Much better
Finnude
offline
offline
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
Nice wall of text.
Do you actually expect a response when you do that?
But because I am lame enough to read some of that, I gotta ask, are YOU a businessman?
Cuz offering people hundreds of dollars to quit buying your product is pure business genius. I think Bort should hire you as his marketing adviser.
Ok you seems to be a good customer, let me sell you a nice porche here and you pay me now. Next thing i tell you that you wont be gettin the porche you paid for but iīll give you something else and I make changes to the deal we have made. No refunds or no permission to compalin. So when will we do some business.
So the point is if they sell me thing A and they want change stuff and offer me B, I still should be able to decide whether the new contract is ok or it is not ok - they cannot make one sided changes and the B thing should be better than A. But if you as a customer are willing to take anything from seller itīs your right to do so, but not every body is fine with sudden changes. What if this new change makes this game such that you dont want to play nor nodoby else wants to play, i.e. text based guess a number and bigger wins (and they plan to get out of business, is that fine with you also?)
Nice wall of text.
Do you actually expect a response when you do that?
But because I am lame enough to read some of that, I gotta ask, are YOU a businessman?
Cuz offering people hundreds of dollars to quit buying your product is pure business genius. I think Bort should hire you as his marketing adviser.
Ok you seems to be a good customer, let me sell you a nice porche here and you pay me now. Next thing i tell you that you wont be gettin the porche you paid for but iīll give you something else and I make changes to the deal we have made. No refunds or no permission to compalin. So when will we do some business.
So the point is if they sell me thing A and they want change stuff and offer me B, I still should be able to decide whether the new contract is ok or it is not ok - they cannot make one sided changes and the B thing should be better than A. But if you as a customer are willing to take anything from seller itīs your right to do so, but not every body is fine with sudden changes. What if this new change makes this game such that you dont want to play nor nodoby else wants to play, i.e. text based guess a number and bigger wins (and they plan to get out of business, is that fine with you also?)
mikemike778
offline
offline
No Idea if this has been answered yet in 63 pages but how do the bonus SAs fit in with the diminishing effects of SAs over 10?
Personally I'd say it should be a free gain because an elusive with head fake of 12 (normal 10 plus say 20% bonus) should be better than a power back with 12 in head fake (say with a bunch from AEQ).
If this isn't the case, it'll slightly water down the effect of archetypes because a lot of players would of ended up in with 10 in that SA anyway.
Personally I'd say it should be a free gain because an elusive with head fake of 12 (normal 10 plus say 20% bonus) should be better than a power back with 12 in head fake (say with a bunch from AEQ).
If this isn't the case, it'll slightly water down the effect of archetypes because a lot of players would of ended up in with 10 in that SA anyway.
tuba_samurai
offline
offline
Originally posted by mikemike778
No Idea if this has been answered yet in 63 pages but how do the bonus SAs fit in with the diminishing effects of SAs over 10?
Personally I'd say it should be a free gain because an elusive with head fake of 12 (normal 10 plus say 20% bonus) should be better than a power back with 12 in head fake (say with a bunch from AEQ).
If this isn't the case, it'll slightly water down the effect of archetypes because a lot of players would of ended up in with 10 in that SA anyway.
I think it will still fall into the diminishing effects over 10, but an elusive back with 12 in HF will still be better than a PB with 12 in HF just because of his skill set.
No Idea if this has been answered yet in 63 pages but how do the bonus SAs fit in with the diminishing effects of SAs over 10?
Personally I'd say it should be a free gain because an elusive with head fake of 12 (normal 10 plus say 20% bonus) should be better than a power back with 12 in head fake (say with a bunch from AEQ).
If this isn't the case, it'll slightly water down the effect of archetypes because a lot of players would of ended up in with 10 in that SA anyway.
I think it will still fall into the diminishing effects over 10, but an elusive back with 12 in HF will still be better than a PB with 12 in HF just because of his skill set.
reedric
offline
offline
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
Yeah, my point does ride on Aura being worth a damn. Not a great foothold for argument
Change that example to Glare and Shed Blocks on a DT then.
Okay, I'll buy that. I still probably won't work the penalty SAs, but at least you made it make since to me
Yeah, my point does ride on Aura being worth a damn. Not a great foothold for argument
Change that example to Glare and Shed Blocks on a DT then.
Okay, I'll buy that. I still probably won't work the penalty SAs, but at least you made it make since to me

TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by ijg
curious, what was the logic between forcing players up to 80 days old (i.e. s13 and 14 builds) to have to choose an AT vs prior guidance that it would be optional?
Is there some exploit you're concerned about catch?
For those of us who created farm teams in s13 that we need to replace other farm teams in the future, this is a real conundrum. I'm sure it will be fine for players but for others where we capped supporting attributes because they were majors and now they're going to minors and skipped minors that now become majors, it kind of bamboozles the build.
For example, today when you build a power WR, you still start with speed/agility and carry and wait on strength because there is no point in training strength for a long time. Well, now if I choose power WR, my str is leveling but I haven't trained it for two seasons and I've lost out on gains I expected on carry and speed. Totally gimps the build or I have to morph into a possession WR (too slow to be a speed WR, so not an option).
I'm sure I can come up with more examples with more time to think about it. Not to mention I've crafted build plans that assume caps are hit in a certain order that now have to be torn up because they will be hitting the decimal for the next cap either much sooner or later and I may not have the SP to hit a cap at the optimal level now.
Again, I'm not saying it's a terrible decision and I'm sure there are cases where it's helpful, but there are definitely cases where it hurts. And just saying "oh, go retire your players then" doesn't really help if you planned out to need those players available down the road at a certain time to take over from other retiring players.
curious, what was the logic between forcing players up to 80 days old (i.e. s13 and 14 builds) to have to choose an AT vs prior guidance that it would be optional?
Is there some exploit you're concerned about catch?
For those of us who created farm teams in s13 that we need to replace other farm teams in the future, this is a real conundrum. I'm sure it will be fine for players but for others where we capped supporting attributes because they were majors and now they're going to minors and skipped minors that now become majors, it kind of bamboozles the build.
For example, today when you build a power WR, you still start with speed/agility and carry and wait on strength because there is no point in training strength for a long time. Well, now if I choose power WR, my str is leveling but I haven't trained it for two seasons and I've lost out on gains I expected on carry and speed. Totally gimps the build or I have to morph into a possession WR (too slow to be a speed WR, so not an option).
I'm sure I can come up with more examples with more time to think about it. Not to mention I've crafted build plans that assume caps are hit in a certain order that now have to be torn up because they will be hitting the decimal for the next cap either much sooner or later and I may not have the SP to hit a cap at the optimal level now.
Again, I'm not saying it's a terrible decision and I'm sure there are cases where it's helpful, but there are definitely cases where it hurts. And just saying "oh, go retire your players then" doesn't really help if you planned out to need those players available down the road at a certain time to take over from other retiring players.
ijg
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by ijg
curious, what was the logic between forcing players up to 80 days old (i.e. s13 and 14 builds) to have to choose an AT vs prior guidance that it would be optional?
See http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3768138&page=1#33338165 from catch
Revised what we will be doing for players between 1-80 days old:
3) If your player is between 1-80 days old you will be forced to choose an archetype before the end of pre-season. If you do not choose one by then you will be assigned the default archetype for that position. If you would rather retire your player then choose an archetype, you can do so and receive a full (100%) refund.
Originally posted by ijg
curious, what was the logic between forcing players up to 80 days old (i.e. s13 and 14 builds) to have to choose an AT vs prior guidance that it would be optional?
See http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3768138&page=1#33338165 from catch
Revised what we will be doing for players between 1-80 days old:
3) If your player is between 1-80 days old you will be forced to choose an archetype before the end of pre-season. If you do not choose one by then you will be assigned the default archetype for that position. If you would rather retire your player then choose an archetype, you can do so and receive a full (100%) refund.
TrevJo
offline
offline
Yeah I know. 
I was bumping your post because I agree with you. I was hoping your question would be answered.
I posted earlier comments on the subject here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3767278&page=60#33343170
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3767278&page=60#33344563

I was bumping your post because I agree with you. I was hoping your question would be answered.
I posted earlier comments on the subject here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3767278&page=60#33343170
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3767278&page=60#33344563
HULK
offline
offline
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
LionsLover
offline
offline
Originally posted by HULK
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
hmm... 36 in Spin total? (20 from SAs, 15 from AEQ 1 from CE) Interesting...ly broken.
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
hmm... 36 in Spin total? (20 from SAs, 15 from AEQ 1 from CE) Interesting...ly broken.
ijg
offline
offline
Originally posted by HULK
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
Like this idea. Spin shouldn't be just for elusives. (Yes, I know combos don't have a penalty on spin, but having 5 majors vs 4 is a big penalty and yet there's no bonus to make up for it).
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
Like this idea. Spin shouldn't be just for elusives. (Yes, I know combos don't have a penalty on spin, but having 5 majors vs 4 is a big penalty and yet there's no bonus to make up for it).
LionsLover
offline
offline
Originally posted by ijg
Originally posted by HULK
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
Like this idea. Spin shouldn't be just for elusives. (Yes, I know combos don't have a penalty on spin, but having 5 majors vs 4 is a big penalty and yet there's no bonus to make up for it).
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Originally posted by HULK
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
Like this idea. Spin shouldn't be just for elusives. (Yes, I know combos don't have a penalty on spin, but having 5 majors vs 4 is a big penalty and yet there's no bonus to make up for it).
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Maddoc
offline
offline
Originally posted by LionsLover
Originally posted by ijg
Originally posted by HULK
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
Like this idea. Spin shouldn't be just for elusives. (Yes, I know combos don't have a penalty on spin, but having 5 majors vs 4 is a big penalty and yet there's no bonus to make up for it).
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Wow, and here I was arguing with you, I had no idea that you didn't even know how the game works.
My mistake.
Originally posted by ijg
Originally posted by HULK
Maybe if you could pull your bonus SA from one of your existing trees, it would allow for even more diversity.
For example, an HB right now has only a couple of useful non tree SAs (route run, sticky hands, and maybe spot blitz?) Not a lot of options that are particularly great for them. However, if they wanted to pull Spin down, or Dive4Yards or something, I think that would be more useful. And then you get people building stuff with a bit more variety. And maybe give them the opportunity to take it to 20 by allowing them to put 10 in each spot?
Like this idea. Spin shouldn't be just for elusives. (Yes, I know combos don't have a penalty on spin, but having 5 majors vs 4 is a big penalty and yet there's no bonus to make up for it).
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Wow, and here I was arguing with you, I had no idea that you didn't even know how the game works.
My mistake.
ijg
offline
offline
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by LionsLover
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Wow, and here I was arguing with you, I had no idea that you didn't even know how the game works.
My mistake.
I think he is trying to say that VA and AEQ has become more important than core builds, which is to some extent true.
Originally posted by LionsLover
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Wow, and here I was arguing with you, I had no idea that you didn't even know how the game works.
My mistake.
I think he is trying to say that VA and AEQ has become more important than core builds, which is to some extent true.
LionsLover
offline
offline
Originally posted by ijg
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by LionsLover
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Wow, and here I was arguing with you, I had no idea that you didn't even know how the game works.
My mistake.
I think he is trying to say that VA and AEQ has become more important than core builds, which is to some extent true.
No I was refering to current Archetype ALGs, not current ALGs, but apparently some people are too stupid to realize that. Current Archetype ALGs are .4 and .33, not varied amounts we currently have.
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by LionsLover
not really... currently majors/minors have VERY little difference in endgame builds.
Wow, and here I was arguing with you, I had no idea that you didn't even know how the game works.
My mistake.
I think he is trying to say that VA and AEQ has become more important than core builds, which is to some extent true.
No I was refering to current Archetype ALGs, not current ALGs, but apparently some people are too stupid to realize that. Current Archetype ALGs are .4 and .33, not varied amounts we currently have.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























