User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Since the testers presumably have an unfair advantage due to advanced knowledge of a game that was built and stayed balanced by releasing very little information on how to build players there is only one solution to this and that is to go back to the way GLB was prior to the testers. The simplest way to do this is to randomly change the attributes names and not reveal them to us, so that catching might become punting, and agility might become blocking, throwing could become speed, etc. This way we go back to the dark ages of GLB when everyone is equally confused how to build the game. It's the only fair way.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
Since the testers presumably have an unfair advantage due to advanced knowledge of a game that was built and stayed balanced by releasing very little information on how to build players there is only one solution to this and that is to go back to the way GLB was prior to the testers. The simplest way to do this is to randomly change the attributes names and not reveal them to us, so that catching might become punting, and agility might become blocking, throwing could become speed, etc. This way we go back to the dark ages of GLB when everyone is equally confused how to build the game. It's the only fair way.


never going to happen... sims needs to keep moving forward. Hopefully we'll just have more transparency in the future as Bort basically screwed over the general users for another season. We can only hope for better in the future....
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Forethought by Bort would solve the better majority of these issues. The game has just recently made an attempt to inform users on how things evolve with the game with changelogs and whatnot. I don't think many guys are truly against a test server, but honestly... Having player agents, owners and GMs who can test essentially whatever they like, this is what I understand the test servers were and I could be wrong... But if in fact these guys were allowed to test anything with builds/tactics/etc... It's a painfully dense decision by Bort. Does Bort think he's got some kind of grasp on how people behave and knows these people will be uniformly honest and stand-up citizens? This game is a competition. Anybody who takes time to win games will take a peek at ways they can capitalize on such an easy advantage.

You know, for a fact, Bort intentionally overlooked this fact.

As a user who honestly has a lot of respect for Bort the programmer but very little respect for Bort the critical thinker, this is sincerely a new low point for Bort & Co. It's comical to me. I mean really, is Bort the guy who watches America's Funniest Home Videos and doesn't realize when there's a clip with a dad with a baseball and a little son holding a baseball bat that the dad is about to get a crotch full of baseball? You aren't that dumb Bort. Come on dude. what are you doing? Explain your logic. Humor us. You ain't anybody special but a dork with an idea and a computer. You aren't above explanations. If you cheat on your girlfriend, do you update your blog's changelog and say "02/14/09: I found some new booty, takes effect after rollover."

It's a simple question. Why did you proceed with a test server with live server users? Just don't care? Didn't think about it? Figured nobody would find out? Too lazy take the 29 minutes necessary to find 30 guys who'd do it without playing GLB on the live server?
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 21:41:54
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali


It's a simple question. Why did you proceed with a test server with live server users? Just don't care? Didn't think about it? Figured nobody would find out? Too lazy take the 29 minutes necessary to find 30 guys who'd do it without playing GLB on the live server?


Great questions. Don't worry though, they will never be answered. Instead we will get some bullshit pseudo-appeasement of a "tester's blog." As if that somehow addresses any of the issues we have been going on for days with...

Seriously, GLB staff. Wake the fuck up.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Agreed, thebigcali.

A lot of mistakes have been made with this game cannot be corrected, like releasing this game into "Beta" after a very shoddy 2 months of "alpha" testing.
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Still going, huh?


Should of not locked the main thread last night IMO> Seems Bort said enough is enough. Pissed me off even more. This GLB thing seems to be run in Russia or North Korea
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
Forethought by Bort would solve the better majority of these issues. The game has just recently made an attempt to inform users on how things evolve with the game with changelogs and whatnot. I don't think many guys are truly against a test server, but honestly... Having player agents, owners and GMs who can test essentially whatever they like, this is what I understand the test servers were and I could be wrong... But if in fact these guys were allowed to test anything with builds/tactics/etc... It's a painfully dense decision by Bort. Does Bort think he's got some kind of grasp on how people behave and knows these people will be uniformly honest and stand-up citizens? This game is a competition. Anybody who takes time to win games will take a peek at ways they can capitalize on such an easy advantage.

You know, for a fact, Bort intentionally overlooked this fact.

As a user who honestly has a lot of respect for Bort the programmer but very little respect for Bort the critical thinker, this is sincerely a new low point for Bort & Co. It's comical to me. I mean really, is Bort the guy who watches America's Funniest Home Videos and doesn't realize when there's a clip with a dad with a baseball and a little son holding a baseball bat that the dad is about to get a crotch full of baseball? You aren't that dumb Bort. Come on dude. what are you doing? Explain your logic. Humor us. You ain't anybody special but a dork with an idea and a computer. You aren't above explanations. If you cheat on your girlfriend, do you update your blog's changelog and say "02/14/09: I found some new booty, takes effect after rollover."

It's a simple question. Why did you proceed with a test server with live server users? Just don't care? Didn't think about it? Figured nobody would find out? Too lazy take the 29 minutes necessary to find 30 guys who'd do it without playing GLB on the live server?


Similar to my thoughts from last night. Some disclosure and an apology are needed yet we don't hear a thing.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
I've said it before: Bort is obviously a smart guy but he makes some really bad business decisions. The fact that he gave some users access to some tools that gave them a massive advantage over others without putting in some controls or providing full disclosure was a big one.

Since he can't undo that, he now needs to be doing damage control. That means not just providing a solution moving forward, as he has done, but realizing that his customer base is upset and angry and apologizing to them, not treating them like dirt and either condoning or instructing his mods to crush any discussion of the matter.

Bort - be a man (and a businessman) and admit to your customer base that you handled this badly and you apologize. Disclose why you did things that way and disclose how testers were chosen (I for one, am very interested in that. From purely a personal standpoint, I have played this game from the early days of "beta" and have made several suggestions that have been implemented in both the sim mechanics and that have become major features of the game. If a contributor like me was not approached to test, who were these people and what criteria did you use?)


 
Link
 
No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Challenge Everything
No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.


Non-paying customer / Non-Booster. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-owner. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-GM. You get the idea
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 22:53:57
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Challenge Everything
No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
Originally posted by Challenge Everything
No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.
Non-paying customer / Non-Booster. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-owner. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-GM. You get the idea

I can laugh at this post because you obviously did not look at my profile. If your post was not in reference to me, fine, but if it was... lol

And, if someone who pays into the game is somehow seen as more important with his/her opinions... I cannot find the right words at this hour... but that is a pretty arrogant belief to hold. I hope you are above that belief.
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 23:16:15
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Challenge Everything
No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.


First off, not outside users, secondly if a tester found something that gave them an advantage do you think they wouldnt use it because they DONT "have little to live for"...

Heres the main problem with this...

One point your missing is that if this is supposed to be a beta game then we are all supposed to be testers. The fact that there was secret testing going on by only certain users undermines the equality of all GLB users who have been paying to be "testers".

Having secret testing that is only available to some users basically means that the beta tag this game has been hiding behind for the last few months is literally bullshit. For me, thats the biggest problem.

 
iiiPOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Challenge Everything
Originally posted by thebigcali

Originally posted by Challenge Everything

No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.
Non-paying customer / Non-Booster. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-owner. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-GM. You get the idea

I can laugh at this post because you obviously did not look at my profile. If your post was not in reference to me, fine, but if it was... lol

And, if someone who pays into the game is somehow seen as more important with his/her opinions... I cannot find the right words at this hour... but that is a pretty arrogant belief to hold. I hope you are above that belief.


Wow. Staying true to you user name
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Termsofuse
Originally posted by Challenge Everything

Originally posted by thebigcali


Originally posted by Challenge Everything


No apology necessary needed for me. I think it is pretty comical at all of the hubbub that has been going on. I applaud Bort for trying to make his game better by giving outside users, not him running all of the scripts, some additional information to help him out. If those individuals need that information and "abuse" that information to win the shiny trophy icons, well, they have very little to live for as is. The stress level of some GLB players over this is pretty immature and does not need to even be escalated.

I also would like to applaud the Mods for cleaning up the forums today as the past couple of days have been an unbearable mess. Thank you.
Non-paying customer / Non-Booster. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-owner. Opinion taken less seriously.

Non-GM. You get the idea

I can laugh at this post because you obviously did not look at my profile. If your post was not in reference to me, fine, but if it was... lol

And, if someone who pays into the game is somehow seen as more important with his/her opinions... I cannot find the right words at this hour... but that is a pretty arrogant belief to hold. I hope you are above that belief.


Wow. Staying true to you user name


Not really, seems like he's firm on "The Man's" side of the line
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.