User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Wow, people are getting up in arms over this, while I think it's a great move. It takes a step in reducing the 100 point blowouts we've been seeing while at the same time, reducing the gap in talent between the top ranked team and the 32nd ranked team in the league.

Based on the mean level numbers I saw Bort post, basically as long as you're under level 20 right now, you should be fine in a BBB league. If you are boosting those higher level guys, that probably means other people are boosting their guys too, which means the median level is going up.

Not only that, I am going to take a wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiild guess and say that if your player is affected, it's not as though they're going to start playing like an autistic donkey on the field. It appears they will take a slight hit in gained experience, and you know what that means? It means they won't level up as fast. Know what else? At those levels, it is probably taking a few games to level up anyway.

In addition, if you have one player on your team above that level cap, it's not going to affect your whole team, just that one player out of over 40. It's not like everybody on the team is going to start having the worst games of their career just because that one player out of over 40 has a slight hit against them.

Long story longer, I see nothing wrong with this move. There are some legitimate cases of higher level players in lower level leagues, and those shouldn't be affected as much. However, this is great for leagues where teams have stacked their rosters. If you have a behemoth team, it kinda takes the entertainment out of it for everyone else. Kudos to Bort and DD for this one.
 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
Who runs GLB Town?

You know who.....

Bort is laying down the law and I like it!
 
Tyler Branch
offline
Link
 
Excellent change for the good of the game. I'm looking forward to seeing how it all plays out.
 
Dimes
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I wish our league was all the same level at every position for every team. Yeah, everyone likes to blow a team out here and there...but how can that be fun to do it every game? To me that would be pretty damn boring. Our league was really competitive last year except for a few teams, and now theres a lot of teams that have been gutted or top teams that changed leagues other than the ones who left from relegation. I should be happy that the league is weaker, but actually it pisses me off. I think this change is definitely a step in the right direction.

I think the only people that are/should be complaining are the ones who don't understand what 'median' means. And those who moved their team/player(s) to low level leagues to win a championship because they suck. I think it's so funny when people brag about stats on their player and then you look at who they played and it's CPU players or people half their level.

If you want to play on a friend's team, then make a new guy. You don't have to bring your level 20 into a league full of level 4 players.

This game should be about player builds and tactics, not which owner can bribe the most high level players into playing in a low level league to pwn noobs.
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
I like it

(just wanted to add my voice, as people who complaint post more than those who are happy)
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
I got curious... and I got creative with the Search function. Here's what I found.

The league with the lowest average level right now is African AA #1. Average level is 6.2972, which puts the median probably around 7. That will probably increase due to boosting on Day 1, but let's be conservative and say that the median will only bounce up to 8. Penalties kick in at 8 over median: level 16.

Realistically, you won't be penalized unless you're level 17 or higher on day 1.

And how many Level 17+ players are in African AA #1 right now?

3.

That's three.




And one of them is a punter.





THIS is what people are freaking out over?


I want everybody to look at this again for emphasis.
 
bluepike
offline
Link
 
I read through probably the first 20 pages then figured I didn't miss much after that. In general, it could be a positive change for the game in the long term. It is good that there is some leeway with not having everyone in that range (mentoring), but the number of mentors will need to be looked at the end of every preseason, in my opinion.

That is unless there's a standard formula including standard deviations instead of an 8 hard cap on the level difference from the median. I think that would be the most reasonable answer so some people who put a lot into recruiting (like myself or Unconquered for example) aren't punished when we can score a big free agent who will be a difference maker in the league.

Basically, I would say that the standard deviations would help in keeping it fair to those who work hard at building a team versus those who don't.
 
lizrdgizrd
offline
Link
 
I can't help but laugh at the overreaction this change has brought. I think I'm just going to wait and see what effect (if any) it has on my players and teams before I start whining like a little girl who dropped her ice cream.
 
schisno
offline
Link
 
I think it's a terrible change to the game.

There shouldn't be a big difference between USA Pro vs every other league. There's some comments out there that this will make things less like the NFL, but all it does it make the USA Pro league superior to everyone else. When every league should have a chance to be just as good with quality players without penalties.

As for the penalties against signing more than 3 players from one agent. What if an owner wants to buy a team then fill it with his players and just his friends players because that's how he wants to play it.

There are just too many restrictions for people who want to play their way and are willing to spend their money to do so. If you want to create parity, make a pay league and make a free league.

The free league can be for those who can't get the high level players and are for those team that just can't win. Let the paying league play how they want to play, if they feel things aren't working for their money then they won't pay. But you would still get those who are willing to pay and play in those confines.

If it continues like this, then why bother shelling out any more money with caps and restrictions all over the place.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by schisno
I think it's a terrible change to the game.

There shouldn't be a big difference between USA Pro vs every other league. There's some comments out there that this will make things less like the NFL, but all it does it make the USA Pro league superior to everyone else. When every league should have a chance to be just as good with quality players without penalties.

As for the penalties against signing more than 3 players from one agent. What if an owner wants to buy a team then fill it with his players and just his friends players because that's how he wants to play it.

There are just too many restrictions for people who want to play their way and are willing to spend their money to do so. If you want to create parity, make a pay league and make a free league.

The free league can be for those who can't get the high level players and are for those team that just can't win. Let the paying league play how they want to play, if they feel things aren't working for their money then they won't pay. But you would still get those who are willing to pay and play in those confines.

If it continues like this, then why bother shelling out any more money with caps and restrictions all over the place.


Of course there should be a difference...there needs to be something to aspire to for team owners. If anything, I think GLB needs to take more measures to reinforce the hierarchy and make people WANT to move up as high as they can. Anyone with money can boost a player all to hell but in order to get into a pro league, it requires levelling and being able to manoveur either your team or a player into a pro league. Adds a dimension to the game

 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by schisno
There are just too many restrictions for people who want to play their way and are willing to spend their money to do so.


So... what you're saying is that you want to be able to spend lots of money on your player, get him up to level 30, and dump him into a BBB league to pwnzr n00bs, and it's all okay because you're spending money?

I'm sorry... but anyone who pays money for the sole purpose of pwnzring n00bs is an asshat.
 
Link
 
Bort's latest announcement on XP change still doesn't address this issue. It'll give penalty to people who boost their players!!!

Let's say 40% of players in a league boost their players. Eventually when the non-boost players are level 20+, the boost players are level 30+. With training and game xp become smaller and smaller, the gap will be even larger.

Then, the median league leavel will fall to non-boost group (60%), the boost players (40%) will be penalized becuase their levels are higher than recommended level and a team can easily have more than 6 players boosting. This will force the boost players leave the league and probably to go pro-league and make it Harder to stick with the same team.
 
rbetesta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Bort's latest announcement on XP change still doesn't address this issue. It'll give penalty to people who boost their players!!!

Let's say 40% of players in a league boost their players. Eventually when the non-boost players are level 20+, the boost players are level 30+. With training and game xp become smaller and smaller, the gap will be even larger.

Then, the median league leavel will fall to non-boost group (60%), the boost players (40%) will be penalized becuase their levels are higher than recommended level and a team can easily have more than 6 players boosting. This will force the boost players leave the league and probably to go pro-league and make it Harder to stick with the same team.


Fallacy #2: This will punish me if I level up or boost but stick with the same team.
Response: This actually encourages you to stick with the same team for a long while. Note that all of the things that harm your sportsmanship score have to do with signing in a new leage as a FA. Stay on your team, level up, improve for the long haul = GREAT! Max XP!
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 12:00:24
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbetesta
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Bort's latest announcement on XP change still doesn't address this issue. It'll give penalty to people who boost their players!!!

Let's say 40% of players in a league boost their players. Eventually when the non-boost players are level 20+, the boost players are level 30+. With training and game xp become smaller and smaller, the gap will be even larger.

Then, the median league leavel will fall to non-boost group (60%), the boost players (40%) will be penalized becuase their levels are higher than recommended level and a team can easily have more than 6 players boosting. This will force the boost players leave the league and probably to go pro-league and make it Harder to stick with the same team.


Fallacy #2: This will punish me if I level up or boost but stick with the same team.
Response: This actually encourages you to stick with the same team for a long while. <b>Note that all of the things that harm your sportsmanship score have to do with signing in a new leage as a FA.</b> Stay on your team, level up, improve for the long haul = GREAT! Max XP!


I read that, and it didn't explain the situation I mentioned above.
 
rbetesta
offline
Link
 
Note that all of the things that harm your sportmanship score have to do with SIGNING in a new league as a FA.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.