User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
time to lock this one down?
 
Finneran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justinkicksass
i seem to remember farve throwing 6 or 7 a few years back vs STL.


Yes but Favre is known for him taking many chances. He is also the all-time leader in picks. For a qb that is known for making many risks, compared to this, is off at minimum.
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finneran
Originally posted by justinkicksass

i seem to remember farve throwing 6 or 7 a few years back vs STL.


Yes but Favre is known for him taking many chances. He is also the all-time leader in picks. For a qb that is known for making many risks, compared to this, is off at minimum.


Dan Marino ftw

Anyways to answer SCACE

NO it is just time to let it die.....soon
 
Link
 
Damn I can't even read all this. My questions is did the OP bitch like this when his team was on the winning side of some 50 point blow outs? I'm betting not. He just refuses to accept that his QB's build sucks.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
time to lock this one down?


919 posts no way
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Originally posted by SCACE

time to lock this one down?


919 posts no way


lol - CEDO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
rebel100102
offline
Link
 
I've had a similar experience.... After the 1st 5 games this season my 2 QB's had thrown a combined total of 3 Ints, only to combine for SEVEN in Game-6, against a team that only managed 4 INTs in 3 games against the bottom 3 teams in the conference. (We were #4 at the time, they were #7.) Needless to say, I was somewhat bent after that game.

Another thing that drives me bat-sh*t.... 3rd & Goal from the 7 in a very close game. Obvious passing situation, right? - Instead of a 3-4 WR set which might have spread the defense out a little, we line up in a 2 TE set and then throw it right into into the teeth of triple coverage. WTF is up with that? Football coaches down in Pop Warner knows better than to use a 2 TE set and then throw it deep in the red zone where the D is bunched.

I've spent a bunch of money on GLB, but when I see crap like this happening, I'm beginning to wonder, why?

Reb
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 19:48:46
 
James Hobbs
offline
Link
 
I wonder if this will break a 1,000 posts
 
jamyp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dabutracing007
Damn I can't even read all this. My questions is did the OP bitch like this when his team was on the winning side of some 50 point blow outs? I'm betting not. He just refuses to accept that his QB's build sucks.


what is OP?
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by hambone77us

well you made the quarterback a retard seriouslly. if you make someone that bad its your fault



And if someone purports to have built an American style football sim that includes coding that allows for TEN picks by one team in a playoff game, that's a laughably bad sim.


This argument just makes no sense at all. You're saying the sim should prevent a player from reaching the potential of his build, be that potential good or bad?

Thankfully, you're not the developer. There's enough "cookie cutter" complaints as is. In your scenario, these matters would be excruciating.

It's possible for a bad QB to throw 10 interceptions. Why is that so hard to grasp?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rebel100102
I've had a similar experience.... After the 1st 5 games this season my 2 QB's had thrown a combined total of 3 Ints, only to combine for SEVEN in Game-6, against a team that only managed 4 INTs in 3 games against the bottom 3 teams in the conference. (We were #4 at the time, they were #7.) Needless to say, I was somewhat bent after that game.

Another thing that drives me bat-sh*t.... 3rd & Goal from the 7 in a very close game. Obvious passing situation, right? - Instead of a 3-4 WR set which might have spread the defense out a little, we line up in a 2 TE set and then throw it right into into the teeth of triple coverage. WTF is up with that? Football coaches down in Pop Warner knows better than to use a 2 TE set and then throw it deep in the red zone where the D is bunched.

I've spent a bunch of money on GLB, but when I see crap like this happening, I'm beginning to wonder, why?

Reb


advanced AI coming, just be patient, season 4.

Also, it depends on your settings -- if you had a high pass to the TE setting, or a high rush setting, you might see more two TE sets. The SIM also seems to go into that type of goalline formation inside the 10 a lot. You'll be able to control the formations in those situations with OAI.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamyp
Originally posted by dabutracing007

Damn I can't even read all this. My questions is did the OP bitch like this when his team was on the winning side of some 50 point blow outs? I'm betting not. He just refuses to accept that his QB's build sucks.


what is OP?


Original Poster. Lamenting Larry, in this case.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
I stopped reading after 10 pages, so I apologize for what I've missed. I think nobody is denying that there will be changes to the sim for next season, but to say that 10 ints in one game means the sim is broken is wrong imo. You need to consider the following:

- By my count, there are 1920 playoff games this season in the 128 leagues. Under the current NFL playoff model, it would take 174 seasons to generate 1914 playoff games. So this GLB season will have as many playoff games as 174-175 NFL seasons. Thus, to say that we've never seen 10 ints in an NFL playoff game proves little. We haven't seen 174 NFL seasons.

- The NFL record for interceptions in a playoff game by one team is 8 (1940). Looking more recently, there have been three 6-interception games since 1990. And again, the NFL hasn't been around 174 seasons.

- Two of those 10 interceptions were thrown in the 4th quarter. When the AI allows you to stop passing the ball when behind by a large margin, those two interceptions won't happen. Therefore, we are really talking about 8 interceptions. Not quite as absurd as to warrant a refund.

- The issues with the QB's build have already been pointed out. So has the Steelers-Ravens example of how playoff rematches can vary greatly from regular season showdowns. With teams boosting right before the playoffs, as well as leveling and training during the season, the variables are far too great to assume that two team who were closely matched in the regular season are the same closely matched teams in the playoffs. Throw in tactics changes and 1,920 playoff simulations and you are going to get these kinds of results.

The sim could be perfectly tuned to reality and you would still see 10-interception games.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 20:29:51
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
My Preference is for the effect of choices to be clear.. but those choices should be balanced enough to prevent cookie cutters. If Field General requires 40 Confidence before it kicks in.. then that is a serious documentation problem, because there is no indication of this anywhere.


+5
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
Will this hit 1000 posts or 75 pages first? I'm betting on 1000 posts.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.