User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Trolling? Do you even understand what you are saying?

I was adding to the discussion, just showing that lower levels are not experiencing problems. It helps to bring focus towards where the issues lie. Now just calm yourself down before you do yourself some mischief.


I sent you a PM.

 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Trolling? Do you even understand what you are saying?

I was adding to the discussion, just showing that lower levels are not experiencing problems. It helps to bring focus towards where the issues lie. Now just calm yourself down before you do yourself some mischief.


I sent you a PM.



I got it. And I replied.

You can bring up those issues in here, I was not threatening you with a ban. I was just asking you why you thought I was trolling when I was just pointing out that at lower levels the issue is not presenting in players that are being built to cope with these kinds of issues. The players that they are playing against should still be relative in terms of ability.

Although, I have not looked at other LVL16 HBs to see if they DO have a fumbling issue. So if we can find ones with low levels in the attributes being discussed then we can lean towards that being part of the issue.

 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
I got it. And I replied.

You can bring up those issues in here, I was not threatening you with a ban. I was just asking you why you thought I was trolling when I was just pointing out that at lower levels the issue is not presenting in players that are being built to cope with these kinds of issues. The players that they are playing against should still be relative in terms of ability.

Although, I have not looked at other LVL16 HBs to see if they DO have a fumbling issue. So if we can find ones with low levels in the attributes being discussed then we can lean towards that being part of the issue.


From what I can tell, the fumbling issue is caused by a variety of factors, but two of the key ones are high strength and tackling for the defender combined with fumbling-causing SAs and Power Tackler. In a low-level capped league, very few LBs and SSs will have spent many points on strength, tackling or SAs and wouldn't be able to add points to Power Tackler. Furthermore, at that level, the players that have relatively high tackling/strength (DTs mostly), are usually not great at getting at the ball carrier on defense and are way too slow to get to the ball carrier in the return game.

In other words, I wouldn't expect this particular fumbling issue to arise until players were in their high 20s/low 30s (though mid-30s is more likely), and I don't expect it to happen in every game (only when defenses/STs are set up for it), though I expect it will increase as the season progresses.
 
JSSynister
offline
Link
 
There are HBs/FBs/KRs at all levels both having fumbling issues and NOT having fumbling issues. That would seem to indicate a build problem and not a sim problem to me. Of course, it is week 1 still, some may have got lucky, not all defenses are set up to force fumbles as well.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JSSynister
There are HBs/FBs/KRs at all levels both having fumbling issues and NOT having fumbling issues. That would seem to indicate a build problem and not a sim problem to me. Of course, it is week 1 still, some may have got lucky, not all defenses are set up to force fumbles as well.


This is what I was bringing into the mix. If there are HBs of equivalent level to mine popping the ball out every other play then we can compare.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JSSynister
There are HBs/FBs/KRs at all levels both having fumbling issues and NOT having fumbling issues. That would seem to indicate a build problem and not a sim problem to me. Of course, it is week 1 still, some may have got lucky, not all defenses are set up to force fumbles as well.


I think, like with many things in this game, it's both a build and a sim problem (much like the power back issue, which has been toned down by both build and sim fixes). I think too many ball carriers have carrying and confidence too low, but I also think that the defensive VAs that make forcing fumbles more likely (Sure Tackler, David v. Goliath and Power Tackler) are not balanced well by offensive VAs that reduce the risk of forcing fumbles, and that relatively small build imbalances create too large an effect (though that latter point may be wrong and might be a useful thing to test on the test server).
 
ElKeeed
offline
Link
 
bruiser va is now based on carrying rather than strength, does that not give you a clue that carrying is much more important to ball carriers now?
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
So, this game started with HB's going mostly speed. Defense adjusted by pumping speed and crying "nerf the speed back"

...so speed HB's became juke/fake HB's and the defense adjusted by pumping agiltiy and vision and crying "nerf the elusive back"

...thus gave rise to the power back and defense adjusted by pumping strength and tackling and crying "nerf the power back".

this is the same thing we have all the time....one side gets the upper hand, the other adjusts.

Now, what makes this one tough to take for HB's is that most LBers weren't using VA's on strength and tackling (they were using them on speed and agility) so LBers got a relative boost to strength while HBs didn't. Of course, this should help out speed/elusive backs just a bit.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
Bort already said nothing changed that would cause more fumbles, except for how people are building players.

Bort has been wrong many times before, and if he said this then he's wrong again. Something clearly changed, and not just how people applied VAs. Plenty of teams used Power Tackler last season and didn't have anywhere near these results.


Originally posted by Demboyz
you are blaming every misfortune by the offense on the simple idea that the sim is broken. just because you(offensive players) think you are entitled to dominate every game like previous seasons doesnt mean its gunna happen this season. stop bitching and adjust

You do nothing but bitch. You don't spend money on the game, and you don't even have enough experience with the game to even have an opinion, much less post it in every thread on the forums. There is no adjustment because it's not a builds or tactics issue.


Originally posted by PierreThomas
Teams that generally force fumbles will continue to force fumbles unless teams adjust. Teams that generally lose fumbles will continue to lose a lot of fumbles unless they adjust. It really is that simple.

BUT THEY HAVEN'T. This has been pointed out repeatedly to you and yet you continue running off at the mouth because you can't just bring yourself to shut up even when you know that you're wrong. The teams with 10+ fumbles or 5+ interceptions aren't having that happen in other games. It's a random occurrence and not an issue of builds or tactics. Similarly, the teams forcing 10+ fumbles or 5+ interceptions in a game aren't having that happen in other games. Of course some defenses invest more in Power Tackler than others, but that's a 2-3 fumble difference from those other teams in most games. The 10+ fumble games happen when something in the sim randomly triggers a mass fumble outcome, which is why neither that offense or defense are involved in other 10+ fumble games. If it wasn't random, those offenses would be having multiple 10+ fumble games and those defenses would be causing multiple 10+ fumble games. THEY AREN'T.


Originally posted by fallingmercury
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=481909

We forced 4 fumbles from their #1 and #2 HBs. That equaled their total fumbles from all of last season.

Also we forced 2 fumbles from their TE which is more than he's had in the sum of his entire career going back to season three.

Our LB that forced five fumbles last game is unremarkable:

64 strength
55 tackling
51 vision
50 confidence

5 monster hit

There were three fumbles on monster hits this game. 5 monster hit isn't a ton, so maybe luck played a role. But don't tell me nothing changed in the sim this year.

Thanks for posting this evidence, but most of these people are so dense that they'll keep repeating the same thing over and over again regardless of whatever facts you present them. They scream "fix your builds!" & "fix your tactics!" to every complaint, regardless of merit.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
jd, you're more intelligent than you're showing.

It's fairly obvious that teams are different.

If a team fumbles 10 times one game and none the next, it couldn't possibly be because they were playing a team built to cause fumbles in the first game and not in the second?

If a team causes 10 fumbles in one game and none the next, it couldn't possibly be because the first team has low carrying/confidence/stamina and the second has high carrying/confidence/stamina?

Come on, man.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock
It's fairly obvious that teams are different.

No. Please stop posting because your brain density is raising my blood pressure to very unhealthy levels. This has been explained to you over and over and over again but you just keep posting the same nonsense regardless of the facts presented to you. Fallingmercury posted the build of a guy who forced five fumbles in one game, and it clearly was not "special." You would not expect that build to cause five fumbles in a game. Similarly, HBs with carrying well over 60 have had five fumble games while others with carrying in the 40s have not. IT IS NOT A BUILDS ISSUE. Stop embarrassing yourself by repeating nonsense that has already been disproven. Shut up and don't speak again until you've come to grips with basic facts.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by BartRock

It's fairly obvious that teams are different.

No. Please stop posting because your brain density is raising my blood pressure to very unhealthy levels. This has been explained to you over and over and over again but you just keep posting the same nonsense regardless of the facts presented to you. Fallingmercury posted the build of a guy who forced five fumbles in one game, and it clearly was not "special." You would not expect that build to cause five fumbles in a game. Similarly, HBs with carrying well over 60 have had five fumble games while others with carrying in the 40s have not. IT IS NOT A BUILDS ISSUE. Stop embarrassing yourself by repeating nonsense that has already been disproven. Shut up and don't speak again until you've come to grips with basic facts.


So, it's impossible that the guy who caused the fumbles was playing a vastly inferior player in terms of carrying/confidence/morale and it's impossible that the guy with carrying in the 60s (low, btw) was playing a team with strength/tackling/confidence/Monster Hit/Power Tackler all very high, i.e. built to force fumbles?

I assume you have proof of this? How can you continue to ignore the build of the guy on the other side of the interaction?

 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Forgive the math here....

There are 279 leagues with 32 teams in each league for a total of 8928 games played each week.

Let's say there is a 2% chance to force a fumble during a run between even teams (we know it's higher in blowouts, so let's assume all of these teams are even).

Now, let's say there are 30 runs in an average game by one team.

The chance of fumbling 5 times is somewhere around 10% (if my math is right).

This means, given amost 9000 sims every week there are roughly 900 games a week in which one team fumbles more than 5 times! And this is only with a 2% chance to force a fumble every game.

Statistics are a bitch!
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
I should read before posting.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 09:04:49
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock
How can you continue to ignore the build of the guy on the other side of the interaction?

I'm talking about when they play the same defense, so that variable is constant.

Moreover, I'm mystified that anyone would be so stupid as to claim that nothing in the sim changed considering that this is suddenly dramatically different than last season. Do you really mean to tell me that builds changed that much in one off-season? You know that you're wrong, so please just shut up and stop trying to argue because you're embarrassed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.