I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Novus
offline
offline
Originally posted by nj1035
I can't really say that I like it at all. Takes away the competitive spirit of the game in my opinion.
Competition is a team of level 8s trying to out-think a team of level 12s to pull off the upset, while the team of level 12s tries to make full use of their level-mismatch to keep the level 8s from stunning them.
Competition is NOT a team of level 33s slaughtering a team of level 6s.
If you want to avoid the penalty, sign with a team in a higher league. What is so anti-competitive-spirit about that very simple concept?
I can't really say that I like it at all. Takes away the competitive spirit of the game in my opinion.
Competition is a team of level 8s trying to out-think a team of level 12s to pull off the upset, while the team of level 12s tries to make full use of their level-mismatch to keep the level 8s from stunning them.
Competition is NOT a team of level 33s slaughtering a team of level 6s.
If you want to avoid the penalty, sign with a team in a higher league. What is so anti-competitive-spirit about that very simple concept?
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 10:14:23
Novus
offline
offline
Originally posted by nj1035
I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
No, it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball against other college teams instead of against the team of 8-year-olds from the elementary school down the street.
I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
No, it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball against other college teams instead of against the team of 8-year-olds from the elementary school down the street.
trog
offline
offline
Exactly. I like every aspect of it, except the boosting gives you higher sportsmanship. I don't really see how the two are connected, and it makes the game less fun for people who don't want to spend real money on the game
But everything else I think is great.
But everything else I think is great.
Crushr
offline
offline
Originally posted by nj1035
I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
Ok, that doesn't even make sense. Its more like telling Kevin GARNETT he can't leave the Celts to go play ball at DUKE. Durant was the same age (actually younger than most) of the kids he played in college. So I don't see how your comparison is even valid.
I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
Ok, that doesn't even make sense. Its more like telling Kevin GARNETT he can't leave the Celts to go play ball at DUKE. Durant was the same age (actually younger than most) of the kids he played in college. So I don't see how your comparison is even valid.
avwjase
offline
offline
Originally posted by SmithersOT
I think a lot of people here are over reacting. This is a fantastic (and well thought out) change that will do a great deal for league parity. From what Bort said he is referring to deviation from MEDIAN. Apparently some of you don't understand what this term means, and this is probably contributing to your concern. "Median" means the middle, not the average (though often the two are close). And Bort has stated that he will probably use something like eight levels over the MEDIAN to determine the league (no penalty) maximum. So, to clarify, lets pretend that a league has nine players (to make the math simple). Their levels are:
13, 13, 13, 13, 14, 14, 16, 18, 21
Note that two of these players are far higher level than the average. The MEDIAN level is determined by adding one to the number of players, dividing the sum by two to determine the middle level. In this case the median level is 14 and the League no-penalty maximum would be approximately level 22. In this scenario no player would have any experience penalty at all, nor would one be likely to develop down the road as lower level characters tend to outlevel higher, and with this leveling the median in a league will climb.
In short, this is a whole lot of concern over a non-issue. If your character is eight levels beyond the median you really don't have any business playing in that league. And if you do, that's fine, but you can and should reasonably expect an experience penalty until the league median climbs enough to catch you.
This is all as it should be.
If it really is eight levels then it's basically worthless. I'd opt for a 5 level span. Nothing I hate worse than unbalanced leagues. Although, I think allowing people to "trade" places in leagues is more damaging than anything. Allowing established teams to move to the African leagues by trading places is ridiculous.
To me, that's something that needs to be stopped.
I think a lot of people here are over reacting. This is a fantastic (and well thought out) change that will do a great deal for league parity. From what Bort said he is referring to deviation from MEDIAN. Apparently some of you don't understand what this term means, and this is probably contributing to your concern. "Median" means the middle, not the average (though often the two are close). And Bort has stated that he will probably use something like eight levels over the MEDIAN to determine the league (no penalty) maximum. So, to clarify, lets pretend that a league has nine players (to make the math simple). Their levels are:
13, 13, 13, 13, 14, 14, 16, 18, 21
Note that two of these players are far higher level than the average. The MEDIAN level is determined by adding one to the number of players, dividing the sum by two to determine the middle level. In this case the median level is 14 and the League no-penalty maximum would be approximately level 22. In this scenario no player would have any experience penalty at all, nor would one be likely to develop down the road as lower level characters tend to outlevel higher, and with this leveling the median in a league will climb.
In short, this is a whole lot of concern over a non-issue. If your character is eight levels beyond the median you really don't have any business playing in that league. And if you do, that's fine, but you can and should reasonably expect an experience penalty until the league median climbs enough to catch you.
This is all as it should be.
If it really is eight levels then it's basically worthless. I'd opt for a 5 level span. Nothing I hate worse than unbalanced leagues. Although, I think allowing people to "trade" places in leagues is more damaging than anything. Allowing established teams to move to the African leagues by trading places is ridiculous.
To me, that's something that needs to be stopped.
brucebond
offline
offline
Originally posted by nj1035
I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
no, it's like kevin durant playing 8 yr olds and not getting any better b/c he's playing against shitty competition.
I suppose it's sort of like making Kevin Durant play his college ball with one shoe on when he was at Texas?
no, it's like kevin durant playing 8 yr olds and not getting any better b/c he's playing against shitty competition.
TheKingOfVa
offline
offline
Originally posted by kuaggie
but this means that any team you buy now, can NEVER become equal w/ a pro team. that's really the only problem i have w/ this.
I agree, I like the rule changes but it will be hard for a lower level team to catch Pro teams.
but this means that any team you buy now, can NEVER become equal w/ a pro team. that's really the only problem i have w/ this.
I agree, I like the rule changes but it will be hard for a lower level team to catch Pro teams.
cane__boy
offline
offline
this is a really good idea i think
it will help make it to were agents dont put there lvl 20 guys on BBB teams
it will help make it to were agents dont put there lvl 20 guys on BBB teams
nj1035
offline
offline
Well, I suppose I see your point if it's solely meant to slow down the progress of the players, rather than having an actual in-game penalty.
I do think this should've been addressed before the offseason though...coming out with it now is pretty lame for all the teams that went out and recruited thinking otherwise. I don't think you can argue with that point.
I do think this should've been addressed before the offseason though...coming out with it now is pretty lame for all the teams that went out and recruited thinking otherwise. I don't think you can argue with that point.
ib_mr_ed
offline
offline
I am interested in seeing how this affects the teams that are stacking. I was kind of pissed when I busted my ass recruiting players, just to see a team in my division with 17 GM's, who own 10 different teams. The team has over a million dollars in a newly created league. Plus their annual salary is very low. No way this happens in a newly created league without something funny going on. 16 teams in the division that all seem to be created fairly except one.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 10:38:01
Novus
offline
offline
Originally posted by nj1035
I do think this should've been addressed before the offseason though...coming out with it now is pretty lame for all the teams that went out and recruited thinking otherwise. I don't think you can argue with that point.
Except that very few teams or players are going to be affected by this at all, regardless of the zero-notice aspect.
I ran an example analysis a couple of pages back that shows that in the league with the lowest average level, a grand total of 3 people are going to be penalized by this rule. And one of them is a frickin' punter.
It's always best to institute major changes with more advance notice, sure, but in this case it's really not a big deal. Heck, if anything, the zero-notice aspect was BETTER. Think about how many people would've freaked out and withdrawn contract offers to players who wouldn't actually get hit with this penalty.
I do think this should've been addressed before the offseason though...coming out with it now is pretty lame for all the teams that went out and recruited thinking otherwise. I don't think you can argue with that point.
Except that very few teams or players are going to be affected by this at all, regardless of the zero-notice aspect.
I ran an example analysis a couple of pages back that shows that in the league with the lowest average level, a grand total of 3 people are going to be penalized by this rule. And one of them is a frickin' punter.
It's always best to institute major changes with more advance notice, sure, but in this case it's really not a big deal. Heck, if anything, the zero-notice aspect was BETTER. Think about how many people would've freaked out and withdrawn contract offers to players who wouldn't actually get hit with this penalty.
nj1035
offline
offline
Originally posted by Novus
Originally posted by nj1035
I do think this should've been addressed before the offseason though...coming out with it now is pretty lame for all the teams that went out and recruited thinking otherwise. I don't think you can argue with that point.
Except that very few teams or players are going to be affected by this at all, regardless of the zero-notice aspect.
I ran an example analysis a couple of pages back that shows that in the league with the lowest average level, a grand total of 3 people are going to be penalized by this rule. And one of them is a frickin' punter.
It's always best to institute major changes with more advance notice, sure, but in this case it's really not a big deal. Heck, if anything, the zero-notice aspect was BETTER. Think about how many people would've freaked out and withdrawn contract offers to players who wouldn't actually get hit with this penalty.
I disagree, that is their own fault for not reading and reviewing the rule properly. More advanced notice than 1 day would've been more appropriate. I've only got one player on my team that might be affected (a level 18 SS in a BBB league). The guy has been with our team since we were new and it kind of irks me that he might have to take it up the ass a bit because he just signed a new contract with absolutely no knowledge of this rule.
Originally posted by nj1035
I do think this should've been addressed before the offseason though...coming out with it now is pretty lame for all the teams that went out and recruited thinking otherwise. I don't think you can argue with that point.
Except that very few teams or players are going to be affected by this at all, regardless of the zero-notice aspect.
I ran an example analysis a couple of pages back that shows that in the league with the lowest average level, a grand total of 3 people are going to be penalized by this rule. And one of them is a frickin' punter.
It's always best to institute major changes with more advance notice, sure, but in this case it's really not a big deal. Heck, if anything, the zero-notice aspect was BETTER. Think about how many people would've freaked out and withdrawn contract offers to players who wouldn't actually get hit with this penalty.
I disagree, that is their own fault for not reading and reviewing the rule properly. More advanced notice than 1 day would've been more appropriate. I've only got one player on my team that might be affected (a level 18 SS in a BBB league). The guy has been with our team since we were new and it kind of irks me that he might have to take it up the ass a bit because he just signed a new contract with absolutely no knowledge of this rule.
Hokie_Pokie08
offline
offline
i like this idea, it will encourage experienced players to not want to own their own teams as their players will be penalized if they play on their own team. more high level free agents are always better.
majech
offline
offline
It is great. Actually adds some more realism. Think about baseball, are the minor league teams full of major league players? No, there is an occasional one here and there, but they don't stay there.
Competive balance? People that are looking to "compete" don't play in lower level leagues. People looking to compete want equal level competition. I'd look like the greatest player to ever play the game of football if I played on a pop-warner team, but when I play against guys my age, I'm average. You know what though, it is a TON more enjoyable playing equal competition than it is beating up on 8 year olds.
I'm not crazy about penalizing the team that have multiple players from one agent though. If you have 5 level 8 players from one owner, I don't see how that affects competitive balance.
KUDOS TO BORT
Competive balance? People that are looking to "compete" don't play in lower level leagues. People looking to compete want equal level competition. I'd look like the greatest player to ever play the game of football if I played on a pop-warner team, but when I play against guys my age, I'm average. You know what though, it is a TON more enjoyable playing equal competition than it is beating up on 8 year olds.
I'm not crazy about penalizing the team that have multiple players from one agent though. If you have 5 level 8 players from one owner, I don't see how that affects competitive balance.
KUDOS TO BORT
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























