User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by BartRock

How can you continue to ignore the build of the guy on the other side of the interaction?

I'm talking about when they play the same defense, so that variable is constant.

Moreover, I'm mystified that anyone would be so stupid as to claim that nothing in the sim changed considering that this is suddenly dramatically different than last season. Do you really mean to tell me that builds changed that much in one off-season? You know that you're wrong, so please just shut up and stop trying to argue because you're embarrassed.


It's not that different than last season, people are just getting the force fumble VAs up. The SS on my team had 25 (or maybe 27) forced fumbles last season. He was ahead of the curve with the power tackler VA and having a lot of points in monster hit.
 
Link
 
Fix your builds
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by BartRock


How can you continue to ignore the build of the guy on the other side of the interaction?

I'm talking about when they play the same defense, so that variable is constant.

Moreover, I'm mystified that anyone would be so stupid as to claim that nothing in the sim changed considering that this is suddenly dramatically different than last season. Do you really mean to tell me that builds changed that much in one off-season? You know that you're wrong, so please just shut up and stop trying to argue because you're embarrassed.


It's not that different than last season, people are just getting the force fumble VAs up. The SS on my team had 25 (or maybe 27) forced fumbles last season. He was ahead of the curve with the power tackler VA and having a lot of points in monster hit.


As were several players on my team. See, JD? Facts! Crazy, huh?
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by BartRock

How can you continue to ignore the build of the guy on the other side of the interaction?

I'm talking about when they play the same defense, so that variable is constant.

Moreover, I'm mystified that anyone would be so stupid as to claim that nothing in the sim changed considering that this is suddenly dramatically different than last season. Do you really mean to tell me that builds changed that much in one off-season? You know that you're wrong, so please just shut up and stop trying to argue because you're embarrassed.


You were talking about one LB and one HB. How can they be playing the same defense. Please stop trying to argue, because you're embarrassed and getting confused.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
By the way, I obviously know that GLB /= NFL, but it's still worth mentioning that no HB in the history of the NFL has ever had 5 fumbles in one game. It has happened 18 times in the history of the NFL to quarterbacks, and the all-time record for fumbles in a game is 7. Meanwhile the highest fumble percentage in NFL history for HBs belongs to Tony Dorsett at 3.07%, or 1 fumble every 32.7 carries. He and Franco Harris are the only two above 3%, while the average is around 2%.


PackMan97:
Your math is wrong. If there is a 2% chance of an event occurring, then wouldn't the chances of it happening five times out of 30 iterations be 0.02^5 * (thirty choose five)? (0.02 * 0.02 * 0.02 * 0.02 * 0.02) = 0.0000000032 Meanwhile "thirty choose five" = (30!) / (5!(30-5)!) = 142506.

So 0.0000000032 * 142506 = 0.0004560192, or 0.0456% chance of happening.

It's been a few years since I took advanced probability theory in grad school, so it's possible I made a mistake, but I'm pretty sure that's the right answer.
 
goshann
offline
Link
 
My level 53 elusive back has 55 carrying, 5 Steady Grip VAs, 53 strength and 43 confidence and fumbled 7 times.

Any advice guys?
Is my build broken?
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 09:47:23
 
Duo
offline
Link
 
My level 24 elusive fumbled TWICE today to a level 10 DT.

u kidin me
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Duo
My level 24 elusive fumbled TWICE today to a level 10 DT.

u kidin me


No.

Enjoy your 7 replies that say nothing but "fix your builds".
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85
It's not that different than last season, people are just getting the force fumble VAs up. The SS on my team had 25 (or maybe 27) forced fumbles last season. He was ahead of the curve with the power tackler VA and having a lot of points in monster hit.

People have already posted many examples of guys without new investment in Power Tackler VAs getting far more forced fumbles this season than ever before, so you're wrong.


Originally posted by BartRock
You were talking about one LB and one HB. How can they be playing the same defense. Please stop trying to argue, because you're embarrassed and getting confused.

Are you 12? Do you need assistance when typing on the internet? I'm flabbergasted by your inability to understand the English language. We know that HBs with carrying in the 40s have been able to avoid 5+ fumble games while playing the exact same defense that a HB with carrying in the 60s had 5+ fumbles against. It's not a builds issue. This has been explained to you over and over and over again.
 
NVJumper
offline
Link
 
I didn't realize fumbling was an issue.... I haven't seen that many fumbles in a game yet.

Must be a lot of out-leveled players expecting to compete with the big dogs, event hough they give up 20 levels :-P
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by XUMuskie85

It's not that different than last season, people are just getting the force fumble VAs up. The SS on my team had 25 (or maybe 27) forced fumbles last season. He was ahead of the curve with the power tackler VA and having a lot of points in monster hit.

People have already posted many examples of guys without new investment in Power Tackler VAs getting far more forced fumbles this season than ever before, so you're wrong.


Originally posted by BartRock

You were talking about one LB and one HB. How can they be playing the same defense. Please stop trying to argue, because you're embarrassed and getting confused.

Are you 12? Do you need assistance when typing on the internet? I'm flabbergasted by your inability to understand the English language. We know that HBs with carrying in the 40s have been able to avoid 5+ fumble games while playing the exact same defense that a HB with carrying in the 60s had 5+ fumbles against. It's not a builds issue. This has been explained to you over and over and over again.


Do you like to insult people's intelligence this much or did we just catch you on a bad day, or something?

Is everything a bad day for you?
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Do no go back to 2 seasons ago when there was just 1 fumble all season per team, stop the bitching
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
PackMan97:
Your math is wrong. If there is a 2% chance of an event occurring, then wouldn't the chances of it happening five times out of 30 iterations be 0.02^5 * (thirty choose five)? (0.02 * 0.02 * 0.02 * 0.02 * 0.02) = 0.0000000032 Meanwhile "thirty choose five" = (30!) / (5!(30-5)!) = 142506.

So 0.0000000032 * 142506 = 0.0004560192, or 0.0456% chance of happening.

It's been a few years since I took advanced probability theory in grad school, so it's possible I made a mistake, but I'm pretty sure that's the right answer.


It's been way to long on statistics for me...let's say your 0.05% (rounded up) is correct....that's still 4-5 games a week against evenly matched teams where folks go fumble crazy.

In this sim we also know that if you fumble once, you are more likely to fumble again and I imagine for some ball carriers vs some defensive guys it's likely higher than 2%.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
It's been way to long on statistics for me...let's say your 0.05% (rounded up) is correct....that's still 4-5 games a week against evenly matched teams where folks go fumble crazy.

Remember, that 0.05% is the chance of one team fumbling five times in a game. We've seen teams fumbling ten times in a game, but the odds of that happening with a 2% fumble chance per carry is 0.000000000145926144%. So yeah, a team fumbling five times in a game should be extremely rare but possible. A team fumbling 10 times in a game, however, is way beyond ludicrous.

For the record, in order to have a 10 fumble game once out of every ten thousand games, your fumble chance per carry would need to be a staggering 26.7846%
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 10:12:23
 
Duo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Duo

My level 24 elusive fumbled TWICE today to a level 10 DT.

u kidin me


No.

Enjoy your 7 replies that say nothing but "fix your builds".


Yeah I know, even though they're nowhere near high enough for VAs
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.