User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
80 tp's down to 10 filtered by 10 every season. Pretty much the s13 dots on wouldn't be affected, and all the new players created are in the era of the archetype who have a huge advantage. So every objection you have is false.

You are losing touch with how this game is played TBH, and the fact that there is 0 advantage to a single player with my idea shows me you don't get it TBH....


I +10 this one.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
forget removing VAs, just apply a decline % of base attributes.

5% not good enough? Make it 6%


I prefer VA removal, Im not sure you can put a % on it and I think 5% is too much. Look at the Whores....they are season 6 dots and dominating...builds>>>>Level.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
10 TPs at the start of a build is actually pretty significant. It's why everyone creates at day 40 or 41 instead of 45 or 46.


you do it by 10 per season, and you scale it so in s13 its over with, and that is only 30 bt, and the gain those s14 players get from an extra season under the new training system far outweighs the 10 tp. Try again
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by 5STAR

stupid idea

now we have to hunt down what % will be lost on a select few dots based on age?


It would be the same as their normal decline pct. It would just treat them like they're 480 days old for X extra days.


what is worth more

5% of all attributes or 8 VAs, 40 trains and 120 BTs

 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by 5STAR

stupid idea

now we have to hunt down what % will be lost on a select few dots based on age?


It would be the same as their normal decline pct. It would just treat them like they're 480 days old for X extra days.


yup, thats the ticket
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Lets us train till 480.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
10 TPs at the start of a build is actually pretty significant. It's why everyone creates at day 40 or 41 instead of 45 or 46.


It's not as significant as 100 TPs at any point in a build.

And I really don't want to lose the 480's if this is going through. Everyone thinks we need a bigger player base and I agree with that - it just needs to be as equitable as possible from the start.

Good luck with the debate all!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
what is worth more

5% of all attributes or 8 VAs, 40 trains and 120 BTs



You are assuming the 120BTs.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by 5STAR


stupid idea

now we have to hunt down what % will be lost on a select few dots based on age?


It would be the same as their normal decline pct. It would just treat them like they're 480 days old for X extra days.


what is worth more

5% of all attributes or 8 VAs, 40 trains and 120 BTs



i think 5% is, no?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
80 tp's down to 10 filtered by 10 every season. Pretty much the s13 dots on wouldn't be affected, and all the new players created are in the era of the archetype who have a huge advantage. So every objection you have is false.

You are losing touch with how this game is played TBH, and the fact that there is 0 advantage to a single player with my idea shows me you don't get it TBH....


good way to get bort to listen to you itp: tell him he doesn't get it.

Originally posted by Bort
It would be the same as their normal decline pct. It would just treat them like they're 480 days old for X extra days.


the problem there is that either the penalty will be too strong, and those dots will fade to retirement, or it won't be strong enough, and tehy'll have an advantage. the chances of you getting the bang on are virtually nil.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Can't quote in Linux for whatever reason:

I understand that, but what's really silly to me is that everyone is in here bickering over the new system catering to a certain generation of players.

Guess what though (not directed at you, just a rant in general), this game unintentionally always has.

It's catering to the S1-2 guys, still to this day that are benefiting from S5-6 being their second or third generation build projects.
We're still reaping the benefits of getting here first, the guys who got here in S5 and rolled a S5? Those dots likely suck, and guess what their second gen they rolled in S8 when they new the game?

Well you're gunna have to wait another half a calendar year before your dots are relevant.

Great idea in concept, but without coupling this change with a reduction in time it takes to hit the plateau is once again catering to a certain generation of players.

If the game wants to survive and thrive, it needs to find a way to make the life span of a peaking player longer, while decreasing the 2 year waiting list to play the end game.

No game ever succeeded without an end game, sure leveling is fun, but if you can't ever play the top end content why play?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
the problem there is that either the penalty will be too strong, and those dots will fade to retirement, or it won't be strong enough, and tehy'll have an advantage. the chances of you getting the bang on are virtually nil.


I think you are overestimating things.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4982 <--------- Season 6 dots in the WL and dominating.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
please propose a penalty that's not to weak and not too strong.

you can't, because different BT and % numbers are worth different amounts to different builds.


yup. Remove the arguments

1) We won't have enough players - because we will now
2) But I already made changes - are you saying that in the 5-6 hours since this announcement was made you made AEQ and personnel decisions that will define your or your club in the long term? I doubt this and if you did, that's on you..you should know better
3) I'm in WL and want to keep my dots

You have no sustantive arguments for the 480 thing.

440 is much easier, easier to understand vs. penalties and handing VP's and stuff out, and makes total sense.

The basic problem here is that EVERY plan except for the 440 thing, to me, gives the 440+ guys some type of advantage. Even if the realize a penalty, they have already been at the top for a season...now they get 3 more? no way.

There is alot of sense being made in this thread by quite a few people, then there are 4-5 people who have a very good team right NOW who just want to keep it that way and are creating weird non-sensical arguments to try to sway opinion. Either that or Blackmailing Bort "I will quit" or "I made decisions and now things are all messed up if you do this"

We all know what the right decision is...
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz

Well you're gunna have to wait another half a calendar year before your dots are relevant.

Great idea in concept, but without coupling this change with a reduction in time it takes to hit the plateau is once again catering to a certain generation of players.

If the game wants to survive and thrive, it needs to find a way to make the life span of a peaking player longer, while decreasing the 2 year waiting list to play the end game.

No game ever succeeded without an end game, sure leveling is fun, but if you can't ever play the top end content why play?


I totally agree with you, but I also know we are in the minority on this subject.

 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by Bort

Newly created players are now worse than every player created before them because they weren't around to get these extra points? Doesn't seem quite right. You'd have to add those points to newly created players too, and we're not doing that.


80 tp's down to 10 filtered by 10 every season. Pretty much the s13 dots on wouldn't be affected, and all the new players created are in the era of the archetype who have a huge advantage. So every objection you have is false.

You are losing touch with how this game is played TBH, and the fact that there is 0 advantage to a single player with my idea shows me you don't get it TBH....


There is a huge gap between season 5-6 dots and season 13 dots...so you are saying everything in between would be affected? Because if so, that makes your idea p terrible now. Otherwise, you need more clarity.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.