Will older players get to redo their height/weight to fit their archetype if they choose to go the archetype route?
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdwillemin
Will older players get to redo their height/weight to fit their archetype if they choose to go the archetype route?
No. The height/weight restrictions won't apply to older players, only to new players.
Will older players get to redo their height/weight to fit their archetype if they choose to go the archetype route?
No. The height/weight restrictions won't apply to older players, only to new players.
Sooner19
offline
offline
Originally posted by AngryDragon
This got me thinking about where SAs are positioned in relation to the bonus and penalty SAs.
I do not know that the bonuses or penalties are but to use LBs as an example. I see that Coverage LBs have a bonus in diving tackle and swat ball and a penalty in Monster Hit and Shed Block. The current position of Shed Block and Swat Ball forces agents to invest in a penalty SA in order to invest in their bonus SA Swat Ball.
interesting, anyone know if this has been addressed?
This got me thinking about where SAs are positioned in relation to the bonus and penalty SAs.
I do not know that the bonuses or penalties are but to use LBs as an example. I see that Coverage LBs have a bonus in diving tackle and swat ball and a penalty in Monster Hit and Shed Block. The current position of Shed Block and Swat Ball forces agents to invest in a penalty SA in order to invest in their bonus SA Swat Ball.
interesting, anyone know if this has been addressed?
chazno
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sooner19
interesting, anyone know if this has been addressed?
I brought it up about 4 pages ago, nobody cares apparently
interesting, anyone know if this has been addressed?
I brought it up about 4 pages ago, nobody cares apparently
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by chazno
I brought it up about 4 pages ago, nobody cares apparently
It's more or less unavoidable.
I brought it up about 4 pages ago, nobody cares apparently
It's more or less unavoidable.
Originally posted by jdbolick
It's more or less unavoidable.
This and penalized doesn't mean non existent. Points put into shed blocks will still help the LOLB who just wanted to get to swat ball.
It's more or less unavoidable.
This and penalized doesn't mean non existent. Points put into shed blocks will still help the LOLB who just wanted to get to swat ball.
Originally posted by AngryDragon
This got me thinking about where SAs are positioned in relation to the bonus and penalty SAs.
I do not know that the bonuses or penalties are but to use LBs as an example. I see that Coverage LBs have a bonus in diving tackle and swat ball and a penalty in Monster Hit and Shed Block. The current position of Shed Block and Swat Ball forces agents to invest in a penalty SA in order to invest in their bonus SA Swat Ball.
I have never heard any kind of a whisper that SA trees will be re-shuffled...
and no matter what - the penalty SA's will still be in the tree - so I expect that yes - you will have to invest in the penalty SA's in order to pump your bonus sa's....(in some cases)
tomorrow's Q&A session would probably be a good place to ask that question - but I expect it will be what I've already said.
This got me thinking about where SAs are positioned in relation to the bonus and penalty SAs.
I do not know that the bonuses or penalties are but to use LBs as an example. I see that Coverage LBs have a bonus in diving tackle and swat ball and a penalty in Monster Hit and Shed Block. The current position of Shed Block and Swat Ball forces agents to invest in a penalty SA in order to invest in their bonus SA Swat Ball.
I have never heard any kind of a whisper that SA trees will be re-shuffled...
and no matter what - the penalty SA's will still be in the tree - so I expect that yes - you will have to invest in the penalty SA's in order to pump your bonus sa's....(in some cases)
tomorrow's Q&A session would probably be a good place to ask that question - but I expect it will be what I've already said.
Edited by TxSteve on Feb 15, 2010 20:37:34
Originally posted by Maddoc
And once again, we learn that LBs are SA-impaired. They are fucked every which way.
here's to hoping the SA evaluation gives LB something to cheer about!

And once again, we learn that LBs are SA-impaired. They are fucked every which way.
here's to hoping the SA evaluation gives LB something to cheer about!

tuba_samurai
offline
offline
Originally posted by TxSteve
here's to hoping the SA evaluation gives LB something to cheer about!

Couldn't hurt.
here's to hoping the SA evaluation gives LB something to cheer about!

Couldn't hurt.
HULK
offline
offline
Originally posted by Maddoc
I could be wrong but...
They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"
They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA
Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
I really think its a poor choice to have the Bonus SA before the Archetype SA in the 3rd tree.
The simple fact is that some archetypes won't have a good or relevant Bonus SA (power back and speed WRs will be hard up imo). But they'll want their archetype SA.
Basically you're forced into an SA you don't want here.
Maybe there should be a "no bonus SA" option as well. I can think of a few places where I would think it makes sense to forgo it.
I could be wrong but...
They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"
They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA
Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
I really think its a poor choice to have the Bonus SA before the Archetype SA in the 3rd tree.
The simple fact is that some archetypes won't have a good or relevant Bonus SA (power back and speed WRs will be hard up imo). But they'll want their archetype SA.
Basically you're forced into an SA you don't want here.
Maybe there should be a "no bonus SA" option as well. I can think of a few places where I would think it makes sense to forgo it.
pottsman
offline
offline
Originally posted by HULK
Originally posted by Maddoc
I could be wrong but...
They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"
They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA
Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
I really think its a poor choice to have the Bonus SA before the Archetype SA in the 3rd tree.
The simple fact is that some archetypes won't have a good or relevant Bonus SA (power back and speed WRs will be hard up imo). But they'll want their archetype SA.
Basically you're forced into an SA you don't want here.
Maybe there should be a "no bonus SA" option as well. I can think of a few places where I would think it makes sense to forgo it.
There is always a SA that will be marginally useful. Think of it as everybody's own personal Smooth Operator.
Power HBs can make it be something like Sticky Hands or Lead Block to run with the FB, Spot Blitz for pass blocking. Speed WRs can get Cover Up to hold onto passes better. It needs to be there for balance issues.
Originally posted by Maddoc
I could be wrong but...
They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"
They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA
Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
I really think its a poor choice to have the Bonus SA before the Archetype SA in the 3rd tree.
The simple fact is that some archetypes won't have a good or relevant Bonus SA (power back and speed WRs will be hard up imo). But they'll want their archetype SA.
Basically you're forced into an SA you don't want here.
Maybe there should be a "no bonus SA" option as well. I can think of a few places where I would think it makes sense to forgo it.
There is always a SA that will be marginally useful. Think of it as everybody's own personal Smooth Operator.
Power HBs can make it be something like Sticky Hands or Lead Block to run with the FB, Spot Blitz for pass blocking. Speed WRs can get Cover Up to hold onto passes better. It needs to be there for balance issues.
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by HULK
Originally posted by Maddoc
I could be wrong but...
They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"
They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA
Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
I really think its a poor choice to have the Bonus SA before the Archetype SA in the 3rd tree.
The simple fact is that some archetypes won't have a good or relevant Bonus SA (power back and speed WRs will be hard up imo). But they'll want their archetype SA.
Basically you're forced into an SA you don't want here.
Maybe there should be a "no bonus SA" option as well. I can think of a few places where I would think it makes sense to forgo it.
There is always a SA that will be marginally useful. Think of it as everybody's own personal Smooth Operator.
Power HBs can make it be something like Sticky Hands or Lead Block to run with the FB, Spot Blitz for pass blocking. Speed WRs can get Cover Up to hold onto passes better. It needs to be there for balance issues.
Smooth Operator is still at least decent
Coverage LB's have Swat Ball and not much else
Most LB SA's suck - the Morale ones don't really work any more since QB's all have confidence 73-capped
Originally posted by HULK
Originally posted by Maddoc
I could be wrong but...
They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"
They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA
Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
I really think its a poor choice to have the Bonus SA before the Archetype SA in the 3rd tree.
The simple fact is that some archetypes won't have a good or relevant Bonus SA (power back and speed WRs will be hard up imo). But they'll want their archetype SA.
Basically you're forced into an SA you don't want here.
Maybe there should be a "no bonus SA" option as well. I can think of a few places where I would think it makes sense to forgo it.
There is always a SA that will be marginally useful. Think of it as everybody's own personal Smooth Operator.
Power HBs can make it be something like Sticky Hands or Lead Block to run with the FB, Spot Blitz for pass blocking. Speed WRs can get Cover Up to hold onto passes better. It needs to be there for balance issues.
Smooth Operator is still at least decent
Coverage LB's have Swat Ball and not much else
Most LB SA's suck - the Morale ones don't really work any more since QB's all have confidence 73-capped
Maddoc
offline
offline
Man, anyone remember the experimental "Aura" MLBs from like season 2?
Just loaded up on all the morale affecting SAs including Defense General.
I should start one of those for when they buff Morale SAs and they go all out of control for a season or two.
Just loaded up on all the morale affecting SAs including Defense General.
I should start one of those for when they buff Morale SAs and they go all out of control for a season or two.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























