User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
That's not all, but building a winner is something everyone should want to do. But why do it now if you're being punished for building a superior team?


I stopped reading your post after this line. You obviously have no idea what's going on.
 
Ibiet
offline
Link
 
its 8 levels over the median. i feel like no one is in danger of being over that anyway. so all you level 20s are scared that you will get less xp when playing against lvl 12s. that's how it would have to be. the median would have to be a lvl 12. if you are level 20 you should get less xp when playing against 12s.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by savagesmurf

My question is are there going to be a couple 100+ more pro teams because this will force players out of all the other leagues.


Have you read ALL of the announcement? This affects so few people it's not a big deal, I promise.


It may only affect few people but it'll eventually affect much more people. This is my post in another thread:

If less than 50% people boost their players, it'll matter in 2 or 3 seasons. The gap between a boosted player and a non-boosted player will be bigger than 8 after both hit higher levels like 20 and leveling up through game/training xp slowly. Since less than 50% people boost, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In other words, eventually the boosting players will be over recommended level (8 over median). They won't get any penalty if they stay at the same team. But a non-pro-league team with more than 6 players boosting will have hard time recruiting boosting players without having them take xp penalties


It'll force boosting players in FA go to pro league.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by bmedders

Originally posted by savagesmurf


My question is are there going to be a couple 100+ more pro teams because this will force players out of all the other leagues.


Have you read ALL of the announcement? This affects so few people it's not a big deal, I promise.


It may only affect few people but it'll eventually affect much more people. This is my post in another thread:

If less than 50% people boost their players, it'll matter in 2 or 3 seasons. The gap between a boosted player and a non-boosted player will be bigger than 8 after both hit higher levels like 20 and leveling up through game/training xp slowly. Since less than 50% people boost, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In other words, eventually the boosting players will be over recommended level (8 over median). They won't get any penalty if they stay at the same team. But a non-pro-league team with more than 6 players boosting will have hard time recruiting boosting players without having them take xp penalties


It'll force boosting players in FA go to pro league.


You mean this rule to increase parity will force players who wish to change teams to play with players their own level? (With the exception of the allowed 1-3 players per team that can be above the level with no penalty whatsoever) That couldn't have been the intended purpose, could it?
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
And where are you finding out how many people boost? I'm not trying to call you out, I'm actually interested in knowing information like that.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by bmedders


Originally posted by savagesmurf



My question is are there going to be a couple 100+ more pro teams because this will force players out of all the other leagues.


Have you read ALL of the announcement? This affects so few people it's not a big deal, I promise.


It may only affect few people but it'll eventually affect much more people. This is my post in another thread:

If less than 50% people boost their players, it'll matter in 2 or 3 seasons. The gap between a boosted player and a non-boosted player will be bigger than 8 after both hit higher levels like 20 and leveling up through game/training xp slowly. Since less than 50% people boost, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In other words, eventually the boosting players will be over recommended level (8 over median). They won't get any penalty if they stay at the same team. But a non-pro-league team with more than 6 players boosting will have hard time recruiting boosting players without having them take xp penalties


It'll force boosting players in FA go to pro league.


You mean this rule to increase parity will force players who wish to change teams to play with players their own level? (With the exception of the allowed 1-3 players per team that can be above the level with no penalty whatsoever) That couldn't have been the intended purpose, could it?


Look at it more closely. Let's say a player is level 16 currently and boosted every season. Three seasons later, he'll be over median league level. When he becomes a FA, he can not go to a non-pro-league team without getting a xp penalty since most teams have more than six players boosting. So his choices are (1) go to a pro-league team and be a 2nd string or even 3rd string, or (2) go to a non-pro-league team and get a xp penalty but get a bigger role. I see this is an issue.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
And where are you finding out how many people boost? I'm not trying to call you out, I'm actually interested in knowing information like that.


I said IF in my post. If a league has less than 50% players boosting, therer will be an issue like this. I think a little adjustment may need to be made.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
At the same time, I think you'll see the median level get a shot in the arm in a couple of seasons when promotion/relegation shakes out. There will more boosters in the AAA leagues than the AA, more in AA than A, etc. So the median levels will be higher. He might be up near the top, but I'm sure he'll be close enough that it a) won't be a big penalty or b) can be regained quickly, probably within a season.

I think more people boost than you're giving credit for. On both of my teams, probably 65%+ boosted. I know on one of my teams it was more like 85%

edit: Fair enough on the boosting, but even if only 25% of the players boost (extremely conservative IMO), the player gets to 8 levels above the median in roughly 4 seasons. If it becomes a big issue, Bort will tweak it to make it work.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 13:16:05
 
MichN18
offline
Link
 
I can't be bothered to read this thread. Just imagining the amount of sobbing and wringing of hands being done by the gutters and the stackers is irritating.

For those of you with legitimate concerns about the impact the new changes will have, I think there is one thing that we can take for granted. If these changes wind up having a negative impact on agents who are playing within the spirit of the game, Bort will fix it. The law of unintended consequences all but guarantees that tweaks will need to be made, and I have every confidence that they will be made fairly and to the benefit of the GLB community.

I can only hope that the XP penalties turn out to be sufficiently severe so as to completely ruin teams that have been stacked in violation of the spirit of the game and Bort's clear policy statements against gutting and stacking.
 
Link
 
But there are also lots of team have more players not boosting. Again, as I mentioned earlier, it depends on the percentage of players boost. If it is less than 50%, there will be an issue like this.

EDIT: it really doesn't matter it is 25% or 49% of players boosting. As long as it is less than 50%, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In this case, it needs few adjustments to take care of this issue.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 13:21:04
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Then they will look to the leagues that minimize the penalty, AAA, then AA which is where they BELONG. boosting already inherently lowers the penalty and after 3 seasons worth, the penalty is minimized even more. chances are, a majority of people won't even notice to penalty anyway. Especially at ridiculously high levels.
 
Fenxis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
But there are also lots of team have more players not boosting. Again, as I mentioned earlier, it depends on the percentage of players boost. If it is less than 50%, there will be an issue like this.

EDIT: it really doesn't matter it is 25% or 49% of players boosting. As long as it is less than 50%, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In this case, it needs few adjustments to take care of this issue.


Well then they will be relegated to level appropriate leagues!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
Originally posted by Dirty Toilet Paper

Originally posted by Novus


Originally posted by schisno



That's exactly what I'm saying, you want to aspire to get the most stats or win and if you're spending hard earn money to do so than why not? Like I said make a league for people who pay and people who don't.

Otherwise there's a greater chance of no one having incentive to buy flex points.


It's not just about winning. It's about winning games that actually mean something.

If you're a Level 30 in a league full of Level 6s, what the hell are you proving, other than that you're an asshat? It's like an NFL player showing up at the local Pee Wee league and suiting up to play against first graders.

But HEY, he PAID the registration fee for the Pee Wee league, and it's all about WINNING and getting MAD STATS YO! And he PAID, so that makes it all okay.

No.

These rules will take that NFL player out of the Pee Wee league and kick him back into the NFL -- where he BELONGS.



I agree. This will be a good move. You have the some people on here who run around screaming like old women with any little change. Whahahaha.


Little change? This isn't a little change... This screws a lot of GMs who went the distance to make their teams A LOT better than their competition and what happens? Oh wait, because they did such a good job bringing in high level players to destroy the competition (isn't that the point of the game?) they can be docked XP during games..

That's not all, but building a winner is something everyone should want to do. But why do it now if you're being punished for building a superior team?

Oh, but "you're beating up on the lower tier teams" and "it's unsportsmanlike"..

Well move their asses up a league if it's that big of a deal. Honestly, the point of this game is to win... Not to make everyone even. It's like elementary school where everyone has to have the same amount of everything or else it's unfair.

You gotta start somewhere and if a team has to begin their journey to USA Pro by dominating teams in USA BBB, then so be it.

No one is stopping you from doing that. They are just saying you will have to do it by building a team over time as opposed to buying one all at once. That is just the direction this league is taking. You will just have to work to bring in players who are at the top of your leagues level scale. This will cause all levels of player to be in demand, but at the appropriate leauge level. Again we are all for it. It makes the owners\GM's job that much harder, as it should be. If it is to easy any moron will be able to figure it out and then what is the point?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Fenxis
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

But there are also lots of team have more players not boosting. Again, as I mentioned earlier, it depends on the percentage of players boost. If it is less than 50%, there will be an issue like this.

EDIT: it really doesn't matter it is 25% or 49% of players boosting. As long as it is less than 50%, the median league level will fall to non-boosting group. In this case, it needs few adjustments to take care of this issue.


Well then they will be relegated to level appropriate leagues!


Who? the teams with fewer players boosting? Who says a team with less players boosting will definitely perform worse, especially after advanced tactics come out later?
 
Link
 
Bullshit rule. I signed Canada AAA#2 in S2 because its my friends team.. Right now im tied for the highest level in the league, and if im investing money into this game I dont want ANY penalty.

2 Best teams go up, 2 Worse teams go down.

The leagues will even up as we go.. Patience is the key but apparently there is none here.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.