User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Mud Turkey 13
offline
Link
 
I'm totally with Gabrosin's idea for doing this.

I just want to urge people to base their votes on statistics rather than builds or levels. This isn't a contest of who has the best build. It's to give recognition to players that have performed well this season.

 
Big_B
offline
Link
 
The pro-bowl is as much a popularity contest as it is a stat's award. Builds should be taken into account because lesser teams don't have the ability to blow out cupcakes teams like the top tier does. That doesn't mean there aren't good players on those teams.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mud Turkey 13
I'm totally with Gabrosin's idea for doing this.

I just want to urge people to base their votes on statistics rather than builds or levels. This isn't a contest of who has the best build. It's to give recognition to players that have performed well this season.



on top of that what players have done for their team. My HB is in a loaded alpha conference and wouldn't make the top 2, but yet he leads our undefeated team....there could be a QB leading an 5-8 team that leads the conference in passing yards and TD's but a QB 3rd or 4th in stats that leads his team to a top 3 finish in the conference should get higher consideration.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigb4486
The pro-bowl is as much a popularity contest as it is a stat's award. Builds should be taken into account because lesser teams don't have the ability to blow out cupcakes teams like the top tier does. That doesn't mean there aren't good players on those teams.


How do we know who has a good build? Are you going to go through to every team in the conference and figure out who has the best build at every position? Plus, how many people actually have their builds open, I know last I checked, my team had 1 guy total I think with their build open
 
double_d1365
offline
Link
 
its like Edgerrin james sorta. He has a great build for a RB, he was a pro-bowler every year with the colts. But now he's on a crappy team so he sucks too.
Builds shouldnt be taken into consideration, its all about the stats.
the 2 leading tacklers in this league are both on the worst team too!!!! you can still get stats if yur good and on a bad team.
 
Big_B
offline
Link
 
I dont mean actual build. I mean a productive player on an otherwise unproductive team. Like the Bangkok Stars RB Juke Box. Put him on another team and he could be leading the league.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by double_d1365
its like Edgerrin james sorta. He has a great build for a RB, he was a pro-bowler every year with the colts. But now he's on a crappy team so he sucks too.
Builds shouldnt be taken into consideration, its all about the stats.
the 2 leading tacklers in this league are both on the worst team too!!!! you can still get stats if yur good and on a bad team.


playing on a bad team goes both ways, if you're always playing from behind you're defense has the chance to build up those defensive stats (tackles/sacks/fumbles, etc.) but if you play on a good team if you're dominating the game and you have it set to when you're up by ## of points its all backups, the starters only see the field for 20-30 plays tops and doesn't have the chance to build up the same numbers as somebody on a bad team.

it goes both ways really, I can see what you're saying.....its like A-Rod winning the MVP on the Rangers.....they did absolutely nothing as a team, but he was a stud of a player.
 
double_d1365
offline
Link
 
yeah.. i stil say we go by stats tho...

 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by double_d1365
yeah.. i stil say we go by stats tho...



 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
i say you take into consideration besides stats team play...still favor the team stats but also take into consideration, a small part at that, team play
 
Paladin58
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by onlyrockerfan
i say you take into consideration besides stats team play...still favor the team stats but also take into consideration, a small part at that, team play


So, by team play, do you mean how much they contributed to getting W's for their respective team?

Say, a hypothetical situation. Sam Diesel (hypothetical, just using name only )continually gets those long plays, but quite a few don't punch through to the endzone. But, then the team eventually gets that rock over the line. Since he would be continually getting the team to fight for those points, would that give him a higher standing in the 'team play' aspect than a back whose offense is built solely around him, and so has more touches, yards and touchdowns? Or am I hella confusing myself?
 
Graevis
offline
Link
 
The problem is this isn't real life where the NFL has television cameras and hundreds of prognosticators and media covering every single aspect of the game. So the unsung hero can get recognition and the fans will know about his great season a horrid team.

In this case we have somebody that has offered to donate their time to compile two lists, one per conference, and the easiest way to do that is by stats and not stats + an X factor. So while it might not be the 100% fair way of doing it, it is probably the best of way doing it with the most chance of being the fairest outcome for everyone involved.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
fine, easy way to do it.....if you're going to go off stats.....see who played well in the big games, and that's against teams that actually give you a game not the Lexington Wildcats or Hattrick/Phucket teams. If they ran for 250 against Phnom and ran for only 52 yards against Colombo then they're not that great of a player. Simple as that
 
Graevis
offline
Link
 
So when LT rushes for 200 against say Cleveland (before they got decent) but is held to 70 against the Pats - he sucks?

It is impossible for the X factor to be taken into account in a computer simulation - but who knows how he is deciding on the nominations. The fairest way to do is by going by the over all stats, click on "full season" stats and look at everything not just rushing yards, or passing yards, or whatever but at everything.

Discounting stats from a game against a supposedly "easy team" makes little to no sense at all.

 
KtOwnsYou
offline
Link
 
our rb shud be in it 2000+ yards + 30 tds
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.