User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
I can force fumbles on Madden with ease.

On All-Pro? If so, congratulations because I haven't seen people able to do so. Regardless, you're still missing the point. A football simulation is supposed to simulate real football. It won't always be accurate and will never be perfectly accurate, but the point is to try and make it as accurate as possible. GLB isn't "NFL Street."

Originally posted by
My point is that the players on the OP's team were probably in a horrible morale spiral which once they started fumbling they couldn't get out of.

If that is the cause, then that's a huge problem that needs to be fixed because it's hideously unrealistic and ruins the game.

Originally posted by
My guy fumbled and I am not okay with it. I will whine until Bort caves and ruins another viable defensive option

My HB has no fumbles this season, genius. I'm concerned about the quality of the sim as a whole, not just what happens to my own players.

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
But things werent changed about fumbling from last season.

Yes, they have.

Originally posted by
Is it NOT logical that defenders have just adjusted to the influx of power backs and have VAs to stop them?

No, it isn't. Boosting only provides you with 15 SPs, which is not nearly enough to radically change the build of a 40+ level player. And as for VAs, if people were still concerned about powerbacks running wild then they would have taken Sure Tackler instead of Power Tackler. They aren't because Bort stepped in and reduced the effectiveness of powerback SAs along with adding other negative effects on momentum and such after you break a tackle. Defenders have not changed radically since last season. Guys who already had 15 points in Power Tackler last season were not forcing nearly this many fumbles.

Originally posted by
You can either listen to the logical responces that you are getting

I have listened to the logical ones. Your responses have no been logical at all, however.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Bort's already said he didn't change anything to the FF chance from last season. In this thread even. It's not a sim problem.

Bort also said he's gonna give you guys a little carry sliding bar (and he's going to get it in the testing server first, and I believe he said he was working on that last night). He said that in this thread also.

Don't believe that? Find it yourself in this 64 page thread. He said all of this last night/evening. In this thread.

Short version: Quit your bitching, Bort's going to rescue you guys with a carrying slider bar.


I hate quoting myself, but maybe people will calm down knowing Bort is to the rescue.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Jason Cash

But things werent changed about fumbling from last season.

Yes, they have.

Originally posted by

Is it NOT logical that defenders have just adjusted to the influx of power backs and have VAs to stop them?

No, it isn't. Boosting only provides you with 15 SPs, which is not nearly enough to radically change the build of a 40+ level player. And as for VAs, if people were still concerned about powerbacks running wild then they would have taken Sure Tackler instead of Power Tackler. They aren't because Bort stepped in and reduced the effectiveness of powerback SAs along with adding other negative effects on momentum and such after you break a tackle. Defenders have not changed radically since last season. Guys who already had 15 points in Power Tackler last season were not forcing nearly this many fumbles.

Originally posted by

You can either listen to the logical responces that you are getting

I have listened to the logical ones. Your responses have no been logical at all, however.



Bort has alreayd said that he didnt change a single thing about the FF chance dude. IF he had changed something, then there would be a sim issue, but he didnt change a single thing about fumbles
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by merenoise

I can force fumbles on Madden with ease.

On All-Pro? If so, congratulations because I haven't seen people able to do so. Regardless, you're still missing the point. A football simulation is supposed to simulate real football. It won't always be accurate and will never be perfectly accurate, but the point is to try and make it as accurate as possible. GLB isn't "NFL Street."


On All-Madden tbh. It's all about hit stick and angles. My point is that fumbles are a part of football. The offense can do its thing and no one complains. The second that the D starts getting something going there are riots in the forums. D line gets sacks? Let's nerf it. LBs tackling well? Nerf them. People forcing fumbles now and the war cry of "Nerf" has once again been raised.

Originally posted by

My point is that the players on the OP's team were probably in a horrible morale spiral which once they started fumbling they couldn't get out of.
Originally posted by jdbolick


If that is the cause, then that's a huge problem that needs to be fixed because it's hideously unrealistic and ruins the game.


It's not at all unrealistic. When you screw up it messes with your head and makes it more likely that you will do so again. Kinda like going on tilt in a poker game.

Originally posted by

My guy fumbled and I am not okay with it. I will whine until Bort caves and ruins another viable defensive option

Originally posted by jdbolick

My HB has no fumbles this season, genius. I'm concerned about the quality of the sim as a whole, not just what happens to my own players.



You seem to be more concerned with calling people names than anything else tbh. I understand that your position is that fumbles occur far too often. What I don't understand is why anyone who disagrees with you must by definition be an idiot. Take a deep breath and really think about why you have to attack other people who disagree with you and maybe, just maybe you might learn something about your own inadequacies.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 12:00:37
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

Originally posted by Jason Cash


Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds


Read the thread. It's not our builds. It's the Power Tackling + Sure Tackling VAs playing on Force Fumble tactics. They're causing way too many fumbles and missing way too few tackles. The reason that it's not happening to everyone is because not everyone has enough VA points to max out both of those VAs, and a lot of those who have enough points haven't done so. This is an exploit that is going to affect only a few teams/players at first, and won't be as evident in lower level leagues.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Not sure if this has been mentioned, but there have been calls to be able to sub based on poor performance (fumbles/interceptions) for many seasons now. I wonder if that will ever happen?
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Jason Cash

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks


Originally posted by Jason Cash



Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds


Read the thread. It's not our builds. It's the Power Tackling + Sure Tackling VAs playing on Force Fumble tactics. They're causing way too many fumbles and missing way too few tackles. The reason that it's not happening to everyone is because not everyone has enough VA points to max out both of those VAs, and a lot of those who have enough points haven't done so. This is an exploit that is going to affect only a few teams/players at first, and won't be as evident in lower level leagues.


Both of those were created to help the issue with missing tackles. Defenders pumped up strength and tackling through boosts and training to stop power backs. It's all due to defenders having to actually care about strength and tackling. Defenders had to adjust. Now HBs have to adjust. Besides, Bort has already said that carrying is the main attribute for HBs.
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Jason Cash

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks


Originally posted by Jason Cash



Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds


Read the thread. It's not our builds. It's the Power Tackling + Sure Tackling VAs playing on Force Fumble tactics. They're causing way too many fumbles and missing way too few tackles. The reason that it's not happening to everyone is because not everyone has enough VA points to max out both of those VAs, and a lot of those who have enough points haven't done so. This is an exploit that is going to affect only a few teams/players at first, and won't be as evident in lower level leagues.


Using your logic we should do away with the Power Through SA and Bruiser VA since they do a similar thing when used in tandem. Some players will be good at forcing fumbles. Some entire teams will base their scheme around this. Other teams will find ways to make it less useful. Before we all cry to have this nerfed at least give OCs a chance to counter it using the AI (more 5 WR sets, power backs at KR, etc).
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

Originally posted by Jason Cash


Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks



Originally posted by Jason Cash




Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds


Read the thread. It's not our builds. It's the Power Tackling + Sure Tackling VAs playing on Force Fumble tactics. They're causing way too many fumbles and missing way too few tackles. The reason that it's not happening to everyone is because not everyone has enough VA points to max out both of those VAs, and a lot of those who have enough points haven't done so. This is an exploit that is going to affect only a few teams/players at first, and won't be as evident in lower level leagues.


Using your logic we should do away with the Power Through SA and Bruiser VA since they do a similar thing when used in tandem. Some players will be good at forcing fumbles. Some entire teams will base their scheme around this. Other teams will find ways to make it less useful. Before we all cry to have this nerfed at least give OCs a chance to counter it using the AI (more 5 WR sets, power backs at KR, etc).


exactly. OCs are gonna have to start gameplanning for a change
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
and there is a ton of precedent that over rides yours..and it's the people who arent fumbling becuase they didnt go with the flavor of the weak builds


Haha - name one precedent. I presented three off the top of my head.

I do agree with one thing - there are people who aren't fumbling. It's because they haven't met the fumbling machines yet.

For the most part, I think fumbling in the run game is fine. It's ST and the fumble recovery rate (and TDs) that mainly concern me.

Last edited Apr 27, 2009 12:34:31
 
core2
offline
Link
 
working as intended,

You guys wanted to get rid of Attribute VA's so where he hell are LB's going to put their VA's? There arent very many except for power tackler and sure tackler. Maybe Fearsome but thats about it.

This is what has changed so deal with it.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Jason Cash

and there is a ton of precedent that over rides yours..and it's the people who arent fumbling becuase they didnt go with the flavor of the weak builds


Haha - name one precedent. I presented three off the top of my heads.

I do agree with one thing - there are people who aren't fumbling. It's because they haven't met the fumbling machines yet.

For the most part, I think fumbling in the run game is fine. It's ST and the fumble recovery rate (and TDs) that mainly concern me.



Alot of special teams guys dont have ANY carrying. I remember bitching last seaon on my teams forums about how our kick returner had 30 carrying and fumbled alot. As a DC, I always look to see who the other team has as a kick returner. If it's a CB, then I know that he isnt gonna have ANY carrying
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by core2
working as intended,


if someone implies 11 fumbles a game is working as intended when it has been explicitly stated by the creater of this game that it's not one more fucking time i'm going on a mass murdering spree
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Bort has alreayd said that he didnt change a single thing about the FF chance dude.

Lots of times Bort has changed something and it had unintended consequences. What Bort means is that he didn't intend to dramatically increase fumbles, but something he did obviously had that result. Players who already had 15 in Power Tackler last season weren't causing nearly this many fumbles.



Originally posted by j10er
For the most part, I think fumbling in the run game is fine.

It isn't. Fumbling on 2% of carries is normal for the NFL, and while GLB obviously isn't the NFL, it's still absurd to see some HBs fumbling on 40% of their carries like the ones in the OP.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.