User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Before you say it is impossible, here is a breakdown on your special abilities and their cost in skill points:

1122 - 6
1122 - 6
112 - 4
1122 - 6
223344 - 18

50 points in special abilities and probably 15 too many in stamina = 65 points that could have been added to throwing, strength, vision, and confidence. Not saying you shouldn't have any specials, but putting 28 points into a Field General with a leve 25 QB is crazy.


I'm guessing he has Custom +1 equip.. making this cost 13 points less.
TBH, if Specials aren't worth having, then they need to be boosted.


I actually took that into account if you notice. He said his specials were 5-5-4-5-7 and my calculation is for 4-4-3-4-6 - Edit. Was for 8 so minus 10 points. I had the right idea, just made a simple counting error! o_O
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 16:51:32
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
I personally think too many people buy into the player builds arguement. Again I went 2 season without equipting 3 WRs all led the team in YDS, TDs and receptions. Oh an the same crappy QB was the guy throwing to one of the WRs. So if I can go 2 seasons and be able to burn CBs, FS and SSs with my speed and skill against a fully customed equipted player, that leads me to believe the numbers everyone argues is all BS.

Unequipted WR#1 16games 102rec 1,039.5yds 8TDs
WR#2 16games 94 1,175.5yds 5TDs
WR#3 16games 99 1,235.5yds 15TDs

Season 1 wasn't that far off either and that was with only 8 games under my belt


Misread your post but this still is proof that numbers count.
Your qb's passer rating is 36 man, 2 td's, 13 ints. Wr's get stats depending on where they start, you are bound to get stats as a No.1 receievers. Don't go around giving out bad info like that man.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 16:53:53
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Bad info? Thats factual info. 3 WRs on 3 different treams, All 3 had good numbers with 0 equiptment for 2 seasons. The only one that dropped off is the 3rd Wr who plays on the Nashville team. (And with fully equipted and custom the stats havnt changed much)
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 16:55:29
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Bad info? Thats factual info. 3 WRs on 3 different treams, All 3 had good numbers with 0 equiptment for 2 seasons. The only one that dropped off is the 3rd Wr who plays on the Nashville team.


Like I said when you are a No.1 receiver you are going to put up stats, try getting equipment and you will do even better
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Before you say it is impossible, here is a breakdown on your special abilities and their cost in skill points:

1122 - 6
1122 - 6
112 - 4
1122 - 6
223344 - 18

50 points in special abilities and probably 15 too many in stamina = 65 points that could have been added to throwing, strength, vision, and confidence. Not saying you shouldn't have any specials, but putting 28 points into a Field General with a leve 25 QB is crazy.


I'm guessing he has Custom +1 equip.. making this cost 13 points less.
TBH, if Specials aren't worth having, then they need to be boosted.


I actually took that into account if you notice. He said his specials were 5-5-4-5-7 and my calculation is for 4-4-3-4-6 - Edit. Was for 8 so minus 10 points. I had the right idea, just made a simple counting error! o_O


Lol, we both fail at Maths. Oh well. I think that his selection of Specials is fine and if they aren't, then it is the Specials which need changing. No other Position has Field General - and if field General isn't the right SA for this Player, then it isn't the right SA for any Player. But I think we all agree that his Stamina should be lower - you say 15, I'd say 20.. but then again, my Players are both backups - and I'm a strong supporter of Backups, so that might have something to do with it.
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
I did and custom and they didn't do any better. So your arguement is as long as you are in the number 1 slot you will get good stats no matter what your build is?
 
MichN18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Bad info? Thats factual info. 3 WRs on 3 different treams, All 3 had
good numbers with 0 equiptment for 2 seasons. The only one that dropped
off is the 3rd Wr who plays on the Nashville team. (And with fully
equipted and custom the stats havnt changed much)



Besides, all you're "proving" here is that the random factor is large enough that WRs who are handicapped by their agent's unwillingness to get them equipment can still perform. No one is saying that there isn't a significant random factor in the sim equations.

Honestly, I thought this sob story would have concluded by now.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Originally posted by tpaterniti



Before you say it is impossible, here is a breakdown on your special abilities and their cost in skill points:

1122 - 6
1122 - 6
112 - 4
1122 - 6
223344 - 18

50 points in special abilities and probably 15 too many in stamina = 65 points that could have been added to throwing, strength, vision, and confidence. Not saying you shouldn't have any specials, but putting 28 points into a Field General with a leve 25 QB is crazy.


I'm guessing he has Custom +1 equip.. making this cost 13 points less.
TBH, if Specials aren't worth having, then they need to be boosted.


I actually took that into account if you notice. He said his specials were 5-5-4-5-7 and my calculation is for 4-4-3-4-6 - Edit. Was for 8 so minus 10 points. I had the right idea, just made a simple counting error! o_O


Lol, we both fail at Maths. Oh well. I think that his selection of Specials is fine and if they aren't, then it is the Specials which need changing. No other Position has Field General - and if field General isn't the right SA for this Player, then it isn't the right SA for any Player. But I think we all agree that his Stamina should be lower - you say 15, I'd say 20.. but then again, my Players are both backups - and I'm a strong supporter of Backups, so that might have something to do with it.


There's a good point there. If it's that bad to train Field General very high, then it needs to be improved.
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
I did and custom and they didn't do any better. So your arguement is as long as you are in the number 1 slot you will get good stats no matter what your build is?


Yep, also if you don't believe equipment doesn't help it is your loss pal, I'm not going to argue about having more attributes makes your players better.
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Maybe it's the "Stick'em" hidden attribute I have been using all along.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

There's a good point there. If it's that bad to train Field General very high, then it needs to be improved.


What if Field General doesn't kick in until 40 Confidence?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Ken1


There's a good point there. If it's that bad to train Field General very high, then it needs to be improved.


What if Field General doesn't kick in until 40 Confidence?


There certainly shouldn't be a threshhold underneath which it's completely wasted, and I doubt there is.

Its level of effectiveness might be dependent on Confidence though; but if so, that's the type of thing that ought to be in the description, just as we know not to put points into Juke unless we have high agility.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
I don't see why there couldn't be a threshold for SAs to kick in... Just because you say there shouldn't be... is not going to cut it...

I see it as reasonable....
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
and BTW... I have no knowledge of this whatsoever... this is pure speculation on my part....
 
jamyp
offline
Link
 
My FB has 23.63 in confidence on the Nashville team. :oops:
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.