User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Actually, the "QB's don't get pulled if they're the unquestioned starter" argument COULD be the topic for another concept thread. I had recommended something like this like 6 weeks ago..


First, Imagine if Players had a "Popularity Attribute", and this attribute affected game attendance, fan support - whatever.. and that the more this player played, the more income the team would have. If such an attribute existed - then there could very well be an "Unquestioned Starter"; because, even if the player was only "OK" - they might bring the team a lot of money. The game currently has nothing like this - so such an argument certainly fails.. but the game Could pretty easily have something like this - and once upon a time, in another thread, I discussed how such a thing could exist within GLB. I may, if I get bored enough, start up a thread regarding this.. but I'm sure that if someone else starts a thread and I feel motivated enough - I'll post an in depth description of this - which almost no one would read.


Amazing.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by sjmay

LMAO hello MCFLY he is a shit QB, end of story, you think because he only threw 15 picks he was GOOD? I mean granted you are new here, but builds are a lot more telling than "stats"

Your continued participation in this thread amounts to Barney Gumble heckling the American Institute of Physics. You obviously think that you're making compelling points and contributing to a productive discussion due to your own intellectual limitations. Unfortunately that's not something anyone can fix for you.


Originally posted by SCACE

Even though anything can happen on any given sunday, as the saying goes.

Simulations by definition are supposed to produce results that mimic those produced by their subject. They are not supposed to be unbounded or places where grossly unrealistic results do occur.


Originally posted by Cruzi

What part of "your QB blows" and "their secondary was picking off passes left and right before boosting 3 levels prior to this game" is so hard for you to wrap your head around? As for your "QBs don't get pulled if they're the unquestioned starter" argument, that doesn't apply here. GLB teams don't have player egos (agents aside) or public relations issues to deal with.

I'm arguing on the basis of facts, not hyperbole. The fact is that Slim had the 6th best interception rate in that conference, and ranked only slightly behind the 3rd best. Meanwhile Miami's interception rate was good but not exceptional. Any attempt to pretend that this was an expected or appropriate result is so preposterous as to eradicate any further credibility.

And make up your mind regarding the QBs being pulled issue. Some people were saying that QBs don't get 9+ interceptions because they get pulled before they can, but that was factually wrong. QBs have the opportunity to get 9+ interceptions, but they don't because it's not a realistic result.


LMAO yes, because even though we have showed you NUMEROUS TIMES, that a team can get intercepted 10 times, it is, grossly unrealstic that it happened here.

THAT is what you are arguing you tool.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
To conclude: If you lessened the effect of confidence AND implemented my suggestions which add realism to the game, you would end up on the other side of the fence, where not nearly enough interceptions are thrown and you never approach the outliers.

Both options solve the problem, but in different ways. One adds realism to the game by adding more options. The other lowers the importance of a key attribute allowing players to continue to neglect it.

While both should achieve more realistic results, one makes A LOT more sense than the other.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by

Which brings us back to: In 1978, Cal threw 10 interceptions against UCLA on 52 pass attempts.

Which still doesn't equal the rate of 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer attempts, something that GLB has achieved at least twice in season 3 alone.



In 1942, Detroit threw 9 interceptions on 29 attempts against Green Bay.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by SCACE


ken - I see what you are saying in terms of YPA. Some teams seem to "get it", and maybe that is game planning + the right builds, not sure. And a lot of it is padded vs. worse competition, but not always, and you could argue that happens in real football as well (the joy of averages).

I hope offense gets the correct tweaks for season 4 to make it more realistic.


Thank you. I applaud your willingness to listen to the argument and, when presented with facts that dispute your original position, alter your position.

I hope that unless Bort already gets it it about ypa, that he reads the thread and "gets it" as well. I'm sure at the very least some Mod will read it, and if it convinced you, hopefully it will also convince the Mod, who may draw Bort's attention to that part of the thread.


Am I remembering right that last season there was a downgrade to the QB's due to unrealistic completion %'s that were complained about? I seem to recall that, which is probably what helped create the current situation.


You are right, and I believe that that is what created the current situation with passing (plus the overeffectiveness of wrap-up tackling, which makes it too easy for CB's to neglect tackling, leaving them with more points for coverage skills; at least that part will be addressed).

I hope that Bort can come to understand-- if he hasn't already-- that ypa is the key stat. It's okay if completion percentage is "too high" if yards per completion (ypc) is "too low," the combo of which would still lead to a fairly realistic ypa.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
In 1942, Detroit threw 9 interceptions on 29 attempts against Green Bay.


Yea, but it's cold in both Detroit and Green Bay, plus we were in the middle of a War that year.. both things which don't happen in GLB - so that game doesn't count.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
We've seen his build. Face it. It's beyond debate. The QB's build is atrocious.

If you can manage to rub two functioning brain cells together, then try to grasp this point. The statistical result of what actually happened in performance during the regular season is far more significant in this argument than your OPINION of the QB's build. Dost thou understand thus much English?


Originally posted by SCACE
While we do both seem to agree something is up here, we completely disagree on what the problem and what the solution is.

Actually you've repeatedly acknowledged that the cascade effect of confidence penalties is real and is a problem. Only you've said that you want ways to hopefully avoid that problem, whereas I'd just rather fix the problem directly. Adding the elements you describe wouldn't fix the underlying issue, they'd only reduce its frequency of occurring. While that would be a step in the right direction, it's a bit like using "Run Flat" on a tire puncture. It helps, but it's not fixing the issue. I would support the changes you propose, but something also needs to be done to prevent morale penalties from completely overwhelming every other determinant.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Thanks Ken, good convo. I know wrap up is getting nerfed, which is perfect...I still think it will be an overly effective way to tackle someone, but I hope the fumbles caused by it will become almost non-existant unless the levels/builds are so far out of whack a fumble should probably occur even on wrap up

Not sure if I recall seeing anything about the passing game getting tweaked, but if the overall offense gets a boost + the new AI, hopefully that will be enough to balance it out.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Amazing.


I love this thread, and will play taps when it finally gets buried.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
To conclude: If you lessened the effect of confidence AND implemented my suggestions which add realism to the game, you would end up on the other side of the fence, where not nearly enough interceptions are thrown and you never approach the outliers. Both options solve the problem, but in different ways. One adds realism to the game by adding more options. The other lowers the importance of a key attribute allowing players to continue to neglect it. While both should achieve more realistic results, one makes A LOT more sense than the other.

Indeed. Fixing a problem makes "A LOT more sense" than seeking ways to avoid it. You keep trying to pretend that what I'm suggesting would make confidence meaningless, which is a lie because you know that's not true. Right now confidence has a disproportionate effect on game outcomes. I'd like to see it brought back into balance with the other result determinants, and I think the problem lies with flat morale penalties instead of progressive ones.
 
Zeke0123
offline
Link
 
Now this has turned into a VERY productive thread..nice going SCACE jdbolick Ken1 etc.
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
1000 posts!!!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Our team went off for 7.9 YPA this season, and played well even versus the better teams in our conference...so I'm intrigued to see what any boost to the offense would do for us


Yep, your team did a great job. Some of that ypa may have been due to beating overmatched teams as you had a 16-0 record.

But the key to note is that in your league, your team and one other did better than the NFL average in ypa, one team equalled it, and the other 29 were mostly pretty far below "average."

Because there's less parity in GLB leagues than in the NFL, I'd expect that if ypa were fixed your team might be getting 9 ypa or something (although probably closer to 7.5 in the tougher games against teams with really good defenses).

But still, whether it's your players or your tactics, you deserve credit for beating the odds.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE

To conclude: If you lessened the effect of confidence AND implemented my suggestions which add realism to the game, you would end up on the other side of the fence, where not nearly enough interceptions are thrown and you never approach the outliers. Both options solve the problem, but in different ways. One adds realism to the game by adding more options. The other lowers the importance of a key attribute allowing players to continue to neglect it. While both should achieve more realistic results, one makes A LOT more sense than the other.

Indeed. Fixing a problem makes "A LOT more sense" than seeking ways to avoid it. You keep trying to pretend that what I'm suggesting would make confidence meaningless, which is a lie because you know that's not true. Right now confidence has a disproportionate effect on game outcomes. I'd like to see it brought back into balance with the other result determinants, and I think the problem lies with flat morale penalties instead of progressive ones.


How do you figure confidence has a disproportionate effect on the game outcomes? Because he threw 10 picks and that never happens, now you are sounding like Larry,

This QB, had no throwing skill, had no vision, had no strength to throw the ball, and to top it off, didn't believe he could throw the ball,

Why are we wondering why he got picked off so much, seriously?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
In 1942, Detroit threw 9 interceptions on 29 attempts against Green Bay.

Momentarily overlooking the fact that you wanted earlier eras of the NFL excluded because they weren't offensively similar to the modern era, you have one example from 66 years ago of something that has happened at least twice in GLB this season alone (with many more games, yes, but not enough to cover nearly that time period). Again, it is beyond obvious that there is a flaw in the way that morale penalties are applied. The existence of this cascade effect is easily observable, and it's going to keep being a problem unless it's addressed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.