User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Jason Cash

Originally posted by SCACE


haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.


that IS the problem because most people just up those two with a QB.

builds are just getting better than they were last season. My linebacker had 3 missed tackles and 103 made tackles last season... This season he had 3 missed in one game alone


If your point here is that players need to work hard on their builds, you are just stating the obvious...not really sure where you are going with this.


the thread starter complained about losing a game..NOt really taking into effect the changed the players on the opposing team may have made and just blamed it on the sim. And how his QB threw what..15 INTs that game... And didnt really think that maybe the other team just had him pegged..or maybe his build is bad

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
noone's arguing that his build is good

Many have offered suggestions to fix it. The build definitely had a big part in it, along with overpowered defense and no way to stop the bleeding during the morale spiral.
 
SpatanHILLMAN
offline
Link
 
lots of teams got beat i mean stop complaining come on
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by methomps

This QB is no Brett Favre, and Brett Favre is not your typical QB. QBs who are throwing interceptions left and right usually get pulled.

No, they do not when they are the unquestioned starter and have a track record of performance. If the coach considers two QBs to be relatively similar in ability, then yes, bad plays result in one replacing the other. In D1-A and the NFL, however, QBs don't get pulled very often.
Originally posted by

There are almost 35k regular season and playoff games played on GLB in season 3.

Can you point me to some verification of that number? In any case, there are approximately 1000 D1-A and NFL football games played each season. What happened in GLB at least twice already has never happened before in "real football" at those levels.
Originally posted by

I disagree with the idea that this particular result is absurd.

I'm sorry, but that's not even really debatable. The result was unquestionably unrealistic, the only debate is about whether or not that sporadic lack of realism needs fixing.


Scace,

Just ignore this freaking idiot, he obviously has his mind made up, despite the evidence to the contrary, just let him thinks he knows football, let him think he knows GLB, because he has been here just a little bit over a month, let him keep babbling on and proving himself a moron.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by methomps

This QB is no Brett Favre, and Brett Favre is not your typical QB. QBs who are throwing interceptions left and right usually get pulled.

No, they do not when they are the unquestioned starter and have a track record of performance. If the coach considers two QBs to be relatively similar in ability, then yes, bad plays result in one replacing the other. In D1-A and the NFL, however, QBs don't get pulled very often.
Originally posted by

There are almost 35k regular season and playoff games played on GLB in season 3.

Can you point me to some verification of that number? In any case, there are approximately 1000 D1-A and NFL football games played each season. What happened in GLB at least twice already has never happened before in "real football" at those levels.
Originally posted by

I disagree with the idea that this particular result is absurd.

I'm sorry, but that's not even really debatable. The result was unquestionably unrealistic, the only debate is about whether or not that sporadic lack of realism needs fixing.


I counted 128 GLB leagues. Each league plays 16 games a week in 16 regular season weeks. Each league also plays 15 playoff games.
16x16=256
256+15=271
271*128=34688

In 1978, Cal threw 10 interceptions against UCLA on 52 pass attempts.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 21:26:19
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by SCACE


haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.


There are some very well built QB's I'm sure, and I know from looking that occasionally the top one or two teams in a league get over 6.9 ypa. But look around at league stats and see if you can find a league (the higher level the league, the better, as the higher level leagues are where the lower level leagues are headed) where half the teams get 6.9 or more yards per pass attempt.

Remember, 6.9 ypa is average in real life, not what the best do but what the average do. The best get more than 8.


Quick question - do you think its a sim issue, or teams "playing it safe" vs. "playing it risky" by not boosting the long pass more often?

And conversely, do teams not set the long pass much yet because their QB's aren't fully completed yet?


I truly believe it's a sim issue, and here's why:

If it were solely or mostly due to teams throwing fewer long passes than in real life, either because their QB's aren't as completed yet or due to being risk-averse, then we would see unrealistically high completion percentages compared to the NFL or NCAA, which throw "normal" amounts of long passes (as QB's would be throwing shorter passes, which are easier to complete, than their real life counterparts).

Instead, completion percentages are pretty much like real life-- but on shorter passes.

I think that's the big mistake right now, that Bort at one point (I have no idea if he still is or not) focused on matching real life completion percentages, rather than ypa.

The Season 3 sim does match completion %s pretty well, but not really; it does it because shorter passes are indeed being thrown. If there were the same lengths of passes thrown in the NFL or NCAA, completion percentages would be too low.

I'll admit it's a loop. People throw shorter passes, so completion %s look okay, so things appear balanced if completion % is the metric. But I hope you can see how, if shorter passes are being thrown than in real life, completion percentages should be higher than real life.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 21:22:43
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
jdbolick - you've been nothing but an asshole to me this entire thread

Actually I think I've been pretty patient with you considering that you're the one who started lobbing personal insults my way because I was making points you couldn't rebut.
Originally posted by
and I'm about done arguing with you when you just don't have a clue.

Very compelling argument there.
Originally posted by
I don't need to be "in the know" to understand what the creators expect out of confidence and morale

I see. So you're such a svengali that you don't need to actually have any first-hand knowledge to know that cascade effects for confidence were intended, and that 9 interception totals are intended to happen. Awesome. Could you also divine Barack Obama's motivations in choosing to visit France before Germany? How about my decision to wear a black shirt today in spite of the heat? Illuminate us as to all these intentions that seem so obvious to you, but which require first-hand knowledge for any ordinary mortal.
Originally posted by
Add in a horrible build, and you just exaggerate the problem.

Once again, Jay Slim did reasonably well in that conference during the regular season and was not turnover prone.
Originally posted by
Add in no ability to throw the ball away, cover up and take a sack or sub the QB out when his morale drops, and you exaggerate the problem.

While those are all issues, they're tertiary. You're trying to apply band-aids to a bullet wound. Yes, it would be helpful if QBs would throw the ball away in certain situations or if coaches could pull players below a certain morale level, but none of that changes the fact that the morale system itself is flawed because it is prone to cascade effects.
Originally posted by
I strongly believe that confidence and morale are working as the creator intends them too

Some people believe they can fly. Others believe that the moon landing was faked on a Hollywood sound stage. What you believe is not particularly relevant or interesting. If you would like to argue facts or statistics, then that would be helpful, but I can't argue over what you believe.
Originally posted by
and I've proposed very valid ways to solve the issue without lessening the importance of the attribute.

Because your inability to understand the mathematics prevents you from grasping the significance or nature of the problem. I'm not saying that your proposed modifications are bad, just that they wouldn't correct the underlying flaw.
Originally posted by
All you have done is propose a poor solution that will lessen the importance of confidence, thus allowing it to be neglected.

Losing 10% of your stats would still be a brutal punishment and likely swing the outcome of any particular game. In no way am I attempting to eliminate the importance or effect of confidence, but simply to make it less disasterous. Right now it doesn't matter how good your build is if you have some unlucky plays at the beginning of a game, because those confidence penalties will wipe out your attributes regardless.
Originally posted by
Sorry, but that in and of itself is an epic fail.

Ah yes, the age old WoW player's baseless assertion of victory. You pwned me, indeed, good sir. And all because you said so. Now that you've established your supremacy simply by insisting that all my points are invalid (without actually explaining why), could you tell me some Chuck Norris jokes?
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 21:27:27
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
I counted 128 GLB leagues. Each league plays 16 games a week in 16 regular season games. Each league also plays 15 playoff games.
16x16=256
256+15=271
267*128=34688

Two teams are always playing each other, so cut that total in half. It's still a hefty number, but only equivalent to 17 years of "real football."
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
It amuses me how many people continue to miss the point in their haste to plant pouty lips on Bort's behind. The people who don't have a player on Nashville aren't concerned that the game was some grave injustice that needs to be rectified. People like me are concerned that there is an obvious problem with the simulation engine and we're worried that similar nonsensical results could happen to us.


Nothing nonsensical or Bort-blowing about it. A shit QB ran into a buzzsaw secondary. The end.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by methomps

I counted 128 GLB leagues. Each league plays 16 games a week in 16 regular season games. Each league also plays 15 playoff games.
16x16=256
256+15=271
267*128=34688

Two teams are always playing each other, so cut that total in half. It's still a hefty number, but only equivalent to 17 years of "real football."


And you claim to know math??? Are you serious? LOL Why would you cut that in half unless you are saying each team only played 8 games.

Each team, plays 16 games, 16 teams, x 16 games.

 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by methomps

I counted 128 GLB leagues. Each league plays 16 games a week in 16 regular season games. Each league also plays 15 playoff games.
16x16=256
256+15=271
267*128=34688

Two teams are always playing each other, so cut that total in half. It's still a hefty number, but only equivalent to 17 years of "real football."


You would be right if I multiplied it by 32, but I didn't. I already accounted for the fact that two teams play each other. There are 32 teams in a league. There are 16 games a week.

Which brings us back to:

In 1978, Cal threw 10 interceptions against UCLA on 52 pass attempts.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Losing 10% of your stats would still be a brutal punishment and likely swing the outcome of any particular game. In no way am I attempting to eliminate the importance or effect of confidence, but simply to make it less disasterous. Right now it doesn't matter how good your build is if you have some unlucky plays at the beginning of a game, because those confidence penalties will wipe out your attributes regardless.


Here's where you're wrong. A QB without at least 40 confidence by level 25 is a bad build. Period. It doesn't matter what his other attributes are.

Other positions can get by with less because the team doesn't depend on them as much.

But if you play with fire by keeping low confidence at QB, you should get burned. You got burned worse than you should have, but only because the sim unrealistically favors defense.

If 10 of those stamina points were in confidence, you'd have had the typical Season 3 GLB can't move the ball problem, and maybe a high but not extreme number of interceptions.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Nothing nonsensical or Bort-blowing about it. A shit QB

Except that he wasn't.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=34840&playoffs=0
Originally posted by
ran into a buzzsaw secondary.

Except that they weren't.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=4&conference_id=8&stat=defense&playoffs=0
http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=122&team2=127
Originally posted by
The end.

Grasping the obvious seems to be more difficult for some people than I had imagined. What part of "no D1-A or pro QB has ever thrown 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer pass attempts" is unclear?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
You haven't made a point I couldn't rebut - you're main point revolves around lessening the negative effects of confidence and morale because you don't believe it is realistic. No matter how you try to disguise it, lessening the important of the confidence attribute and its effect on morale means players can neglect it without the proper negative side effects. That, in my opinion, is not a good thing.

You say my solutions are "bandaids to cover a bullet wound." And that is where we disagree. I don't think the SIM has an issue in this case. Based on what Bort and company have posted on this in numerous threads, I can (and you can too) get a good understanding of their expectations for this attribute. You claim it is broken, they say it is working as intended.

Now, if it is working as intended, options need to be available to avoid this spiral. Right now the only options are raising confidence and having high energy sub settings. The first is a good thing, the second isn't optimal. This is why I've suggested things missing from the SIM that if implemented would (or should) remove the risk of having these types of games unless someone really screwed with their settings....and if they screwed with settings, the outlier should be exaggerated, that's why its a game.

Anyways, I respect that you have your opinion on the depth of the problem and what needs to be done to fix it, and maybe you can get off your high horse and can accept that you just might be wrong. If I'm wrong, I'll happily eat crow and thank you for finding a grave error in the current SIM, you can be sure of that, because it will make the game better. Not sure if you'd do the same.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
You would be right if I multiplied it by 32, but I didn't. I already accounted for the fact that two teams play each other. There are 32 teams in a league. There are 16 games a week.

Fair enough, my mistake.
Originally posted by
Which brings us back to: In 1978, Cal threw 10 interceptions against UCLA on 52 pass attempts.

Which still doesn't equal the rate of 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer attempts, something that GLB has achieved at least twice in season 3 alone.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.