User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
scarletmbb
offline
Link
 
Wow...thank you guys for uncovering this. This changes a lot of things. It is kind of sucky that no one said a word about it when we were all running around worrying about stamina. It would have been nice if someone had stepped in a little earlier to enlighten us, haha.

It's no wonder the 60/0 strategy worked, it never did make sense to me because it's completely counterintuitive and backwards. Probably should see what a 0/0 strategy gives you, haha. But if your energy never drops below 70, it's not gonna hurt you that much to totally drain players.

A huge remedy to this situation would be to let energy drop all the way and have a danger zone where if they hit it (like an energy of 20 or so), they become inactive for the rest of the game(basically like fainting) and will end the game with that energy. Add injuries on top of this and it would make more sense and reward teams that have depth.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 00:16:16
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarletmbb
Wow...thank you guys for uncovering this. This changes a lot of things. It is kind of sucky that no one said a word about it when we were all running around worrying about stamina. It would have been nice if someone had stepped in a little earlier to enlighten us, haha.

It's no wonder the 60/0 strategy worked, it never did make sense to me because it's completely counterintuitive and backwards. Probably should see what a 0/0 strategy gives you, haha. But if your energy never drops below 70, it's not gonna hurt you that much to totally drain players.

A huge remedy to this situation would be to let energy drop all the way and have a danger zone where if they hit it (like an energy of 20 or so), they become inactive for the rest of the game(basically like fainting) and will end the game with that energy. Add injuries on top of this and it would make more sense and reward teams that have depth.


Thats not true, you didn't quite get it right. A player can go all the way to 0 stamina in a game, it's post game where he can only lose 30 or so of his stamina coming into the game.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I think 10% energy should equal 10% effectiveness. The fact that it doesn't explains a LOT.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 00:21:38
 
scarletmbb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54

Thats not true, you didn't quite get it right. A player can go all the way to 0 stamina in a game, it's post game where he can only lose 30 or so of his stamina coming into the game.


Yeah, sorry I didn't word it very well. I was referring to fact that there's no carry-over effect from the actual game, it's like you magically gained 70 energy when the game finished, haha. But the other issue is that the penalty for dropping to 0 in-game doesn't seem to affect people enough to discourage them from doing it constantly. After all, once the game is finished they just do it all over again.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 00:36:15
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by Bort

Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


Bort, can we now assume stamina will play a bigger role in season 2 so teams can plan ahead?



Yeah, I'll make some adjustments. Maybe I should increase the effect slowly over the course of the first week or so of the new season, to give people time to adjust? I'll probably do various adjustments over the course of the season, too, just to make sure it gets balanced out properly.

"Power gamers" will bitch and moan about this I assure you, but I guess they bitch and moan about everything anyway.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 00:38:14
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by Bort


Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


Bort, can we now assume stamina will play a bigger role in season 2 so teams can plan ahead?



Yeah, I'll make some adjustments. Maybe I should increase the effect slowly over the course of the first week or so of the new season, to give people time to adjust? I'll probably do various adjustments over the course of the season, too, just to make sure it gets balanced out properly.

"Power gamers" will bitch and moan about this I assure you, but I guess they bitch and moan about everything anyway.


Awesome. I'm very glad to hear this. Thanks Bort.
 
scarletmbb
offline
Link
 
When you do start making the adjustments can you post that you are doing it (obviously not exactly what you're doing), so that we can toy around with the sub-in/out values knowing that something is actually changing? It would suck if everyone changed and tweaked values thinking that you did something, when you didn't. Well, it'd suck for us, but it'd be kinda funny, haha.

Thanks Bort.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 00:41:17
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarletmbb
When you do start making the adjustments can you post that you are doing it (obviously not exactly what you're doing), so that we can toy around with the sub-in/out values knowing that something is actually changing? It would suck if everyone changed and tweaked values thinking that you did something, when you didn't. Well, it'd suck for us, but it'd be kinda funny, haha.

Thanks Bort.


I'll do an announcement for sure. Don't want people to be too surprised by it.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Summary

Basically, from what I read:

-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.

-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.

-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.

 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
You the man bort!!!
Need to trust your gut more.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Summary
Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.


I wouldn't say that entirely with the current system. You do lose a percentage of your skill values - it's just not a 1:1 relationship like you might have assumed.

Of course, if your opponent is just as tired as you, you'll be the same effectiveness against him, since you'll both be depleted the same.

Morale also plays an part - high morale because you've been playing well can help balance out low stamina some. It can't make up for it entirely, but it can help.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Summary

Basically, from what I read:

-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.

-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.

-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.



10% stamina shouldn't = 10% effectiveness. Just because I'm warmed up doesn't mean I play slower. The only time it really impacts a player is when he's gassed and can't put that extra effort in required to make a play. A gassed player becomes almost useless on the field.

I'd much prefer some sort of bell curve where fatigue starts to set in more rapidly as a player gets more and more gassed.
 
islandlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Summary

Basically, from what I read:

-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.

-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.

-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.



10% stamina shouldn't = 10% effectiveness. Just because I'm warmed up doesn't mean I play slower. The only time it really impacts a player is when he's gassed and can't put that extra effort in required to make a play. A gassed player becomes almost useless on the field.

I'd much prefer some sort of bell curve where fatigue starts to set in more rapidly as a player gets more and more gassed.


this along with an increase of injury when stamina hits the gassed level will solve that short depth problem.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Good info here tonight. Tracking our playing time patterns had us thinking that the nature of the work our players were putting in had to be a factor (DT being double teamed often, CB's running with receivers, etc.) Will be glad to see STAMINA become a bigger part of things as well.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarletmbb
Wow...thank you guys for uncovering this. This changes a lot of things. It is kind of sucky that no one said a word about it when we were all running around worrying about stamina. It would have been nice if someone had stepped in a little earlier to enlighten us, haha.


#1 it was the alpha players who were telling everyone to pump skill points into stamina. We learned in the first season that stamina was by FAR the MOST important stat. Sounds like a real fun way to build, huh? We had no idea, no special insight, that it was gonna work like this.

#2 situation dictated Borts dicision as much as "complaining" players. In alpha, you had to play CPU players becuase there were no humans. So obvioulsy we hated stamina being so important. Maybe Bort took it too far the other way, but i dont think so.

#3 now there are way way more humans that teams. So obviouly there are more backups who want their players on the field. the reason teams have the luxury of having deep rosters is becuase there arent enough teams to get players. If we swing stamina's value too far back the other way we will be making the same mistake... letting the situation dictate the game play. What happens when new team owners cant get 3 players at every spot? They will be more pissed off than you are right now because they are wasting PT on computer players who can perform. "they got three players per spot because they got a team when their were not enough teams. Why do they get an advantage over us?" It will be a frustration that makes people lose intrest fast. B&D, please don't make that mistake.

#4 realism is overated. You want everything real, then you would lose a player you spent good money to boost to a career ending injury. you would have teams that have far better players and tactics lose to sucky teams because it happens. You would have cities paying taxes for stadium builds. you would have Agents taking 30% of your players salary. there would be T.O.'s that kill a great team. You would have your players have stretches where they get no stats and dont perform to their abilities due to family problems. the whole game would suck next season due to the sophmore jinx. your players would get suspended from GLB for off field antics, your top ranked QB would be in prison after you spent 50 bucks on him in 5 seasons. I could go on.
Realism is not the real complaint. No one wants realism. We want to play a game that does some things like the real sport and some things like a game. The complaint is that someone lost or someone isnt getting enough PT. the complaint is what someone thought the game should play like didnt happen. I personally think that practice and timing is what makes a team great, not just skill. And some chemisty bar isnt gonna fix that. But it would make this game boring and cumbersum as would finding 2-3 players at every position.

Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game? That's a game, not reality. Everyone wants to play, not support a team from the bench. Im not investing time (or money) into a game to watch you. And seriously, building players through PT is what drives this game, so lets get the team to player balance right and then worry about changing stamina. Until that happens, live with it.

Thats my essay and Im stickin to it.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.