It amuses me how many people continue to miss the point in their haste to plant pouty lips on Bort's behind. The people who don't have a player on Nashville aren't concerned that the game was some grave injustice that needs to be rectified. People like me are concerned that there is an obvious problem with the simulation engine and we're worried that similar nonsensical results could happen to us.
And to sum up some of the more pertinent points:
* No QB in the history of college or pro football has ever thrown 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer attempts. It has never happened.
* Regardless of personal opinions about Jay Slim's build, he had success in that conference during the regular season and was not turnover prone.
* While some people have claimed that Miami gameplanned to take away Nashville's running game and others have claimed the opposite that they gameplanned to focus on the pass (and thus get interceptions), that only addresses what set the ball in motion. Miami deserved to win because they were the better team and seemingly had the better approach (not sure why Nashville tried to pass so often early in the game, but that's another issue), but this game doesn't turn into a full-fledged Godzilla-style disaster movie without poor programming of morale. By having a flat percentage decrease instead of a sliding scale, these types of cascades are not only possible but probable over a large enough sample.
As someone else in the thread pointed out a number of pages ago, another GLB game between two similarly rated teams also ended with one throwing 9 interceptions. It's a problem with the simulation engine. While bad plays should hurt morale and lead to more bad plays, having a flat percentage instead of a decreasing penalty leads to cascade effects where a team's attributes are basically wiped out completely. That's why Slim threw 9 interceptions when he'd only had 15 the whole regular season, and why Nashville ran for less than yard per carry even though it seems as if Miami was playing a pass defense. Unbounded morale penalties caused Nashville to become basically a D-league team, which is poor programming.
When something like this comes to light, it doesn't need misguided sycophants leaping to the game's defense. This is a beta game and flaws are to be expected. This is one, it was discovered, it's been discussed, and the proper response now is not to make excuses for it but rather to fix it.
And to sum up some of the more pertinent points:
* No QB in the history of college or pro football has ever thrown 9 interceptions in 45 or fewer attempts. It has never happened.
* Regardless of personal opinions about Jay Slim's build, he had success in that conference during the regular season and was not turnover prone.
* While some people have claimed that Miami gameplanned to take away Nashville's running game and others have claimed the opposite that they gameplanned to focus on the pass (and thus get interceptions), that only addresses what set the ball in motion. Miami deserved to win because they were the better team and seemingly had the better approach (not sure why Nashville tried to pass so often early in the game, but that's another issue), but this game doesn't turn into a full-fledged Godzilla-style disaster movie without poor programming of morale. By having a flat percentage decrease instead of a sliding scale, these types of cascades are not only possible but probable over a large enough sample.
As someone else in the thread pointed out a number of pages ago, another GLB game between two similarly rated teams also ended with one throwing 9 interceptions. It's a problem with the simulation engine. While bad plays should hurt morale and lead to more bad plays, having a flat percentage instead of a decreasing penalty leads to cascade effects where a team's attributes are basically wiped out completely. That's why Slim threw 9 interceptions when he'd only had 15 the whole regular season, and why Nashville ran for less than yard per carry even though it seems as if Miami was playing a pass defense. Unbounded morale penalties caused Nashville to become basically a D-league team, which is poor programming.
When something like this comes to light, it doesn't need misguided sycophants leaping to the game's defense. This is a beta game and flaws are to be expected. This is one, it was discovered, it's been discussed, and the proper response now is not to make excuses for it but rather to fix it.






























