User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Blitzing is BROKEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I've been testing this recently and it seems to work on my test machine, but sometimes it looks as though players aren't blitzing (even though they are trying to) on run plays because they are positioning themselves to cut off the runner.


Unless all blitz in GLB are delay blitz, sometimes we should still see defensive players moving toward LOS after ball is snapped and before the play is developed. However, among all the games I watched, blitz at running play is close to zero.

I decided to randomly pick 5 games among different leagues and checked blitz ratio on passing and running plays. (I didn't selectively pick these 5 games, please feel free to randomly pick one or two games and do the same)

(I ignore sacks since sacks are counted as rush plays in GLB, people may argue they are pass plays)


(1) Denver Globetrotters vs. Miami Bulldogs: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=78327

Bulldogs: Blitz in 9 of 25 pass plays and blitz none in 44 rush plays
Globetrotters: blitz in 32 of 32 pass plays and blitz none in 21 rush plays


(2) Omaha Beef vs. Richmond Retros: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=79581

Beef: blitz in 5 of 28 pass plays and blitz none in 35 rush plays
Retros: blitz in 38 of 45 pass plays and blitz none in 19 rush plays


(3) Yukon Gold Rush vs. Arctic Bay Yetis: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=78435

Gold Rush: blitz in 17 of 47 pass plays and blitz none in 27 rush plays
Yetis: blitz 26 of 26 pass plays and blitz none in 36 rush plays


(4) Rocky Mountain Gladiators vs. Kingston Regiment: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=81703

Gladiators: blitz in 14 of 31 pass plays and blitz none in 36 rush plays
Regiment: blitz in 11 of 30 pass plays and blitz 1 in 38 rush plays (I gave MLB credit in this play even though it looks like MLB recognized the play from the beginning: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81703&pbp_id=266910)


(5) La Jolla Surf vs. Rapid City Sioux: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=78427

Surf: blitz 14 of 21 pass plays and none in 23 rush plays
Sioux: blitz in 7 of 39 pass plays and none in 42 rush plays



The blitz ratio in rush plays looks really strange.

Last edited Jul 30, 2008 21:57:46
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
The problem I ran into when having the guys blitz on rush plays is that they would overshoot the runner pretty frequently when blitzing, so I made them try and position themselves for the play. Maybe that should just be the drawback of blitzing, though? I guess you'd never be able to pull off a trap play otherwise.
 
Link
 
Bort, it looks like this needs to be tuned a little bit to find the balance. (Close to) no blitz in rush plays seems strange in football games. For example, teams sometimes may choose to blitz in 3rd & inches situation to fill the gaps, but right now, these LB/SS stand still and do not move toward LOS.

Last edited Jul 30, 2008 22:09:19
 
chrome
offline
Link
 
bort, would you please take a look at this play? http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78391&pbp_id=317893

It appears as if the ROLB is blitzing as he should, but when he sees the HB coming out of the backfield, he stops rushing and drops into coverage. Problem is the MLB is already covering the HB, so now I'm short a pass rusher that I'd prefer to have.

It seems like good AI if he were a DE in a standard zone def that called for him to cover the flats, but he's supposed to be blitzing, so he should be ignoring guys like that, right?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chrome
bort, would you please take a look at this play? http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78391&pbp_id=317893

It appears as if the ROLB is blitzing as he should, but when he sees the HB coming out of the backfield, he stops rushing and drops into coverage. Problem is the MLB is already covering the HB, so now I'm short a pass rusher that I'd prefer to have.

It seems like good AI if he were a DE in a standard zone def that called for him to cover the flats, but he's supposed to be blitzing, so he should be ignoring guys like that, right?


I don't think he's actually blitzing - he's just playing man from where he's standing and heading toward his HB assignment.

That game was simmed before I identified the problem with blitzing, though.
 
rick61
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

Bort...

I have about 20 different inputs. 1 is nickel, and 1 is quarter. Both these were wrong like you said.

But i have dime and the rest of the 15 inputs are all base 3-4. All varying blitzers, from ILBs and/or OLBs and/or SS. None of these worked on pass plays. The film shows it. There were say 80/90 defensive plays called that did have the base 3-4, and no one still blitzed. Maybe it happened 1 or 2 times all game. The regularity of my settings would have seen 1-4 blitzers per pass play.


Are you sure they would match the situation, though? For example, you have some single back inputs with 0-2 receivers. A single back set has 3 receivers.

I'm not saying that it's impossible there is something wrong, but your base D is a 3-4 and it might just have been falling back on that and your basic settings because there weren't any inputs to match.


hi bort...i want an all cpu team..gutted...im number 376 on the waiting list..whatwhat league should i put first for a 13 capped team
 
Galileo
offline
Link
 
Blitzing still seems somewhat out of whak to me. Our SIM ran after your earlier statements about correcting the code.

First series
play 1: 2WR/1st down - D should be Cover 2 Man under ROLB blitz - LOLB blitzes instead of ROLB. ROLB drops and covers our FS...ON A RUNNING PLAY! http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=360357

Play 2: 3WR/2nd down - Cover 3 Zone No Blitz - D seems to run as called

Play 3: 2WR/3rd down - Should be Cover 2 Zone ROLB blitz - There is no blitz http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=360437

Second Series
play 1: 2WR/1st down - Cover 2 Man under ROLB blitz - ROLB does not blitz http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=360707

Play 2: 3WR/2nd down - Cover 3 Zone No Blitz - D seems to run as called

Play 3: 3WR/3rd down - Cover 3 Zone LOLB blitz CB3 blitz- LOLB does not blitz http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=360793

Third Series
Play 1: 2WR/1st down - ROLB does not blitz http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=361086

Play 2: 3WR/2nd down - correct call

Play 3: 2WR/3rd down - Cover 2 Zone ROLB blitz - MLB blitzes instead of ROLB http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=361178


The other thing I noticed about all three of the first down plays here is that our OLB's alignment is way down inside. Is this is a by product of the "stack the box" setting? If so, then outside plays are going to be a heck of a lot tougher to handle when play focus is on run.

Last edited Jul 30, 2008 22:31:00
 
chrome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I don't think he's actually blitzing - he's just playing man from where he's standing and heading toward his HB assignment.

That game was simmed before I identified the problem with blitzing, though.

Thank you.

Any suggestions on how to stop both LBs from covering the same guy M2M? j/k
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Galileo

play 1: 2WR/1st down - D should be Cover 2 Man under ROLB blitz - LOLB blitzes instead of ROLB. ROLB drops and covers our FS...ON A RUNNING PLAY! http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=360357


It looks like LOLB didn't blitz in this play as well. He moved backward and to the right at the beginning and only started to move toward HB after the ball was pitched to HB.

It definitely looks like blitz formula needs to be adjusted for rush plays.
 
Galileo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by Galileo


play 1: 2WR/1st down - D should be Cover 2 Man under ROLB blitz - LOLB blitzes instead of ROLB. ROLB drops and covers our FS...ON A RUNNING PLAY! http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78957&pbp_id=360357


It looks like LOLB didn't blitz in this play as well. He moved backward and to the right at the beginning and only started to move toward HB after the ball was pitched to HB.

It definitely looks like blitz formula needs to be adjusted for rush plays.


I can buy that, but it still doesn't explain why our ROLB is not blitzing...Max = 1, ROLB = 100%
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The problem I ran into when having the guys blitz on rush plays is that they would overshoot the runner pretty frequently when blitzing, so I made them try and position themselves for the play. Maybe that should just be the drawback of blitzing, though? I guess you'd never be able to pull off a trap play otherwise.


Absolutely, the Blitz should not come with a built in safety mechanism, although I understand entirely the reasoning.

But right now I could Blitz all 3 LBs 100% of the time, and not have it happen against a run play?

Instead of having a one on one LB vs HB with the LB likely to miss the HB, I get 3 LBs converging on the HB???

Thats an exploit and a half, predeterminism ftw!

Most LBs are taught to Blitz the Gap in a Run Blitz.

The idea is that they have the same gap responsibility as a normal play, but they are supposed to be on or beyond the line of Scrimmage to make the tackle.

As long as the Blitz is accounting for one Gap, then the LB is doing his job properly against the Run.

He should only react if he sees the ball being handed off, not a player moving out of the back field. (This will lead to a play fake one day )

Looking 2 or 3 seasons down the line, the option to dictate a Pass Blitz (Aim for the QB no matter what) or a Run Blitz (Go 1 yard beyond the LoS then find target) would be frekin awesome.

Probably impossible to code though.



Last edited Jul 30, 2008 22:46:19
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Looking 2 or 3 seasons down the line, the option to dictate a Pass Blitz (Aim for the QB no matter what) or a Run Blitz (Go 1 yard beyond the LoS then find target) would be frekin awesome.

Probably impossible to code though.


Not impossible, pretty easy actually. I could just add it as an "auto" option based on the play call. Not a bad idear...
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 23:36:10
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mike Rogers



Looking 2 or 3 seasons down the line, the option to dictate a Pass Blitz (Aim for the QB no matter what) or a Run Blitz (Go 1 yard beyond the LoS then find target) would be frekin awesome.

Probably impossible to code though.


Not impossible, pretty easy actually. I could just add it as an "auto" option based on the play call. Not a bad idear...


That makes me 2 for 2 tonight, and with that I think I'll retire and protect my 100% record
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The problem I ran into when having the guys blitz on rush plays is that they would overshoot the runner pretty frequently when blitzing, so I made them try and position themselves for the play. Maybe that should just be the drawback of blitzing, though? I guess you'd never be able to pull off a trap play otherwise.


Bort, it still looks like there is almost no blitz in rush plays in early games today.
 
Shorteous
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by Bort

The problem I ran into when having the guys blitz on rush plays is that they would overshoot the runner pretty frequently when blitzing, so I made them try and position themselves for the play. Maybe that should just be the drawback of blitzing, though? I guess you'd never be able to pull off a trap play otherwise.


Bort, it still looks like there is almost no blitz in rush plays in early games today.


Ya I agree that should be fixed as well. you should be able to use blitzs to help attack the LOS and close running lanes.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.