User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by lump7502

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Originally posted by drifter




Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)


except the rule in football is the defense always determines the matchups thats why the line has to set before the snap



There's no using logic or analogies to real life football with these types.


"With these types" as though you can put me into a box and dismiss what I am saying so casually.

Tell me this, oh football master; In real football, are QBs able to assess the matchups prior to the snap and call for an audible to change from a pass play to a run play? GLB will never be the same as real football.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 14:58:19
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by lump7502


Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



Originally posted by drifter





Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)


except the rule in football is the defense always determines the matchups thats why the line has to set before the snap



There's no using logic or analogies to real life football with these types.


"With these types" as though you can put me into a box and dismiss what I am saying so casually.

Tell me this, oh football master; In real football, are QBs able to assess the matchups prior to the snap and call for an audible to change from a pass play to a run play? GLB will never be the same as real football.


and motion can always be used to "re-create" a matchup
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
id say 99% of the time an audible is called its not the matchups that inflence it usually its the qb reading a blitz usually if he dont like a match up he just automatically knows to check down
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 15:06:00
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
It honestly would be easier to set their WRs as a "threat" depth chart and have your CBs on a "threat counter" depth chart.. then you put their guys in order from best to worst and your guys from best to worst and it comes up with the best scenario for you.

Adding 3 WRs to each of your CBs each game is kind of tedious, when you really just want your best guy vs their best guy.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Originally posted by drifter


Originally posted by lump7502



Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi




Originally posted by drifter





Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)


except the rule in football is the defense always determines the matchups thats why the line has to set before the snap



There's no using logic or analogies to real life football with these types.


"With these types" as though you can put me into a box and dismiss what I am saying so casually.

Tell me this, oh football master; In real football, are QBs able to assess the matchups prior to the snap and call for an audible to change from a pass play to a run play? GLB will never be the same as real football.


and motion can always be used to "re-create" a matchup


if its a man defense all the motion in the world wont help you other than to tell you they are in man
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 15:10:31
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Drifter, there were ways to get your #1 WR into the slot without sacrificing him on starting plays. The new WR slots, just made it easy so that every coach could do it without having to think outside the box and be clever about it.

The new system works very well, I like it, everyone else likes it, you don't like it. My advice would be to figure out a way to counter their strategy and use their "exploit" against them. It really isn't that hard to put your best CB on the slot, and it really isn't that hard to punish a team that does put their best CB on the slot.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
It honestly would be easier to set their WRs as a "threat" depth chart and have your CBs on a "threat counter" depth chart.. then you put their guys in order from best to worst and your guys from best to worst and it comes up with the best scenario for you.


about 2 months ago I posted this in the Suggestions thread... And really I'm not that concerned... Whether assignments are based upon DC positioning (which can be "fixed" prior to the game), random (which bears no semblance to reality, but atleast could be called "fair"), some Defense chosen mechanism which allows the Defense to determine matchups -- in the end, the mechanism will work for both teams.. so it isn't really that big of a deal. I just don't like it when people call something an "exploit" just because the word itself carries such a negative and strong connotation within the world of online gaming. If Drifter had called it a "problem" - I probably wouldn't have even posted.. but his choice of words was to intentionally draw attention to his thread and to overstate the issue.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
It honestly would be easier to set their WRs as a "threat" depth chart and have your CBs on a "threat counter" depth chart.. then you put their guys in order from best to worst and your guys from best to worst and it comes up with the best scenario for you.

Adding 3 WRs to each of your CBs each game is kind of tedious, when you really just want your best guy vs their best guy.


That's why with my suggested system, you could do just that and leave everything else blank.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Drifter, there were ways to get your #1 WR into the slot without sacrificing him on starting plays. The new WR slots, just made it easy so that every coach could do it without having to think outside the box and be clever about it.

The new system works very well, I like it, everyone else likes it, you don't like it. My advice would be to figure out a way to counter their strategy and use their "exploit" against them. It really isn't that hard to put your best CB on the slot, and it really isn't that hard to punish a team that does put their best CB on the slot.


As discussed ad nauseum (please read the whole thread), you switch it up and they just switch it back. Whoever switches last, wins. That's ridiculous.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by lump7502


Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



Originally posted by drifter





Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


And by setting the CB to always guard the WR of choice - what this does is exactly the same thing, except insure that the Defense wins the matchup of who can be at their computer at game time.

I wouldn't have a problem with that at all, except the offense should be able to look at the matchups, before the ball is snapped, and determine that the passing play looks bad and audible it to a running play.

Anyways, Bort has final say -- and just like everything else in life.. our options are either to Deal with it, or register our opinions by going elsewhere. (not a threat, just the way things are)


except the rule in football is the defense always determines the matchups thats why the line has to set before the snap



There's no using logic or analogies to real life football with these types.


"With these types" as though you can put me into a box and dismiss what I am saying so casually.

Tell me this, oh football master; In real football, are QBs able to assess the matchups prior to the snap and call for an audible to change from a pass play to a run play? GLB will never be the same as real football.


I dismiss what you say based on what you have said and that, in turn, resulted in you being put in a box.

As pointed out audibles are more about reading the play the defense is prepared to make, not what the matchups are. Defense also call audibles. Since neither team can do that here and there are not any ways to exploit the inability to dynamically call an audible, then your point is not analogous and therefore moot.

As for the motion argument. In man coverage, if a player goes in motion, very often his matchup in man, will follow him through the motion.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Drifter - the reason Audibles are NOT moot was because, as you acknowledge - we can not do audibles. That is my reason for bringing them into the conversation. You use a comparison with real life football as your justification for allowing CBs to determine the matchups... I use the lack of audibles to demonstrate that GLB is NOT real life football.

Don't use Real life football as proof that something needs to change in the game. If you perceive an imbalance in the game, then real life be damned - that is the incentive for change. If you had posted this thread in the suggestions forum and wanted to argue that it'd be better for the game if matchups were determined by the defense - sweet. But you didn't. You posted this in the Bugs forum, and even admitted that it isn't a bug. /thread.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Drifter - the reason Audibles are NOT moot was because, as you acknowledge - we can not do audibles. That is my reason for bringing them into the conversation. You use a comparison with real life football as your justification for allowing CBs to determine the matchups... I use the lack of audibles to demonstrate that GLB is NOT real life football.

Don't use Real life football as proof that something needs to change in the game. If you perceive an imbalance in the game, then real life be damned - that is the incentive for change. If you had posted this thread in the suggestions forum and wanted to argue that it'd be better for the game if matchups were determined by the defense - sweet. But you didn't. You posted this in the Bugs forum, and even admitted that it isn't a bug. /thread.


The issues is that the ability to not do audibles does not give one side or another a giant advantage (ie exploit) because of its lack. That is why it is moot.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
The issues is that the ability to not do audibles does not give one side or another a giant advantage (ie exploit) because of its lack. That is why it is moot.


If the determining factor, as to whether something is moot or not, is whether both sides are affected equally.. then does it really matter if matchups benefit the offense or defense more? Both teams have an offense and both teams have a defense, so any mismatch would be available to both teams?

But that aside, my purpose in mentioning audibles is not moot simply because I am not referring to their effect upon the game, but rather to draw a distinction between real football and GLB. Maybe, instead of Audibles, I should have pointed towards a Player being able to purchase their team using funds earned from playing the game. Sound not related to whether offense or defense has an advantage from mismatches? It doesn't have to be related to show a distinction between real life football and GLB. The fact that GLB is NOT real life football is precisely why any argument which begins and ends with "well in real football.." is moot.

As I keep saying, if you want to argue that it would be beneficial for GLB to allow Defense determined matchups - great, make that argument in the Suggestions thread. But it is by no means a bug, and therefore does not belong in this forum. You placed it here.. and gave it the "exploit" title - purely to draw attention. It worked, but that doesn't mean that it should have been rewarded with praise.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 16:13:52
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

Drifter, there were ways to get your #1 WR into the slot without sacrificing him on starting plays. The new WR slots, just made it easy so that every coach could do it without having to think outside the box and be clever about it.

The new system works very well, I like it, everyone else likes it, you don't like it. My advice would be to figure out a way to counter their strategy and use their "exploit" against them. It really isn't that hard to put your best CB on the slot, and it really isn't that hard to punish a team that does put their best CB on the slot.


As discussed ad nauseum (please read the whole thread), you switch it up and they just switch it back. Whoever switches last, wins. That's ridiculous.


No sir, you are wrong. That is not what I was talking about. There are 'other' ways. I am sure I am not the only one who uses them either.

I see this in other games that I play. In Dagorhir, when a rule gets changed, there are always people who whine and bitch about it from one side or the other. But my friend Ori says you just have to adapt and get better. The rules are the rules, and complaining about them doesn't make you a better player.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 16:39:36
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter

The issues is that the ability to not do audibles does not give one side or another a giant advantage (ie exploit) because of its lack. That is why it is moot.


If the determining factor, as to whether something is moot or not, is whether both sides are affected equally.. then does it really matter if matchups benefit the offense or defense more? Both teams have an offense and both teams have a defense, so any mismatch would be available to both teams?

But that aside, my purpose in mentioning audibles is not moot simply because I am not referring to their effect upon the game, but rather to draw a distinction between real football and GLB. Maybe, instead of Audibles, I should have pointed towards a Player being able to purchase their team using funds earned from playing the game. Sound not related to whether offense or defense has an advantage from mismatches? It doesn't have to be related to show a distinction between real life football and GLB. The fact that GLB is NOT real life football is precisely why any argument which begins and ends with "well in real football.." is moot.

As I keep saying, if you want to argue that it would be beneficial for GLB to allow Defense determined matchups - great, make that argument in the Suggestions thread. But it is by no means a bug, and therefore does not belong in this forum. You placed it here.. and gave it the "exploit" title - purely to draw attention. It worked, but that doesn't mean that it should have been rewarded with praise.



Being able to put your #1 CB on their #3 WR is not creating a mismatch in favor of the defense. This type of bad logic illustrates why I made the comments I made earlier.

It also certainly is an exploit. People are using it to create a situation that was not Bort's intention when he implemented it. He himself, thought that his implementation woudl help the mismatch situation instead of making it worse. That means that it belongs here since it was not working as Bort intended and was creating an exploitable situation.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.