let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cactus71
let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls
I really don't expect my LB's to cover Fast WR's tbph.
let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls
I really don't expect my LB's to cover Fast WR's tbph.
Just out of curiosity how does Bob Sanders stone guys who are bigger than him? it seems there may be no right answer if Bort does it right. Some guys may take the Levon Kirkland approach, which is 300 lb MLB meeting force with force. Others take the Bob Sanders approach using speed, acceleration, and leverage, and in terms of physics it makes sense. If force is mass times acceleration you should be able to increase either one of those with the same result. Levon Kirland would be the mass approach, Bob Sanders would be the acceleration approach. But both should apply the same force on the HB. After reading this I think there should be several ways to stop this type of player. I am not sure exactly how you would program Bob Sanders into the game though, LOL. He is basically a master at applying the proper leverage. He uses his body to its max potential in that way and that is how he is able to stone guys that he is neither larger nor physically stronger than.
Also as in real life many people are answering the question behind the question or another question that wasn't rreally asked, which is how feasible it is to build such a player as GLB exists today.
One thing I notice about the build is that it is very focussed. I think that within reason an equally focussed build on defense should be able to stop him, although if it took a little more on the part of the defensive player that would be understandable simply because you design that HB to do one thing and one thing only, but you generally want a LB or S to do many things (e.g. play a zone, cover the WR in man coverage, maybe blitz, all in addition to tackling the ball carrier).
Also as in real life many people are answering the question behind the question or another question that wasn't rreally asked, which is how feasible it is to build such a player as GLB exists today.
One thing I notice about the build is that it is very focussed. I think that within reason an equally focussed build on defense should be able to stop him, although if it took a little more on the part of the defensive player that would be understandable simply because you design that HB to do one thing and one thing only, but you generally want a LB or S to do many things (e.g. play a zone, cover the WR in man coverage, maybe blitz, all in addition to tackling the ball carrier).
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:29:55
Cactus71
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Just out of curiosity how does Bob Sanders stone guys who are bigger than him? it seems there may be no right answer if Bort does it right. Some guys may take the Levon Kirkland approach, which is 300 lb MLB meeting force with force. Others take the Bob Sanders approach using speed, acceleration, and leverage, and in terms of physics it makes sense. If force is mass times acceleration you should be able to increase either one of those with the same result. Levon Kirland would be the mass approach, Bob Sanders would be the acceleration approach. But both should apply the same force on the HB. After reading this I think there should be several ways to stop this type of player. I am not sure exactly how you would program Bob Sanders into the game though, LOL. He is basically a master at applying the proper leverage. He uses his body to its max potential in that way and that is how he is able to stone guys that he is neither larger nor physically stronger than.
yea you can take things down different ways as well which is also a problem on how you would determine that
Just out of curiosity how does Bob Sanders stone guys who are bigger than him? it seems there may be no right answer if Bort does it right. Some guys may take the Levon Kirkland approach, which is 300 lb MLB meeting force with force. Others take the Bob Sanders approach using speed, acceleration, and leverage, and in terms of physics it makes sense. If force is mass times acceleration you should be able to increase either one of those with the same result. Levon Kirland would be the mass approach, Bob Sanders would be the acceleration approach. But both should apply the same force on the HB. After reading this I think there should be several ways to stop this type of player. I am not sure exactly how you would program Bob Sanders into the game though, LOL. He is basically a master at applying the proper leverage. He uses his body to its max potential in that way and that is how he is able to stone guys that he is neither larger nor physically stronger than.
yea you can take things down different ways as well which is also a problem on how you would determine that
Maddoc
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Just out of curiosity how does Bob Sanders stone guys who are bigger than him? it seems there may be no right answer if Bort does it right. Some guys may take the Levon Kirkland approach, which is 300 lb MLB meeting force with force. Others take the Bob Sanders approach using speed, acceleration, and leverage, and in terms of physics it makes sense. If force is mass times acceleration you should be able to increase either one of those with the same result. Levon Kirland would be the mass approach, Bob Sanders would be the acceleration approach. But both should apply the same force on the HB. After reading this I think there should be several ways to stop this type of player. I am not sure exactly how you would program Bob Sanders into the game though, LOL. He is basically a master at applying the proper leverage. He uses his body to its max potential in that way and that is how he is able to stone guys that he is neither larger nor physically stronger than.
That'd just be really high Tackling in-game, I would think.
Just out of curiosity how does Bob Sanders stone guys who are bigger than him? it seems there may be no right answer if Bort does it right. Some guys may take the Levon Kirkland approach, which is 300 lb MLB meeting force with force. Others take the Bob Sanders approach using speed, acceleration, and leverage, and in terms of physics it makes sense. If force is mass times acceleration you should be able to increase either one of those with the same result. Levon Kirland would be the mass approach, Bob Sanders would be the acceleration approach. But both should apply the same force on the HB. After reading this I think there should be several ways to stop this type of player. I am not sure exactly how you would program Bob Sanders into the game though, LOL. He is basically a master at applying the proper leverage. He uses his body to its max potential in that way and that is how he is able to stone guys that he is neither larger nor physically stronger than.
That'd just be really high Tackling in-game, I would think.
Gott
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
Depends what you mean by "consistently." 90% of the time?
Look at all of the max speed, low strength and tackling people trying to influence you instead of being honest. I think you'd be hard pressed to find many people with more than soft capped tackling.
I don't think speed should be part of the equation. Speed will get you to the back, but it shouldn't make you tackle better.
To consistently stop this HB, it should take a lot.
First, you should have a ton of tackling. Maybe 80+.
Second, you'd need decent strength and agility. Maybe 60+ in each.
Third, you should need some SAs and VAs to counter the back's investment in those. Sure Tackler VA, Wrap Up SA. I suggest giving a tackling bonus to SAs such as Big Hit and Monster Hit.
I also think vision should play a part in both tackling and breaking tackles. For tackling, you need to have good vision to combat that stiff arm or cut. For breaking tackles, you should have some vision to tell when to power through or stiff arm, etc. Maybe just have vision affect the triggering of tackling and breaking tackles SAs.
Also, you really need to improve the MLB's AI.
Wrap up tackling should keep the current bonus to tackling, but the defender should be carried a few yards. Playing on balanced or power tackling would reduce that, greatly with the latter, but it should be greatly affected by strength and keep the negative effect of increased chance to miss the tackle.
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
Depends what you mean by "consistently." 90% of the time?
Look at all of the max speed, low strength and tackling people trying to influence you instead of being honest. I think you'd be hard pressed to find many people with more than soft capped tackling.
I don't think speed should be part of the equation. Speed will get you to the back, but it shouldn't make you tackle better.
To consistently stop this HB, it should take a lot.
First, you should have a ton of tackling. Maybe 80+.
Second, you'd need decent strength and agility. Maybe 60+ in each.
Third, you should need some SAs and VAs to counter the back's investment in those. Sure Tackler VA, Wrap Up SA. I suggest giving a tackling bonus to SAs such as Big Hit and Monster Hit.
I also think vision should play a part in both tackling and breaking tackles. For tackling, you need to have good vision to combat that stiff arm or cut. For breaking tackles, you should have some vision to tell when to power through or stiff arm, etc. Maybe just have vision affect the triggering of tackling and breaking tackles SAs.
Also, you really need to improve the MLB's AI.
Wrap up tackling should keep the current bonus to tackling, but the defender should be carried a few yards. Playing on balanced or power tackling would reduce that, greatly with the latter, but it should be greatly affected by strength and keep the negative effect of increased chance to miss the tackle.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:35:47
Well if I were to translate the two guys into GLB physically (ignoring special abilities) here is how I would do it:
Bob Sanders
Strength: 55
Speed: 80
Agility: 85
Vision: 70
Confidence: 65
Tackling: 70
Levon Kirkland
Strength: 90
Speed : 60
Agility: 70
Vision: 60
Confidence: 60
Tackling: 60
Bob Sanders
Strength: 55
Speed: 80
Agility: 85
Vision: 70
Confidence: 65
Tackling: 70
Levon Kirkland
Strength: 90
Speed : 60
Agility: 70
Vision: 60
Confidence: 60
Tackling: 60
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:35:45
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cactus71
so after the HB breaks the tackle of a linebacker it should be an automatic TD
If the LB has no help, and if the HB has a clear route to the endzone and the saftey's can't make a diving tackle, then yes that would be a TD.
so after the HB breaks the tackle of a linebacker it should be an automatic TD
If the LB has no help, and if the HB has a clear route to the endzone and the saftey's can't make a diving tackle, then yes that would be a TD.
Cactus71
offline
offline
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Originally posted by Cactus71
so after the HB breaks the tackle of a linebacker it should be an automatic TD
If the LB has no help, and if the HB has a clear route to the endzone and the saftey's can't make a diving tackle, then yes that would be a TD.
no like say the LB misses the tackle but the safety still can make it but if he needs 70 tackling and strength to do so, but he doesn't have those stats because he needs 100+ speed to cover WRs
Originally posted by Cactus71
so after the HB breaks the tackle of a linebacker it should be an automatic TD
If the LB has no help, and if the HB has a clear route to the endzone and the saftey's can't make a diving tackle, then yes that would be a TD.
no like say the LB misses the tackle but the safety still can make it but if he needs 70 tackling and strength to do so, but he doesn't have those stats because he needs 100+ speed to cover WRs
trazer
offline
offline
Runner....
str + agi + (head fake) + (juke) + (Spin) + (Lower shoulder) + (stiff arm) + (power through) + (vet break tackle stuff) = x
x+(advanced gear bonus) = Y
100+55+37= 192+8% = 207.36
Defensive player
{Str + agi + tackling (vision x .2) + (whatever supervision bonus is) x Tackle style modifier} x (Range modifier) + Wrap up SA bonus = x
t+(advanced gear bonus) = R
{[30 + 70 + 55 + (65x.2)] x 1.15(just guessing at tackle style mod)x .97} + 8 = 195.404
R/Y= Tackle %
195.404/207.36 = approx 94.2% chance
Adjust the numbers and values a tad to make them how ya want (add in whatever i forgot)
thats kinda what im thinking. I just approximated numbers..but shit like that eh?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Explaining range modifier,
I assume that being closer is easier to make a tackle.
1 foot away = easy.
3 feet away = hard (arm tackle?)
5 feet away = diving tackle. blah blah im sure bort has this kinda thing already in the game. but this is kinda what i expected it to work out to be.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just realized a problem..if the tacklers numbers are higher than its over 100% tackling..im sure there is a fix..ill think about it (obviously others can too)
str + agi + (head fake) + (juke) + (Spin) + (Lower shoulder) + (stiff arm) + (power through) + (vet break tackle stuff) = x
x+(advanced gear bonus) = Y
100+55+37= 192+8% = 207.36
Defensive player
{Str + agi + tackling (vision x .2) + (whatever supervision bonus is) x Tackle style modifier} x (Range modifier) + Wrap up SA bonus = x
t+(advanced gear bonus) = R
{[30 + 70 + 55 + (65x.2)] x 1.15(just guessing at tackle style mod)x .97} + 8 = 195.404
R/Y= Tackle %
195.404/207.36 = approx 94.2% chance
Adjust the numbers and values a tad to make them how ya want (add in whatever i forgot)
thats kinda what im thinking. I just approximated numbers..but shit like that eh?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Explaining range modifier,
I assume that being closer is easier to make a tackle.
1 foot away = easy.
3 feet away = hard (arm tackle?)
5 feet away = diving tackle. blah blah im sure bort has this kinda thing already in the game. but this is kinda what i expected it to work out to be.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just realized a problem..if the tacklers numbers are higher than its over 100% tackling..im sure there is a fix..ill think about it (obviously others can too)
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:45:46
Originally posted by Cactus71
let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls
That is part of the game and part of the fun. You can't do everything well and stop everyone. If everyone could do that the game would be no fun at all. It is hard for Americans to hear because of our "I want it all and I want it now" culture, but you have to pick and choose. You can't have it all - you take risks and build certain skills at the expense of others. It is not a weakness in the game that you are forced to do this - IT IS THE GAME.This is what creates matchups and strategy and what makes the game both realistic and fun. Sure every now and then in sports you have superstars like Lebron or Kobe or Ed Reed, but these guys tend to be 1 in 100,000 or so. Most players have strengths and weaknesses, and you try to put together a team where players at one position use their strengths to complement the weaknesses of their teammates. In fact this is the very essence of what a team is in the first place. Furthermore if everyone could make a team full of players who did everything well the game would become stale and boring. Instead of Rock Paper Scissors it would turn into Rock Rock Rock and let's see who's rock is shinier or whatever. The very basic element of games that millions of people have found the most fun over time combine elements of choice, elements of strength and weakness, and the fun is not in acquiring super piece after super piece, but in combining the flawed pieces in clever, new ways to outwit your opponent. This is true of chess, Magic the Gathering, Monopoly, any excellent and enduring game really, and if you think about it, deep down the appeal of assembling and utilized flawed elements to achieve a result greater than the sum of their parts has something profound to say about the human condition as well.
let me post this again how do expect defensive players to be able to cover 100 speed WRs and take down 100 strength HBs we can't have the skills to do both by the time they can get to those lvls
That is part of the game and part of the fun. You can't do everything well and stop everyone. If everyone could do that the game would be no fun at all. It is hard for Americans to hear because of our "I want it all and I want it now" culture, but you have to pick and choose. You can't have it all - you take risks and build certain skills at the expense of others. It is not a weakness in the game that you are forced to do this - IT IS THE GAME.This is what creates matchups and strategy and what makes the game both realistic and fun. Sure every now and then in sports you have superstars like Lebron or Kobe or Ed Reed, but these guys tend to be 1 in 100,000 or so. Most players have strengths and weaknesses, and you try to put together a team where players at one position use their strengths to complement the weaknesses of their teammates. In fact this is the very essence of what a team is in the first place. Furthermore if everyone could make a team full of players who did everything well the game would become stale and boring. Instead of Rock Paper Scissors it would turn into Rock Rock Rock and let's see who's rock is shinier or whatever. The very basic element of games that millions of people have found the most fun over time combine elements of choice, elements of strength and weakness, and the fun is not in acquiring super piece after super piece, but in combining the flawed pieces in clever, new ways to outwit your opponent. This is true of chess, Magic the Gathering, Monopoly, any excellent and enduring game really, and if you think about it, deep down the appeal of assembling and utilized flawed elements to achieve a result greater than the sum of their parts has something profound to say about the human condition as well.

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 02:47:59
trazer
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Well if I were to translate the two guys into GLB physically (ignoring special abilities) here is how I would do it:
Bob Sanders
Strength: 55
Speed: 80
Agility: 85
Vision: 70
Confidence: 65
Tackling: 70
Levon Kirkland
Strength: 90
Speed : 60
Agility: 70
Vision: 60
Confidence: 60
Tackling: 60
Lets assume these guys are using my formula above..(no SAs or %s)
Runner
90+70=160
Tackler
55+85+70= 210
210/160 = 131.25%...hhmm...ill have to rethink this a tad. Maybe an algorithm or some sliding scale to adjust the percentages a bit better. Im good at math but not a major in college or anything. Anyone?
Well if I were to translate the two guys into GLB physically (ignoring special abilities) here is how I would do it:
Bob Sanders
Strength: 55
Speed: 80
Agility: 85
Vision: 70
Confidence: 65
Tackling: 70
Levon Kirkland
Strength: 90
Speed : 60
Agility: 70
Vision: 60
Confidence: 60
Tackling: 60
Lets assume these guys are using my formula above..(no SAs or %s)
Runner
90+70=160
Tackler
55+85+70= 210
210/160 = 131.25%...hhmm...ill have to rethink this a tad. Maybe an algorithm or some sliding scale to adjust the percentages a bit better. Im good at math but not a major in college or anything. Anyone?
Originally posted by trazer
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Well if I were to translate the two guys into GLB physically (ignoring special abilities) here is how I would do it:
Bob Sanders
Strength: 55
Speed: 80
Agility: 85
Vision: 70
Confidence: 65
Tackling: 70
Levon Kirkland
Strength: 90
Speed : 60
Agility: 70
Vision: 60
Confidence: 60
Tackling: 60
Lets assume these guys are using my formula above..(no SAs or %s)
Runner
90+70=160
Tackler
55+85+70= 210
210/160 = 131.25%...hhmm...ill have to rethink this a tad. Maybe an algorithm or some sliding scale to adjust the percentages a bit better. Im good at math but not a major in college or anything. Anyone?
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I think that within reason an equally focussed build on defense should be able to stop him, although if it took a little more on the part of the defensive player that would be understandable simply because you design that HB to do one thing and one thing only, but you generally want a LB or S to do many things (e.g. play a zone, cover the WR in man coverage, maybe blitz, all in addition to tackling the ball carrier).
This.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Well if I were to translate the two guys into GLB physically (ignoring special abilities) here is how I would do it:
Bob Sanders
Strength: 55
Speed: 80
Agility: 85
Vision: 70
Confidence: 65
Tackling: 70
Levon Kirkland
Strength: 90
Speed : 60
Agility: 70
Vision: 60
Confidence: 60
Tackling: 60
Lets assume these guys are using my formula above..(no SAs or %s)
Runner
90+70=160
Tackler
55+85+70= 210
210/160 = 131.25%...hhmm...ill have to rethink this a tad. Maybe an algorithm or some sliding scale to adjust the percentages a bit better. Im good at math but not a major in college or anything. Anyone?
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I think that within reason an equally focussed build on defense should be able to stop him, although if it took a little more on the part of the defensive player that would be understandable simply because you design that HB to do one thing and one thing only, but you generally want a LB or S to do many things (e.g. play a zone, cover the WR in man coverage, maybe blitz, all in addition to tackling the ball carrier).
This.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























