Ok, I've absorbed a lot more with the last few replies.
Here are some more thoughts/questions from me.
1. Actually, I like the idea of CPU owned teams (to prevent gutting/ruin). It would be awesome to have the Pro Elite Leagues all then CPU owned only. So the teams themselves, generically named, cannot ever be gutted or relegated OUT of Elite League (ie, NFL). They only relegate in the sense of relegating if there were like 8 leagues of Pro Level Region. So a team called San Jose Spartans that is default named that, always remains in the Elite level whether it's AAA or AA or A. But it cannot fall OUTSIDE the elite level to the arena level. Meanwhile, all other arena and minor league and high school etc teams CAN be owned by people. If this was the idea then Id actually be all for it. It's basically turning the concept of a D-League away from being about noob level 1s, and calling it Elite-League and having all those CPU owned teams filled with level 20+ players, run by human GMs. Never can a team be gutted or ruined somehow.
2. I still am not understanding how the leagues are broken up, by players' levels or age in seasons? If I have a level 27 player that is 4 seasons old, and I have a player that's level 18 and 4 seasons old, which thing is making the player become College-Eligible? Does the level 27-4 player or level 18-4 player become college-eligible? Or do both because of their age in seasons? I ask because a level 18 player entering college-eligibility and being signed would mean you can still end up with whole teams of level 18-20 players 4 seasons old playing against level 27-33 players who are also 4 seasons old....and therefore that disparity happening again, 100-0 scores. Why it's tricky is because if you say, ok, make it levels only, then you get that gray area of 3 levels between boosters and non-boosters. Also, you get players whittling away as back-ups falling behind the level rise of starters. So you could still end up with level 27 players beating up on level 23 players because some people decided not to boost anymore and/or are not getting enough snaps that they dont level up faster.
3. So, if you make it seasons only, then you run into the same problems of that 3+ level disparity occuring between people who do and dont boost.
4. The only other aspect that Bort would also worry about is the idea of minimizing boosting to like 1 boost per season or something.
5. Another thing that would be awesome, tho Bort wont like it, is if you have that whole Pro, Arena, College, HS set up, you COULD implement a draft process when players reach eligibility. But that's another heated debate left for another thread.
I had another question or something, but forgot what it was just now. I'll post it when i remember.
Here are some more thoughts/questions from me.
1. Actually, I like the idea of CPU owned teams (to prevent gutting/ruin). It would be awesome to have the Pro Elite Leagues all then CPU owned only. So the teams themselves, generically named, cannot ever be gutted or relegated OUT of Elite League (ie, NFL). They only relegate in the sense of relegating if there were like 8 leagues of Pro Level Region. So a team called San Jose Spartans that is default named that, always remains in the Elite level whether it's AAA or AA or A. But it cannot fall OUTSIDE the elite level to the arena level. Meanwhile, all other arena and minor league and high school etc teams CAN be owned by people. If this was the idea then Id actually be all for it. It's basically turning the concept of a D-League away from being about noob level 1s, and calling it Elite-League and having all those CPU owned teams filled with level 20+ players, run by human GMs. Never can a team be gutted or ruined somehow.
2. I still am not understanding how the leagues are broken up, by players' levels or age in seasons? If I have a level 27 player that is 4 seasons old, and I have a player that's level 18 and 4 seasons old, which thing is making the player become College-Eligible? Does the level 27-4 player or level 18-4 player become college-eligible? Or do both because of their age in seasons? I ask because a level 18 player entering college-eligibility and being signed would mean you can still end up with whole teams of level 18-20 players 4 seasons old playing against level 27-33 players who are also 4 seasons old....and therefore that disparity happening again, 100-0 scores. Why it's tricky is because if you say, ok, make it levels only, then you get that gray area of 3 levels between boosters and non-boosters. Also, you get players whittling away as back-ups falling behind the level rise of starters. So you could still end up with level 27 players beating up on level 23 players because some people decided not to boost anymore and/or are not getting enough snaps that they dont level up faster.
3. So, if you make it seasons only, then you run into the same problems of that 3+ level disparity occuring between people who do and dont boost.
4. The only other aspect that Bort would also worry about is the idea of minimizing boosting to like 1 boost per season or something.
5. Another thing that would be awesome, tho Bort wont like it, is if you have that whole Pro, Arena, College, HS set up, you COULD implement a draft process when players reach eligibility. But that's another heated debate left for another thread.
I had another question or something, but forgot what it was just now. I'll post it when i remember.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 22:21:34






























