User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
Originally posted by Ceteral

Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
decided to get rid of it.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 22:35:40
 
Oden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
Originally posted by stat2883

Originally posted by Ceteral


Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Then how do different animals end up with different amounts of chromosomes?
 
Oden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Ceteral

Originally posted by stat2883


Originally posted by Ceteral



Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Better yet, who would want to? *shivers*

Thats probably going to get me banned : /


Lol, why would that get you banned? That's tame compared to most of the things said on this site!
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Oden
Originally posted by Ceteral

Originally posted by stat2883


Originally posted by Ceteral



Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Then how do different animals end up with different amounts of chromosomes?


You prove my point.
 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
Originally posted by stat2883

Originally posted by Ceteral


Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Did you read the link I posted? You can have fertile offspring. You were supposed to keep reading
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 23:24:15
 
Oden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ceteral
Originally posted by Oden

Originally posted by Ceteral


Originally posted by stat2883



Originally posted by Ceteral




Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Then how do different animals end up with different amounts of chromosomes?


You prove my point.


Whether I prove your point or not, how did different animals evolve to have different numbers of chromosomes unless they could breed regardless?
 
hellbound201
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/3963/darwinnotg7.jpg

AHAHAHAHAHA


Get rid of that horrible rag that claims to be a science magazine. Go read Nature, or Science if you want to get some actual decent articles that aren't fluffed or outright lies.

There are a lot of problems with our theories on the cosmos and the 'big bang'. We have made several assumptions that work out on paper but there are other options to them, these are just the most probable.

Darwin was right to an extent, you can breed for specific traits, the problem comes in that a species evolving into an entirely new species is really not going to happen. I'm sorry I'm a punctuated equilibrium guy, it is the only thing IMO that fits the data.

If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.
 
Oden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hellbound201
Originally posted by cbarge

http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/3963/darwinnotg7.jpg

AHAHAHAHAHA


Get rid of that horrible rag that claims to be a science magazine. Go read Nature, or Science if you want to get some actual decent articles that aren't fluffed or outright lies.

There are a lot of problems with our theories on the cosmos and the 'big bang'. We have made several assumptions that work out on paper but there are other options to them, these are just the most probable.

Darwin was right to an extent, you can breed for specific traits, the problem comes in that a species evolving into an entirely new species is really not going to happen. I'm sorry I'm a punctuated equilibrium guy, it is the only thing IMO that fits the data.

If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Evolution is obviously real. Whether god does or doesn't exist we can never know.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hellbound201
If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Not really. We have a clue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment
 
hellbound201
offline
Link
 
as said I'm a punctuated equlibrium kind of guy, I think darwinian evolution into new species is incorrect. Meaning that we have realtively small changes over time then BAM a genetic freak occurs, some of these work out some don't but that is what I see as the correct view. THis is not the main stream view of scientists in the biology field but there are some that believe it. They are attacked heavily because this undermines Darwinian evolution and by god we can't have that because that would help those attackers out.

Originally posted by Oden
Originally posted by hellbound201

Originally posted by cbarge


http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/3963/darwinnotg7.jpg

AHAHAHAHAHA


Get rid of that horrible rag that claims to be a science magazine. Go read Nature, or Science if you want to get some actual decent articles that aren't fluffed or outright lies.

There are a lot of problems with our theories on the cosmos and the 'big bang'. We have made several assumptions that work out on paper but there are other options to them, these are just the most probable.

Darwin was right to an extent, you can breed for specific traits, the problem comes in that a species evolving into an entirely new species is really not going to happen. I'm sorry I'm a punctuated equilibrium guy, it is the only thing IMO that fits the data.

If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Evolution is obviously real. Whether god does or doesn't exist we can never know.


 
stat2883
online
Link
 
Actually evolution as Darwin described it has gone through quite a few refinements and alterations. Evolution as its understood today isn't the same as what Darwin first put forth.
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by hellbound201

If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Not really. We have a clue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment


Actually, that test was tainted.
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Oden
Originally posted by Ceteral

Originally posted by Oden


Originally posted by Ceteral



Originally posted by stat2883




Originally posted by Ceteral





Macro-evolution would involve chromosomes. As in gaining or losing them. That is why a whale cannot turn into a dog. They don't have the same number of chromosomes.

Now, tell me how Macro-evolution is going to happen without sounding as much a nut as anyone who aregues for creationism.

Down's Syndrome is venturing along these paths, though hardly beneficial, it isn't that big of a leap to imagine a similar mutation on the other end of the spectrum. Chromosomal differences happens more often than I think you know in nature.


See, the problem with that is, the difference in chromosomes doesn't allow for breeding to function properly.


Then how do different animals end up with different amounts of chromosomes?


You prove my point.


Whether I prove your point or not, how did different animals evolve to have different numbers of chromosomes unless they could breed regardless?


That's the point, they can't.
 
hellbound201
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by hellbound201

If you discuss the chemical origins of life then we honestly have no clue really how DNA comes about. No models currently are thought to be legit, we simply do not have a clue how random chemicals can turn into DNA or into a single celled organism.


Not really. We have a clue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment


At present no serious biologist will cite that experiment, there are numerous errors in it. Miller was using what he thought the best mix to create DNA or at least some form of it, he did not use known atmospheric compositions, or at least believed atmospheric compositions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.