turning or rounding a corner, they seem to lose all momentum before getting moving again. I see this as a bug, and maybe can be looked at sometime in the future.
Injuries I've covered, and just an additional thought is that those injured can either do something to shorten injury time, ot do things to improve themselves while injured.
Best of luck to all.


Hmm if I'm the MLB and I see the blocking TEs come off the bench and onto the feild, Damned if I'm not stacking the box... a lot.
 
Vawn
The Red Pill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Originally posted by Vawn



Hope you sent BORT a HB screen and WR screen with those plays!



Oh yeah
 
Link
 
Originally posted by JTullDotCom
I cannot believe I'm on page 60 something in orger to have to make a post, but here it is. Having been, and being a professionally trained programmer for over 20 years, I do really appreciate Borts incredible attempt at not only getting new information to people, but seriously requesting suggestions and likeley implementing the best ideas. This is an aggressive and hopefully progressive and not divisive way to keep everyone involved. This is an immense project, and just keeping in touch and getting feed back is becoming a tremendous project as well,
My 2 cents :
I'm concerned about the training. My hopes are it is simple enough for new people, as I'm sure those who've been around will pick it up quickly. Training, though, was a relatively easy process for new people before, if it gets too convoluted, it could keep many people from either joining or staying.



Good point. Some football fans are going to show up, create their free player and say "WTF do tokens have to do with football". There really needs to be a balance between where it's easy enough for new guys to pick it up while giving older players variety.

There is some definite potential to scare guys away. There are going to be older players that get bored with it no matter what so there needs to be some kind of balance without making it a hassle for new guys to try and figure out. That was one of the great things about the old system.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
What worries me about the items is bort said they would be better than we could get from upgrades.

At level 32 a person can get +5 in total and that adds +20 when all four are combined. Even if they are not all in one attribute that is a large bonus.

Will we see +7 speed items on level 24 WRs, +3 speed/catching? If random equipment is going to be super uber pwnage I can definitely see people being P.O. when someone posts their great new item.

Do items really need to get better? Is that what the average using was clamoring for? More upgrades to gear. I may be completely divorced from what the average user wants but I think most people wanted a better solution to competitiveness not better items.


You can't get a +7 speed thing without a heck of a lot of upgrades. That would be too overpowering.
 
Goody_MoB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai
dammit now I have to retire all my players and start 'Slow-token-coin-fame-build them all... eitherwise all this time has been wasted training and we will have guys 4 levels lower than us with better attributes because they hit their caps faster and have already saved up all they need from training and whatnot to get special items that make them a beast beyond beasts. it's bad enough to have speed become a lame duck and force power-backs to get agility... then you make strength lame and we have to get agility/carrying up to ridiculous amounts to break tackles (im sorry but if a HB has 70 str and a guy with 12 str and 35 tackling can take you down every time... something is WRONG) now we are being thrown yet again into a nerf where players who start over are going to be great!

I suppose I'll go start my HB over again and start slow-token-OVER 9000!!!!!!-gloves of BreakTackle-build him til I am blue in the face.

I mean, if you are going to change things this much and throw around the whole 'hey it's still a beta' thing... don't charge us money for a damned beta that can be changed, rearranged, and thrown around until we no longer have what we payed for. Sorry if I seem cranky, bt I have had to re-think builds and change everything around, it's getting impossible to build a decent specialized player due to needing so many support skills, it's like your saying 'well the people who didn't know what they were doing were right... next we'll see all those OTs with tackling be able to 'cut block' better because it's 'like tackling'as if O-linemen weren't overpowered as is.

o-linemen: "So all we have to do is pump points into strength and blocking, and then even if the other person is 5 levels higher and is 30 points higher in strength, I won't get run over? or if they are 30 points higher in agility I can just hold them? sweet, now all we have to worry about is the fact that our WRs are not as fast as their CBs/Safeties..."

oh wait, bort nerfed CBs/safeties so even if someone with more speed and more agility is covering someone with less speed and less agility, they get beat, AND cannot catch up all the way to the endzone (and YES bort, it has happened, and I was ticked off, especially since we have depth, and the WRs build was open... it even happened 4 times with one being so early in the game, it couldn't have been energy issues. and yes, he entered the game at 100% energy.)

this game is evolving into something terrible, and instead of focusing on making plays go down right, you just turn it into more of a joke/rinky-dink rpg-type game. this was supposed to be about football, this was supposed to be 'make a player, make him how YOU want him, see how the guy YOU envision stacks up to the rest... now people have to follow strict guidelines or else they are terrible. Hell even SAs are a waste, and yet you give people the option to stack points into them at will from level one (unlike other RPGs where you have to get to a certain level to start running 'prestige classes' and what not. there are a lot of things about this game that are great, but nerfing players constantly, and making your oldest and most loyal base of players feel more and more ostracized as they cannot change their builds fast enough...

I know I rant, but this has been bothering me for a long time, focus on what you need to, stop nerfing players, or at least if you do, offer some sort of roll back to make it SOMEWHAT backtrackable (even though with the whole automatic gaines from levels things it means losing SPs overall) and maybe care about the older players a little.

The perspectives of a person who doesn't matter-
Atatakakunai.


AMEN!!! change is good but i feel like im playing a new game every season GLB V is next and next christmas GLB VI hmm seems just like final fantasy...there ya go bort theres a marketing idea
Last edited Sep 12, 2008 01:14:32
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
huh I forgot to mention the backs vision was higher as well, oh well.
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Bort is still up and reading...

I assume the biggest issue with programming new offense as many people have suggested is not simply making it work, because that isn't hard. It is testing it over and over again to make sure there isn't an exploit and that making sure that the defense reacts correctly to it.

If you give complete play-calling into the hands of the owners, it would be a logistical nightmare for Bort to make sure that you couldn't just create a play that couldn't be defended correctly by the defense. Someone, somewhere would find this play and the playbook would end up getting nerfed and people would spam the bugs forum and Bort's inbox with complaints....

I understand how cool it would be to be able to make your own offensive playbook, but at the same time, I understand that it isn't just a matter of doing it. It is a matter of making it fair and balanced.

Take your time Bort, because many of us still have confidence that you are doing everything in your power to make this the best Football Sim out there, and I for one am willing to be patient and see what you have in store for the future!
 
Southpaw247
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Goody_MoB
Originally posted by Atatakakunai

dammit now I have to retire all my players and start 'Slow-token-coin-fame-build them all... eitherwise all this time has been wasted training and we will have guys 4 levels lower than us with better attributes because they hit their caps faster and have already saved up all they need from training and whatnot to get special items that make them a beast beyond beasts. it's bad enough to have speed become a lame duck and force power-backs to get agility... then you make strength lame and we have to get agility/carrying up to ridiculous amounts to break tackles (im sorry but if a HB has 70 str and a guy with 12 str and 35 tackling can take you down every time... something is WRONG) now we are being thrown yet again into a nerf where players who start over are going to be great!

I suppose I'll go start my HB over again and start slow-token-OVER 9000!!!!!!-gloves of BreakTackle-build him til I am blue in the face.

I mean, if you are going to change things this much and throw around the whole 'hey it's still a beta' thing... don't charge us money for a damned beta that can be changed, rearranged, and thrown around until we no longer have what we payed for. Sorry if I seem cranky, bt I have had to re-think builds and change everything around, it's getting impossible to build a decent specialized player due to needing so many support skills, it's like your saying 'well the people who didn't know what they were doing were right... next we'll see all those OTs with tackling be able to 'cut block' better because it's 'like tackling'as if O-linemen weren't overpowered as is.

o-linemen: "So all we have to do is pump points into strength and blocking, and then even if the other person is 5 levels higher and is 30 points higher in strength, I won't get run over? or if they are 30 points higher in agility I can just hold them? sweet, now all we have to worry about is the fact that our WRs are not as fast as their CBs/Safeties..."

oh wait, bort nerfed CBs/safeties so even if someone with more speed and more agility is covering someone with less speed and less agility, they get beat, AND cannot catch up all the way to the endzone (and YES bort, it has happened, and I was ticked off, especially since we have depth, and the WRs build was open... it even happened 4 times with one being so early in the game, it couldn't have been energy issues. and yes, he entered the game at 100% energy.)

this game is evolving into something terrible, and instead of focusing on making plays go down right, you just turn it into more of a joke/rinky-dink rpg-type game. this was supposed to be about football, this was supposed to be 'make a player, make him how YOU want him, see how the guy YOU envision stacks up to the rest... now people have to follow strict guidelines or else they are terrible. Hell even SAs are a waste, and yet you give people the option to stack points into them at will from level one (unlike other RPGs where you have to get to a certain level to start running 'prestige classes' and what not. there are a lot of things about this game that are great, but nerfing players constantly, and making your oldest and most loyal base of players feel more and more ostracized as they cannot change their builds fast enough...

I know I rant, but this has been bothering me for a long time, focus on what you need to, stop nerfing players, or at least if you do, offer some sort of roll back to make it SOMEWHAT backtrackable (even though with the whole automatic gaines from levels things it means losing SPs overall) and maybe care about the older players a little.

The perspectives of a person who doesn't matter-
Atatakakunai.


AHMEN!!! change is good but i feel like im playing a new game every season GLB V is next and next christmas GLB VI hmm seems just like final fantasy...there ya go bort theres a marketing idea


I have to agree with the original poster here. I left an MMORPG because it was changed so much form the original it was not fun anymore. I started playing this game because it was about football not the RPG aspect. Bort this has the potential to be one of the greatest games on the market, but I think you need to target football fans, not RPG fans.
 
Goody_MoB
offline
Link
 
The new changes are like all the old companies putting bells and whistles and little shit thats shiny but doesnt matter to attract new people...thats what this feels like...a bunch of shiny nice looking crap tossed on to grab attention saying hey look at us we're hip...we're with it...tucka tucka tucka tucka tucka tucka tucka....aaaahhhhaaa (if anyone knows where im quoting that from then you rock and you have to let us all know what its from)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai
dammit now I have to retire all my players and start 'Slow-token-coin-fame-build them all... eitherwise all this time has been wasted training and we will have guys 4 levels lower than us with better attributes because they hit their caps faster and have already saved up all they need from training and whatnot to get special items that make them a beast beyond beasts. it's bad enough to have speed become a lame duck and force power-backs to get agility... then you make strength lame and we have to get agility/carrying up to ridiculous amounts to break tackles (im sorry but if a HB has 70 str and a guy with 12 str and 35 tackling can take you down every time... something is WRONG) now we are being thrown yet again into a nerf where players who start over are going to be great!

I suppose I'll go start my HB over again and start slow-token-OVER 9000!!!!!!-gloves of BreakTackle-build him til I am blue in the face.

I mean, if you are going to change things this much and throw around the whole 'hey it's still a beta' thing... don't charge us money for a damned beta that can be changed, rearranged, and thrown around until we no longer have what we payed for. Sorry if I seem cranky, bt I have had to re-think builds and change everything around, it's getting impossible to build a decent specialized player due to needing so many support skills, it's like your saying 'well the people who didn't know what they were doing were right... next we'll see all those OTs with tackling be able to 'cut block' better because it's 'like tackling'as if O-linemen weren't overpowered as is.

o-linemen: "So all we have to do is pump points into strength and blocking, and then even if the other person is 5 levels higher and is 30 points higher in strength, I won't get run over? or if they are 30 points higher in agility I can just hold them? sweet, now all we have to worry about is the fact that our WRs are not as fast as their CBs/Safeties..."

oh wait, bort nerfed CBs/safeties so even if someone with more speed and more agility is covering someone with less speed and less agility, they get beat, AND cannot catch up all the way to the endzone (and YES bort, it has happened, and I was ticked off, especially since we have depth, and the WRs build was open... it even happened 4 times with one being so early in the game, it couldn't have been energy issues. and yes, he entered the game at 100% energy.)

this game is evolving into something terrible, and instead of focusing on making plays go down right, you just turn it into more of a joke/rinky-dink rpg-type game. this was supposed to be about football, this was supposed to be 'make a player, make him how YOU want him, see how the guy YOU envision stacks up to the rest... now people have to follow strict guidelines or else they are terrible. Hell even SAs are a waste, and yet you give people the option to stack points into them at will from level one (unlike other RPGs where you have to get to a certain level to start running 'prestige classes' and what not. there are a lot of things about this game that are great, but nerfing players constantly, and making your oldest and most loyal base of players feel more and more ostracized as they cannot change their builds fast enough...

I know I rant, but this has been bothering me for a long time, focus on what you need to, stop nerfing players, or at least if you do, offer some sort of roll back to make it SOMEWHAT backtrackable (even though with the whole automatic gaines from levels things it means losing SPs overall) and maybe care about the older players a little.

The perspectives of a person who doesn't matter-
Atatakakunai.


+10000000
 
nathbear
offline
Link
 
Firstly, I think the changes really seem to be quite well thought out and should definitely provide an additional layer of depth to PLAYER management, which is incredibly important as not everyone can be involved in team management.

One thing that I really hope is being considered, however, is the impact that these changes will have on the high level economy.

Up until the level 32 equipment upgrade costs, cash was almost meaningless in this game. You simply couldn't run out. That all changes with level 32 equipment upgrades costing 800k per player, though.

Under the new training system players cannot even take a super cheap training option to help offset some of their equipment costs themselves. Player wages are going to have to be high enough to AT LEAST cover the costs of normal training and will likely leave very little room for saving.

Teams are going to be left with the responsibility of finding a LOT more cash for players to cover all of these features as under the current financial system the players themselves are not going to be able to afford their own toys. A brilliant initial step has been taken here with the development a team bank account to draw money from to cover these costs however I would STRONGLY urge you to consider thinking long and hard about additional ways for TEAMS to generate the cash to pay for these features at the high end of the game or you're going to find yourself with a LOT more gutted/sold teams as high level team after high level team shuts up shop because they simply cannot afford to stay in business.

One of my many hats in the real world is that of an economist and I have direct experience building economies of online sports management games so if you want any consulting advice on these matters, please feel free to contact me any time via in game PM.
 
merk
offline
Link
 
Can we at least give this a season tryout before calling it bad/hitting the panic button?
 
Southpaw247
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Goody_MoB
The new changes are like all the old companies putting bells and whistles and little shit thats shiny but doesnt matter to attract new people...thats what this feels like...a bunch of shiny nice looking crap tossed on to grab attention saying hey look at us we're hip...we're with it...tucka tucka tucka tucka tucka tucka tucka....aaaahhhhaaa (if anyone knows where im quoting that from then you rock and you have to let us all know what its from)


Welcome to my underground laaaaiir. As you all know I have been frozen for 30 years.
 
Goody_MoB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Southpaw247
Originally posted by Goody_MoB

Originally posted by Atatakakunai


dammit now I have to retire all my players and start 'Slow-token-coin-fame-build them all... eitherwise all this time has been wasted training and we will have guys 4 levels lower than us with better attributes because they hit their caps faster and have already saved up all they need from training and whatnot to get special items that make them a beast beyond beasts. it's bad enough to have speed become a lame duck and force power-backs to get agility... then you make strength lame and we have to get agility/carrying up to ridiculous amounts to break tackles (im sorry but if a HB has 70 str and a guy with 12 str and 35 tackling can take you down every time... something is WRONG) now we are being thrown yet again into a nerf where players who start over are going to be great!

I suppose I'll go start my HB over again and start slow-token-OVER 9000!!!!!!-gloves of BreakTackle-build him til I am blue in the face.

I mean, if you are going to change things this much and throw around the whole 'hey it's still a beta' thing... don't charge us money for a damned beta that can be changed, rearranged, and thrown around until we no longer have what we payed for. Sorry if I seem cranky, bt I have had to re-think builds and change everything around, it's getting impossible to build a decent specialized player due to needing so many support skills, it's like your saying 'well the people who didn't know what they were doing were right... next we'll see all those OTs with tackling be able to 'cut block' better because it's 'like tackling'as if O-linemen weren't overpowered as is.

o-linemen: "So all we have to do is pump points into strength and blocking, and then even if the other person is 5 levels higher and is 30 points higher in strength, I won't get run over? or if they are 30 points higher in agility I can just hold them? sweet, now all we have to worry about is the fact that our WRs are not as fast as their CBs/Safeties..."

oh wait, bort nerfed CBs/safeties so even if someone with more speed and more agility is covering someone with less speed and less agility, they get beat, AND cannot catch up all the way to the endzone (and YES bort, it has happened, and I was ticked off, especially since we have depth, and the WRs build was open... it even happened 4 times with one being so early in the game, it couldn't have been energy issues. and yes, he entered the game at 100% energy.)

this game is evolving into something terrible, and instead of focusing on making plays go down right, you just turn it into more of a joke/rinky-dink rpg-type game. this was supposed to be about football, this was supposed to be 'make a player, make him how YOU want him, see how the guy YOU envision stacks up to the rest... now people have to follow strict guidelines or else they are terrible. Hell even SAs are a waste, and yet you give people the option to stack points into them at will from level one (unlike other RPGs where you have to get to a certain level to start running 'prestige classes' and what not. there are a lot of things about this game that are great, but nerfing players constantly, and making your oldest and most loyal base of players feel more and more ostracized as they cannot change their builds fast enough...

I know I rant, but this has been bothering me for a long time, focus on what you need to, stop nerfing players, or at least if you do, offer some sort of roll back to make it SOMEWHAT backtrackable (even though with the whole automatic gaines from levels things it means losing SPs overall) and maybe care about the older players a little.

The perspectives of a person who doesn't matter-
Atatakakunai.


AHMEN!!! change is good but i feel like im playing a new game every season GLB V is next and next christmas GLB VI hmm seems just like final fantasy...there ya go bort theres a marketing idea


I have to agree with the original poster here. I left an MMORPG because it was changed so much form the original it was not fun anymore. I started playing this game because it was about football not the RPG aspect. Bort this has the potential to be one of the greatest games on the market, but I think you need to target football fans, not RPG fans.


I agree...the RPG fans have plenty of other RPGs to go to if they dont like this one....but the people that like this one because of the football have no where else to go...show me another MMORPG football game...point me in the direction and ill gladly check it out....oh wait there isnt one...guess im just shit out of luck huh...
 
erebus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Goody_MoB
Originally posted by Southpaw247

Originally posted by Goody_MoB


Originally posted by Atatakakunai



dammit now I have to retire all my players and start 'Slow-token-coin-fame-build them all... eitherwise all this time has been wasted training and we will have guys 4 levels lower than us with better attributes because they hit their caps faster and have already saved up all they need from training and whatnot to get special items that make them a beast beyond beasts. it's bad enough to have speed become a lame duck and force power-backs to get agility... then you make strength lame and we have to get agility/carrying up to ridiculous amounts to break tackles (im sorry but if a HB has 70 str and a guy with 12 str and 35 tackling can take you down every time... something is WRONG) now we are being thrown yet again into a nerf where players who start over are going to be great!

I suppose I'll go start my HB over again and start slow-token-OVER 9000!!!!!!-gloves of BreakTackle-build him til I am blue in the face.

I mean, if you are going to change things this much and throw around the whole 'hey it's still a beta' thing... don't charge us money for a damned beta that can be changed, rearranged, and thrown around until we no longer have what we payed for. Sorry if I seem cranky, bt I have had to re-think builds and change everything around, it's getting impossible to build a decent specialized player due to needing so many support skills, it's like your saying 'well the people who didn't know what they were doing were right... next we'll see all those OTs with tackling be able to 'cut block' better because it's 'like tackling'as if O-linemen weren't overpowered as is.

o-linemen: "So all we have to do is pump points into strength and blocking, and then even if the other person is 5 levels higher and is 30 points higher in strength, I won't get run over? or if they are 30 points higher in agility I can just hold them? sweet, now all we have to worry about is the fact that our WRs are not as fast as their CBs/Safeties..."

oh wait, bort nerfed CBs/safeties so even if someone with more speed and more agility is covering someone with less speed and less agility, they get beat, AND cannot catch up all the way to the endzone (and YES bort, it has happened, and I was ticked off, especially since we have depth, and the WRs build was open... it even happened 4 times with one being so early in the game, it couldn't have been energy issues. and yes, he entered the game at 100% energy.)

this game is evolving into something terrible, and instead of focusing on making plays go down right, you just turn it into more of a joke/rinky-dink rpg-type game. this was supposed to be about football, this was supposed to be 'make a player, make him how YOU want him, see how the guy YOU envision stacks up to the rest... now people have to follow strict guidelines or else they are terrible. Hell even SAs are a waste, and yet you give people the option to stack points into them at will from level one (unlike other RPGs where you have to get to a certain level to start running 'prestige classes' and what not. there are a lot of things about this game that are great, but nerfing players constantly, and making your oldest and most loyal base of players feel more and more ostracized as they cannot change their builds fast enough...

I know I rant, but this has been bothering me for a long time, focus on what you need to, stop nerfing players, or at least if you do, offer some sort of roll back to make it SOMEWHAT backtrackable (even though with the whole automatic gaines from levels things it means losing SPs overall) and maybe care about the older players a little.

The perspectives of a person who doesn't matter-
Atatakakunai.


AHMEN!!! change is good but i feel like im playing a new game every season GLB V is next and next christmas GLB VI hmm seems just like final fantasy...there ya go bort theres a marketing idea


I have to agree with the original poster here. I left an MMORPG because it was changed so much form the original it was not fun anymore. I started playing this game because it was about football not the RPG aspect. Bort this has the potential to be one of the greatest games on the market, but I think you need to target football fans, not RPG fans.


I agree...the RPG fans have plenty of other RPGs to go to if they dont like this one....but the people that like this one because of the football have no where else to go...show me another MMORPG football game...point me in the direction and ill gladly check it out....oh wait there isnt one...guess im just shit out of luck huh...


http://www.easports.com/nflheadcoach09/playbook.jsp

may not be MMORPG but it does have an online component
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.