User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
Link
 
best suggestion on this forum yet
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
I like this idea a lot. I'll forward it on to those who call the shots.
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
I like this idea a lot. I'll forward it on to those who call the shots.


Hooray for a member of the Whitecaps gettin' some recognition for a great idea!
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Seems pretty well thought out. Needs some small tweaks, but definitely helps things in several key areas.

To the guy who's saying it would make everyone the same - no, not really. What it really does is help those who play smart, rather than those who live for the moment. Those who push to get their players up there as the best of the best are probably still going to get there first - but their career will be a flash in the pan. How many superstar rookies have pro-teams signed, only to have them be forgotten about in a couple seasons as they burn out?

Overall, I think this somewhat randomizes (in a realistic way) who's going to be a superstar and when, and when teams will begin their decline because of too many aging players - and I see that as a good thing.
 
Skorge
offline
Link
 
If you do it by plays then there will be guys (like the guys who own several teams and players) who make characters intentionally designed to sit on the bench the whole game in hopes to level up later in their careers while their starters wear down. Let's say these guys boost em up. So before they even play one game, after 10 seasons, they are level 35+, and haven't even seen one play...hell you can take it even a step farther and say they do this twice, then after 20 seasons some people, and yes people will do this, will have level 70+ players who havent even seen 1 play on the field yet.

 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skorge
If you do it by plays then there will be guys (like the guys who own several teams and players) who make characters intentionally designed to sit on the bench the whole game in hopes to level up later in their careers while their starters wear down. Let's say these guys boost em up. So before they even play one game, after 10 seasons, they are level 35+, and haven't even seen one play...hell you can take it even a step farther and say they do this twice, then after 20 seasons some people, and yes people will do this, will have level 70+ players who havent even seen 1 play on the field yet.



read the thread - there's an age (season) limit as well that works in conjunction with the wear and tear (plays) to determine the point at which a player stops progressing It would have to be a formula to determine how they work in conjunction, but you need to have it in conjunction to prevent people from doing exactly what you are describing

 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skorge
If you do it by plays then there will be guys (like the guys who own several teams and players) who make characters intentionally designed to sit on the bench the whole game in hopes to level up later in their careers while their starters wear down. Let's say these guys boost em up. So before they even play one game, after 10 seasons, they are level 35+, and haven't even seen one play...hell you can take it even a step farther and say they do this twice, then after 20 seasons some people, and yes people will do this, will have level 70+ players who havent even seen 1 play on the field yet.



Yea this system will reward people who sit on the bench...which is why i dont think it makes alot of sense in practice. I still think even with the age limit you'll still have them sit for a while to gain the maximum points.
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Skorge

If you do it by plays then there will be guys (like the guys who own several teams and players) who make characters intentionally designed to sit on the bench the whole game in hopes to level up later in their careers while their starters wear down. Let's say these guys boost em up. So before they even play one game, after 10 seasons, they are level 35+, and haven't even seen one play...hell you can take it even a step farther and say they do this twice, then after 20 seasons some people, and yes people will do this, will have level 70+ players who havent even seen 1 play on the field yet.



Yea this system will reward people who sit on the bench...which is why i dont think it makes alot of sense in practice. I still think even with the age limit you'll still have them sit for a while to gain the maximum points.


But that won't matter seeing as how there's an "age" to your player as well. So what if some turd rides the pine stackin' up points and not playing for 8-10 years. He'll get 1-2 years of peak performance (maybe) and then drop off. What a great time he had. "Then after 20 seasons...." Who said anything about playing that long?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
20 is just his number he said....i see the same problem with allowing 15 seasons like the original post said. Sit for 5 seasons not playing a single play....then do your 60 a game for 10 years and you're playing as the best.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
20 is just his number he said....i see the same problem with allowing 15 seasons like the original post said. Sit for 5 seasons not playing a single play....then do your 60 a game for 10 years and you're playing as the best.


I don't see why that's such a bad thing. If anything it will shut a lot of people up about complaining about starting spots when they first start.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
20 is just his number he said....i see the same problem with allowing 15 seasons like the original post said. Sit for 5 seasons not playing a single play....then do your 60 a game for 10 years and you're playing as the best.


if you sit for 5 years, you're not going to get 60 plays a game for 10 years. The 2 factors would work in conjunction with eachother.

So - if you never played a play in your life, you get 15 years. But once you start playing, you seasons would go down because of the wear and tear.

e.g. (just an example). if a player plays 60 plays every game they have 10 years. If a player plays 30 plays every game they have 12.5 years. If they play 0 plays every game, they get 15 years. So the player gets some added benefit for being a backup, but not so much as to off-balance the game.

so, in your example you sit for 5 years, then start playing 60 plays a game, they may only get 6-7 seasons of peak playing time... It will be a tradeoff on how you develop your player and how you want to play the game..
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 10:23:31
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
another idea - you could have this work on the flip side as well. Wear and Tear plus age = how fast your player declines....
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by bigtisme

20 is just his number he said....i see the same problem with allowing 15 seasons like the original post said. Sit for 5 seasons not playing a single play....then do your 60 a game for 10 years and you're playing as the best.


I don't see why that's such a bad thing. If anything it will shut a lot of people up about complaining about starting spots when they first start.


Seems to me that the only people doing that would be the ones pumping money into the game anyway by owning teams and lots of players. Let them tie their money up on bench sitters for some small delayed gratification. In the meantime, GLB will be using their money to make a better game.

The guy who creates one or two players probably isn't going to do that - and the ones that do would probably end up becoming inactive players anyway.

Yes, I'm betting that human impatience and our growing need for instant gratification will balance it out.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
It would also be easy enough to curtail abuse by giving players "20 plays" towards their eventual decline in every game, regardless of whether they play or not.

This would prevent someone from creating a player, burying them on a team for 5 years while they boost and gain EXP and then starting their career at about level 17-19 and getting 10 solid years. You can still do that but every year they are accumulating 320 plays, so after 5 years, they may start their career at level 17-19 but they do have the equivalent of 1600 plays under their belt. This combined with the "or 15 years" limit would keep people from totally taking advantage. Sure, there's still some advantage but it's not a gigantic one.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of position specific age hits. Some punters play for 20 years. I think a durability stat would be excellent. Adding points to durability would of course be fewer points to add to other abilities, but the more durability you had the less you would get injured and since their would be some algorithm controlling years/plays versus decline of skills, the increased durability would decrease this value. So you would still decline as you got older, but your rate of decline would be inversely proportional to the amount of durability points you had.

Like other abilities, certain positions would start out with a higher durability number. For example, LBs start out with a higher base tackling attribute than Punters. Likewise Punters would start out with a much higher base durability attribute than say HBs.

I like the idea of players retiring. I have players I want to create once the ones I have retire. It is just too expensive to have them all at once. You have to pace yourself people!
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 10:53:49
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.