Originally posted by JTullDotCom
I cannot believe I'm on page 60 something in orger to have to make a post, but here it is. Having been, and being a professionally trained programmer for over 20 years, I do really appreciate Borts incredible attempt at not only getting new information to people, but seriously requesting suggestions and likeley implementing the best ideas. This is an aggressive and hopefully progressive and not divisive way to keep everyone involved. This is an immense project, and just keeping in touch and getting feed back is becoming a tremendous project as well,
My 2 cents :
I'm concerned about the training. My hopes are it is simple enough for new people, as I'm sure those who've been around will pick it up quickly. Training, though, was a relatively easy process for new people before, if it gets too convoluted, it could keep many people from either joining or staying.
I support the injuries, as this will prompt owners to HAVE backups, therby making lowere level players more important, but make thise working hard to build hihger level players the appreciation for the opportunity to play. This is a violent sport, and to ignore injuries is ubrealistic at best. As long as it's kept to 3 games or less. And perhaps orthopedic equipment could be made available to allow a player to play sooner.
Offensive AI needs work, but I don't see anything that everyone will find somewhat acceptable for some time, As a programmer, I can barely imagine the headaches involved. My first GM position, I was told "This ain't Madden", and we shouldn't expect it to be. My suggestions to make the most impact for the short term are as follows:
a. Alllow the choice of which side the running play goes to in the AI.
b. ideally you have a blocking FB and a running FB. Be able to choose which on different running plays. Same with TE's.
Holding my breath on the new training, hoping it is a plus for the experienced players and not a deterrent for the new(er) players. I'm curious as to why the relaxed mode had to be removed.
Replays: Too often when a player is turning or rounding a corner, they seem to lose all momentum before getting moving again. I see this as a bug, and maybe can be looked at sometime in the future.
Injuries I've covered, and just an additional thought is that those injured can either do something to shorten injury time, ot do things to improve themselves while injured.
Best of luck to all.
Hmm if I'm the MLB and I see the blocking TEs come off the bench and onto the feild, Damned if I'm not stacking the box... a lot.
I cannot believe I'm on page 60 something in orger to have to make a post, but here it is. Having been, and being a professionally trained programmer for over 20 years, I do really appreciate Borts incredible attempt at not only getting new information to people, but seriously requesting suggestions and likeley implementing the best ideas. This is an aggressive and hopefully progressive and not divisive way to keep everyone involved. This is an immense project, and just keeping in touch and getting feed back is becoming a tremendous project as well,
My 2 cents :
I'm concerned about the training. My hopes are it is simple enough for new people, as I'm sure those who've been around will pick it up quickly. Training, though, was a relatively easy process for new people before, if it gets too convoluted, it could keep many people from either joining or staying.
I support the injuries, as this will prompt owners to HAVE backups, therby making lowere level players more important, but make thise working hard to build hihger level players the appreciation for the opportunity to play. This is a violent sport, and to ignore injuries is ubrealistic at best. As long as it's kept to 3 games or less. And perhaps orthopedic equipment could be made available to allow a player to play sooner.
Offensive AI needs work, but I don't see anything that everyone will find somewhat acceptable for some time, As a programmer, I can barely imagine the headaches involved. My first GM position, I was told "This ain't Madden", and we shouldn't expect it to be. My suggestions to make the most impact for the short term are as follows:
a. Alllow the choice of which side the running play goes to in the AI.
b. ideally you have a blocking FB and a running FB. Be able to choose which on different running plays. Same with TE's.
Holding my breath on the new training, hoping it is a plus for the experienced players and not a deterrent for the new(er) players. I'm curious as to why the relaxed mode had to be removed.
Replays: Too often when a player is turning or rounding a corner, they seem to lose all momentum before getting moving again. I see this as a bug, and maybe can be looked at sometime in the future.
Injuries I've covered, and just an additional thought is that those injured can either do something to shorten injury time, ot do things to improve themselves while injured.
Best of luck to all.
Hmm if I'm the MLB and I see the blocking TEs come off the bench and onto the feild, Damned if I'm not stacking the box... a lot.






























