User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by Cactus71

let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls


That is part of the game and part of the fun. You can't do everything well and stop everyone. If everyone could do that the game would be no fun at all. It is hard for Americans to hear because of our "I want it all and I want it now" culture, but you have to pick and choose. You can't have it all - you take risks and build certain skills at the expense of others. It is not a weakness in the game that you are forced to do this - IT IS THE GAME.This is what creates matchups and strategy and what makes the game both realistic and fun. Sure every now and then in sports you have superstars like Lebron or Kobe or Ed Reed, but these guys tend to be 1 in 100,000 or so. Most players have strengths and weaknesses, and you try to put together a team where players at one position use their strengths to complement the weaknesses of their teammates. In fact this is the very essence of what a team is in the first place. Furthermore if everyone could make a team full of players who did everything well the game would become stale and boring. Instead of Rock Paper Scissors it would turn into Rock Rock Rock and let's see who's rock is shinier or whatever. The very basic element of games that millions of people have found the most fun over time combine elements of choice, elements of strength and weakness, and the fun is not in acquiring super piece after super piece, but in combining the flawed pieces in clever, new ways to outwit your opponent. This is true of chess, Magic the Gathering, Monopoly, any game really, and if you think about it, deep down the appeal of assembling and utilized flawed elements to achieve a result greater than the sum of their parts has something profound to say about the human condition as well.


yea I know I don't expect every player to be amazingly good at everything but with a 100 strength HB and a 100 speed WR I would be able to score 50 points a game on any defense if the tackling requirements were that high, like you said defensive players have to do a lot of things
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:52:13
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
The key point to remember is that there is a big difference between stopping him and stuffing him.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Baustin
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by britdevine316



If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


How does the D "burn" the O then?


There's no way for the D to burn the O with 100 STR. It doesn't do jack for you on the D-line, why should it work for RB's?


Power Backs > Strength D-lineman. Why? Dunno. Fact is it does work for RBs.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cactus71
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Originally posted by Cactus71


let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls


That is part of the game and part of the fun. You can't do everything well and stop everyone. If everyone could do that the game would be no fun at all. It is hard for Americans to hear because of our "I want it all and I want it now" culture, but you have to pick and choose. You can't have it all - you take risks and build certain skills at the expense of others. It is not a weakness in the game that you are forced to do this - IT IS THE GAME.This is what creates matchups and strategy and what makes the game both realistic and fun. Sure every now and then in sports you have superstars like Lebron or Kobe or Ed Reed, but these guys tend to be 1 in 100,000 or so. Most players have strengths and weaknesses, and you try to put together a team where players at one position use their strengths to complement the weaknesses of their teammates. In fact this is the very essence of what a team is in the first place. Furthermore if everyone could make a team full of players who did everything well the game would become stale and boring. Instead of Rock Paper Scissors it would turn into Rock Rock Rock and let's see who's rock is shinier or whatever. The very basic element of games that millions of people have found the most fun over time combine elements of choice, elements of strength and weakness, and the fun is not in acquiring super piece after super piece, but in combining the flawed pieces in clever, new ways to outwit your opponent. This is true of chess, Magic the Gathering, Monopoly, any game really, and if you think about it, deep down the appeal of assembling and utilized flawed elements to achieve a result greater than the sum of their parts has something profound to say about the human condition as well.


yea I know I don't expect every player to be amazingly good at everything but with a 100 strength HB and a 100 speed WR I would be able to score 50 points a game on any defense if the tackling requirements were that high, like you said defensive players have to do a lot of things


Not true at all. You have 11 players on defense. The same guy doesn't have to do everything. So lets say you get strong LBs and fast CBs, or strong CBs and fast Ss, or a strong LB an SS and everyone else is fast. That is what building a team is all about. I build my defenses this way. We have run stuffers and pass coverage people, and we specialize for certain things. If you are going to have 6 LBs on a team, why have them all made in the same 85 Speed, 65 Agility, 48 Strength, 60 Vision, 48 Tackling 30 Confidence, 35 Jumping mold? I thought this was defense 101.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:59:53
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Baustin

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by britdevine316




If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


How does the D "burn" the O then?


There's no way for the D to burn the O with 100 STR. It doesn't do jack for you on the D-line, why should it work for RB's?


Power Backs > Strength D-lineman. Why? Dunno. Fact is it does work for RBs.


I am pretty happy with my 100+ strength d-linemen. They stuff the hell out of the run, among other things. Perhaps folks shouldn't build a bunch of pass rushers at DT and NT? hmmm.
 
Saerin
offline
Link
 
part of the reason High Str Defenders didnt work has been fixed. I think you will see high strength D-lineman perform even better this year.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
FYI, related to this thread (check changelog, too) - I've added the ability for a tackler to hang on and be dragged a bit if he barely misses his make tackle roll. I don't know if it will make much of a difference since he normally would slow down the ball carrier a lot in that case anyway, but it looks kinda neat in some cases and makes for possible gang tackles without a "missed tackle" stat being recorded.
 
cober
offline
Link
 
Tackling should be the most important skill.But your physical skills should have an effect. This is why great coaches are not great players they know how to tackle but as slow weak and fat. Your ability to tackle should be combination of tackle 50% strength 20% agility 20% & vision 10%.

Tackle - Correct use of the physical skills
Strength - amount of force you can bring to bear
Agility - Ability to adjust your force
Vision - judgeing the optimal time to launch.

Major focus of being able to tackle should be the skill itself. With related skills giving a bonus to the attempt.
In this way having 100 tackle and no strength agility vision to support it would work out to be less effective.

Then a player with 70 tackle 60 strength 50 agi 50 vision. making balanced builds more optimal. Rather then unrealistic min/max builds.

Same could be applied to movement speed or any other action a player takes.

Movement - speed 50% Agi 30% strength 10 Vision 20. In that way your total speed would be decided by a number of statistics rather then min / maxing one. Createing more varied builds.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Sounds like a great addition and I am sure the DC's will enjoy this addition. Getting more realistic every season. Thanks for all the hard work.

Also Bort take a look at the Pulling Guard in the AI thread in suggestions please.

Thanks for everything.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
FYI, related to this thread (check changelog, too) - I've added the ability for a tackler to hang on and be dragged a bit if he barely misses his make tackle roll. I don't know if it will make much of a difference since he normally would slow down the ball carrier a lot in that case anyway, but it looks kinda neat in some cases and makes for possible gang tackles without a "missed tackle" stat being recorded.


did you test my LB?
 
davidbowie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
Originally posted by


What is the situation? is he being stuffed just after the handoff?

IRL momentum/speed and position play a much, much larger role in tackling than straight up strength or tackling/carrying skill does. Even punters/kickers/qbs take down runners on occasion, simply because they have the good position.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort

FYI, related to this thread (check changelog, too) - I've added the ability for a tackler to hang on and be dragged a bit if he barely misses his make tackle roll. I don't know if it will make much of a difference since he normally would slow down the ball carrier a lot in that case anyway, but it looks kinda neat in some cases and makes for possible gang tackles without a "missed tackle" stat being recorded.


did you test my LB?


Didn't get a chance actually, since I was focusing on just getting the updates done.

I will add his player id to my list right now. "I'll Force a Fumble On Yo Momma fo a Dolla" is the LB I should look at right?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
yeah, here is the link to make it easier for you

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=804491
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
yeah, here is the link to make it easier for you

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=804491


Great build you got going Rob!
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
yeah, here is the link to make it easier for you

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=804491


K, I'll put him at MLB vs somebody good.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.