User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Jason Cash

Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Broker Hart
Do we need to go on with what is not real life football?

And every season Bort says that he'll attempt to fix those problems. I've certainly been in support of them too. One of the benefits of owning every position is that I've seen all sides of the issue, plus I've been an OC & DC since Season 3, so I'm sensitive to how any unbalanced part of the game affects the outcome.

Originally posted by
Deal with it, and build players to stop it.

You can't. Guys with 60+ carrying are still fumbling a ridiculous amount, while some guys with carrying in the 40s are doing fine. There is no build that will stop fumbles, you just have to get lucky. And like you said, no reasonable amount of tackling would stop elite powerbacks last season either. I was in here complaining about that too.


Originally posted by Jason Cash
its only a sim problem if EVERYONE has a problem with it. EVERYONE does NOT have a problem with it. So it has to be a build issue

Ugh. This statement has been repeated far too many times considering how blatantly illogical it is, plus the fact that people like me have pointed out why it's illogical. You are aware that the sim has a heavily random output, right? The random number generator is god, more or less. That's why you can get different results if the offense and defense both call the same plays. As has been repeatedly pointed out, some HBs with 60+ carrying have had 5+ fumble games while other HBs with carrying in the 40s have been fine. It is not a build issue.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by goshann
Nobody has answered my question.
I have a level 54 HB, 56 carry, 53 strength, 6 VA PTs allocated toward 'Steady Grip'.
Any advice for me on my build as he fumbled 7 times last game in USA A league play.



How fast is he???... I am willing to bet if yous wap your Speed number for your Carrying number that you would not fumble as much....
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

Originally posted by Jason Cash


Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds


obviously builds obviously builds

builds is the most pussy excuse i have ever seen
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Broker Hart

Do we need to go on with what is not real life football?

And every season Bort says that he'll attempt to fix those problems. I've certainly been in support of them too. One of the benefits of owning every position is that I've seen all sides of the issue, plus I've been an OC & DC since Season 3, so I'm sensitive to how any unbalanced part of the game affects the outcome.

Originally posted by

Deal with it, and build players to stop it.

You can't. Guys with 60+ carrying are still fumbling a ridiculous amount, while some guys with carrying in the 40s are doing fine. There is no build that will stop fumbles, you just have to get lucky. And like you said, no reasonable amount of tackling would stop elite powerbacks last season either. I was in here complaining about that too.


Originally posted by Jason Cash

its only a sim problem if EVERYONE has a problem with it. EVERYONE does NOT have a problem with it. So it has to be a build issue

Ugh. This statement has been repeated far too many times considering how blatantly illogical it is, plus the fact that people like me have pointed out why it's illogical. You are aware that the sim has a heavily random output, right? The random number generator is god, more or less. That's why you can get different results if the offense and defense both call the same plays. As has been repeatedly pointed out, some HBs with 60+ carrying have had 5+ fumble games while other HBs with carrying in the 40s have been fine. It is not a build issue.


then why isnt everyone having problems with it? Hmm? And also, Bort said nothing was changed from last season either. IF you dont think that it's your build, then you need to go hide back under your rock becuase you're an idiot
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash

its only a sim problem if EVERYONE has a problem with it. EVERYONE does NOT have a problem with it. So it has to be a build issue


Not true at all. Not every one is playing the same fumble-generating machines.

Put anyone up against this guy - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=78213 - and tell me what happens. He did that against an equal-leveled Pro team that was 8-8 last year.

And he's not the only one.

There is a ton of precedent in GLB that completely overrides your argument. QBs, DEs, HBs, etc., etc., etc.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Jason Cash

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks


Originally posted by Jason Cash



Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.


and its also not a GLB wide issue. not EVERYONE is having problems. It OBVIOUSLY has to be a problem with your builds


obviously builds obviously builds

builds is the most pussy excuse i have ever seen


and you've been in here crying like a bitch for 2 days
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Jason Cash


its only a sim problem if EVERYONE has a problem with it. EVERYONE does NOT have a problem with it. So it has to be a build issue


Not true at all. Not every one is playing the same fumble-generating machines.

Put anyone up against this guy - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=78213 - and tell me what happens. He did that against an equal-leveled Pro team that was 8-8 last year.

And he's not the only one.

There is a ton of precedent in GLB that completely overrides your argument. QBs, DEs, HBs, etc., etc., etc.


and there is a ton of precedent that over rides yours..and it's the people who arent fumbling becuase they didnt go with the flavor of the weak builds
 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Broker Hart


Running Backs don't fall forward for 4 yards when hit fron the front. They go backwards.
Teams cannot run the same play 75 times in a row ang gain 5 yards every time.
DE do not get 10 sacks in a game (They dont here anymore either)

Do we need to go on with what is not real life football?



All three things you cited have been changed in GLB.


Yes they have been changed. I agree with that. I am just saying that there are always issues that are not in line with real life Football.

 
StiffarmSteve
offline
Link
 
Fumbling needs fixed.
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise

First off how many times someone has fumbled in the NFL, NCAA, high school football doesn't matter at all. GLB is not any of those things.

Of course it matters, don't be stupid. This is a game simulating real football. It's not exactly the same, which is why I acknowledged that qualifier, but it's supposed to operate along the same lines. If GLB didn't resemble real football, I know I wouldn't have spent money on it, and I imagine that many people feel the same. That's why we play, because it's a football sim.


I can force fumbles on Madden with ease. Also a football sim and much closer to the NFL style. Does that mean that Madden isn't a "football sim"? Your argument is severely flawed.

Originally posted by

The fumbles seem fine to me, even including a 14 fumble performance in the OP since 8 of the fumbles occurred on special teams and the HBs on that team weren't doing anything even when they weren't fumbling (6 fumbles on 14 carries with no runs of more than 4 yards).
Originally posted by jdbolick

Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Any HB who isn't getting a lot of yards obviously deserves to fumble 42% of the time they run the ball. And 8 fumbles on special teams is perfectly reasonable. /sarcasm Good lord. It's like you guys don't even care how retarded you look when you post something dumb, just because it's the internet and you feel like you're anonymous.

My point is that the players on the OP's team were probably in a horrible morale spiral which once they started fumbling they couldn't get out of. 8 fumbles on special teams is reasonable when the players taking kicks don't have high carrying and/or cover up. The only person who looks bad here is you, slinging insults and generally coming across as a whiny baby.

Originally posted by jdbolick

My guy fumbled and I am not okay with it. I will whine until Bort caves and ruins another viable defensive option.

Last edited Apr 27, 2009 11:44:58
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
then why isnt everyone having problems with it? Hmm?

Because of the random number generator, you retard. I just got through explaining that to you. Good grief. If you're unlucky with the sim's numbers, you get screwed. If you aren't, you're fine.


Originally posted by Jason Cash
and it's the people who arent fumbling becuase they didnt go with the flavor of the weak builds

There is not a proportional relationship between carrying and fumbles. Some people with very high carrying are having 5+ fumble games, while some people with low carrying haven't fumbled at all yet. It is not about offensive builds. Stop posting before you embarrass yourself any further.
 
masierra
offline
Link
 
How can people here seriously not see this as a problem? I am all for fumbles in games (my team plays that way as well), but to see a ridiculously high number of fumbles is just not normal.

And how come we aren't seeing the defensive players cough up the ball when they get hit by a lineman with 80+ strength? I highly doubt any of these players have higher than 30 carrying. Shouldn't the ball fly out of their hands when they get hit?
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 11:46:39
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Jason Cash

then why isnt everyone having problems with it? Hmm?

Because of the random number generator, you retard. I just got through explaining that to you. Good grief. If you're unlucky with the sim's numbers, you get screwed. If you aren't, you're fine.


Originally posted by Jason Cash

and it's the people who arent fumbling becuase they didnt go with the flavor of the weak builds

There is not a proportional relationship between carrying and fumbles. Some people with very high carrying are having 5+ fumble games, while some people with low carrying haven't fumbled at all yet. It is not about offensive builds. Stop posting before you embarrass yourself any further.


But things werent changed about fumbling from last season. Is it NOT logical that defenders have just adjusted to the influx of power backs and have VAs to stop them? You can either listen to the logical responces that you are getting..Or you can continue to cry like a bitch until Bort nerfs defense again and you HB cant even be tackled at all
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by masierra
How can people here seriously not see this as a problem? I am all for fumbles in games (my team plays that was as well), but to see a ridiculously high number of fumbles is just not normal.

And how come we aren't seeing the defensive players cough up the ball when they get hit by a lineman with 80+ strength? I highly doubt any of these players have higher than 30 carrying. Shouldn't the ball fly out of their hands when they get hit?


If the offensive players have the right VAs and high tackling then yes they should also be fumbling. Highly doubt we will see RBs with 15 power tackling though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.