User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
Originally posted by stat2883

Originally posted by Ceteral


My apologies, I didn't read about the mule that was barely fertile.

apparently you stopped there...

Horses and mice have been observed as well. Yes, fertility rates were fairly low, but again that fits in with the evidence too. We don't see new species popping up every day. These aren't common occurrences, but it is possible, which is what you were debating.


And only fertile when combined with a normal mares egg they didn't mind adding. So when it finally is considered a different species, it won't have anything else to breed with.

Well yeah...where do you think the other half of the genetic material comes from?

as far as not having anyone to breed with...

Say we have two populations of similar species. We'll stick with horses. There can be some breeding and while a majority of the offspring will be infertile, there will be some that are. In a large population, there are bound to be others, as well as breeding between the crosses and the pures of either side.

This is also from that link I posted:

Originally posted by link
The significance of centric fusions (Robertsonian translocations) in domestic animals, with special reference to sheep, is reviewed. The mating is described of a further 856 ewes with either a normal chromosome number 2n = 54 or carrying one or more of the three different translocations (centric fusions) t1, t2 and t3 in various heterozygous and homozygous arrangements. Rams which were used in the matings were homozygous for one of the translocation chromosomes (2n = 52), double heterozygotes (2n = 52), triple heterozygotes (2n = 51) or were carriers of 4 translocation chromosomes (2n = 50) and 5 translocation chromosomes (2n = 49). A remarkably even distribution of segregation products was recorded in the progeny of all combinations of translocation ewes x translocation rams in those groups in which sufficient animals were available for statistical analysis. Forty-eight chromosomally different groups of animals were mated. Further, the overall fertility of the translocation sheep, measured by conception rate to first service, lambing percentage and number of ewes which did not breed a lamb, was not significantly different from New Zealand national sheep breeding data. In some groups the poorer reproductive performance could be explained by the age structure of the flock and inbreeding depression, which probably affected the performance of some animals. Sheep with progressively decreasing chromosome numbers, due to centric fusion, 2n = 50, 2n = 49 and 2n = 48, are reported. The 2n = 48 category represents a triple homozygous ewe and a triple homozygous ram and is the first report of the viable evolution of such domestic animals. Less than 1% of phenotypically abnormal lambs were recorded in a total of 1995 progeny born over 10 years. It is now considered that there is little or no evidence to suggest that centric fusions in a variety of combinations affect the total productive fitness of domestic sheep. It is suggested that future research should be more actively directed to understanding their genetic significance.
Last edited Jun 15, 2008 00:57:40
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Somebody lock this, it's nothing but trouble man.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Somebody lock this, it's nothing but trouble man.

Its still civil. Its not the flame war the first one was.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Somebody lock this, it's nothing but trouble man.

Its still civil. Its not the flame war the first one was.


Actually I think this is the first one, then it branched out to other threads then came back here.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by stat2883

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Somebody lock this, it's nothing but trouble man.

Its still civil. Its not the flame war the first one was.


Actually I think this is the first one, then it branched out to other threads then came back here.

oh yeah...oops. Forgot what thread I was in. I was thinking of the creationism one.
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Originally posted by Ceteral

Originally posted by stat2883


Originally posted by Ceteral



My apologies, I didn't read about the mule that was barely fertile.

apparently you stopped there...

Horses and mice have been observed as well. Yes, fertility rates were fairly low, but again that fits in with the evidence too. We don't see new species popping up every day. These aren't common occurrences, but it is possible, which is what you were debating.


And only fertile when combined with a normal mares egg they didn't mind adding. So when it finally is considered a different species, it won't have anything else to breed with.

Well yeah...where do you think the other half of the genetic material comes from?

as far as not having anyone to breed with...

Say we have two populations of similar species. We'll stick with horses. There can be some breeding and while a majority of the offspring will be infertile, there will be some that are. In a large population, there are bound to be others, as well as breeding between the crosses and the pures of either side.

This is also from that link I posted:

Originally posted by link

The significance of centric fusions (Robertsonian translocations) in domestic animals, with special reference to sheep, is reviewed. The mating is described of a further 856 ewes with either a normal chromosome number 2n = 54 or carrying one or more of the three different translocations (centric fusions) t1, t2 and t3 in various heterozygous and homozygous arrangements. Rams which were used in the matings were homozygous for one of the translocation chromosomes (2n = 52), double heterozygotes (2n = 52), triple heterozygotes (2n = 51) or were carriers of 4 translocation chromosomes (2n = 50) and 5 translocation chromosomes (2n = 49). A remarkably even distribution of segregation products was recorded in the progeny of all combinations of translocation ewes x translocation rams in those groups in which sufficient animals were available for statistical analysis. Forty-eight chromosomally different groups of animals were mated. Further, the overall fertility of the translocation sheep, measured by conception rate to first service, lambing percentage and number of ewes which did not breed a lamb, was not significantly different from New Zealand national sheep breeding data. In some groups the poorer reproductive performance could be explained by the age structure of the flock and inbreeding depression, which probably affected the performance of some animals. Sheep with progressively decreasing chromosome numbers, due to centric fusion, 2n = 50, 2n = 49 and 2n = 48, are reported. The 2n = 48 category represents a triple homozygous ewe and a triple homozygous ram and is the first report of the viable evolution of such domestic animals. Less than 1% of phenotypically abnormal lambs were recorded in a total of 1995 progeny born over 10 years. It is now considered that there is little or no evidence to suggest that centric fusions in a variety of combinations affect the total productive fitness of domestic sheep. It is suggested that future research should be more actively directed to understanding their genetic significance.


It says right there, poorer reproduction rates. The more I am hearing the less likely it seems that any of these changes can perpetuate. Even funnier is that it is happening due to inbreeding.
 
Link
 
FUCK THIS THREAD! GO TO HELL! YOU ARE RUINING THE FFA BOARDS! THE FUNNY PEOPLE HAVE STOPPED COMING NOW BECAUSE OF YOU GUYS!
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
It says right there, poorer reproduction rates. The more I am hearing the less likely it seems that any of these changes can perpetuate. Even funnier is that it is happening due to inbreeding.

poorer relative to the rest of the test subjects....it also states that overall fertility rates are on par with data gathered in New Zealand. The last couple lines of the paragraph state as much - little or no evidence that the fusions affect productive fitness. If that doesn't float your boat for an example of breeding among differing pairs of chromosomes, then I'm done arguing that point. Its all right there. Fertile offspring, and multiple generations no less. I can pull up examples in plants too if you really want.
Last edited Jun 15, 2008 13:25:29
 
ssaints4ever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Go_Rams_1111
FUCK THIS THREAD! GO TO HELL! YOU ARE RUINING THE FFA BOARDS! THE FUNNY PEOPLE HAVE STOPPED COMING NOW BECAUSE OF YOU GUYS!


Bull shit.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Go_Rams_1111
FUCK THIS THREAD! GO TO HELL! YOU ARE RUINING THE FFA BOARDS! THE FUNNY PEOPLE HAVE STOPPED COMING NOW BECAUSE OF YOU GUYS!

oh no....we're holding down an entire population of funny men with our virtual self-representations!
 
Link
 
It was this and the the F.O.X getting drunk with power.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
It would all be so much simpler if we could just fuck our sisters.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
It would all be so much simpler if we could just fuck our sisters.


Ive always wanted a kid with webbed feet.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/6/11/15631/9132/632/527201
 
plcmds
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hellbound201
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by hellbound201


If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Not really. We have a clue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment


At present no serious biologist will cite that experiment, there are numerous errors in it. Miller was using what he thought the best mix to create DNA or at least some form of it, he did not use known atmospheric compositions, or at least believed atmospheric compositions.


Next!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.