User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
admit it peeps, its the speed nerf, if u agree please start talking about it, becasue nerfing other positions isnt going to make it any better just means that someone else besides us will get to decide what our build will eventually look like because they cant stop it or dont like it

and if they nerf db's thre will be some kind of unforseen impact somewhere else, it will never end


Exactly. That's the problem i've been harping about for 3 seasons now. You cant keep nerfing/tweaking something because it ends up causing something else to be nerfed/tweaked and round and round.

The answer is....creating a more advanced player base skill module. That has MORE factors in it than just "speed" "strength" "agility" and which 10 different positions use the same thing for different reasons, therefore shouldnt be the same thing!
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 23:50:19
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.


please explain why they are superhuman all of a sudden ? im not being an ass im just trying to understand your logic, obviously last year they were not superhuman, or we wouldn’t have the speed nerf, now we get the nerf and the db's are super human ?

do u see my point at all here or am i wasting my time, the reason im harping on this is because u said bort listens to you

all im really saying is that the wr's cannot create separation off of the line of scrimmage, which logically tells me that they do not have enough acceleration, which is what the nerf did so instead of messing with the db's why not un mess with the wr's or weak the original nerf to where it allows more acceleration

does that make sense 2 u or is it that you have such an issue with speed that u are willing to discount what most are saying is wrong with the passing game namely wr's and attribute it to the db's being superhuman all of a sudden
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.


Maybe those DBs had already built in agility so the Nerf didn't affect them the way it did the WRs...for example both of my corners have agility (and speed) in excess of 50. Therefore they weren't really affected by the nerf.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.


+1,000,000,000,000,000
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.


I agree, now having said that, what attributed would result in a decline of PI penalties? Vision? Catching? Jumping? There isn't a discipline attribute that I am aware of,

what I am saying is, yes PI should definitely be introduced, but here should be some way to improve on that, ie, a CB getting 5 calls per game, should be able to do something to reduce that.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
Originally posted by Ken1

I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.


please explain why they are superhuman all of a sudden ? im not being an ass im just trying to understand your logic, obviously last year they were not superhuman, or we wouldn’t have the speed nerf, now we get the nerf and the db's are super human ?

do u see my point at all here or am i wasting my time, the reason im harping on this is because u said bort listens to you

all im really saying is that the wr's cannot create separation off of the line of scrimmage, which logically tells me that they do not have enough acceleration, which is what the nerf did so instead of messing with the db's why not un mess with the wr's or weak the original nerf to where it allows more acceleration

does that make sense 2 u or is it that you have such an issue with speed that u are willing to discount what most are saying is wrong with the passing game namely wr's and attribute it to the db's being superhuman all of a sudden


They were superhuman last season as well. Why do you think there were so few shootouts despite all the passing people did?

I can't find last season's league stats. I guess they aren't being kept beyond the current season.

But yards per pass attempt were around 5 last season. I actually think (though there are no league stats for preseason games to check this) they may be a tiny bit higher this preseason. Real life is just short of 7.

Yards per pass attempt in real life are almost 7.
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.


well 80 \20 is a bit much but i think the problem is that the nerf crapped everyone's build right, not just builds like the one u mentioned, the team i own and the others i gm have speed and agility within 15-20 points of one another, so instead of just going after the extreme builds like the 80\20 ( which i think if someone wants to build is fine, its their build their money ) it hurt all wr builds

if we got the PI you want all we'd see are more penalties which no one wants , 75 of the plays would be penalties on tight man coverage lol seriously how would more penalties give us higher comp % the wr'sstill have no accel and the db's are stil going to play tight coverage , what changes ?


 
Vindictus
offline
Link
 
Honestly a lot of what people are seeing this season is less to do with the sim changes and more to do with level stratification. You get level 16s v level 25s as a common occurance where last season it was lvl 13 v lvl 16 as the common case. This will continue to increase as the seasons go on and the levels get further and further apart.

A simple study for Bort, check the level variance per game, per season. Compare the variance in scores. If each season it the variance is increasing, there is a potential balance problem.

Considering winning teams make more money (which makes sense), and can offer better contracts, this situation could worsen where the best players pool to the same teams over time.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
Originally posted by dpell

I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.


well 80 \20 is a bit much but i think the problem is that the nerf crapped everyone's build right, not just builds like the one u mentioned, the team i own and the others i gm have speed and agility within 15-20 points of one another, so instead of just going after the extreme builds like the 80\20 ( which i think if someone wants to build is fine, its their build their money ) it hurt all wr builds

if we got the PI you want all we'd see are more penalties which no one wants , 75 of the plays would be penalties on tight man coverage lol seriously how would more penalties give us higher comp % the wr'sstill have no accel and the db's are stil going to play tight coverage , what changes ?



Look, you obviously just have a fast guy who doesn't do other things well and you don't like that track stars can't play football anymore when they're built for the wrong sport.

That's not in the spirit of this discussion.
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TDmaker99

Originally posted by Ken1


I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.


please explain why they are superhuman all of a sudden ? im not being an ass im just trying to understand your logic, obviously last year they were not superhuman, or we wouldn’t have the speed nerf, now we get the nerf and the db's are super human ?

do u see my point at all here or am i wasting my time, the reason im harping on this is because u said bort listens to you

all im really saying is that the wr's cannot create separation off of the line of scrimmage, which logically tells me that they do not have enough acceleration, which is what the nerf did so instead of messing with the db's why not un mess with the wr's or weak the original nerf to where it allows more acceleration

does that make sense 2 u or is it that you have such an issue with speed that u are willing to discount what most are saying is wrong with the passing game namely wr's and attribute it to the db's being superhuman all of a sudden


They were superhuman last season as well. Why do you think there were so few shootouts despite all the passing people did?

I can't find last season's league stats. I guess they aren't being kept beyond the current season.

But yards per pass attempt were around 5 last season. I actually think (though there are no league stats for preseason games to check this) they may be a tiny bit higher this preseason. Real life is just short of 7.

Yards per pass attempt in real life are almost 7.


i dont care about ypa, because you are taking TE's and HB's into account with that stat, plus broken tackles for long gains. so ypa means nothing as a whole

all im talking about is the DB being able to dominate the WR, despite lvl, despite playing tight coverage and build

in your games do u not see that when the db plays tight the wr cant get open ?
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I think what happened was the speed nerf slowed the game down, but Bort probably didn't change any of the algorithms that affected reaction time by DB's. So while the speed nerf slowed the game down say 25%, the CB's are breaking on the ball as fast as they used to. He also mentioned that he was going to put press coverage in this season as another way to make sure people weren't ignoring certain attributes like strength for CB's and WR's. Not sure if that happened, but it does appear that CB's are suddenly all over WR's before the ball gets there even if the WR has inside positioning. Last season the WR made those catches and the CB made an immediate tackle. This season there are a lot more drops and deflections.

The changes this offseason weren't minor like advertised. They were major changes to the game mechanics that have been more drastic than anything I've seen since I started in season 1.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TDmaker99


Originally posted by Ken1



I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.


please explain why they are superhuman all of a sudden ? im not being an ass im just trying to understand your logic, obviously last year they were not superhuman, or we wouldn’t have the speed nerf, now we get the nerf and the db's are super human ?

do u see my point at all here or am i wasting my time, the reason im harping on this is because u said bort listens to you

all im really saying is that the wr's cannot create separation off of the line of scrimmage, which logically tells me that they do not have enough acceleration, which is what the nerf did so instead of messing with the db's why not un mess with the wr's or weak the original nerf to where it allows more acceleration

does that make sense 2 u or is it that you have such an issue with speed that u are willing to discount what most are saying is wrong with the passing game namely wr's and attribute it to the db's being superhuman all of a sudden


They were superhuman last season as well. Why do you think there were so few shootouts despite all the passing people did?

I can't find last season's league stats. I guess they aren't being kept beyond the current season.

But yards per pass attempt were around 5 last season. I actually think (though there are no league stats for preseason games to check this) they may be a tiny bit higher this preseason. Real life is just short of 7.

Yards per pass attempt in real life are almost 7.


i dont care about ypa, because you are taking TE's and HB's into account with that stat, plus broken tackles for long gains. so ypa means nothing as a whole

all im talking about is the DB being able to dominate the WR, despite lvl, despite playing tight coverage and build

in your games do u not see that when the db plays tight the wr cant get open ?


Same as last season. I saw it both then and now.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TDmaker99


Originally posted by Ken1



I can only find the place you said this in quotes, but the problem is the superhuman pass defenders.


please explain why they are superhuman all of a sudden ? im not being an ass im just trying to understand your logic, obviously last year they were not superhuman, or we wouldn’t have the speed nerf, now we get the nerf and the db's are super human ?

do u see my point at all here or am i wasting my time, the reason im harping on this is because u said bort listens to you

all im really saying is that the wr's cannot create separation off of the line of scrimmage, which logically tells me that they do not have enough acceleration, which is what the nerf did so instead of messing with the db's why not un mess with the wr's or weak the original nerf to where it allows more acceleration

does that make sense 2 u or is it that you have such an issue with speed that u are willing to discount what most are saying is wrong with the passing game namely wr's and attribute it to the db's being superhuman all of a sudden


They were superhuman last season as well. Why do you think there were so few shootouts despite all the passing people did?

I can't find last season's league stats. I guess they aren't being kept beyond the current season.

But yards per pass attempt were around 5 last season. I actually think (though there are no league stats for preseason games to check this) they may be a tiny bit higher this preseason. Real life is just short of 7.

Yards per pass attempt in real life are almost 7.


i dont care about ypa, because you are taking TE's and HB's into account with that stat, plus broken tackles for long gains. so ypa means nothing as a whole

all im talking about is the DB being able to dominate the WR, despite lvl, despite playing tight coverage and build

in your games do u not see that when the db plays tight the wr cant get open ?


Nope our WRs had a field day on both the team I own and the one I GM. The one I'm a DC on doesn't even have a full roster yet, so bad example there.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
My wr's had no problem in the sim because I was never one to build or get guys who were all flash and no bang. hell one of my leading recievers from the last sim actually has more in catching than speed imagine that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.