User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Does Blitz SA even work?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3592308&page=13#33332857


no one can know... but PP did say in that thread that catch would hopefully be testing SAs this season to see if some dont work/need a buff. i can imagine blitz would fall under the category.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Pretty obviously because of if Run Blocking had Strength, Blocking, & Agility then there would never be any motivation to pick anything else.


Meh..

Gs and Cs are already losing a lot of level gains with the new archetypes. If both pass blocking and run blocking archetypes have strength, blocking, and agility as major skills that would slightly solve the issue of one being favored over the other.

The issue of one archetype being favored is impossible to solve. Trying to solve this is only going to hurt this project. I would suggest crunching the numbers and only working for a balanced sim. That is something that can be controlled. People and their choices is not a variable worth trying to control imo.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Even if there were 10 different archtype's per position, there would always be a "best choice" for the sim.

The sim has never/will never be 100% balanced. It has been good at times and bad at times, but its never perfect.

After 80% of people start choosing one kind of archtype, that one will get nerfed somehow and the process will repeat itself.

Instead of nerfing, there should just be buffs to parts of the sim that don't work as well as others.
 
chazno
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
Every defensive player besides DT would pick speed, agility, and vision for their first three and the last one would be a choice between strength and tackling. Every HB would be Speed, agility, carrying, strength. Most WR would be Speed, Catching, Agility, Vision.

It sounds like you would have more options but if you wanted to be good you would really only have one choice.


Do you think changing the ALGs will stop flavor of the month building? Those people who wanted Speed, agility and Vision will do the math, pick the most appropriate archetype and still max those attributes and as long as those are the most effective attributes everyone else will follow suit.

If they want people to build differently, different builds have to be equally effective. For the record, I think that will be impossible to do.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
What if players got to choose their majors but with some restrictions. The restrictions would be as follows:

1 All players must have 4 majors and 4 minors. (It just makes the math simpler.)
2 Only 2 Physical skills can be majors.

Well I guess that is it. I thought i was going to make a long list of rules but I think that pretty much solves it. lol
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
What if players got to choose their majors but with some restrictions. The restrictions would be as follows:

1 All players must have 4 majors and 4 minors. (It just makes the math simpler.)
2 Only 2 Physical skills can be majors.

Well I guess that is it. I thought i was going to make a long list of rules but I think that pretty much solves it. lol


This is perfect
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chazno
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu

Every defensive player besides DT would pick speed, agility, and vision for their first three and the last one would be a choice between strength and tackling. Every HB would be Speed, agility, carrying, strength. Most WR would be Speed, Catching, Agility, Vision.

It sounds like you would have more options but if you wanted to be good you would really only have one choice.


Do you think changing the ALGs will stop flavor of the month building? Those people who wanted Speed, agility and Vision will do the math, pick the most appropriate archetype and still max those attributes and as long as those are the most effective attributes everyone else will follow suit.

If they want people to build differently, different builds have to be equally effective. For the record, I think that will be impossible to do.


tbh it's not impossible to do, and it has been done already. There are pretty good players out there without OMG amazing speed. It just takes a lot of vision to compensate.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chazno
Do you think changing the ALGs will stop flavor of the month building? Those people who wanted Speed, agility and Vision will do the math, pick the most appropriate archetype and still max those attributes and as long as those are the most effective attributes everyone else will follow suit.

If they want people to build differently, different builds have to be equally effective. For the record, I think that will be impossible to do.


It seems like they were careful to make sure none of the types had all the attributes you need to do that, and if it did, they were of the .4 variety and not the .5 or .67. With a couple exceptions (strength DT for 1).

Pick your own ALG is absolutely the most cookie cutter option, that's why it's not an option.

The archetypes might not create the kind of diversity you see irl, but it cannot make for less diversity than we have now. At the very least we will have a couple seasons of people trying stuff out and bringing along their mutant changeover builds. Obviously Bort will have to monitor which types work and which don't and make adjustments to keep them all viable or some will die off and we'd lose some diversity.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
will older players who select an archetype also be able to select a bonus SA to start putting SP into?

are the SA trees going to be different by archetype withing a position? like coverage LB vs. hard hitting LB?

coverage LB should have FS, CD, SB, SV, SDC for their coverage tree, or something to that effect
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
will older players who select an archetype also be able to select a bonus SA to start putting SP into?

are the SA trees going to be different by archetype withing a position? like coverage LB vs. hard hitting LB?

coverage LB should have FS, CD, SB, SV, SDC for their coverage tree, or something to that effect


I could be wrong but...

They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"

They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA

Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
will older players who select an archetype also be able to select a bonus SA to start putting SP into? - YES

are the SA trees going to be different by archetype withing a position? like coverage LB vs. hard hitting LB? - I don't think so currently.



 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve


are the SA trees going to be different by archetype withing a position? like coverage LB vs. hard hitting LB? - I don't think so currently.


This got me thinking about where SAs are positioned in relation to the bonus and penalty SAs.

I do not know that the bonuses or penalties are but to use LBs as an example. I see that Coverage LBs have a bonus in diving tackle and swat ball and a penalty in Monster Hit and Shed Block. The current position of Shed Block and Swat Ball forces agents to invest in a penalty SA in order to invest in their bonus SA Swat Ball.

 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by reddogrw

will older players who select an archetype also be able to select a bonus SA to start putting SP into?

are the SA trees going to be different by archetype withing a position? like coverage LB vs. hard hitting LB?

coverage LB should have FS, CD, SB, SV, SDC for their coverage tree, or something to that effect


I could be wrong but...

They'll choose a bonus SA, and also get access to the "Archetype Specific SA"

They will have a third SA line that will go,
Bonus SA - Archetype SA

Following the normal rules for spending SP in those.


they aren't bonus SAs, they are bonuses to the SAs you already have

Edit: There is 1 selectable SA, but not 2. I temporarily forgot about this nm
Edited by LionsLover on Feb 15, 2010 13:09:21
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
lolu
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LionsLover


Edit: There is 1 selectable SA, but not 2. I temporarily forgot about this nm


1 selectable - PLUS 1 archetype specific
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.