User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Team Loans, Chemistry
Page:
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps

why should we have a season by season reset?


Maybe to make the game realistic?

If this were a real team with a real offseason the team chemistry would drastically change over the long offseason period.

So it only makes sense that if this game is going to grow from BETA stage and be realistic that it would reset after EVERY season.

 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
There should be a reset to help give teams that are not as good the chance to make offseason moves to improve their teams. Without a reset how would the newer teams and worse teams ever catch up?

It also parallels real football: in NFL there is not a lot of team movement, especially trades or even FA pickups, during the season. There is a TON of movement during the offseason.
 
Thaliko
offline
Link
 
i think the best way to do a reset would be at the end of the regular season, any chemistry below 70 or 60 or even 50 whatever bort decides fair would be reset to that level. This way teams that have stayed together will not be penalized for it but teams that got screwed or had to rebuild for other reasons would not be completely lost. Also doing it at the end of the regular season would mean your still going to take meaningful hits as non playoff teams shuffle players around keeping it somewhat fair are realistic.

And i dont believe signing an All-Pro caliber player helps any teams chemistry in the nfl. A boost to moral definatly, but they still have to learn new systems, learn to play with new team mates, learn the strengths and weaknesses of his fellow players around him so that they can contribute at their highest potential. Not to mention personalities and ego's have a huge effect on team chemistry irl.

One last thing to consider is how much chemistry really effects a team. I have not seen any numbers just bort said "small" effect. I'd define small as 2-3% stat boost at 100 with 5% starting to be significant. As i understand it if a team is going to beat you by 14 with you both a 70, that team would still win in theory with them at 0 and your team at 100.
Last edited May 10, 2008 12:54:03
 
Titus Pullo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
Originally posted by LT56

Originally posted by lawdog


Are chemistry levels reset at the end of the season?


I don't think any of us know that answer. Bort and the others would be the ones to tell us that.

But I think a reset would be a good idea.


why should we have a season by season reset?



In college and the NFL, a teams 'team chemistry' is established in training camp each year. That is why they usually take off to some location other then their home facilities where they eat and live together for a few weeks. New coaches and new players come in with new schemes and skills and a new team chemistry is established.

So reseting any team below 70 to 70 before each season starts makes sence to me. Teams who have stayed together for several years though and have a current team chemistry rating above 70 should not be punished for keeping the team together IMO. Brady and Moss have already established some chemistry and figured out each others tendicies and timing of throws/route running. They don't need to relearn those things every year.
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
The best way to do it would be to have every addition or subtraction affect the team by -1 and every trade -2 until around 6 games before the playoffs. Then, at that time, triple the penalty for trades.

This way, teams can attempt to build, but when it comes playoff time, they will have to already of had a good group of guys in place. Teams will still be able to make trades, but it will be tougher for them to put together a playoff run.

In real football, there are over 50 players on everyday rosters. The effect of a trade or addition is not as significant as in other sports. Most people don't realize it, but the everyday rosters change from game to game, and it really doesn't have an affect on overall chemistry.
 
LT56
offline
Link
 
Another solution would be to keep chemistry settings as they are now, but only have it this way IN-SEASON. When the off-season comes around, much more changes should be allowed without the chemistry hits---because you would still have training camp, etc. to develop team chemistry.

But, this change would have to go along with a change in contract structure. Contracts ending in the middle of seasons cause teams to make moves and create chemistry hits. Contracts need to end at the end of seasons--not in mid-season.

I see these as two HUGE issues to the realism of GLB and one cannot be solved without addressing the other.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Titus Pullo
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps

Originally posted by LT56


Originally posted by lawdog



Are chemistry levels reset at the end of the season?


I don't think any of us know that answer. Bort and the others would be the ones to tell us that.

But I think a reset would be a good idea.


why should we have a season by season reset?



In college and the NFL, a teams 'team chemistry' is established in training camp each year. That is why they usually take off to some location other then their home facilities where they eat and live together for a few weeks. New coaches and new players come in with new schemes and skills and a new team chemistry is established.

So reseting any team below 70 to 70 before each season starts makes sence to me. Teams who have stayed together for several years though and have a current team chemistry rating above 70 should not be punished for keeping the team together IMO. Brady and Moss have already established some chemistry and figured out each others tendicies and timing of throws/route running. They don't need to relearn those things every year.


yes reset teams below to a certain level but teams about 70 or whatever you are right should not be reset, i would say teams below 50-60 get reset to around there no higher

OR alternatively everyteam gets a 10 point jump in chemistry for overall, offense, and defense that would be more fair and realistic
 
comicfanman
offline
Link
 
I vote for teams that had to get rid of CPU at beginning of this season should catch somewhat of a break. All of the human players on my team that I signed wondered what happend to the chemistry. I spent hours and hours trying to sign and trade off CPUs and did not have time to read all posts about this chemistry. We are finally up to a 11 chemistry.

Maybe an email with rule changes should have been sent to the owners of teams.

Last edited May 10, 2008 14:23:16
 
ortizhr13
offline
Link
 
Could you put up a separate post with everything that happens with chemistry? Like what happens when you drop someone below lvl 5..etc..
 
ravensfan
offline
Link
 
i hate this chemistry crap....the core of our team has been together for 2 seasons and we get along great but since we have made a few moves..mostly with backups.we have to take a big hit..it is idiotic that moving back-ups has affected us so negatively....i guess my owner should be like some and not move people when they get a chance to start somewhere....what bullshit.
 
baseball52
offline
Link
 
It should be determined by the actual player not the computer
 
comicfanman
offline
Link
 
Thats a good idea, let teammates have a rating system
 
Staners
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ravensfan
i hate this chemistry crap....the core of our team has been together for 2 seasons and we get along great but since we have made a few moves..mostly with backups.we have to take a big hit..it is idiotic that moving back-ups has affected us so negatively....i guess my owner should be like some and not move people when they get a chance to start somewhere....what bullshit.


Not disagreeing with your perspective, but the job of a great owner is keeping his entire roster happy. This is very difficult when many on here all want to be the starters etc. If owners look at their roster and are honest with players about their role for the team, maybe this would be less of an issue. I know as an owner I spend a lot of time explaining to my players what I am trying to do and explaining that it is a squad effort not just my 24 starters.

I think you are right that it is unfortunate that the kind owners who allow unhappy players to leave, take a chem hit, but thats life. If they trade a player they also get revenue too so its not all downside.

Maybe if you simply cut a player you dont take a chem hit, but even talking as an owner you shouldnt be able to keep cutting and trading your roster and this have no effect on the OVERALL chem of the roster.

This game shouldnt be easy! It should be difficult with lots of balances to weigh up and difficult decisions to make. Some on here want all actions to have no downside.

Leave exactly the way that is, apart from look at releasing players for no chem hit, then owners can weigh up whether to trade or to cut and also maybe be a bit more careful about who they offer contracts to, just like in real NFL.

 
Link
 
Once again it's not the chem hit that's unrealistic but gaining it back. 1/day is too slow. There should be an accelerated gain once you've got you team set and also a bonus for wins.
 
Staners
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoldenHorseshoe
Once again it's not the chem hit that's unrealistic but gaining it back. 1/day is too slow. There should be an accelerated gain once you've got you team set and also a bonus for wins.


Thats what morale is for isnt it? win games your players increase morale and lose games and morale drops?

Maybe they should look at 1 point loss for each of your first 3 changes in a season, 2 for next 3, and so on...

I think that gaining 1 point back per day you stay the same is spot on though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.