User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > League fix for player disparity
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Ok, I've absorbed a lot more with the last few replies.

Here are some more thoughts/questions from me.

1. Actually, I like the idea of CPU owned teams (to prevent gutting/ruin). It would be awesome to have the Pro Elite Leagues all then CPU owned only. So the teams themselves, generically named, cannot ever be gutted or relegated OUT of Elite League (ie, NFL). They only relegate in the sense of relegating if there were like 8 leagues of Pro Level Region. So a team called San Jose Spartans that is default named that, always remains in the Elite level whether it's AAA or AA or A. But it cannot fall OUTSIDE the elite level to the arena level. Meanwhile, all other arena and minor league and high school etc teams CAN be owned by people. If this was the idea then Id actually be all for it. It's basically turning the concept of a D-League away from being about noob level 1s, and calling it Elite-League and having all those CPU owned teams filled with level 20+ players, run by human GMs. Never can a team be gutted or ruined somehow.

2. I still am not understanding how the leagues are broken up, by players' levels or age in seasons? If I have a level 27 player that is 4 seasons old, and I have a player that's level 18 and 4 seasons old, which thing is making the player become College-Eligible? Does the level 27-4 player or level 18-4 player become college-eligible? Or do both because of their age in seasons? I ask because a level 18 player entering college-eligibility and being signed would mean you can still end up with whole teams of level 18-20 players 4 seasons old playing against level 27-33 players who are also 4 seasons old....and therefore that disparity happening again, 100-0 scores. Why it's tricky is because if you say, ok, make it levels only, then you get that gray area of 3 levels between boosters and non-boosters. Also, you get players whittling away as back-ups falling behind the level rise of starters. So you could still end up with level 27 players beating up on level 23 players because some people decided not to boost anymore and/or are not getting enough snaps that they dont level up faster.

3. So, if you make it seasons only, then you run into the same problems of that 3+ level disparity occuring between people who do and dont boost.

4. The only other aspect that Bort would also worry about is the idea of minimizing boosting to like 1 boost per season or something.

5. Another thing that would be awesome, tho Bort wont like it, is if you have that whole Pro, Arena, College, HS set up, you COULD implement a draft process when players reach eligibility. But that's another heated debate left for another thread.

I had another question or something, but forgot what it was just now. I'll post it when i remember.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 22:21:34
 
donkeycondon
offline
Link
 
um i can sit in a deerstand all week for 12 hours a day alone and im a math wiz but this is to long for me to understand your point.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
On CPU owned pro league teams. The odds are there'll be like thousands of pro-eligible players, enough to fill about 10 or more leagues of 32 teams split into 2 conferences. So you'd have to have more than 32 pro-teams. More like 300+.

Actually, here's a better analogy. Currently, there's Pro-League USA, SEA, OCEANIA, CANADA, AFRICA, EU, WU, SA. Eight all up. What you could do is have 8 regions called Pro League as they are, all have 32 teams each, and you can make them all CPU owned, with Bort creating their own names. USA would have LA, Chicago etc. WE would have London, etc. The city and nickname are created by Bort and set that way, cant be changed. GMs are all human. Now, the thing is, those teams cannot ever get relegated OUT of their Pro-League status. They dont fall to Arena League or Minor League. So that maintains that consistency. You're playing for or GMing an established franchise, and all these pro-franchises have the same financial situations at the start, follow the same salary rules and stadium costs etc, so teams cannot ever gut them or ruin them without consequences or parameters. THey have to run them legit.

So that could work imo. Then you just have Arena League all human owned, which can be ruined and gutted, can get into financial strife, can be relegated thru the current AAA#1, AA#5, etc type structure. Same with Minor League. Same with College and High School. You could still have the D-league there under all this for level 1-4 players. Or you could replace D-league with the High School structure.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
To answer one of your questions, league levels are broken up by player age in seasons. You're right, we'd have something of the same issues surrounding the whole thing, but basically, once you reach the 'top' and aren't Pro caliber, or for whatever reason (salary hold-out too long and get snubbed by GMs) don't get signed to a Pro team, there's the Minors and Arena leagues to go through. Once you progress a bit more, you may draw the attention of a Pro scout and get on board a team at some point in time - or you may never reach that pinnacle with your player.

It would make a reason for boosting other than simply doing so because if you don't you suck compared to players around you created at the same time who's agents DO boost - you probably will not reach the Pros if you don't boost.

Hell, even a booster who doesn't build a stellar player wouldn't make it to the Pros in all reality with this system. They are literally the best of the best, because there are so few positions available, GMs would HAVE to look for the cream of the crop for each and every signing, and make smart trades at that level. Simply selling a player for cash is gonna be a tough decision, because you may not find another one of that superb quality just waiting around to be picked up in the Arena League. The team management system is basically becoming more of a management system and not just "Ok, you're the GM of Offense" and "all right you do the Defense" and "I'll handle recruitings" - it would be something extremely more important than it is now, because at that level, the people running the teams in each of their respective areas would ALSO be the cream of the crop as far as management, team tactics/playbook creation, financial adviser prowess, etc...everything about the Pro level would be superhuman, and to compete, you'd HAVE to stay superhuman.

High School? Well...they just muck around in the mud and get their fundamentals down...anyone could plausibly win on any given day with absolutely no game plan at all...

College? Takes more talent to win than game planning, but here game planning would come more into play, due to the GMs, Coaches, etc being better suited for those jobs, rather than 'cutting their teeth' at the H.S. level, so to speak...

I feel like I'm making no sense anymore and reaching a bit on things...so I'm gonna let this be debated without my input for a while to get some fresh perspectives...
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
How about...make enough Arena and Minor League teams and leagues to suffice about 75% of the amount of players projected to be coming out of College at any given season, so that there's 15% of them probably going to the "official" Pro teams, 75% of them heading through the Arena and Minors, and 10% who just don't have what it takes to play at that level.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 23:39:39
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I will be back tomorrow. I've bookmarked this page in case it is covered in shit. Thanks for awesome sugggestion and the subsequent quality ideas....you guys are the definition of quality ideas that will not die, I thought this forum was dead with repeats and never gonna happens.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I understand the great plusses to having the pro, arena, minor, college, and hs structures in place, and doing so based on seasons. It's just eligibility, doesnt guarantee a non-booster a place in the elite Pro's. And really, the GMs there wont sign a bunch of level 20 4 season old players if they find their team getting smacked around, so only the best will ultimately end up in the elite pro level and there should end up far less 100-0 scores. so in that sense, THO there will be a loophole where teams can end up being all level 18, they wont! so yeah, i like the idea. tho i still also like my 200 idea too.

anyway, the idea i really love too the more i think about it is the cpu owned elite leagues. basically creating 8 regions of pro-league (like we have now), just they're all cpu owned, humans gm it, and they are established franchises that NEVER relegate OUT of pro-league status, and the GMs have a responsibility to run them all legit. That's a really great idea imo. I would hope people get back on that bandwagon.

but people dont need to worry/complain, because all existing teams right thru GLB from pro-league down to BBB will end up remaining human owned as is. It's just they now become different. The current pro-league and AAA human owned teams all become Arena league teams and minor pro league teams. All AA and A become college. All BBB, BB and B teams become high school.

The only downside to all this is that a lot of people may not want to own these teams anymore knowing they're level/season capped leagues/teams. Only able to sign level 1-4 players. etc. And a sense that people cannot anymore own their own teams and just fill them up with their own players and spend however much money they want on their players. For instance, me. My MASH team is all my own players and really i wanna keep it that way in the long-term. So as i have a bunch of level 20's and level 1 players then i cannot ever bring them into the one team and truly own my own team for my own players and spend money how i want to spend.

I would get 'screwed' in that whole idea. However, i still think your whole idea has a lot of merit. if nothing else gets approved, one thing i DO love is the cpu owned elite league idea. You dont even have to have the whole arena and college thing. Just that cpu owned elite league NEWLY created to live above the current pro-leagues, and all current leagues and teams just remain as they are, being relegated promoted, gutting, one-man teams like me existing, etc etc....but still somehow find a way to solve the 100-0 disparities in player builds.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
I will be back tomorrow. I've bookmarked this page in case it is covered in shit. Thanks for awesome sugggestion and the subsequent quality ideas....you guys are the definition of quality ideas that will not die, I thought this forum was dead with repeats and never gonna happens.


Love your work too. Thanks for the think-tank you and turnerhero and many others out there provide.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
bumpinit
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
and again...
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
has everything that CAN be said been said? I'm sure that's not the case...anybody else have any thoughts on this? Does it suck harder than Britney Spears tryin to score a rock? Is it so awesome Christina Aguilera would explode into spontaneous combustion upon seeing it? Add comments here
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
one more bump then I let this one die apparently.
 
AD_SoDope
offline
Link
 
IDK, I kind of like the current system. Well, I think It's a good idea at least. This system got me. When I first started playing this game, I wasn't planning on spending any money, ever. Well, they hooked me with this system...
Sorry Turner, I didn't read your post because I think they have a great system already in place to hook players and reel em' in.

In other words, Bump because it looks like you've put a lot of thought into this.
Last edited Aug 24, 2008 12:54:56
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
another bump, just cause I see a clone idea in the suggestions area right now
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
bump - as I saw something similar being wanted recently, and I've not heard a flat-out "NO!" from an Admin or Bort yet...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.