User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Originally posted by jdbolick


Originally posted by lolMurp



Exploit, no. Ridiculous, yes. Exploit, no. An example of an exploit was the "I am decimals!" scandal, the strong I slam, and boosting in pee-wee. But forced fumbles is not something we're intentionally bringing on.

Agreed. Defenses can increase their chance of causing fumbles, while carrying doesn't seem to matter much when it comes to preventing them (unless you need something absurd like 75+ carrying), but the mass turnover games only happen every once in a while and generally not to the same teams. It's a ghost in the sim.


Why is that absurd when you're going up against defenders with 80+ (90+) strength and over the dbl cap in tackling?


A better question is, why are you not up to the defender's level?

If you're that good, it shouldn't be a doublecap problem.


That's pretty much what I was asking him. I mean what does everyone think a defender should have to cause these fumbles? They think their HBs need just 60 carrying/strength at level 50ish, so I am asking them what they expect defenders to have..
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Why is that absurd when you're going up against defenders with 80+ (90+) strength and over the dbl cap in tackling?

Ugh. Arguing on the internet means constantly explaining things that should be obvious.

First, the only defenders who have 80+ strength are defensive linemen, or maybe a very small percentage of MLBs who just didn't bother much with speed or agility. Second, there are only so many SPs to go around, so you can't get everything above 68. Having 75+ carrying on a HB means neglecting some other important attribute. Maybe you could do it if you didn't try to push agility beyond 48, I don't know, but you'd need to sacrifice something. 60+ carrying is already a massive investment, and while I'm definitely not expecting that to prevent fumbles altogether, it should prevent you from having 5+ in one game. Just for reference, no HB has ever had 5 fumbles in one game in NFL history (yes, GLB /= NFL, but still).
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Why is that absurd when you're going up against defenders with 80+ (90+) strength and over the dbl cap in tackling?

Ugh. Arguing on the internet means constantly explaining things that should be obvious.

First, the only defenders who have 80+ strength are defensive linemen, or maybe a very small percentage of MLBs who just didn't bother much with speed or agility. Second, there are only so many SPs to go around, so you can't get everything above 68. Having 75+ carrying on a HB means neglecting some other important attribute. Maybe you could do it if you didn't try to push agility beyond 48, I don't know, but you'd need to sacrifice something. 60+ carrying is already a massive investment, and while I'm definitely not expecting that to prevent fumbles altogether, it should prevent you from having 5+ in one game. Just for reference, no HB has ever had 5 fumbles in one game in NFL history (yes, GLB /= NFL, but still).


First off how many times someone has fumbled in the NFL, NCAA, high school football doesn't matter at all. GLB is not any of those things. If you know that it doesn't have anything to do with the topic at hand why do you keep bringing it up?

The fumbles seem fine to me, even including a 14 fumble performance in the OP since 8 of the fumbles occurred on special teams and the HBs on that team weren't doing anything even when they weren't fumbling (6 fumbles on 14 carries with no runs of more than 4 yards). Some teams this season will be very good at forcing fumbles thanks to the nerf of the attribute VAs and people stocking up on some of the only useful VAs for D-line and LBs. If you don't want to fumble a bunch invest in cover up and use a powerback at KR/PR.
 
masierra
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=482364&mode=pbp

Check out the third quarter. If this happened in real life the players would all be cut. I'm not even talking about my own team. It looked like the game got stuck in a fumble frenzy for like 5 minutes. just looks strange to me
 
goshann
offline
Link
 
Nobody has answered my question.
I have a level 54 HB, 56 carry, 53 strength, 6 VA PTs allocated toward 'Steady Grip'.
Any advice for me on my build as he fumbled 7 times last game in USA A league play.

 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
The big problem is a general problem with the sim.

There are huge, gigantic swings every season.

In one season, elusive backs are very overpowered. In the next, they are worthless. Season after that, power backs are horribly overpowered, next, they are worthless. Now, forcing fumbles is way too easy.

There is no balance. Instead of a slight increase to forced fumbles, or a slight decrease in the power of RBs, the pendulum is swinging from one extreme to the other. That is where the problem is for most people, myself included. RBs should not go from 4 fumbles a season to 4 fumbles a game, even with LBs getting STR/TKL over the course of a boost. On that same note, an RB shouldn't go from 3 YPC to 7 YPC either.

The pendulum needs to stop swinging from one extreme to the next, and instead be gradual. We should see an RB fumble maybe once per 4 games for neglecting carrying, then maybe once per three the next season, and so on and so forth. LBs who neglect tackling should gradually see missed tackle numbers go up, not see them jump from 0-1 per game to 3-4 per game just by neglecting STR/TKL for one season.

Another big problem is that builds are not encouraged to be balanced until very recently. Players have been encouraged to build extreme builds to have a chance to be viable in the sim. Otherwise, their player did nothing and they were no longer motivated to play. What this game really needs at this point is a reset and a doing away with of decreasing level gains in stats. It needs to discourage slow building, which would discourage the idea of freak builds. Until that happens, the pendulum will keep swiniging wildly instead of gradually.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
First off how many times someone has fumbled in the NFL, NCAA, high school football doesn't matter at all. GLB is not any of those things.

Of course it matters, don't be stupid. This is a game simulating real football. It's not exactly the same, which is why I acknowledged that qualifier, but it's supposed to operate along the same lines. If GLB didn't resemble real football, I know I wouldn't have spent money on it, and I imagine that many people feel the same. That's why we play, because it's a football sim.

Originally posted by
The fumbles seem fine to me, even including a 14 fumble performance in the OP since 8 of the fumbles occurred on special teams and the HBs on that team weren't doing anything even when they weren't fumbling (6 fumbles on 14 carries with no runs of more than 4 yards).

Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Any HB who isn't getting a lot of yards obviously deserves to fumble 42% of the time they run the ball. And 8 fumbles on special teams is perfectly reasonable. /sarcasm Good lord. It's like you guys don't even care how retarded you look when you post something dumb, just because it's the internet and you feel like you're anonymous.
 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Why is that absurd when you're going up against defenders with 80+ (90+) strength and over the dbl cap in tackling?

Ugh. Arguing on the internet means constantly explaining things that should be obvious.

First, the only defenders who have 80+ strength are defensive linemen, or maybe a very small percentage of MLBs who just didn't bother much with speed or agility. Second, there are only so many SPs to go around, so you can't get everything above 68. Having 75+ carrying on a HB means neglecting some other important attribute. Maybe you could do it if you didn't try to push agility beyond 48, I don't know, but you'd need to sacrifice something. 60+ carrying is already a massive investment, and while I'm definitely not expecting that to prevent fumbles altogether, it should prevent you from having 5+ in one game. Just for reference, no HB has ever had 5 fumbles in one game in NFL history (yes, GLB /= NFL, but still).


Running Backs don't fall forward for 4 yards when hit fron the front. They go backwards.
Teams cannot run the same play 75 times in a row ang gain 5 yards every time.
DE do not get 10 sacks in a game (They dont here anymore either)

Do we need to go on with what is not real life football?

I have a DE and am the recipient of this Fumble mess, and I honestly am not that happy about it either, but I am also not happy about every season I have to change my players build to make him productive. Every one wants more production for their player. I understand that, and I am sure Bort does as well. Am I happy with the way things have gone in this game? Heck no, but last season, we had to deal with teams running the Strong I, and nothing was changed until the season was over. Offensive owners did not seem to mind when it was helping their players, why all the whining now tha tsomethign has swung the oposite direct. Deal with it, and build players to stop it. That is what we as Defensive owners were told all season. I am sure because this is a problem that is affecting to offensive side of things it will be changed pretty quickly. It it was a problem that the defense was complaining about it would be ignored until next season.


 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Whiners.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
The big problem is a general problem with the sim.

There are huge, gigantic swings every season.

In one season, elusive backs are very overpowered. In the next, they are worthless. Season after that, power backs are horribly overpowered, next, they are worthless. Now, forcing fumbles is way too easy.

There is no balance. Instead of a slight increase to forced fumbles, or a slight decrease in the power of RBs, the pendulum is swinging from one extreme to the other. That is where the problem is for most people, myself included. RBs should not go from 4 fumbles a season to 4 fumbles a game, even with LBs getting STR/TKL over the course of a boost. On that same note, an RB shouldn't go from 3 YPC to 7 YPC either.

The pendulum needs to stop swinging from one extreme to the next, and instead be gradual. We should see an RB fumble maybe once per 4 games for neglecting carrying, then maybe once per three the next season, and so on and so forth. LBs who neglect tackling should gradually see missed tackle numbers go up, not see them jump from 0-1 per game to 3-4 per game just by neglecting STR/TKL for one season.

Another big problem is that builds are not encouraged to be balanced until very recently. Players have been encouraged to build extreme builds to have a chance to be viable in the sim. Otherwise, their player did nothing and they were no longer motivated to play. What this game really needs at this point is a reset and a doing away with of decreasing level gains in stats. It needs to discourage slow building, which would discourage the idea of freak builds. Until that happens, the pendulum will keep swiniging wildly instead of gradually.


its only a sim problem if EVERYONE has a problem with it. EVERYONE does NOT have a problem with it. So it has to be a build issue
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 11:31:02
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great
 
Link
 
Originally posted by goshann
Nobody has answered my question.
I have a level 54 HB, 56 carry, 53 strength, 6 VA PTs allocated toward 'Steady Grip'.
Any advice for me on my build as he fumbled 7 times last game in USA A league play.



Get carrying, Strength, and Confidence to at least 70, and don't play teams that cause fumbles. That's apparently the only thing that can be done right now.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Broker Hart

Running Backs don't fall forward for 4 yards when hit fron the front. They go backwards.
Teams cannot run the same play 75 times in a row ang gain 5 yards every time.
DE do not get 10 sacks in a game (They dont here anymore either)

Do we need to go on with what is not real life football?



All three things you cited have been changed in GLB.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Bort's already said he didn't change anything to the FF chance from last season. In this thread even. It's not a sim problem.

Bort also said he's gonna give you guys a little carry sliding bar (and he's going to get it in the testing server first, and I believe he said he was working on that last night). He said that in this thread also.

Don't believe that? Find it yourself in this 64 page thread. He said all of this last night/evening. In this thread.

Short version: Quit your bitching, Bort's going to rescue you guys with a carrying slider bar.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Anybody really actually look at STAMINA as a possible issue with fumbles? I'm sure a tired as runningback cant really hold on to the ball all that great


I'm sure he can do ok... but running backs are fumbling multiple times w/ less than 15 carries... not a stamina issue. And I remind you that these are guys that have not had any fumbling problems before.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.