User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
ksychic
offline
Link
 
You just wanna keep USA Pro happy..

Because they weren't happy with WL, you ruin it for everyone..

I was actually Looking Forward to playing this fucking game next season..

Not anymore..

You really need to communicate with your user base better Bort.

Your Mods are going around saying there will be a world league, and you could have told the user base that there MAY have been a world league, but you said there WILL be one.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
MAKE THE WORLD LEAGUE VERY SIMPLE.

Qualifications for entry are as now.

A team that reaches the WPL will only play 1 season in the WPL. At the end of the season, ALL teams are relegated back to their respective PRO league. The top 4 Pro teams, promote to WPL. Rotation completed.

There would be no way for any team to have consecutive seasons in WPL. Thus, no bitching.


This would create two parallel WPL leagues and create many arguments over who is best. Probably not the best way to figure out who is the best of the best imo.
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TexanInMA
Originally posted by Bort

Staying in your league is something that is earned by making your way up the ladder. Getting dumped to a different region is going to annoy people just as much as anything else. I'm sure people would rather play in an official tournament than to be told they can't go back to their region.


I actually disagree. If you demoted across the leagues, then you'd end up balancing them out and making the Pro Leagues healthier. The way it is now, it's stacked to USAPL.

I refer back to my ealier post. CPL has what are 3 or the top 6 ranked teams in the latest poll. While I love CPL, there is only 1 real regular season game a year right now (against Drygerian). So, if Marblehead was to be promoted and then demoted as one of the bottom 4, we'd be happy to go somewhere other than CPL as long as it was more competitive. The simple demotion system would handle that by "spreading the wealth" of best teams.

Summary -- I think you misread the customer's need again. It's for a league that's exciting. It's not happening where we are. Talking to many other owners, I don't think I'm alone.



Well put (except that we were within a TD and driving when you got that late fourth quarter INT so easy on the one-game-a-season stuff )
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
There are a couple of people in this thread who have almost exactly the right idea on a competent demotion setting. Let me see if I can type this all up in a single post and see if the detractors can find the holes in it...
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
I can already see teams boycotting the WP tournament and/or not giving a crap about it.

And yes, I am a fan of the WPL. Is it problematic sending teams back to the league they came from? Yes, but there are enough bad teams in the Pro leagues that you can just demote extra teams back to AAA... really not that hard.


have to disagree w/ you hazy. My team would have been demoted in season 9 had WPL been in effect. This season most people know what happened.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrobb525
For these world league teams or whatever there should be a certain amount of GMs the team can have.


why? most of the higher teams aren't just giving away free trophies...
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Frank Booth
Originally posted by Bort


QFIrony

Really, though,...........


Wouldnt Irony be more like the fact that The BANK ON IT statement was made by you and now act like it was never said?
And if this was a poor choice of words on your part..Why didnt you squash the BANK ON IT to a We are trying to make it work?



it was said on test server.

you are right that once it was brought to the main forums that we should have clarified it.

---

the biggest challenge on this wpl idea is demotions. that is one of the big reasons we went with the tourney plan.

anyway, poll should help get some good ideas.

thanks for your concern frank, let's kiss
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by jfbueno



I have a feeling at least 80% of the teams would want the WPL, just for the fact that they'd be in it.


I have worked my ass off for over a year, literally spent hundreds and hundreds of hours working on this game to prepare Santiago for the advent of a world league.

Now it's erased because Bort cant make up his mind, listens to whiners and cant figure out demotion.

Make a committee of the handful of top owners/GMs who actually care deeply about this sim and I am sure we could figure out an equitable demotion system within a few days if Bort doesnt want to do it himself.

The tournament idea was fine but it was only ever a stop gap until the world league was ready.

The best teams want to play the best competition. I dont want yet another season of playing a ton of walkover and blowouts, which still take time to prepare for, and then be forced to do game planning for the real tournament on my off days.

What an awful, awful idea. Make the world league. If someone doesnt want to leave their precious USA/CAN/SA Pro/Whatever, just give them option of avoiding the World League altogether.

Let those of us who want to see who is really the best play in the World League. If Santiago gets demoted, they can send my team to whatever damn region they please.



Here is what I posted on a private forum when I found out the news...


To me, the solution is simple. You initially promote the top 4 from each region. You divide the WPL into divisions based on region and the bottom 2 teams after the first season relegate back to their respective region. The two conference champions then promote to the WPL. Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TexanInMA
Originally posted by Bort

Staying in your league is something that is earned by making your way up the ladder. Getting dumped to a different region is going to annoy people just as much as anything else. I'm sure people would rather play in an official tournament than to be told they can't go back to their region.


I actually disagree. If you demoted across the leagues, then you'd end up balancing them out and making the Pro Leagues healthier. The way it is now, it's stacked to USAPL.



I can almost guarantee you'll be met with mouth foaming resistance towards teams randomly demoted. MAybe not even know, but if it happens hoooooly shit.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Originally posted by TexanInMA

Originally posted by Bort


Staying in your league is something that is earned by making your way up the ladder. Getting dumped to a different region is going to annoy people just as much as anything else. I'm sure people would rather play in an official tournament than to be told they can't go back to their region.


I actually disagree. If you demoted across the leagues, then you'd end up balancing them out and making the Pro Leagues healthier. The way it is now, it's stacked to USAPL.
.



i dont like the idea of teams getting demoted into different regions


seems simple... each conference has 2 teams from each region. If you the lower of the 2 from that region at the end of the season you get replaced by that region's Pro conference champ.

You keep "regional pride" and in time will probably help balance regions as all pro leagues get treated the same to make it to the top
Edited by smallbugger on Jul 27, 2009 17:45:02
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ksychic
You just wanna keep USA Pro happy..

Because they weren't happy with WL, you ruin it for everyone..

I was actually Looking Forward to playing this fucking game next season..

Not anymore..

You really need to communicate with your user base better Bort.

Your Mods are going around saying there will be a world league, and you could have told the user base that there MAY have been a world league, but you said there WILL be one.


GUT!!!!
 
randey
offline
Link
 
I fail to see why teams "have" to move down to the league they originated from. Include an option that allows you to choose to accept promotion to WPL, and if you accepted it, and you earn demotion, then throw them back down into any Pro League. Imo, keep it relatively stable, only demote the bottom 8 of the WPL, being as even coming in at 16 could signify a very good team.

So demote the bottom 8, including gutted teams first, and bring up the Championship winning team of each league. Easy demotion, and more stability in the system. As it is we have perennial power houses that dominate their respective pro leagues which only goes to discourage the above average teams of the same leagues. It just doesn't make sense to keep a top 32 team in a league where only one or two games during the season is a major threat.
 
James128
offline
Link
 
Slap owners are out in numbers right now
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Originally posted by Ubasstards

Originally posted by TexanInMA


Originally posted by Bort



Staying in your league is something that is earned by making your way up the ladder. Getting dumped to a different region is going to annoy people just as much as anything else. I'm sure people would rather play in an official tournament than to be told they can't go back to their region.


I actually disagree. If you demoted across the leagues, then you'd end up balancing them out and making the Pro Leagues healthier. The way it is now, it's stacked to USAPL.
.



i dont like the idea of teams getting demoted into different regions


based on what KAI not making the playoffs being demoted to USAPL?


nah, that wont happen. But does MEM want to play in CPL or OPL if they get demoted? Does anyone want to play in OPL?
 
Speedcat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ksychic
You just wanna keep USA Pro happy..

Because they weren't happy with WL, you ruin it for everyone..

I was actually Looking Forward to playing this fucking game next season..

Not anymore..

You really need to communicate with your user base better Bort.

Your Mods are going around saying there will be a world league, and you could have told the user base that there MAY have been a world league, but you said there WILL be one.


+1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.