User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure if this is the place to ask this, but with these new archetypes and maybe some SA balancing, is it time to reconsider the SPs required to invest in the last SA in each tree? Isn't it enough of a penalty that you have to build the entire tree out to the end and also build up the prereq SAs before you can invest heavily in to the overpriced SA?

Now you are going to allow other positions to add these same SAs at a reduced cost. It would add some build variety if a position didn't have to spend his AEQ for SAs already in his tree (because they are overpriced), in the cases where that SA is even useful.

It's p lolworthy anyways that Big Sack cost double what Shed Block costs. Or that Monster Hit costs double what Super Vision costs, etc.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
The difference is not as big as you think, IMO. If you don't choose an archetype, you don't get the benefit of the new bonus SAs (i.e. Get Low, Pancake for Cs). Also, Old-style Gs and Cs have .2 points wasted in tackling, DTs have .2 wasted in blocking, Ks and Ps have .17 wasted in throwing, and old-style Gs and Cs get 0 in speed.

Not to mention, on a 55 man roster, a team only has 12 Gs, Cs, DTs, Ks, and Ps. So they probably have 39 QBs, HBs, FBs, TEs, OTs, LBs, CBs, and Safeties. (Old-style DEs are basically the same as new-style.) So this decision means the new teams will be better at 39 positions and worse at 12. I guess that was too rough on the new teams, so they had to change it.


If the 80 rule didn't exist and the new roller was scheduled for release on day 41, new teams would build all their Cs,Ks,Ps, on day 40 and the rest on day 41, and it would be a season before anyone was willing to build a C again.

Unless:

Originally posted by trevjo

The difference is not as big as you think, IMO. If you don't choose an archetype, you don't get the benefit of the new bonus SAs (i.e. Get Low, Pancake for Cs). Also, Old-style Gs and Cs have .2 points wasted in tackling, DTs have .2 wasted in blocking, Ks and Ps have .17 wasted in throwing, and old-style Gs and Cs get 0 in speed


In that case, what was your initial post about? If they're not that much better, then why do you need to keep them in their old forms.

But tbh, a lot is riding on the potency of the arch specific SAs, if they're good, then no one will feel like they're being "forced" to make the change.

I actually do have 2 level 14 Cs who will be forced to change now, and I am kind of baffled on what to do with their builds at this point. I may have to cap STR and BLK higher now that the ALGs aren't as big, kinda effs me up cuz I already left STR and the price has risen considerably.
 
chazno
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
If the 80 rule didn't exist and the new roller was scheduled for release on day 41, new teams would build all their Cs,Ks,Ps, on day 40 and the rest on day 41, and it would be a season before anyone was willing to build a C again.


If you build on Day 40, you can either boost to 4 immediately or you lose out on a boost at the end of your career. At the end of your career you'd be stuck at 69,70 while the rest of your team was 72,73.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chazno
If you build on Day 40, you can either boost to 4 immediately or you lose out on a boost at the end of your career. At the end of your career you'd be stuck at 69,70 while the rest of your team was 72,73.


I figured I was screwing that up. The point remains the same, those Cs could have an effective level much higher than their archetyped counterparts.

Though I think the extra 2 SAs will make keeping the old ones undesirable anyway.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Wr's are horrible in this new scheme. Not only is their nat level gain .4, but they have 2 completely worthless majors. (vis conf) at least swap jump/stamina. Most speedsters can jump, and have high stamina, most don't have high vision.
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
How do these new changes apply to already existing players?
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
Wr's are horrible in this new scheme. Not only is their nat level gain .4, but they have 2 completely worthless majors. (vis conf) at least swap jump/stamina. Most speedsters can jump, and have high stamina, most don't have high vision.


Vision helps them catch the ball in stride and confidence is really important for dropped passes (WRs usually have the most morale issues anyways), so I can see the reasoning behind those choices. It looks like they are trying to push speedster WRs into going only for separation. 140+ speed and 10+FS with higher vision and catching so that they can get separation. Confidence to keep them playing without penalties and to recover from dropping passes or getting revcaked on running plays.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
does this affect older players? For example I have a level 41 C that I pretty much planned out his entire build with the current level gains. He was projected to have 140 strength by mid level 60. If the level gains change for him he will not reach that goal and all the time I spent building him will have been wasted.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
Originally posted by trevjo


The difference is not as big as you think, IMO. If you don't choose an archetype, you don't get the benefit of the new bonus SAs (i.e. Get Low, Pancake for Cs). Also, Old-style Gs and Cs have .2 points wasted in tackling, DTs have .2 wasted in blocking, Ks and Ps have .17 wasted in throwing, and old-style Gs and Cs get 0 in speed


In that case, what was your initial post about? If they're not that much better, then why do you need to keep them in their old forms.


Try to follow me here:
I said that old-style interior linemen and kickers and punters are better.
You said old-style Cs would be "massively overpowered" against new dots.
I don't think they would be massively overpowered, I just think they are better. Obviously, my initial post was about the fact that season 13 and 14 teams need these better interior linemen to compete with the many advantages that season 15 teams will have due to starting out with the archetypes.
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 12, 2010 17:26:33
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 12, 2010 15:33:32
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary.
How do these new changes apply to already existing players?
Originally posted by Angry Dragon
does this affect older players? For example I have a level 41 C that I pretty much planned out his entire build with the current level gains. He was projected to have 140 strength by mid level 60. If the level gains change for him he will not reach that goal and all the time I spent building him will have been wasted.


Read Catch 22's post explaining Archetypes. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3768138 Originally posted by Catch 22
1) Players created before the archetypes were implemented will be allowed a one time archetype selection. This is optional and you will only have until the end of the pre-season to do so. When you select the archetype, you will start getting the ALG's and SA bonuses/penalties and will be allowed to select the bonus SA.

2) If your player is between 81-120 days old as of the first day after rollover to the new season, you will be able to retire your player for 80% return of CE/boost FP investment. For example, you created a WR (300 FP), equipped them with complete CE (900 FP), and boosted them 3 times (900 FP), you would receive 1,740 flex in return instead of 1,560.

3) If your player is between 1-80 days old you will be forced to choose an archetype before the end of pre-season. If you do not choose one by then you will be assigned the default archetype for that position. If you would rather retire your player then choose an archetype, you can do so and receive a full (100%) refund.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Thanks TrevJo.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Try to follow me here:
I said that old-style interior linemen are kickers and punters are better.
You said old-style Cs would be "massively overpowered" against new dots.
I don't think they would be massively overpowered, I just think they are better. Obviously, my initial post was about the fact that season 13 and 14 teams need these better interior linemen to compete with the many advantages that season 15 teams will have due to starting out with the archetypes.


Fair enough, I see what you're getting at.

A forced-change C still might be better than an S15 C though, they'll have the SAs of the younger ones while still stacking up +1s for a season or two before they drop down to .67s and spread out. My S13 C will have added about 30 +1s above at least the 48 cap.before having to switch, that's 10 more gains than a new one will get on their top 2 attributes in that time. Probably close to 30 SP worth. New Cs will probably have a tough time coming out ahead in effective level until the old ones retire.
 
reedric
offline
Link
 
Are we still going to have to load an SA tree in "order"?

I'm okay with the cost of the SAs, but now that there will be penalty SAs I think we should be able to fill any SA we want without having to fill the one before it in the tree, or at the very least not have to pump a penalty SA to get to the next one in line.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reedric
Are we still going to have to load an SA tree in "order"?

I'm okay with the cost of the SAs, but now that there will be penalty SAs I think we should be able to fill any SA we want without having to fill the one before it in the tree, or at the very least not have to pump a penalty SA to get to the next one in line.


Yes you will.
 
reedric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Yes you will.


Then why even offer the penalty SA tree?

Why would anyone waste SP into something that will be less productive?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.