Originally posted by redwolfe11
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
I have the west totally done. i kinda hate the #'s cause they dont factor in backups. so just everyone starters. I will work on a formula to include backups..... the current numbers DONT reflect your tactics and your backup so keep that in mind and dont get upset cause some lower ranked teams in the west beat higher.
If its based off starters I think the Seminoles are not going to be anywhere near the top. I will be interested to see the rankings after you figure in back-ups.
I also think that basing it off player level is a little flawed. I do not think that player level is the best reflection of his impact in games. Depending on a players "Roll" when he created his player there is up to a 4 level difference in attribute points to his "promary" skills. So a level 1 player could be just as good skill points wise as a level 4 player. Or for our league, a level 12 player could equal the attribute points of a level 15 player. There is also the factor of one player buying all the special equipment and some not.
Player attributes would be a much more accurate ranking of a player. I realize the information for each player is most likely hidden from opposing teams (depending on each players setting). However, if you were able to get player attributes information it would be the most accurate power rankings out there for any league.
For ranking players based off attributes you could combine a few different ratings depending on which position that player is. FOr example:
A WR would use Agility, Speed, Jumping, Stamina, Vision, Catching
An OL would use Strength, Speed, Confidence, Blocking
etc, etc
The only problem is getting all the team owners to submit their player ratings to one person to make the rankings. It would probably never happen.
I think its great that you are taking the time to compile the list and I commend you for your efforts. I look forward to seeing how it comes out. Im fairly sure that the Seminoles wont come in the Top 5, and maybe not the Top 10.
I agreed before seeing the #'s and still do... but people and being bias doesnt help with power ranking
and i dont think everyone in the league is gonna show their players stats just so one guy can rank the teams... so count that out. lvl is a # you can kinda guess how good the player is.
Last edited May 10, 2008 16:17:38