You can try being happy in your team's success. You get a reward on your stat page.
Forum > Suggestions > XP Bonuses for Impact Plays made on the field - a must add
Killer V
offline
offline
Wow. Thanks Pollyanna. You're the bestest team-player ever!
I'm simply suggesting a way (which others have already stated & supported) in which the actual games can be made a little more interesting for the individuals.
No need to get smarmy.
I'm simply suggesting a way (which others have already stated & supported) in which the actual games can be made a little more interesting for the individuals.
No need to get smarmy.
PackMan97
offline
offline
The biggest issue with having "big play" experience is that the rich will get richer and the poor won't get anything.
Let's say you have a team with an average defense of 6, and this one linebacker that is level 12. He's built with great vision and great speed and as such he's making tackles, getting sacks, breaking up passes and is a monster. He's going to be getting the lion's share of the experience while everyone else starves.
The same will happen with good offensive teams, all the stars will want to play on those teams so they can score a lot while the teams that struggle offensively will have trouble recruiting talent and even worse, will have trouble developing talent because no one on their team is scoring they aren't getting big play experience.
It gets even worse when you look at a poor offensive team will throw more int's have more fumbles, and get tackled more than a good team...this will give their opponent more experience while they get starved. Ditto for a good offense against a bad defense. Lots of big plays (+exp) for the offense, few for the defense (no exp).
While I like the idea in general, it isn't one that is sustainable because it will just frustrate those teams that happen to be poorly run and not give them any chance to develop.
Keep in mind, good teams will likely have better builds and better teamwork already...so they have their edge. I see no reason to give them more of an edge.
Of course, maybe we should take away experience if you blowout a team, because the team wouldn't have developed any and they are getting overconfident feasting on cupcakes. Now that's an idea
Let's say you have a team with an average defense of 6, and this one linebacker that is level 12. He's built with great vision and great speed and as such he's making tackles, getting sacks, breaking up passes and is a monster. He's going to be getting the lion's share of the experience while everyone else starves.
The same will happen with good offensive teams, all the stars will want to play on those teams so they can score a lot while the teams that struggle offensively will have trouble recruiting talent and even worse, will have trouble developing talent because no one on their team is scoring they aren't getting big play experience.
It gets even worse when you look at a poor offensive team will throw more int's have more fumbles, and get tackled more than a good team...this will give their opponent more experience while they get starved. Ditto for a good offense against a bad defense. Lots of big plays (+exp) for the offense, few for the defense (no exp).
While I like the idea in general, it isn't one that is sustainable because it will just frustrate those teams that happen to be poorly run and not give them any chance to develop.
Keep in mind, good teams will likely have better builds and better teamwork already...so they have their edge. I see no reason to give them more of an edge.
Of course, maybe we should take away experience if you blowout a team, because the team wouldn't have developed any and they are getting overconfident feasting on cupcakes. Now that's an idea

drifter
offline
offline
I agree with Packman.
Yesterday I had a game where my RB faced a much inferior team. He had 240 yards rushing, 4TDs and 26 broken tackles.
While I enjoy the stat boost, should he really get more experience for it?
Yesterday I had a game where my RB faced a much inferior team. He had 240 yards rushing, 4TDs and 26 broken tackles.
While I enjoy the stat boost, should he really get more experience for it?
colwag
offline
offline
*only reads the first page*
It would unbalance the game somewhat, only the rich (the people who do good, maybe even only because they have higher stats) get rewarded, thus separating them from the poor even more, making it harder for the lesser players to catch up. Same thing the admins said for not giving players a bonus for making the playoffs.
It would unbalance the game somewhat, only the rich (the people who do good, maybe even only because they have higher stats) get rewarded, thus separating them from the poor even more, making it harder for the lesser players to catch up. Same thing the admins said for not giving players a bonus for making the playoffs.
SAGA45
offline
offline
Originally posted by kowman28
What about a Reputation/Intimidation stat? It could play against an opponent's Confidence & Morale stats. When you make an impact play like a forced fumble, 50-yard run, or an interception, your Reputation increases. If you miss a tackle or throw an interception, your Reputation drops. The amount your Rep changes would depend on your level (Lower level players would get high rewards/small penalties for big plays, High level players would receive low rewards/high penalties). Like Morale, this is not a stat you can add skill points to - you have to earn your Rep.
I believe the devs already have something like this in the works. What I like about the concept, as it relates to the morale-xp bonus/penalty system we came up with, is that it would allow players who don't have stats to still be rewarded for providing a psychological impact on the opponent -- like a Shutdown corner, Tony Boselli-like LT, Lorenzo Neal-like FB, or a Glenn Dorsey-like (I'm a Chiefs fan
) defensive tackle....players who are great but who's impact may be more mental than statistical.
Also, the great thing about the final, three-headed idea we came up with is the overall team concept. The whole team will benefit from a developmental standpoint when players make plays...not just the individual. I think that's something that made it much more palatable to the developers and I've been told that we'll see something added to GLB along these lines.
What about a Reputation/Intimidation stat? It could play against an opponent's Confidence & Morale stats. When you make an impact play like a forced fumble, 50-yard run, or an interception, your Reputation increases. If you miss a tackle or throw an interception, your Reputation drops. The amount your Rep changes would depend on your level (Lower level players would get high rewards/small penalties for big plays, High level players would receive low rewards/high penalties). Like Morale, this is not a stat you can add skill points to - you have to earn your Rep.
I believe the devs already have something like this in the works. What I like about the concept, as it relates to the morale-xp bonus/penalty system we came up with, is that it would allow players who don't have stats to still be rewarded for providing a psychological impact on the opponent -- like a Shutdown corner, Tony Boselli-like LT, Lorenzo Neal-like FB, or a Glenn Dorsey-like (I'm a Chiefs fan
) defensive tackle....players who are great but who's impact may be more mental than statistical.Also, the great thing about the final, three-headed idea we came up with is the overall team concept. The whole team will benefit from a developmental standpoint when players make plays...not just the individual. I think that's something that made it much more palatable to the developers and I've been told that we'll see something added to GLB along these lines.
Last edited May 5, 2008 10:30:48
SAGA45
offline
offline
Originally posted by colwag
*only reads the first page*
I'd recommend Packman and yourself read pages 3-5 before commenting. Thanks
*only reads the first page*
I'd recommend Packman and yourself read pages 3-5 before commenting. Thanks

PackMan97
offline
offline
^ Huh? I did...I thought your idea is bad and therefore I commented. Is that a problem?
I see nothing in pages 3-5 that would make this a worthwhile idea.
Success on the field results in a better team, more ticket sales, quicker stadium expansions, more money for equipment upgrades (which will become an issue), etc. There is no reason to create an XP gap for teams doing well. Doing well already has it's own reward, it's called WINNING.
I see nothing in pages 3-5 that would make this a worthwhile idea.
Success on the field results in a better team, more ticket sales, quicker stadium expansions, more money for equipment upgrades (which will become an issue), etc. There is no reason to create an XP gap for teams doing well. Doing well already has it's own reward, it's called WINNING.
SAGA45
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
^ Huh? I did...I thought your idea is bad and therefore I commented.
Well evidently you missed the concepts that addressed level of competition and overall team benefit as your entire argument against the idea seems to be centered around those two factors. Basically, the points you raised were already brought up quite awhile back.
^ Huh? I did...I thought your idea is bad and therefore I commented.
Well evidently you missed the concepts that addressed level of competition and overall team benefit as your entire argument against the idea seems to be centered around those two factors. Basically, the points you raised were already brought up quite awhile back.
Last edited May 5, 2008 10:54:38
Razorthorns
offline
offline
I don't like the idea of rewarding outstanding plays with bonus experience. It's just going to give the better players even more experience to put the back-ups even further. It might also lead to too much specialization in builds where a players is only good for one thing because he wants to win those bonus exp points. NO THANKS! Players are there to play they don't need a bonus for doing what they are made to do. If you want a bonus system give the owners ways to offer player's incentives with gamecash or awards. Giving your best players a bonus for their big plays is only going to make it unfair to your back-ups who don't get as many oppurtunities as it is to make big plays.
killacam99
offline
offline
i don't think the bonus should be for big plays but more towards game stats. it could be set up close to the same as the XP is set up now. in that i mean, the higher your level the lower the amount of XP you recieve, BUT i must agree that by pumping skill points into your stamina just to be able to play more to recieve more XP doesn't make much sense. i mean, i could probably run longer than the majority of the players in the NFL but that doesn't mean i should be gaining more 'experience' than them if i were on an NFL team, just cause i have more stamina. i could be missing something.
BUT, i am extremely happy with the way this game is going. i'm fairly new to this but i absolutely love it!!
BUT, i am extremely happy with the way this game is going. i'm fairly new to this but i absolutely love it!!
GoVolsKickSomeAss
offline
offline
Originally posted by hiuhyoi
Before something like this is implemented lvl caps & salary caps need to be put on leagues so that the lower leagues don't just get farmed out by higher lvl teams bringing their starters down and racking up amazing stats.
there has to be some sort of adjustment made for level of competeion.
a lv 20 OT who gets 10 pancakes against a lv 4 D-Line shouldnt be rewarded as much as the same lv 20 OT getting 10 pancakes against a lv 20 D-Line.
Before something like this is implemented lvl caps & salary caps need to be put on leagues so that the lower leagues don't just get farmed out by higher lvl teams bringing their starters down and racking up amazing stats.
there has to be some sort of adjustment made for level of competeion.
a lv 20 OT who gets 10 pancakes against a lv 4 D-Line shouldnt be rewarded as much as the same lv 20 OT getting 10 pancakes against a lv 20 D-Line.
hostyle
offline
offline
How many times do people need this suggested AND shot down before people actually get the point?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=16609
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=16609
Last edited May 24, 2008 08:56:40
SAGA45
offline
offline
Originally posted by GoVolsKickSomeAss
Originally posted by hiuhyoi
Before something like this is implemented lvl caps & salary caps need to be put on leagues so that the lower leagues don't just get farmed out by higher lvl teams bringing their starters down and racking up amazing stats.
there has to be some sort of adjustment made for level of competeion.
a lv 20 OT who gets 10 pancakes against a lv 4 D-Line shouldnt be rewarded as much as the same lv 20 OT getting 10 pancakes against a lv 20 D-Line.
Yep, I suggested that on page 4: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=63851&page=4
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
The only incentive it would give would be the incentive to play against lower competition to get more stats.
I think you can counter that with one or both of the following methods:
1) Higher the LVL = the lower morale/XP bonus for positive plays and the higher the morale/XP penalty for negative plays.
2) Add a "Level of Competition" modifier where:
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (positive plays) = higher morale/XP bonus rate for the low lvl and lower morale/XP bonus rate for the high lvl.
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (negative plays) = lower morale/XP penalty
rate for the low lvl and higher morale/XP penalty rate for high lvl.
--In both cases, The wider the difference in lvl, the larger the impact (whether accelerated/decelerated) on the morale/XP bonus and morale/XP penalty rates.
What I believe the above two methods would do is make it far more beneficial, from a progression standpoint, for players to compete against an equal or higher level of competition.
I also agree with hiuhyoi, other things have to be implemented first before this could be done.
Originally posted by hiuhyoi
Before something like this is implemented lvl caps & salary caps need to be put on leagues so that the lower leagues don't just get farmed out by higher lvl teams bringing their starters down and racking up amazing stats.
there has to be some sort of adjustment made for level of competeion.
a lv 20 OT who gets 10 pancakes against a lv 4 D-Line shouldnt be rewarded as much as the same lv 20 OT getting 10 pancakes against a lv 20 D-Line.
Yep, I suggested that on page 4: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=63851&page=4
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
The only incentive it would give would be the incentive to play against lower competition to get more stats.
I think you can counter that with one or both of the following methods:
1) Higher the LVL = the lower morale/XP bonus for positive plays and the higher the morale/XP penalty for negative plays.
2) Add a "Level of Competition" modifier where:
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (positive plays) = higher morale/XP bonus rate for the low lvl and lower morale/XP bonus rate for the high lvl.
--A lower lvl competing against higher lvl (negative plays) = lower morale/XP penalty
rate for the low lvl and higher morale/XP penalty rate for high lvl.
--In both cases, The wider the difference in lvl, the larger the impact (whether accelerated/decelerated) on the morale/XP bonus and morale/XP penalty rates.
What I believe the above two methods would do is make it far more beneficial, from a progression standpoint, for players to compete against an equal or higher level of competition.
I also agree with hiuhyoi, other things have to be implemented first before this could be done.
Last edited Jun 2, 2008 08:03:44
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























