User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Binestar

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Robbnva




yeah, here is the link to make it easier for you

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=804491


K, I'll put him at MLB vs somebody good.


Ok, I've run him against a couple top guys from USA Pro league - did fairly decent, got dragged a few times with the new code, but actually didn't give up a whole lot for being underleveled comparatively. Looks like he's on his way


So now you're saying our MLB's need to ignore the Defensive General Ability in order to be able to make tackles? Great. Looks like it's time for another round of slow builds to start. I wonder what the numbers are for new LB's created in the last day.


general SA helps everyone not just the mlb, if my MLB had more maybe the rest of the team would do better.

Who said SAs are so great anyway? I know a couple of players who dominate in Pro and don't have any SAs at all.


My MLB has 9 in def gen. Not a single regret.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kavadas

But when a back has double the strength of a defender and carrying that is double the defender's tackling then the defender should be a given whistle so he can blow it when he's regularly raped by the power back.


So then...any defender without 100 speed and 70 agility should get raped by speed offensive players?

I'm really sorry that defensive players can't have 100 strength, 100 speed, 80 tackling, 80 agility, and 80 vision.

Defensive players have to be flexible, they can lean towards stopping power or speed players, but they need to be flexible. They shouldn't HAVE to lean 100% one way to stop speed or power...currently they DO have to lean to near 100% to stop speed, and now you are wanting them to have to lean 100% to stop power.

Focused offensive players with 100 in an attribute should have certain advantages, and excel at certain things, however, they should never dominate defensive players that don't have 100 in that attribute. That is the problem with speed, and making it the problem with strength isn't going to make anything better.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 08:19:06
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

So then...any defender without 100 speed and 70 agility should get raped by speed offensive players?


Are we playing the same game? Defenders without a 100 speed and 70 agility already are raped by speed based offensive players because strength is meaningless.

If you make strength and carrying/tackling more attractive on both sides of the ball then players will naturally slow down as more points are migrated towards those attributes.

SPs don't come from nowhere FYI.

Is the fastest guy in the NFL the best player? Doubt it. Is the fastest guy in GLB the best player? Pretty much.

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 08:23:33
 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Kavadas


But when a back has double the strength of a defender and carrying that is double the defender's tackling then the defender should be a given whistle so he can blow it when he's regularly raped by the power back.


So then...any defender without 100 speed and 70 agility should get raped by speed offensive players?

I'm really sorry that defensive players can't have 100 strength, 100 speed, 80 tackling, 80 agility, and 80 vision.

Defensive players have to be flexible, they can lean towards stopping power or speed players, but they need to be flexible. They shouldn't HAVE to lean 100% one way to stop speed or power...how they DO have to lean near 100% to stop speed, and now you are wanting them to have to lean 100% to stop power.

Focused offensive players with 100 in an attribute should have certain advantages, and excel at certain things, however, they should never dominate defensive players that don't have 100 in that attribute. That is the problem with speed, and making it the problem with strength isn't going to make anything better.


IMO rock paper scissors would work best. if the HB is a Rock with Strenght, then the Paper LB should be able to cover him. unless he is Scissors and we know what happens rock meets scissors. on the other hand if is the elusive hb paper then scissor will tear him up
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kavadas

If you make strength and carrying/tackling more attractive on both sides of the ball then players will naturally slow down as more points are migrated towards those attributes.


I agree with making carrying/catching more important...

But do you think that elusive backs and WR's are going to suddenly start dumping everything into strength? No, they will still be lopsided towards speed. Power runners will be lopsided towards strength, elusive runners will be lopsided towards speed. That isn't going to change.

Requiring defensive players to have speed equal to an elusive runner, and strength equal to a power back, 70 tackling, and 80 vision just isn't really a viable solution to much of anything.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1


My MLB has 9 in def gen. Not a single regret.


and I will start working on that at some point, my guy is a level 27 and I should not be spending points in SAs yet. By the time I get to level 45 like your guy I should easily have 9 in Def General.

I still have more work to do with my guy.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 08:25:03
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Are we talking power back like Jim Brown? Or Jerome Bettis.

Because Brown had some wheels, Bettis just drug people kicking and screaming until his momentum was finally stopped.

Momentum may need to play a larger role in power backs.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
I think the equation should just be physics based, really.

Yes, a 100 strength back is a beast - but you can't just say the defender needs a similar level strength and tackle to take him down. The defender also has momentum going for him, he can take out legs, the direction of the tackle is factored in. I think in general the sim is working great in this regard, very realistically. If your team has neglected strength and tackling, you're probably going to miss alot of tackles. Gang tackling is the one thing that should help this - undersized "Tampa 2" defenses make tackles on big backs like this because they are swarming and flying to the ball.
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
But do you think that elusive backs and WR's are going to suddenly start dumping everything into strength?


If strength/carrying meant my WR or receiving TE could actually bulldoze 20 strength, 30 tackling cornerbacks fuckin' A right I'd dump points into them.

Works for Hines Ward.

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 08:28:31
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by joebus36

Listen Up


In the NFL Linebackers have good speed. But in this game, everyone just puts a ton in speed. I think your LBs are too fast. Look at a guy like James Harrison. He is just incredibly strong but is nowhere as fast as people make their LBs on this game.


And in the NFL, not every WR, TE, and HB is over "100 speed". They are in this game because other attributes matter little for them. Suddenly making 2 more attributes very important for the defense isn't going to do anything positive for the game unless offense is required to start dumping points elsewhere as well.




Strength should be more important than it is for the offensive players as well--even the "Elusive" based ones. Take a look at the guns on Steve Smith (WR-Carolina) and tell me that his strength isn't a factor in getting seperation from DBs, in pulling in passes in traffic, in getting out of traffic while running with the ball, etc. And he's 5 foot-nothing and under 200 lbs. We could go around the NFL and find example after example of players that are perceived as "Elusive" offensive players that are nevertheless strong as hell.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


Assuming we are only talking about Breaking Tackles and not Avoiding Tackles.....

HB : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Carrying

ie 220+60/2+100+70= 310 (Base comparison value before modifiers)

VS

Tackler : Weight + (Current Speed)/2 + Strength + Tackling + (Vision+Agility/2)

So using some ball park figures that reresent some of the more common build types...

CB : 187 + 90/2 + 30 + 30 + (60+60)/2 = 258.5
LB : 250 + 80/2 + 48 + 48 + (50+60)/2 = 316.0
NT : 330 + 48/2 + 80 + 60 + (40+70)/2 = 384.0


NB: Current Speed = Current Speed /100 * Morale. So if your player has given up, he'll get run over more often.

I would then say the %age difference is the %age chance of Breaking the Tackle.

So as seen above, a CB with 30 Strength and 30 Tackling (value 258.5) Vs HB Value 310 is likely to miss 16.6% of his Tackles, before any Break Block/Make Tackle modifiers. Assuming they activate a lot, he will miss most tackle chances.

LB with Value 316.0 will make most tackles, but has no chance if a SA or Modifier fires.

NT with 384 value has no problem stopping the HB, and it would take high amount of modifiers triggering to make a difference.

Then as fatigue and morale loss kicks in, things can go to the HBs favour.

That seems to be rational and realistic to me, but might need some work to smooth it out.

 
dpell
offline
Link
 
A LB with 60/60 str/tkl should be able to consistently tackle a power back. I agree he should be be dragged at times, but if that LB is set to wrap-up tackling he should make the tackle 90+% of the time. Against 50/50 softcapped players it should probably be more in the 80% range for making the tackle.

What I think we're missing is the effects of stamina. Tackling that power back should require a lot of energy and the longer the game goes on the chance to miss those tackles should go up. At the same time, I think breaking tackles using strength doesn't put enough drain on the HB. You don't run a guy like Jerome Bettis more than 20-25 times a game max, and more often it was more like 17-20 attempts. A back that big gets beat up and tired too. I've seen the builds of some great power backs, and not one of them had stamina to the soft cap.

So while I have no problem seeing power backs be very successful with a good build against LB's with low str/tkl, I also think it's stupid to see that back rushing the ball 30 times and still breaking 2-3 tackles in the 4th quarter.



Last edited Dec 30, 2008 08:34:04
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by navytexas1

IMO rock paper scissors would work best. if the HB is a Rock with Strenght, then the Paper LB should be able to cover him. unless he is Scissors and we know what happens rock meets scissors. on the other hand if is the elusive hb paper then scissor will tear him up


No, rock paper scissors doesn't work without having a middle ground that is "decent". Balanced builds should do ok against any kind of player, while specialized players do better against some specialized players but worse against others. Of course, there would be a varying degrees of specialization.

The current problem is that the balanced build can't compete against specialized speed build. Making balanced builds not able to compete against power builds won't solve anything...
 
Supahfli
offline
Link
 
I think the bigger up front guys should require higher strength/Tackling, while Smaller players like CB's should have high Agility/tackling. Some of the best tacklers in the NFL in the secondary wouldn't be as strong as a D-Lineman, yet they can still make the tackle on the big back. They use their agility to go low, and wrap up the legs.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Well it should be a equation obviously and percentages in a way

simple adding-up stats should help, so 100 strength/70 carrying = 170 v. 85 (40 strength/45tackling).... it should be a 50% chance to tackle the RB...

even a missed tackle should slow down a RB considerably for a few steps allowing for the defense to get more guys on the RB, but the RB should get a good chance of breaking a single tackle if the person doesn't invest in strength/tackling as a defender.

So even a 20strength/20 tackling guy against a power back has a small chance to make a tackle, it just isn't much
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 08:31:45
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.