Originally posted by SCACE
Passing has been fine except for the high turnovers, but the yardage and TD's were definitely fine in most cases.No, the yards per pass are too low. I keep making this point because people have to realize it for it to be changed to be realistic.
Real life yards per pass attempt (not per completion, per attempt) average 6.9. That's about what the very, very best GLB passing offenses do in that category. That should be what the average GLB offense does, not the very, very best. And those very, very best likely got there by padding stats against weaker teams.
A sim needs to simulate something, in this case real football. The best NFL team in ypa in 2007 got 8.1, the worst 5.2, the median 6.9.
http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats;jsessionid=255197197C5B1F5B217648978B445203?offensiveStatisticCategory=TEAM_PASSING&archive=false&seasonType=REG&defensiveStatisticCategory=null&d-447263-o=2&conference=null&d-447263-s=PASSING_AVERAGE_YARDS&d-447263-n=1&season=2007&qualified=true&Submit=Find&tabSeq=2&role=TM&d-447263-p=1There might be one, some team that really overmatches its competition, that got 8.1 per attempt in GLB; but I doubt it. In most leagues, the
best teams' ypa are around the NFL
average of 6.9.
It was a major mistake when they nerfed passing because some QB's, throwing short because they lacked strength, had completion percentages that were unrealistically high.
So would most NFL (or NCAA or High School) QB's have extremely high completion %s, if they were throwing passes under 10 yards almost all the time, as the QB's in question were.
I can't say how important it is to me that this is known, because it'll only be fixed if it is.
Originally posted by SCACE
The correct answer is to provide more advanced tactics for the team and the individual QB.
- Pull when morale hits X% for the backup (key for the team)
- Willingness to risk throwing into coverage (key for the player, including a throw the ball away option)
- Willingness to cover up and take a sack (key for the player)I agree that all of these are very good options, and importantly something that allows a QB to set a tactic to avoid backfield passes. Someday they may be balanced, but right now they're a horrible deal.
But until people realize just how high realistic pass ypa are, and why it's important we get there, we'll never have a game with realistic O/D balance.
Pass ypa in real life are much higher than rush ypa, with higher risks of turnover (interception) compared to rushes as well as sack as the balancers. It's also thought, and is in the GLB game, that a rushing offense wears opponents down more; that may be true in real life, and it's already part of GLB.
Pass ypa being higher than rush ypa (with higher turonver risk than rushes) is vital, as that's why when you're behind you pass.