User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Piemaster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Everyone seems to be ignoring the fact that this solves nothing.

Nothing whatsoever.


Yeah, at 8 levels above the median level, it really doesn't do much at all.



I agree. In fact, I think Bort may have read all the whining and bottled it a little bit, making a rule that is so toothless it might as well not be there. I would be surprised if more than half a dozen players notice any difference in their XP gain this season.

I cling to the hope that this rule will be made stricter in future seasons once the hubub has died down.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by theplaymaker14
Bullshit rule. I signed Canada AAA#2 in S2 because its my friends team.. Right now im tied for the highest level in the league, and if im investing money into this game I dont want ANY penalty.

2 Best teams go up, 2 Worse teams go down.

The leagues will even up as we go.. Patience is the key but apparently there is none here.


If you signed in AAA because its your friends team, then so be it. It doesn;t hurt your performance, just your xp. So you'll level up more slowly but still be a dominant player in the league. Does 30 less xp a game really mean that much to you?
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by theplaymaker14
Bullshit rule. I signed Canada AAA#2 in S2 because its my friends team.. Right now im tied for the highest level in the league, and if im investing money into this game I dont want ANY penalty.

2 Best teams go up, 2 Worse teams go down.

The leagues will even up as we go.. Patience is the key but apparently there is none here.


And? You're boosting and sticking with a friend's team in this scenario. If you get any sort of penalty, it'll be absolutely minimal.

What don't people understand about "stopping high levels from trying to dominate new leagues?"
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
But there are also lots of team have more players not boosting. Again, as I mentioned earlier, it depends on the percentage of players boost. If it is less than 50%, there will be an issue like this.

EDIT: it really doesn't matter it is 25% or 49% of players boosting. As long as it is less than 50%, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In this case, it needs few adjustments to take care of this issue.


It will fall in between. So yes, eventually the booster will fall out of it in time, provided that it is ALWAYS less than 50%. I kinda doubt that will be the case for higher leagues, considering promotion/relegation, don't you?
 
TigerBloodJoe
offline
Link
 
i erased my post cuz...i just read borts "fallacy" stuff and i was wrong....sorry bout that.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 14:16:40
 
avgbrad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by theplaymaker14
Bullshit rule. I signed Canada AAA#2 in S2 because its my friends team.. Right now im tied for the highest level in the league, and if im investing money into this game I dont want ANY penalty.

2 Best teams go up, 2 Worse teams go down.

The leagues will even up as we go.. Patience is the key but apparently there is none here.


OK, take a deep breath
Canadian AAA #2: 13.4207
That median should be around 15
add 8
equals......23

Then throw in this

Fallacy #3: This means I can't recruit any high level players for my team.
Response. Note that you are afforded an "allowance" of over-the-limit players joining your team, with no penalty to them at all. You can recruit even more if they don't mind a possible penalty. This is not a hard cap, but rather an encouragement to not attempt to buy a championship overnight. You can recruit all the players you want who are under or slightly over the limit, and they can improve and boost over time to help you win that championship.

You are good, especially since you have been on the team not a gutter/stacker.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders

It will fall in between. So yes, eventually the booster will fall out of it in time, provided that it is ALWAYS less than 50%. I kinda doubt that will be the case for higher leagues, considering promotion/relegation, don't you?


I don't know, probably only Bort knows the percentage of players boost per league.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by theplaymaker14
Bullshit rule. I signed Canada AAA#2 in S2 because its my friends team.. Right now im tied for the highest level in the league, and if im investing money into this game I dont want ANY penalty.

2 Best teams go up, 2 Worse teams go down.

The leagues will even up as we go.. Patience is the key but apparently there is none here.



This offseason has proven that it won't though. There are people leaving established teams to go to teams in Africa as higher levels.

You're level 21 right now. The league mean is 13 and change. The median is probably 14 or maybe 15. And you're already on the team. This rule isn't close to affecting you at all.
 
Garza
offline
Link
 
hey I am a level 16 WR, soon to be 17. I am on a AAA team in Eastern Europe and have been so since season 1. Will this affect me in anyway, I have been on this team since the beginning and are WRs on the team are 17 16(me) and 15. Just making sure this will not hurt my XP.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 14:01:51
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
Originally posted by Dirty Toilet Paper

Originally posted by Novus


Originally posted by schisno



That's exactly what I'm saying, you want to aspire to get the most stats or win and if you're spending hard earn money to do so than why not? Like I said make a league for people who pay and people who don't.

Otherwise there's a greater chance of no one having incentive to buy flex points.


It's not just about winning. It's about winning games that actually mean something.

If you're a Level 30 in a league full of Level 6s, what the hell are you proving, other than that you're an asshat? It's like an NFL player showing up at the local Pee Wee league and suiting up to play against first graders.

But HEY, he PAID the registration fee for the Pee Wee league, and it's all about WINNING and getting MAD STATS YO! And he PAID, so that makes it all okay.

No.

These rules will take that NFL player out of the Pee Wee league and kick him back into the NFL -- where he BELONGS.



I agree. This will be a good move. You have the some people on here who run around screaming like old women with any little change. Whahahaha.


Little change? This isn't a little change... This screws a lot of GMs who went the distance to make their teams A LOT better than their competition and what happens? Oh wait, because they did such a good job bringing in high level players to destroy the competition (isn't that the point of the game?) they can be docked XP during games..

That's not all, but building a winner is something everyone should want to do. But why do it now if you're being punished for building a superior team?

Oh, but "you're beating up on the lower tier teams" and "it's unsportsmanlike"..

Well move their asses up a league if it's that big of a deal. Honestly, the point of this game is to win... Not to make everyone even. It's like elementary school where everyone has to have the same amount of everything or else it's unfair.

You gotta start somewhere and if a team has to begin their journey to USA Pro by dominating teams in USA BBB, then so be it.


I give kudos to all owners who busted their asses to make their teams. I have no problem whatsoever being out recruited. The problem I have is when people get to that position by resources not available to everyone. There is a team in my division that has 17 GM's, who own 10 different teams and their team is STACKED.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
The boost % debate is meaningless.
Firstly, whenever you boost you're at a higher level so you get less XP anyway. This means the median will be gaining on you throughout the season (you boosted from 11 to 14, the league stayed at 11 and the median was 11...you gained up to level 17, but every non-booster got to level 15 due to increased XP from being a lower-level, so the median is 2 behind you at the end of the year even though you boosted to the point where it was 3 behind you to start the season. This 'drop' will increase every year.)

Let's assume that you boost and nobody else in your league does, and that every level has the exact same XP path with no slow-down as you increase in level, just for the sake of argument.

By the time you make boosts #8 and #9 to put you 'over the median' for the league, you've already got three full seasons of team loyalty, games played and boosts to increase your sportsmanship, and if you resigned with the team at any point in there you got a boost from that as well. Even in this absurd, mathematically impossible scenario, you still won't be penalized.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 14:11:37
 
kostitsyn
offline
Link
 
So, if I have a player that signed in a lower leveled league in the off-season. Those changes wont affect him right?

Even if i decide to re-sign once his cotnract is up?

Edit: The modifier cant go up, it can only go down right?
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 14:11:49
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
The boost % debate is meaningless.
Firstly, whenever you boost you're at a higher level so you get less XP anyway. This means the median will be gaining on you throughout the season (you boosted from 11 to 14, the league stayed at 11 and the median was 11...you gained up to level 17, but every non-booster got to level 15 due to increased XP from being a lower-level, so the median is 2 behind you at the end of the year even though you boosted to the point where it was 3 behind you to start the season. This 'drop' will increase every year.)


After certain levels (20? 25? 30?), both boosters and non-boosters level up in slower rates that the difference can not make up any boosting level (or just very few). At that time, the level gap between boosted players and non-boosted players will be bigger than it is now.

Originally posted by oldskool
By the time you make boosts #8 and #9 to put you 'over the median' for the league, you've already got three full seasons of team loyalty, games played and boosts to increase your sportsmanship, and if you resigned with the team at any point in there you got a boost from that as well.


Many teams gutted their old team and moved to Africa or other new leagues have played together for 1+ season and also boost. Since this change intends to penalize this kind of action (in next offseason, many teams would play together for 2+ seasons), it makes me wonder the gain on sportmanship may not be as huge. Have Bort confirmed that the accumulated gain on sportmanship from team loyalty and boost is bigger than the penalty from signing to a new team with more than six players over recommended level? If so, it will certainly ease the concern.

EDIT: Bort just added to his announcement that he'll moniter the change and make adjustments. It should ensure to penalize unsportmanlike people and not others
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 14:46:39
 
kevzor
offline
Link
 
how did this post get 66 pages in 1 day?
 
avgbrad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevzor
how did this post get 66 pages in 1 day?


to many 12 year olds?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.