Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Ken1
Much of what you said, I agree at least somewhat with.
I don't think it's hard enough to play tight coverage (in terms of staying with the man). It should really take a super DB to consistently play tight coverage successfully on a decent WR. If tight coverage were difficult enough to play now, then when it did work the tip rate could be increased to some level intermediate between the superhuman levels of the past and the low levels of now.
As long as tight coverage works as well as now, the tip rate can't be increased at all, as passing stats remain lower than real life (and even with some actual bugs in coverage that inflate them). Also, the tip rate should not go up at all when going for the interception, even once it's harder to maintain tight coverage.
When tight coverage is risky enough that in most situations it's smarter to play either medium or zone, then it's fine to increase tips when not going for the interception (although never back to as high as they were; WR's vistually never used to win ball fights).
Just do me a favor and try the following:
- take two good teams (preferrably with good builds - WRs with agility at 50)
- count the pass plays where no WR can get separation (not just the one thrown at, but anyone able to catch the pass)
I'd bet, you come up with like 20-30%. Some guys are covered, but others open. Of course, that increases by the number of WRs and the defensive play called might change that too (if defense puts double coverage on the WRs, the offense shouldn't get a succesful passing play too often; on the other hand a run should show great results).
Part of the problem are WRs focussing on speed mostly in the past. It just takes time to get agility and route run up to significant levels (just like it should be). Most guys worked their catching and jumping up due to the higher number in drops at beginning of season 4. So how many WRs got equal or even more agility than speed yet?
Don't you believe that it's similar with CB's, though? How many of them got their agility up close to their speed, given that they've needed to increase tackling (and jumping)?
Originally posted by RAPB
Now IF you let those "broken builds" work just as you like it to be in the long run... why would those guys change their builds? A 70 speed, 40 agility WR should suck at all routes. He's a guy build to get his chances on go-routes and teams need to call the long pass to play him effectivly.
IF the cover corner is more agile, perhaps...although even lesser WR's should sometimes beat better CB's. They know where they're going, and the CB doesn't.
Originally posted by RAPB
I sure agree with your idea of getting reasonable averages. But making the game more realistic is more imporant i.m.h.o. So that higher passing averages should be earned by more realistic WR builds - not just by presents to unreasonable builds.
Well, passing averages are still lower than real life, and maybe, given your arguments, they should remain as low as they are at this point. I strongly feel they shouldn't be lower, though.
Originally posted by RAPB
WRs need to get separation from the defenders (not much and not all the time). Just a step ahead of the defender on a route and a pass thrown to be picked up without slowing down is enough to make a successfull pass play (mostly I see WRs slow down to make the catch; that's not like it should work on a good pass play either).
And most important: the CB owners need to have fun too. It's just frustrating to see your guy letting the WR slip quite a bit on lot of plays (that's how it should be) and then you finally shut him down perfectly the other plays... and he still catches all the time.
There's one thing you're missing, and that is that, just as there can't be only one form of tackling that's best (Wrap-Up, which is still too good compared to other types; that might at this point mean helping Balanced tackling out as opposed to nerfing Wrap-Up further-- although I'd do a bit of that too, in that Wrap-Up should all but eliminate the chance of a fumble), there can't be one form of coverage (Tight man-to-man) that dominates.
Most CB's in most cases should be forced into Medium coverage and most teams should have to play a fair amount of zone.
I do put realistic outcomes first, whereas you put realistic means first; but we'd both like to see realistic outcomes achieved by realistic means, ideally.
Few CB's can get away with tight man to man all the time in real life, and they shouldn't in GLB, either. Few teams can play man all game or almost all game in real life consistently. The same should be true in GLB.
It also was dispiriting with the WR's I had in previous seasons that in one on one coverage they'd go up against the WR and almost always lose the ball fight. There needs to be room for possession WR's, such that in a ball fight a receiver with the possession stats like Catching, Vision, and Jumping should, even while well covered (as he won't have the speed or agility of a typical CB), often come down with the ball even when blanketed, at least if one on one.
My one last comment is that averages still aren't equal to real life; they're still lower. I'm willing to accept that that difference might be due to build issues. But certainly a bigger difference wouldn't be reasonable.