User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Worker 3
well then there should be a penalty to catch% or something (i dont think thats really possible though.) otherwise every deep ball is going to be caught, which isnt the most realistic thing in the world... that is if we are going for realism. if not, carry on.
or maybe a bigger penalty to pass quality on deep balls, but then QBs will complain.


I'm pretty sure there is some sort of penalty to catching for WR who is running faster. It is also harder for the QB to get there and PQ goes down the farther he throws it. The WR will also probably have lower strength and jumping, so if the CB or safety can keep up with him, they will probably have a better shot at winning the roll. Basically the WR's sole goal is to create separation and keep speed. while making the catch. Doing that will probably be hard.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024


I'm pretty sure there is some sort of penalty to catching for WR who is running faster.


I believe Bort has said the faster a player is moving, the tougher it is to pass the vision check to catch a pass.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
I'm pretty sure there is some sort of penalty to catching for WR who is running faster. It is also harder for the QB to get there and PQ goes down the farther he throws it. The WR will also probably have lower strength and jumping, so if the CB or safety can keep up with him, they will probably have a better shot at winning the roll. Basically the WR's sole goal is to create separation and keep speed. while making the catch. Doing that will probably be hard.


makes sense... dont know why i didnt think of that before. i know there is a penalty to deep balls, i guess i just forgot about the penalty to catch chance when going super fast. im sure its been tested, but if it hasnt, well at least its been brought up and will be tested.

im a bit worried about the bonus to FS and the speedster WR getting better ALGs on speed than they used to, but man CBs get better ALGs and a bonus to SDC. so hopefully it balances out.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Here are the first 2 players I have created on the test server. One is a Scat FB archetype, the other a Possession WR archetype

Bigs Catback (Lv. 72 FB)
Ht/Wt: 6'0", 220lbs

Experience, Skill Points, and Cash
Money: $5123500
Daily Salary: $0
Skill Points: 15
Training Points: 7
Bonus Tokens: 15
Veteran Points: 0
Next Level: 0/1000

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 66
Speed: 146.01 (+51)
Agility: 88.03
Jumping: 29.71
Stamina: 55.71
Vision: 64.02
Confidence: 54.71

Football Skills
Blocking: 10
Catching: 64.76
Tackling: 10
Throwing: 10
Carrying: 72 (+3)
Kicking: 10
Punting: 10

Special Abilities
Blocking Abilities
Hands: 0
Lead Block: 0
Spot Blitz: 0
Strong Arm: 0
Pancake: 0

Offensive Abilities
Cover Up: 5
Sticky Hands: 9
Power Through: 5
Quick Cut: 9
Dive for Yardage: 1

Veteran Abilities
Heart of a Champion: 1
Mr. Reliable: 15
Overtime Killer: 1
Scat Back: 15
Slippery: 15
YAC attack: 15


Bigs Catcher (Lv. 72 WR)
Ht/Wt: 6'6", 235lbs

Experience, Skill Points, and Cash
Money: $25286000
Daily Salary: $0
Skill Points: 15
Training Points: 7
Bonus Tokens: 11
Veteran Points: 0
Next Level: 0/1000

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 50
Speed: 116.49 (+46)
Agility: 89.59 (+6)
Jumping: 82.59
Stamina: 48.49
Vision: 72.6 (+3)
Confidence: 54.49

Football Skills
Blocking: 10
Catching: 75.59
Tackling: 12
Throwing: 10
Carrying: 68.49
Kicking: 10
Punting: 10

Special Abilities
Posession Receiver Abilities
Route Running: 9
Sticky Hands: 9
Jumping Catch: 7
Diving Catch: 7
One Handed Cach: 1

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 0
Quick Cut: 0
Head Fake: 0
Spin: 0
Juke: 0

Veteran Abilities
Clutch: 1
Mr. Reliable: 15
Overtime Killer: 1
Possession Receiver: 15
Prime Time Player: 15
Slot Machine: 15



 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here are the first 2 players I have created on the test server. One is a Scat FB archetype, the other a Possession WR archetype

Bigs Catback (Lv. 72 FB)
Ht/Wt: 6'0", 220lbs

Experience, Skill Points, and Cash
Money: $5123500
Daily Salary: $0
Skill Points: 15
Training Points: 7
Bonus Tokens: 15
Veteran Points: 0
Next Level: 0/1000

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 66
Speed: 146.01 (+51)
Agility: 88.03
Jumping: 29.71
Stamina: 55.71
Vision: 64.02
Confidence: 54.71

Football Skills
Blocking: 10
Catching: 64.76
Tackling: 10
Throwing: 10
Carrying: 72 (+3)
Kicking: 10
Punting: 10

Special Abilities
Blocking Abilities
Hands: 0
Lead Block: 0
Spot Blitz: 0
Strong Arm: 0
Pancake: 0

Offensive Abilities
Cover Up: 5
Sticky Hands: 9
Power Through: 5
Quick Cut: 9
Dive for Yardage: 1

Veteran Abilities
Heart of a Champion: 1
Mr. Reliable: 15
Overtime Killer: 1
Scat Back: 15
Slippery: 15
YAC attack: 15


Bigs Catcher (Lv. 72 WR)
Ht/Wt: 6'6", 235lbs

Experience, Skill Points, and Cash
Money: $25286000
Daily Salary: $0
Skill Points: 15
Training Points: 7
Bonus Tokens: 11
Veteran Points: 0
Next Level: 0/1000

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 50
Speed: 116.49 (+46)
Agility: 89.59 (+6)
Jumping: 82.59
Stamina: 48.49
Vision: 72.6 (+3)
Confidence: 54.49

Football Skills
Blocking: 10
Catching: 75.59
Tackling: 12
Throwing: 10
Carrying: 68.49
Kicking: 10
Punting: 10

Special Abilities
Posession Receiver Abilities
Route Running: 9
Sticky Hands: 9
Jumping Catch: 7
Diving Catch: 7
One Handed Cach: 1

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 0
Quick Cut: 0
Head Fake: 0
Spin: 0
Juke: 0

Veteran Abilities
Clutch: 1
Mr. Reliable: 15
Overtime Killer: 1
Possession Receiver: 15
Prime Time Player: 15
Slot Machine: 15





How many bonus tokens diid you end up with? Because without 2 pieces of aeq both of those players are worthless
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
DT's kind of get screwed in this... The DL archetypes that would be best for an interior lineman would be the strength build but the SA bonuses are subpar for a DT. I'd love to see, a Shed Block/Swat Ball with Strength/Agility as majors
 
cbothe
offline
Link
 
I definitely think this needs some changing, i've made 2 scrambling qb's and am working on my 3rd, and I wouldn't use this archetype at all if I wanted to make one. The Scrambling SA's are basically garbage except for one, and the bonuses need to be set up better for the auto level gains...Here's the current suggestion

QB Scrambler
5'11" - 6'3", 190-230 Lbs
Major Agility Throwing Vision (+.67)
Minor Confidence Speed Strength Carrying (+.25)
Bonus SA's - On The Run, Dump Pass
Penalty SA's - Pump Fake, Tight Spiral

Here's My Suggestion

QB Scrambler
5'11" - 6'5"(Vince Young/Terrell Pryor are both over 6'3), 190-230 Lbs
Major Agility Throwing Vision Speed(+.5)
Minor Confidence Stamina Strength Carrying (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Tight Spiral, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Pump Fake, Turn Shoulder

The proposed archetype qb would only be made by people that want to run, not be a dual threat. Tight Spiral is easily the in the top 2 of most important SA's any qb can have in this game and penalizing it is crazy.
 
dnooner
offline
Link
 
If we make a player on day 41, will we be able to choose whether or not they have an Archetype? I think I'm gonna make like 30 Centers, and trade them every year
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch 22
Revised what we will be doing for players between 1-80 days old:

3) If your player is between 1-80 days old you will be forced to choose an archetype before the end of pre-season. If you do not choose one by then you will be assigned the default archetype for that position. If you would rather retire your player then choose an archetype, you can do so and receive a full (100%) refund.


Great, so our season 14 skill players will be shitty compared to season 15 skill players, but our interior lineman and kickers can't be better to make up for it. FFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUU
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Great, so our season 14 skill players will be shitty compared to season 15 skill players, but our interior lineman and kickers can't be better to make up for it. FFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUU


With the re-do of the archetypes, most aren't that superior to the ones we have now, it's mostly a wash.

The current C would be massively OP'd against the new dots. And the K and P are so juiced they stop improving at level 35 anyway.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
There's a huge difference in those ranges, i.e. between 15% and 30%. Definitely too vague imo.


I don't know how you can say it's "too vague" when right now, there's no indication whatsoever that there will be any way of having any idea whatsoever the penalty is going to be, other than via testing it out empirically.
 
chazno
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
The current C would be massively OP'd against the new dots.


OP'd against who? The OP'd D-linemen that were built in the same season. You know the people they will be playing against nearly their entire career.

If you take a Season 15 team versus a Season 14 Team and throw out the level difference it boils down to a team with a superior inner line ( DL & OL) versus a team with superior Skill players ( including LBs and DBs)

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
With the re-do of the archetypes, most aren't that superior to the ones we have now, it's mostly a wash.


Please...
New safeties can get .33 more agility and .1 more speed per level than old ones, with no points wasted in carrying or tackling.
New QBs will get .27 more in throwing, vision, and confidence or strength.
New OTs waste .5 less in tackling and .17 less in stamina per level.
New HBs can get .17 more in three of strength, speed, agility, and carrying.
New LBs can get .17 more in three of strength, speed, agility, and tackling.
New FBs can get .25 or even .5 more in speed.
New TEs will get .23 more in agility and can get .23 more in speed.

Those are huge differences even when applied only over the first season (which is 14 levels of full ALGs). Plus, people who created their season 14 dots with starting attributes that would make for efficient builds under the old system won't have started in such a way as to be efficient in the new system. It's a total screwjob if they also have to watch their plans for Gs, Cs, and DTs get screwed up.

Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
The current C would be massively OP'd against the new dots. And the K and P are so juiced they stop improving at level 35 anyway.


The difference is not as big as you think, IMO. If you don't choose an archetype, you don't get the benefit of the new bonus SAs (i.e. Get Low, Pancake for Cs). Also, Old-style Gs and Cs have .2 points wasted in tackling, DTs have .2 wasted in blocking, Ks and Ps have .17 wasted in throwing, and old-style Gs and Cs get 0 in speed.

Not to mention, on a 55 man roster, a team only has 12 Gs, Cs, DTs, Ks, and Ps. So they probably have 39 QBs, HBs, FBs, TEs, OTs, LBs, CBs, and Safeties. (Old-style DEs are basically the same as new-style.) So this decision means the new teams will be better at 39 positions and worse at 12. I guess that was too rough on the new teams, so they had to change it.
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 12, 2010 13:56:05
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 12, 2010 10:27:34
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 12, 2010 10:24:51
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chazno
OP'd against who? The OP'd D-linemen that were built in the same season. You know the people they will be playing against nearly their entire career.

If you take a Season 15 team versus a Season 14 Team and throw out the level difference it boils down to a team with a superior inner line ( DL & OL) versus a team with superior Skill players ( including LBs and DBs)


Yeah, it won't affect competition until the end of the players' careers. Then, if season 14 teams had to pick archetypes across the board, at the end of their plateau season they will get destroyed by season 15 teams that just reached their plateau.
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 12, 2010 10:16:28
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
trevjo crushing in this thread
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.