User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth


And as for the "they know how to make good builds where we don't" crap... So flawed. There have been dozens of great build advice threads out there, and we still see very terrible builds. It doesn't matter if you TELL people EXACTLY how to build good players, they will still build crappy players. It's unavoidable, look at the Marketplace. At least half the players are unusable on good teams.


Totally disagree. What you see is just natural selection. The stupid get weeded out. Well that and until very recently around here communication was miserable.

If I were a tester and I knew what the best build was, I wouldn't stray far from it, tbh.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Byrney
Originally posted by Boltz


WHERES BORT, LIKE WHERES WALDO LOL


[ ] LOL


[X] JAIL BOLTZ
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by TxSteve


nowhere did i see tpat or anyone else post that they only tested 'extreme' builds - they can test 60 carrying vs 20; they can test 20 confidence vs 80; they can test 120 agility vs 90...etc etc etc


It was in the first... 10 pages... But, I'm still on Page 14, so I have a long way to go.

I want Bort to come in and clear this all up, tell us exactly what's going on and what advantage it offers, but... I don't know, I'm not really outraged by this. We all knew there was a test server, Bort has spoken about it on many occasions. That said, I think most people are ****ed because they made the assumption that the server allows them to have a clear and decided advantage, and nothing any of the mods have said lead me to believe that's the case. Most mods have seemed unusually upfront about all this... Again, only up to P14, but still.

And as for the "they know how to make good builds where we don't" crap... So flawed. There have been dozens of great build advice threads out there, and we still see very terrible builds. It doesn't matter if you TELL people EXACTLY how to build good players, they will still build crappy players. It's unavoidable, look at the Marketplace. At least half the players are unusable on good teams.


I think most people are worried that by being able to test 60 vision vs. 20 vision, the testers can figure out that vision is going to be super important for WRs or HBs or OTs in this years sim before anyone else.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti


Option 3 - Choose a bunch of testers from the site but forbid them from playing the game anymore. Well we Absolutely get no added compensation for being a tester so there would be no point in tsting for a game you can no longer play, not because of the advantage it gives you but because the game wouldn't pertain to you any more at all. Who would want to test a game they can't play for no compensation of any kind? Also we all love GLB or we wouldn't play it in the first place, so it would be pretty cruel to ask us to give that up for the sake of testing.



Why not rotate the testers on a season by season basis? If you are testing, you don't play...
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 16:13:24
 
Link
 
... This is like the steroid scandal in baseball, right?

Seriously, what the fuck is going on?
 
daysend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kost0121
Originally posted by quzur

Mods do flock to teams together. Interesting how their teams always do very well. they are clever.


Interesting, good players wanting to play with other good players. I think the Patriots did the same thing, they got some inside information about the new rules in the upcoming season and got together and figured out how to best exploit the new rules.


You mean like filming the opposing teams calls/practices?
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNoobAvenger
... This is like the steroid scandal in baseball, right?

Seriously, what the fuck is going on?


SCANDAL YES
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Grim Truth



And as for the "they know how to make good builds where we don't" crap... So flawed. There have been dozens of great build advice threads out there, and we still see very terrible builds. It doesn't matter if you TELL people EXACTLY how to build good players, they will still build crappy players. It's unavoidable, look at the Marketplace. At least half the players are unusable on good teams.


Totally disagree. What you see is just natural selection. The stupid get weeded out. Well that and until very recently around here communication was miserable.

If I were a tester and I knew what the best build was, I wouldn't stray far from it, tbh.



they know how to make good builds....in their very own players - quit looking at it in the sense of teams....they can make their very own players very good....

which - when next to someone else's comment about tpat finding teams for his players....but refusing to open the builds.....

seems to support
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Iceman16
What do you not understand about the fact that your two sentences are not bound to each other. GLB is a breeding ground for it, but you have to be one of the most ignorant posters I've ever encountered on the site.

okay, let's be serious for a moment, because i think this is the crux of the confusion.
i think the only reason why you think those two sentences aren't "bound to each other" is because you don't understand what i mean by them... and i'll admit they're clumsily phrased. so let me try again...
i'm saying that even if the testers did glean crucial information from the test servers, that doesn't automatically mean that their teams are going to dominate. why? because their teams are filled with existing players with existing builds... and at the upper levels, there's only so much you can do to adjust a build.
in other words, it doesn't work to claim that the test server was no advantage solely on the basis that testers' teams didn't always dominate. again, even with complete insider information, they still have to deal with other people's builds/etc on their actual teams in the actual game.
if i'm still losing you, let me know and i'll try again.

Not losing me. That statement actually makes perfect sense.


okay... but it's not far from my original phrasing:Originally posted by Catullus 16
whether or not the testers were able to translate their insider information into success is irrelevant. even with complete information, you still have to deal with other people's builds/etc.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2067898&page=34#17251267

...which is why i remain confused that you were confused (let alone so violently claiming that i was "wrong"). but whatever. if we encounter each other again (like on remaxjon's forum), let's just remember that it's unlikely that one of us suddenly dropped 100 points in IQ -- rather, there's likely just been a miscommunication. at a minimum, let's note that invective always makes "discussions" worse.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MightyPoopster
Originally posted by tpaterniti



Option 3 - Choose a bunch of testers from the site but forbid them from playing the game anymore. Well we Absolutely get no added compensation for being a tester so there would be no point in tsting for a game you can no longer play, not because of the advantage it gives you but because the game wouldn't pertain to you any more at all. Who would want to test a game they can't play for no compensation of any kind? Also we all love GLB or we wouldn't play it in the first place, so it would be pretty cruel to ask us to give that up for the sake of testing.



Why not rotate the testers on a season by season basis? If you are testing, you don't play...


There ya go.. BRILLIANT
 
Link
 
Should I.. Should I call for impeachment?
 
WalterManning
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNoobAvenger
... This is like the steroid scandal in baseball, right?

Seriously, what the fuck is going on?


They are testing to see if you would be a good tester for the testing part of the game. Are you?
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNoobAvenger
Should I.. Should I call for impeachment?


YOUD GET BANNED BUT A LEGIT SUGGESTION LOL JK
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNoobAvenger
Should I.. Should I call for impeachment?


I have a sinking feeling that somehow, this is all Barack Obama's fault.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Grim Truth




And as for the "they know how to make good builds where we don't" crap... So flawed. There have been dozens of great build advice threads out there, and we still see very terrible builds. It doesn't matter if you TELL people EXACTLY how to build good players, they will still build crappy players. It's unavoidable, look at the Marketplace. At least half the players are unusable on good teams.


Totally disagree. What you see is just natural selection. The stupid get weeded out. Well that and until very recently around here communication was miserable.

If I were a tester and I knew what the best build was, I wouldn't stray far from it, tbh.



they know how to make good builds....in their very own players - quit looking at it in the sense of teams....they can make their very own players very good....

which - when next to someone else's comment about tpat finding teams for his players....but refusing to open the builds.....

seems to support


Why do you assume these individuals don't own teams...or don't GM teams?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.