User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by superman8456


System should have max INT's thrown in a game.


That's gotta be the stupidest post of the thread, and there have been many candidates.


How? It will also control games with good teams vs. gutted teams.


LOL - who cares about controlling those games...better idea - fix the gutting problem, don't make excuses for it, and definitely don't do anything in the SIM engine to compensate for it.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
its just some of these players are getting better builds as they go...and others arent really focusing on others.. Like some QB's arent even bothering workin on vision and confidence...When vision is a very important thing for a QB and if his confidence level is low..and he throws ONE INT..then he's gonna throw 6 more after that
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
superman, just for you - yes.. the system does have a max INT's thrown in the game: it's 255. I am certain that this is the case.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
its just some of these players are getting better builds as they go...and others arent really focusing on others.. Like some QB's arent even bothering workin on vision and confidence...When vision is a very important thing for a QB and if his confidence level is low..and he throws ONE INT..then he's gonna throw 6 more after that


Sorry, not sure what point you are trying to make?
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Jason Cash

its just some of these players are getting better builds as they go...and others arent really focusing on others.. Like some QB's arent even bothering workin on vision and confidence...When vision is a very important thing for a QB and if his confidence level is low..and he throws ONE INT..then he's gonna throw 6 more after that


Sorry, not sure what point you are trying to make?



point is that if the CB's are learning to adapt their builds..and actually build better players....... Then the QBs better started adapting their builds so that they're actually good.

some players are easier to build...QB being one of them.. You think strength and throwing and go on about your business. Well now the Defense guys are catching up
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

This is football, not hockey. The starter only gets pulled if the coach believes that the backup is capable of performing better, which generally only happens in situations where the two QBs are considered to be close in ability. Favre and others have had terrible INT games (though nowhere near this bad) and didn't get pulled.


This QB is no Brett Favre, and Brett Favre is not your typical QB. QBs who are throwing interceptions left and right usually get pulled.

Originally posted by
You're clearly not understanding the point. Throwing 9 interceptions on 45 or fewer attempts has never happened at the college or pro level and should not happen in a realistic football simulation, yet it's happened at least twice in GLB.


There are almost 35k regular season and playoff games played on GLB in season 3. That is almost 130 NFL seasons. How many NFL seasons have been played in the modern era with teams passing the way they do now?

Again, I'm not saying that there is nothing wrong with the sim. Quite the opposite. I disagree with the idea that this particular result is absurd.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
jdbolick - I know you like to think you are a guru, but you've admitted to not knowing GLB all that well and you are missing some key points.

I don't see any points that I'm missing, as I've responded to every excuse you've made, you're just so intent on living inside Bort's colon that you ignore everything you can't rebut and pretend that you've provided adequate rationalizations.
Originally posted by
You are also saying the code needs fixing in regards to morale when it is working as intended.

Why don't you stop babbling about what is and isn't intended when you're not part of the development team? Unless I'm missing something, you showed up near the end of season 1, and you're not involved with the creation or maintenance of GLB. You're just some random person trying to pretend like you're in a position to know what was or wasn't intended. Note that I am not speculating on what was intended, I simply recognize that this is a problem and that these results shouldn't happen in a game that purports to be a realistic simulation.
Originally posted by
it just means players can afford to put less points in confidence because people like you want the SIM to baby them - not the answer.

One of the impediments that prevents me from being able to enlighten you, beyond your enormous and unjustified ego, is that you apparently don't have a sufficient understand of mathematical concepts to understand the significant of what I'm describing. Any time you have a flat percentage penalty, you have a substantial risk of a cascade effect because one bad event greatly increases the chances of another bad event, and so on and so forth.

While I have no idea about what is the actual performance penalty of throwing an interception, let's indulge in a hypothetical and say that it's -5% to stats. So after QB Joe's first interception, his stats drop to "0.95 x X." The penalized attributes increase the likelihood of a second interception, dropping him to "0.95^2 x X," or 0.9025 x X. With each passing interception, we see more drastic results. 0.857, then 0.815, then .774 and so on. By the end of this chain, the original AA level QB now has the effective attributes of someone much lower level.

A more appropriate design would be to have declining penalties where the fourth interception doesn't hurt as much as the first. You'd still see morale drop with every bad play, but instead of being three-fourths of the beginning stats, you could be something more along the lines of 85-90%. That's more realistic and would prevent these absurd results where quarterbacks throw 60% of their regular season interceptions total in one playoff game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Passing has been fine except for the high turnovers, but the yardage and TD's were definitely fine in most cases.


No, the yards per pass are too low. I keep making this point because people have to realize it for it to be changed to be realistic.

Real life yards per pass attempt (not per completion, per attempt) average 6.9. That's about what the very, very best GLB passing offenses do in that category. That should be what the average GLB offense does, not the very, very best. And those very, very best likely got there by padding stats against weaker teams.

A sim needs to simulate something, in this case real football. The best NFL team in ypa in 2007 got 8.1, the worst 5.2, the median 6.9.

http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats;jsessionid=255197197C5B1F5B217648978B445203?offensiveStatisticCategory=TEAM_PASSING&archive=false&seasonType=REG&defensiveStatisticCategory=null&d-447263-o=2&conference=null&d-447263-s=PASSING_AVERAGE_YARDS&d-447263-n=1&season=2007&qualified=true&Submit=Find&tabSeq=2&role=TM&d-447263-p=1

There might be one, some team that really overmatches its competition, that got 8.1 per attempt in GLB; but I doubt it. In most leagues, the best teams' ypa are around the NFL average of 6.9.

It was a major mistake when they nerfed passing because some QB's, throwing short because they lacked strength, had completion percentages that were unrealistically high.

So would most NFL (or NCAA or High School) QB's have extremely high completion %s, if they were throwing passes under 10 yards almost all the time, as the QB's in question were.

I can't say how important it is to me that this is known, because it'll only be fixed if it is.

Originally posted by SCACE
The correct answer is to provide more advanced tactics for the team and the individual QB.

- Pull when morale hits X% for the backup (key for the team)

- Willingness to risk throwing into coverage (key for the player, including a throw the ball away option)

- Willingness to cover up and take a sack (key for the player)


I agree that all of these are very good options, and importantly something that allows a QB to set a tactic to avoid backfield passes. Someday they may be balanced, but right now they're a horrible deal.

But until people realize just how high realistic pass ypa are, and why it's important we get there, we'll never have a game with realistic O/D balance.

Pass ypa in real life are much higher than rush ypa, with higher risks of turnover (interception) compared to rushes as well as sack as the balancers. It's also thought, and is in the GLB game, that a rushing offense wears opponents down more; that may be true in real life, and it's already part of GLB.

Pass ypa being higher than rush ypa (with higher turonver risk than rushes) is vital, as that's why when you're behind you pass.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 21:01:31
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.


There are some very well built QB's I'm sure, and I know from looking that occasionally the top one or two teams in a league get over 6.9 ypa. But look around at league stats and see if you can find a league (the higher level the league, the better, as the higher level leagues are where the lower level leagues are headed) where half the teams get 6.9 or more yards per pass attempt.

Remember, 6.9 ypa is average in real life, not what the best do but what the average do. The best get more than 8.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
jdbolick - you've been nothing but an asshole to me this entire thread, and I'm about done arguing with you when you just don't have a clue. I haven't ignored any point you've tried to make. I don't need to be "in the know" to understand what the creators expect out of confidence and morale - it has been posted on by the creator, the admins and the mods enough times to know what the purpose of both are AND what the risks are for neglecting it. Add in a horrible build, and you just exaggerate the problem. Add in no ability to throw the ball away, cover up and take a sack or sub the QB out when his morale drops, and you exaggerate the problem.

I strongly believe that confidence and morale are working as the creator intends them too, and I've proposed very valid ways to solve the issue without lessening the importance of the attribute. All you have done is propose a poor solution that will lessen the importance of confidence, thus allowing it to be neglected.

Sorry, but that in and of itself is an epic fail.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
This QB is no Brett Favre, and Brett Favre is not your typical QB. QBs who are throwing interceptions left and right usually get pulled.

No, they do not when they are the unquestioned starter and have a track record of performance. If the coach considers two QBs to be relatively similar in ability, then yes, bad plays result in one replacing the other. In D1-A and the NFL, however, QBs don't get pulled very often.
Originally posted by
There are almost 35k regular season and playoff games played on GLB in season 3.

Can you point me to some verification of that number? In any case, there are approximately 1000 D1-A and NFL football games played each season. What happened in GLB at least twice already has never happened before in "real football" at those levels.
Originally posted by
I disagree with the idea that this particular result is absurd.

I'm sorry, but that's not even really debatable. The result was unquestionably unrealistic, the only debate is about whether or not that sporadic lack of realism needs fixing.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 21:08:11
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.


that IS the problem because most people just up those two with a QB.

builds are just getting better than they were last season. My linebacker had 3 missed tackles and 103 made tackles last season... This season he had 3 missed in one game alone
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by SCACE

haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.


There are some very well built QB's I'm sure, and I know from looking that occasionally the top one or two teams in a league get over 6.9 ypa. But look around at league stats and see if you can find a league (the higher level the league, the better, as the higher level leagues are where the lower level leagues are headed) where half the teams get 6.9 or more yards per pass attempt.

Remember, 6.9 ypa is average in real life, not what the best do but what the average do. The best get more than 8.


Quick question - do you think its a sim issue, or teams "playing it safe" vs. "playing it risky" by not boosting the long pass more often?

And conversely, do teams not set the long pass much yet because their QB's aren't fully completed yet?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Originally posted by SCACE

haha - if you think a good QB is easy to build...maybe that's the problem here. Defenses are getting creative, if you think throwing + strength then coast....ouch is all I can say.

Truth is, there is a mix between better DEF builds AND an overpowered defense - which makes the better builds look even better than the are. There are good QB's out there as well though, just look around the leagues.


that IS the problem because most people just up those two with a QB.

builds are just getting better than they were last season. My linebacker had 3 missed tackles and 103 made tackles last season... This season he had 3 missed in one game alone


If your point here is that players need to work hard on their builds, you are just stating the obvious...not really sure where you are going with this.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.