User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player goes up 8 levels in 4 games and 17 levels in 13 games
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
All that needs to happen is to drastically lower the exp ceiling for K/P. It should be just a little more than other positions, but you shouldn't be able to get exp at kicker, then on top of that, 50 regular snaps.

That, and de-leveling the people that have exploited this. Without de-leveling those people, all you're doing is handing them those free levels.


So...just make the max XP (base for lv 1) 600 for K/P?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Forbin

All that needs to happen is to drastically lower the exp ceiling for K/P. It should be just a little more than other positions, but you shouldn't be able to get exp at kicker, then on top of that, 50 regular snaps.

That, and de-leveling the people that have exploited this. Without de-leveling those people, all you're doing is handing them those free levels.


So...just make the max XP (base for lv 1) 600 for K/P?


And make their minimum per game (base for level 1) 300. Kickers & punters don't need to see the field to be practicing their kicks on the sidelines, and it's annoying as hell to be in the D-leagues and see next to no action at K/P because somebody else signed on the same team as you and they were designated the 'starter'.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Forbin


All that needs to happen is to drastically lower the exp ceiling for K/P. It should be just a little more than other positions, but you shouldn't be able to get exp at kicker, then on top of that, 50 regular snaps.

That, and de-leveling the people that have exploited this. Without de-leveling those people, all you're doing is handing them those free levels.


So...just make the max XP (base for lv 1) 600 for K/P?


And make their minimum per game (base for level 1) 300. Kickers & punters don't need to see the field to be practicing their kicks on the sidelines, and it's annoying as hell to be in the D-leagues and see next to no action at K/P because somebody else signed on the same team as you and they were designated the 'starter'.


I would think it should probably be something along the lines of what islander said - 300 pts minimum, split amongst all the K's on the DC. Same for P's. Then you can't just put 20 P's on the depth chart to get them all 300 XP's every game.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I would love to be able to tell my undefeated team they can take me off special teams now because my experience is no longer killed.

Bort you can see my exp logs here. Take a wild guess which games are the ones I didn't play on special teams

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=424188
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Footballmike

meh let them play duel positions if they want.....theres a penalty already for playing out of position right?


Only for the actual skills. Not for XP gained. These guys exploiting the system dont care about losing games because theyre using it as a farm team for their "real" team. The position penalty doesnt affect them since theyre TRYING to lose to get more XP. Sheesh, they have a DT at QB and safety, etc etc. Theyre purposely losing games just to get the max XP for their players to send up to their real team. I wish the game wouldnt have come down to this, but i guess i expected it. I remember the old Madden online pull the plug glitch. I just cant imagine getting so much joy for "winning" a game in that fashion, i dunno
 
czman
offline
Link
 
I really think this game needs a MAX/MIN xp per game that is directly tide to the players level. Therefore, if you do not punt in a game the punter still gets some XP and if you punt 100 times he is capped at the amount of XP he can obtain.

Maybe all players/postions need this.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
I really think this game needs a MAX/MIN xp per game that is directly tide to the players level. Therefore, if you do not punt in a game the punter still gets some XP and if you punt 100 times he is capped at the amount of XP he can obtain.

Maybe all players/postions need this.


well there is a max xp already, not sure about a min xp
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


The current cap is around 550ish for lv 1, so a cap around the same amount for "extra XP" gained by kicking and punting would seem to make sense, and is quite easy to put in.

The thing I'm worried about is the minimum suggestion - definitely would have to have a split time factor or something to address the farming problem it would create.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


unrealistic.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Robbnva

being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


unrealistic.


so is every other MMORPG
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


The current cap is around 550ish for lv 1, so a cap around the same amount for "extra XP" gained by kicking and punting would seem to make sense, and is quite easy to put in.

The thing I'm worried about is the minimum suggestion - definitely would have to have a split time factor or something to address the farming problem it would create.


I'm confused here Bort. What am I missing?

There should be no minimum. There should be only maximum exp. The equivalent exp a normal player would get for maximum snaps (effectively speaking).

Let's say for level 10, that value is 400.
One punter punts the whole game - he gets 400 exp. # of punts regardless.
If two placekickers each take turns kicking, they each get 200 exp. The maximum divided by 2.

Really, we should only see multiple kickers/punters on D league teams anyway, right?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Robbnva


being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


unrealistic.


so is every other MMORPG


This is based off a legitimate sport though.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Robbnva

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Robbnva



being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


unrealistic.


so is every other MMORPG


This is based off a legitimate sport though.


but it is also a game is it not? I own a team because I spent my own money to buy FPs. If I want a punter as a gunner I should be able to do so without any xp penalty.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Robbnva


Originally posted by islander1



Originally posted by Robbnva




being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


unrealistic.


so is every other MMORPG


This is based off a legitimate sport though.


but it is also a game is it not? I own a team because I spent my own money to buy FPs. If I want a punter as a gunner I should be able to do so without any xp penalty.


No. A punter is a punter. He kicks footballs. Allowing punters or placekickers to dip into two different exp pools is completely unfair. The only reason its tolerable now is because the kicker/punter exp assignment is broken, and has been since the game began.

Let's say the max exp fix is put in. What happens next? Wide receivers double as punters, get their one punt in, and gain max experience for that too?

Wrong.

If you want your wimpy punter to be a gunner, go right ahead. But make no mistake, he's a punter and that punter/kicker exp pool is the only one he gains from.

Last edited Aug 28, 2008 12:51:12
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.