User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
hellbound201
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Actually evolution as Darwin described it has gone through quite a few refinements and alterations. Evolution as its understood today isn't the same as what Darwin first put forth.


I know, but his lineage of evolution, if you will, I don't believe is correct. For saying this I'm a heretic because by saying he is wrong then obviously I'm thinking God did it, which I'm not, I'm simply saying I believe that another theory is more correct. The problem is there is no mechanism in PE so it is not well liked for this fact.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral

That's the point, they can't.


Science isn't about going to our bullshit book and quoting a phrase from it that some pothead wrote 2000 years ago.

Science is about solving things and finding out why and how things happen.

Just because there is one part of it that has not been figured out yet does not mean that the entire concept is wrong.

The vast amount of evidence that we do have shows that the concept is valid except for the parts of it that have not been figured out yet.

Compared to Intelligent Design, Evolution is miles ahead in the evidence department. The only thing Intelligent Design has going for it is a story book with a fictional character named God that was written by a handful of storytellers; and it seems like that is all the evidence that is ever going to be given because the people that believe in Intelligent Design make up excuses for why they don't need evidence, such as "If he proved he was real then faith is pointless".

So as it stands, Evolution's evidence is increasing daily, and Intelligent Design's bullshit is increasing daily.

 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by hellbound201
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by hellbound201


If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Not really. We have a clue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment


At present no serious biologist will cite that experiment, there are numerous errors in it. Miller was using what he thought the best mix to create DNA or at least some form of it, he did not use known atmospheric compositions, or at least believed atmospheric compositions.

While I don't subscribe to the experiment either, I also don't buy some of the creationist arguments against it. Things like the atmoshphere, or harmful UV rays that were present during the planet's infancy would have minimal impact if life were to have developed in the deep oceans where conditions are more favorable.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
That's the point, they can't.

Again, go back and re-read the rest of that Down's Syndrome post. It can and does happen.
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Ceteral


That's the point, they can't.


Science isn't about going to our bullshit book and quoting a phrase from it that some pothead wrote 2000 years ago.

Science is about solving things and finding out why and how things happen.

Just because there is one part of it that has not been figured out yet does not mean that the entire concept is wrong.

The vast amount of evidence that we do have shows that the concept is valid except for the parts of it that have not been figured out yet.

Compared to Intelligent Design, Evolution is miles ahead in the evidence department. The only thing Intelligent Design has going for it is a story book with a fictional character named God that was written by a handful of storytellers; and it seems like that is all the evidence that is ever going to be given because the people that believe in Intelligent Design make up excuses for why they don't need evidence, such as "If he proved he was real then faith is pointless".

So as it stands, Evolution's evidence is increasing daily, and Intelligent Design's bullshit is increasing daily.



Okay, first of all, what I just said there was the only problem I have with any part of Evolution.

Second, the only thing I'm trying to prove is that you are putting your faith in something as much as anyone who believes in Intelligent Design concepts by believing in Macro-Evolution. So don't put words in my mouth. Believe what you will. Just know that it is as much belief as anyone puts in God.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by hellbound201
Originally posted by stat2883

Actually evolution as Darwin described it has gone through quite a few refinements and alterations. Evolution as its understood today isn't the same as what Darwin first put forth.


I know, but his lineage of evolution, if you will, I don't believe is correct. For saying this I'm a heretic because by saying he is wrong then obviously I'm thinking God did it, which I'm not, I'm simply saying I believe that another theory is more correct. The problem is there is no mechanism in PE so it is not well liked for this fact.

I have no problem with PE. I believe it can be incorporated in with the common view of evolution without any problems really. You can almost look at PE as gradual evolution in fast forward...in a manner of speaking. I don't think Darwin was flat out wrong, but I also don't think he was absolutely correct. I believe he had the right idea.
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Originally posted by Ceteral

Originally posted by stat2883


Originally posted by Ceteral



Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Did you read the link I posted? You can have fertile offspring. You were supposed to keep reading


My apologies, I didn't read about the mule that was barely fertile.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral

Okay, first of all, what I just said there was the only problem I have with any part of Evolution.

Second, the only thing I'm trying to prove is that you are putting your faith in something as much as anyone who believes in Intelligent Design concepts by believing in Macro-Evolution. So don't put words in my mouth. Believe what you will. Just know that it is as much belief as anyone puts in God.


Well, if the amount of belief needed for something that is 80% proved is the same amount of belief needed for something that is 0% proved, then yeah evolution requires just as much belief as religion.

 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Ceteral


Okay, first of all, what I just said there was the only problem I have with any part of Evolution.

Second, the only thing I'm trying to prove is that you are putting your faith in something as much as anyone who believes in Intelligent Design concepts by believing in Macro-Evolution. So don't put words in my mouth. Believe what you will. Just know that it is as much belief as anyone puts in God.


Well, if the amount of belief needed for something that is 80% proved is the same amount of belief needed for something that is 0% proved, then yeah evolution requires just as much belief as religion.



I understand your point. I am just trying to point out that it isn't exactly fair to ridicule someone elses beliefs when what you think is true has holes that require belief.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
My apologies, I didn't read about the mule that was barely fertile.

apparently you stopped there...

Horses and mice have been observed as well. Yes, fertility rates were fairly low, but again that fits in with the evidence too. We don't see new species popping up every day. These aren't common occurrences, but it is possible, which is what you were debating.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Originally posted by Ceteral

My apologies, I didn't read about the mule that was barely fertile.

apparently you stopped there...

Horses and mice have been observed as well. Yes, fertility rates were fairly low, but again that fits in with the evidence too. We don't see new species popping up every day. These aren't common occurrences, but it is possible, which is what you were debating.


Not to mention the domestic horse that has 32 pairs and the wild horse that has 33 pairs, they can breed and are completely fertile.
Last edited Jun 15, 2008 00:38:01
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Ceteral
Okay, first of all, what I just said there was the only problem I have with any part of Evolution.

Second, the only thing I'm trying to prove is that you are putting your faith in something as much as anyone who believes in Intelligent Design concepts by believing in Macro-Evolution. So don't put words in my mouth. Believe what you will. Just know that it is as much belief as anyone puts in God.

Well, if the amount of belief needed for something that is 80% proved is the same amount of belief needed for something that is 0% proved, then yeah evolution requires just as much belief as religion.

that's a problem with these kinds of debates is that some people want to put creation/itelligent desing on the same scientific footing as evolution when that just isn't the case. Neither creation nor ID qualify as science as they can't be proven wrong, thus don't really even belong in a scientific discussion. The difference in 'faith' is that we believe evolution because of the evidence, they believe despite the evidence. Faith is belief without evidence. We have evidence which supports evolution, or whatever other scientific principle you wish to apply to it (punctuated equilibrium etc.), therefore faith is not required.
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Originally posted by Ceteral

My apologies, I didn't read about the mule that was barely fertile.

apparently you stopped there...

Horses and mice have been observed as well. Yes, fertility rates were fairly low, but again that fits in with the evidence too. We don't see new species popping up every day. These aren't common occurrences, but it is possible, which is what you were debating.


And only fertile when combined with a normal mares egg they didn't mind adding. So when it finally is considered a different species, it won't have anything else to breed with.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
http://content.karger.com/ProdukteDB/produkte.asp?Doi=130300&Scope=archiv

Different chromosome count, interbreed, fertile offspring.
Last edited Jun 15, 2008 00:50:33
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Both of these are capable of producing normal offspring if they fertilize the eggs of a domestic mare.



And thus no longer a different species. Makes domestic offspring.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.