User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
ElvisMonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is another solution

I've looked at game logs from several games and 40 plays looks to be a good cut off for getting XP. Many games there are only a few defensive players get over 40 plays when they do well and the team has depth. With offensive positions, once again many players fail to get to 40 or more plays.

Here are my arguments on why the cap

1. It fights against owners building 30 players on the same team then starting them all the time and building up. While backups sit and get nothing.

2. It encourages human player depth on teams and getting backups in to keep non owner players happy.

3. It fights against gaming the system. (calling all pass plays in early games to level up players faster)

4. It counters the penalty to good defenses or quick strike offenses.

5. It helps lower level players catch up to upper level players faster, because they get more XP per play and starters can't keep outgaining them by getting 50 more plays per game.

6. It retains importance of boosting, because it gets harder and harder to level up through XP as players get to higher levels.

edited to add 7. It stops players from leveling up as fast and contracts continually needing to be renegotiated.


Very well thought out post.
 
skel1977
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is another solution




3. It fights against gaming the system. (calling all pass plays in early games to level up players faster)

.


How does passing level up players quicker than running?

 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
I would definetly expect alot more from a Mod. But hey..to each his own.

You or anyone else shouldnt focus on flawed aspects of the game, if you really cared, you would be helping to improve the problem. Not saying how this or that wont work.


Maybe you don't understand what power Mods have around here right now. We try to police the forums, filter out some of the "junk" (duplicate threads, questions which can be answered by one of us instead of the admins, etc.), and have maybe just a tiny drop more of the ear of B&D. That's it. We're not developers, we don't have any say in how this game is made more than you guys do.

So I don't know what you would expect from me other than to play the game as it's made. As I said before (hell, I even said it at the top of my last post), I've argued for the XP suggestion I made since I think that would be the best and cleanest solution to this. If I see a work-around or loophole in another suggestion which, after the work it would take to implement, would do nothing, I'm going to say so now. I don't want to see time/work wasted like that.

Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
Min roster wouldnt work. BUT a Min roster PER POSITION would. MUST have 5 WR's, 3 TE's, 2 QB's, 2 FS's, etc...


So I pick up 1 level 1 CPU punter, 1 level 1 CPU QB, 1 level 1 CPU WR.....really, roster mins won't do anything other than raise my daily salary a couple of bucks. and it'll barely even do that since I'll sign level 1 CPU's to min contracts for max length of time.


Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
1) Associate a % that drops the overall skills of a player down the lower his stamina gets. Stamina at 100 speed at 45, stamina at 75 speed at 30, stamina at 50 speed at 20 etc...

2) Injuries SHOULD take a player completely out of a game. Not this "they just get weaker" nonsense. 5 different injury lvls ( injury lvl 1- out a quater, 2- out a game, 3- out 3 games, 4- out 5 games, 5- out 8 games).

Counter this by NOT having injury time be part of the "age" thing yet to be installed. Also, maybe injured players dont play, but get 50% of the average xp gained on the team. (so if the average xp per player for the game is 300 the injured players get 150)

3) Age- As age and seasons go up, skills start degrading.


1 and 3 already happen, 2 is ridiculous. Try telling someone who just started this game (or hell, even one who's played for a while) that they don't get to play for over the next 2 weeks and see how many of them even bother coming back. I don't care if it's realistic, it's just not good for the game.

And then the whole part where injured players get EXP is just even more ridiculous. The only reason to have injuries take people out of games is to make it more realistic. To have them still get EXP takes away that realism.


Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
You DONT slow down nearly enough. There are PLAYOFF teams out there with 1 person in each position, dont tell me its high stamina either. Bottom line is this low of a lvl there SHOULD NOT be a high enough stamina to let a player last the entire game. Only at stamina 75+ should that happen.


So what you're saying here is you want everyone who wants to max level their players to stop everything, raise their Stamina to 75, then go back to leveling actual skills? Cause that's exactly what would happen with a system like this.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed

Originally posted by xxsyrusvb

Min roster wouldnt work. BUT a Min roster PER POSITION would. MUST have 5 WR's, 3 TE's, 2 QB's, 2 FS's, etc...


So I pick up 1 level 1 CPU punter, 1 level 1 CPU QB, 1 level 1 CPU WR.....really, roster mins won't do anything other than raise my daily salary a couple of bucks. and it'll barely even do that since I'll sign level 1 CPU's to min contracts for max length of time.



But then those Level 1 CPU guys would take away from the playing time of the Level 9 human, somewhat accomplishing the goal, no?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
No you wouldn't play the level 1 cpu Vilita.
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb

I would definetly expect alot more from a Mod. But hey..to each his own.

You or anyone else shouldnt focus on flawed aspects of the game, if you really cared, you would be helping to improve the problem. Not saying how this or that wont work.


Maybe you don't understand what power Mods have around here right now. We try to police the forums, filter out some of the "junk" (duplicate threads, questions which can be answered by one of us instead of the admins, etc.), and have maybe just a tiny drop more of the ear of B&D. That's it. We're not developers, we don't have any say in how this game is made more than you guys do.

So I don't know what you would expect from me other than to play the game as it's made. As I said before (hell, I even said it at the top of my last post), I've argued for the XP suggestion I made since I think that would be the best and cleanest solution to this. If I see a work-around or loophole in another suggestion which, after the work it would take to implement, would do nothing, I'm going to say so now. I don't want to see time/work wasted like that.

Originally posted by xxsyrusvb

Min roster wouldnt work. BUT a Min roster PER POSITION would. MUST have 5 WR's, 3 TE's, 2 QB's, 2 FS's, etc...


So I pick up 1 level 1 CPU punter, 1 level 1 CPU QB, 1 level 1 CPU WR.....really, roster mins won't do anything other than raise my daily salary a couple of bucks. and it'll barely even do that since I'll sign level 1 CPU's to min contracts for max length of time.


Originally posted by xxsyrusvb

1) Associate a % that drops the overall skills of a player down the lower his stamina gets. Stamina at 100 speed at 45, stamina at 75 speed at 30, stamina at 50 speed at 20 etc...

2) Injuries SHOULD take a player completely out of a game. Not this "they just get weaker" nonsense. 5 different injury lvls ( injury lvl 1- out a quater, 2- out a game, 3- out 3 games, 4- out 5 games, 5- out 8 games).

Counter this by NOT having injury time be part of the "age" thing yet to be installed. Also, maybe injured players dont play, but get 50% of the average xp gained on the team. (so if the average xp per player for the game is 300 the injured players get 150)

3) Age- As age and seasons go up, skills start degrading.


1 and 3 already happen, 2 is ridiculous. Try telling someone who just started this game (or hell, even one who's played for a while) that they don't get to play for over the next 2 weeks and see how many of them even bother coming back. I don't care if it's realistic, it's just not good for the game.

And then the whole part where injured players get EXP is just even more ridiculous. The only reason to have injuries take people out of games is to make it more realistic. To have them still get EXP takes away that realism.


Originally posted by xxsyrusvb

You DONT slow down nearly enough. There are PLAYOFF teams out there with 1 person in each position, dont tell me its high stamina either. Bottom line is this low of a lvl there SHOULD NOT be a high enough stamina to let a player last the entire game. Only at stamina 75+ should that happen.


So what you're saying here is you want everyone who wants to max level their players to stop everything, raise their Stamina to 75, then go back to leveling actual skills? Cause that's exactly what would happen with a system like this.




Thats funny, you say I dont know the responsibilities of a MOD. Maybe your overlooking the fact that, TO the community, you hold a certain lvl of esteem and responsibility. Your are the "ears and voice" of the devs in ALOT of senses. It is only natural that the community would expect one to act with such a demeanor.

Because you are more then just the average user, you are looked up to in alot of ways and whether you like it or not, and are also mimicked by other users.

Just because you could, doesnt mean you should...

And furthermore, pointing out all the flaws without giving a solution in return, does not help anything. Constructive criticisms is one thing, saying something will not work and being negative towards its progress is another...

Honestly, there will always be a work around EVERY rule you can possibly think of. It is about minimizing the weaknesses while solving the problem at hand. Or should we just forget about discussing possible fixes because "it just wont work"?

Last edited Apr 15, 2008 19:05:04
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
a) Playing starters for a full game is hardly cheating. It's not like I bought 6 teams and funneled all the money on those teams to 1 team. You have to see the difference between playing a game with the system that's in place and actively trying to cheat a system.

b) Did you not read my original post? I gave 2 suggestions:

"There's really only 2 ways I, or anyone who's thinking like me will care about backups:

1) There's a much lower cap put in place for experience (40 or so plays before the big dropoff instead of 90). Then I'll carry a few extra players to have more options. Even under that system, I can't imagine wanting to carry more than 40-45 players. I'd still keep the Energy penalty in the same place (gets much higher after the 80-90 play range) so if a team wants to just have single starters, they can, they're just not helped very much by it.

2) Lower the cap for the point where the Energy penalty hits hard to around 50 plays. That basically forces teams to carry a lot of depth and eliminates single starters across the board (other than maybe P/Ks). I don't like this idea since I don't think teams should be forced into a system like that if they don't want to, but hey, it'll solve the current problem...."

and got 0 comments on either one. Frankly, I'm still waiting to hear why the first 1 isn't good and where the loophole in that one is.

So if I shoot down others, I've already given good ones to go with.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I would like to see 60 or 70 plays....and your first suggestion honestly Jed.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by skel1977
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Here is another solution




3. It fights against gaming the system. (calling all pass plays in early games to level up players faster)

.


How does passing level up players quicker than running?



Passing plays cause the clock to stop more. More plays per game. More plays per game, more xp for players in the game. I've seen a game with less than 100 total plays, and there are games with over 160. Check the number of plays when both teams pass over 60% of the time vs. games where both teams run over 60% of the time.

 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
a) Playing starters for a full game is hardly cheating. It's not like I bought 6 teams and funneled all the money on those teams to 1 team. You have to see the difference between playing a game with the system that's in place and actively trying to cheat a system.


Yeah, he's not doing anything wrong here... i think i am quoting Herm here...

"YOU PLAY, TO WIN, THE GAME!"

There is nothing cheating here... the thread was created to point out that the system needs changed for the groth of the game. Not to say people doing that are cheating, its the best way to set up your team as of right now.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
I would like to see 60 or 70 plays....and your first suggestion honestly Jed.


Yea, the number is quite debatable, I just threw one out there to start with, I'm more concerned with the general idea of it.

The more I think about it, I think around 50-60 would be good. I've noticed that my LBs (who have backups), CBs (same), and WRs (also, same) seem to get in that range for plays/game, so that would be a natural place to go.

Originally posted by ohmybriguy
Yeah, he's not doing anything wrong here... i think i am quoting Herm here...

"YOU PLAY, TO WIN, THE GAME!"

There is nothing cheating here... the thread was created to point out that the system needs changed for the groth of the game. Not to say people doing that are cheating, its the best way to set up your team as of right now.


Gotta love Herm

And thank you, I was hoping this wasn't going to turn into "dogpile on the mod!" part 2.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 19:18:54
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Yea i totally agree with your idea Jed...and of course the number can be debated. I think we seem to be around the same area. The 4 LB's in the 4-3 will all play around 55-70 plays it seems depending on the "flow" of the game. So from that thats why i think the number out to be in that area.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
No you wouldn't play the level 1 cpu Vilita.


Well I'm thinking then of having a certain number of players required on the depth chart then, not the roster
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I just want it stated for the record, I am accusing no one of cheating. I am just trying to look at ways to make the playing field more even and more fun for everyone involved, especially players who can't put the time in or can't afford to run a team.

Anyone who has maximized the benefits of the current system in place, shouldn't be accused of cheating because they were smart about how they went about running their team or players.

Also, better to see potential problems with the current system in the first season rather than the 5th or 6th.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I think that trying to micro manage people's depth charts with limits might not be a great idea either. But just my opinion.

Im just saying that i have a team that will be under 40 players next year (unless there is a cap) and im not really trying to "power level" guys.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.