User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
It amuses me how many people continue to miss the point in their haste to plant pouty lips on Bort's behind. The people who don't have a player on Nashville aren't concerned that the game was some grave injustice that needs to be rectified. People like me are concerned that there is an obvious problem with the simulation engine and we're worried that similar nonsensical results could happen to us.


And to sum up some of the more pertinent points:

* No QB in the history of college or pro football has ever thrown 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer attempts. It has never happened.

* Regardless of personal opinions about Jay Slim's build, he had success in that conference during the regular season and was not turnover prone.

* While some people have claimed that Miami gameplanned to take away Nashville's running game and others have claimed the opposite that they gameplanned to focus on the pass (and thus get interceptions), that only addresses what set the ball in motion. Miami deserved to win because they were the better team and seemingly had the better approach (not sure why Nashville tried to pass so often early in the game, but that's another issue), but this game doesn't turn into a full-fledged Godzilla-style disaster movie without poor programming of morale. By having a flat percentage decrease instead of a sliding scale, these types of cascades are not only possible but probable over a large enough sample.


As someone else in the thread pointed out a number of pages ago, another GLB game between two similarly rated teams also ended with one throwing 9 interceptions. It's a problem with the simulation engine. While bad plays should hurt morale and lead to more bad plays, having a flat percentage instead of a decreasing penalty leads to cascade effects where a team's attributes are basically wiped out completely. That's why Slim threw 9 interceptions when he'd only had 15 the whole regular season, and why Nashville ran for less than yard per carry even though it seems as if Miami was playing a pass defense. Unbounded morale penalties caused Nashville to become basically a D-league team, which is poor programming.

When something like this comes to light, it doesn't need misguided sycophants leaping to the game's defense. This is a beta game and flaws are to be expected. This is one, it was discovered, it's been discussed, and the proper response now is not to make excuses for it but rather to fix it.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigdawg_56
Will this hit 1000 posts or 75 pages first? I'm betting on 1000 posts.


obviously 1000 post. 75 pages would be 1100+ post
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
It amuses me how many people continue to miss the point in their haste to plant pouty lips on Bort's behind. The people who don't have a player on Nashville aren't concerned that the game was some grave injustice that needs to be rectified. People like me are concerned that there is an obvious problem with the simulation engine and we're worried that similar nonsensical results could happen to us.


And to sum up some of the more pertinent points:

* No QB in the history of college or pro football has ever thrown 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer attempts. It has never happened.



It has happened in GLB though already and with only 40 attempts.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=39486

 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Nobody has thrown 9 interceptions in fewer than 45 passes because they would be yanked long before that.

I agree that the sim needs some tweaks, but 9 interceptions shouldn't be impossible.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
maybe they used drugs i havent heard anything about testings yet
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigdawg_56
It has happened in GLB though already and with only 40 attempts. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=39486

Thanks for the info. Having more and more examples just serves to highlight what I'm saying. The programming needs to be adjusted because it currently has a flaw that, on some occasions, will produce grossly unrealistic results.


Originally posted by methomps
Nobody has thrown 9 interceptions in fewer than 45 passes because they would be yanked long before that. I agree that the sim needs some tweaks, but 9 interceptions shouldn't be impossible.

This is football, not hockey. The starter only gets pulled if the coach believes that the backup is capable of performing better, which generally only happens in situations where the two QBs are considered to be close in ability. Favre and others have had terrible INT games (though nowhere near this bad) and didn't get pulled.

You're clearly not understanding the point. Throwing 9 interceptions on 45 or fewer attempts has never happened at the college or pro level and should not happen in a realistic football simulation, yet it's happened at least twice in GLB. While I'm not saying there should be a hard cap on the number of interceptions a quarterback can throw, the odds of someone throwing an interception that often should be so minute as to never happen. The same goes for someone throwing a touchdown on every pass attempt. You don't need the code to specifically forbid that from being possible, you just need it sufficiently designed to make the odds infinitesimal.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 20:42:09
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
As many here will attest, I've been one of the more ardent defenders of Goal Line Blitz--I've argued against crappy suggestion after crappy suggestion because I've trusted the developers had a vision for the game that would in time make it great.

But not any more.

Our 11-5 team (seeded sixth overall) just played a 13-3 team (seeded third overall) in an opening round playoff game. We lost 45-0.

But I'm just getting started.

Our starting QB threw only 15 INTs all season long. He threw NINE in today's game.

Our backup QB threw another, putting us at TEN INTs for the day.

Add in 3 sacks and 7 hurries.

Add in a "running game" that amassed 17 yards on 18 carries ("Yes", I already backed out the sack yardage--"Yes", even with the sacks removed, we averaged less than a yard a carry).

In short, Season #3's sims have demonstrated all year long that they are far from acceptable when it comes to realism. Myself and others have documented in other threads that the offensive side of the sim is BROKEN--that neither the run nor the pass works well when 2 "roughly similar" teams square off in the higher level leagues. And I went on record more than once pointing out that it would be a MISTAKE to allow this nonsense to continue on thru the playoffs without fixing the offenses.

But to pretend that our entire team (which nearly every member of paid to boost the entire 3 levels for this season, last season, and the innaugural one) is supposed to be satisified with such a BULLSHIT playoff sim as being the end to our "season" is an absolute joke.

Sorry Bort, I tried to support you. But you should have stepped in and fixed the sims before it ever got to the PLAYOFFS of "Season 3". 10 freaking interceptions in a game belongs nowhere in your coding--particularly so when its a playoff game between 2 teams with roughly similar records and roughly similar levels.

You owe Nashville a refund--and not in flex points that could only be spent on a BROKEN sim. Cash please--no "sim" worth paying pretends that a PLAYOFF TEAM throws 10 picks in a single game. There's not an excuse you can offer as to why we're supposed to be happy having our "season" end with TEN interceptions in a SINGLE GAME--NINE of them by our starter who threw only 15 all season.



ever stop and think that MAYBE the other team knew what you were gonna do and had a Defense ready for that?
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
Missouri did throw 7 INT's in only 28 attempts in the 1970 Orange Bowl against Penn State.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
System should have max INT's thrown in a game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Well... I don't know I think that is where I differ from you... I am in the camp where I do not want to know how to build players...

For me that is a big part of this... I have retired players that had crappy builds... I learned...

If they just tell you how to be the most bad ass players at any position then that would let a lot of fun out of the game for me... Your mileage may very...


I don't think we should know anything exact unless there are threshholds, and I doubt there are threshholds. If, in fact, there were threshholds, then there absolutely should be a warning that points in a given SA aren't just poorly allocated, but a complete waste.

I also think if (as is more likely) an SA requires a high particular attribute to function well (as opposed to functioning at all), that it does: no knowledge of optimal SA to attribute ratios, just (if it's true) that Field General requires high Confidence to function well.

They do that with many attributes: We know you need high Agility to Juke or Spin. We know you need high Strength to Power Thru. We know that Super Vision helps much more if Vision itself is high, etc..

We don't know, and shouldn't know, whether someone with 60 Agility and 6 Spin will use the ability better putting 4 points into one more Spin level or into two more Agility points. But we know that if you have 29 Agility you shouldn't bother with Spin; and that's the kind of thing we should know.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
jdbolick - I know you like to think you are a guru, but you've admitted to not knowing GLB all that well and you are missing some key points.

There is an already admitted gap between the power of offense and defense (defense was too strong all season). At the higher levels, having a solid rushing game is a rarity. Passing has been fine except for the high turnovers, but the yardage and TD's were definitely fine in most cases.

You are also saying the code needs fixing in regards to morale when it is working as intended. Low confidence and multiple mistakes leads to a morale spiral. Lowering this spiral is not the answer, it just means players can afford to put less points in confidence because people like you want the SIM to baby them - not the answer.

The correct answer is to provide more advanced tactics for the team and the individual QB.

- Pull when morale hits X% for the backup (key for the team)

- Willingness to risk throwing into coverage (key for the player, including a throw the ball away option)

- Willingness to cover up and take a sack (key for the player)
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
System should have max INT's thrown in a game.


That's gotta be the stupidest post of the thread, and there have been many candidates.
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by superman8456

System should have max INT's thrown in a game.


That's gotta be the stupidest post of the thread, and there have been many candidates.


I think I addressed that point 30 pages ago.
 
drea
offline
Link
 
Everybody keeps complaining that there were too many INT's thrown and that it has never happened before in the NFL or NCAA.

Well I would like to re-introduce a famous quote to everyone.

"There's a first for everything"
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by superman8456

System should have max INT's thrown in a game.


That's gotta be the stupidest post of the thread, and there have been many candidates.


How? It will also control games with good teams vs. gutted teams.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.